High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7686/2016dismissed

Rafiq Khan v. Yogesh Kumar

2017-03-09Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari4 pages

!"# $

& "(#) *&*+" ',-+./&/&0 !1/(

& *&3/"4 1-+./&00/&5/6 !1/(

'2"!

2& "(2 ( ( ",/'7

" "/"(+"!

&&( 6

"'( (+( " "! //"! '! & !/0/ "'((, &!

&!/(

2/''

1 6+!0 9& 1:

/&5/"/ & ' "0(,

25 & "("(&66 &< !

'/ !&!

/226 /( "+"!

& +6 & /.

"( (, 5& (( " '(/( "( ,/' 7

! '. ''

! /.

"(5, ,5/''+0,( "(, 5& (( "'(/( "(5/'

(,/(/6 0/674 ( "5/'7 "0&/ '

!+"!

&3 9%: /&8/"/ &7/"9"(&6 "(=1 ( ":( $%9 &',&((, >(>:(,/((,

"'(&+( " ',2,/'7

".26 ! "

5 ( ( "'5 "'6 !/( !,/1 "07

" !"

/"! ?

/"!7

& ! "8 /&',/1 6/2'

! '+6(/"(68 2&1 ' "'

"((5+6!"(7 /226 /76

/"!(,

'+6(/"(

5+6!7 (,/((, 4+& '! ( " "("(&66 & ('

5/' "@+ '( "( 5/' +&(, & .

"( "

! " (, /226 /( " /6' (,/( (, /226 /"()( "/"(

5+6!"(6 /!/"8 1 !

2(&/6/"!!+.

"(/&8 1 !

/6& /!8 "(, , /(+. ',2',/1 "07

""'(&+( ! "(, 8 /&

5/'71 +'68"( "(, A"56 !0 /226 /"(

( +6!"(7 /!

!/((,/(( .

& /'" "0 0 1 " " (, .2+0"

! &!

& 78 (, & '(,/((, 5/'6/A !+ ! 6 0

/"!(, (& /6,/!/6& /!8 ..

!/"!(,

"1 5 2&1 ' "' &!

&+6

/226 /( "5/'"(/665 !' "

,/!& /, !/((, '(/0

"/6/&0+.

"('(5/'"( !(,/("

&/"8 ''+ 5/' &/.

!& 0/&! "0 '/.

"&/"8 1 !

,/'7

"6 "&/"8@+ '( "

0/&! "0(, ''+ 5/'/'A &5, 6 &'') ;/. " "0(,

5 ("

' /226 /"()& '2"!

"(,

(+6!"(7 , 6!(,/( " 1 !

5+6!7 @+ & !(7 2&!+ !"(, /'

'+6(/"(68

/226 /( "5/'! '. ''

! +"'

6 &1 , "(68'+7. (( !(,/("68/ 0/6 ''+ 5/''+0,((7 &/ '

/"!(,

/226 /( "',+6!

,/1

"/665 !, 6/52 &(/ " "0(/.

"( '6 7 &/6 /"!(,

&5/'"(/5/& '/ ! /(5, , '"5'+0,((7 7&+0,( "& &! 1 ( "2 ( ( "5+6!0"(',5(,/((,

'2"!

"()6/"!6&!5/'(,/((, ',25/'(/A ""& "(1 !

"("( !/( !%

&! "068 &'(2 ( ( "5/' !"

"(, 0&+"! 1 ( "!+ (""2/8.

"(3 . 6/&68

"!2 ( ( "5/' !" ?

& 1 ( ""(, 0&+"!(,/((,

2& . '

'5 @+ & ! &7"/ @+ & /"!(/A "0(, '/.

/ (,/(& "("( 5/' 8 /&

9""

;+& B :, '(/"! "/"(

% '2

/6685/'(,/((, (& (8""

( "5/'(/A " ", '"/.

"(,

%(5/', ''2

(,/(, 5/'/'(/(+(&8( "/"( "(,

. '

!2& . '

'' "

%,+'

4+& '! ( " +&(/''+,

,/!7

"/ 2( !/"!(, /,/!7

"(/A "(,/(, 5/' /'(/(+(&8 "/"(,

, 5/'5 66/5/& (,/(, 5/'(, &'(+2/"(/''+,

/' ( '"5/66 !(,/((, 7+ 6! "05/'.26 ! "

(5+6!"(6 ", '.+(,('/8, 5/'"(/5/&

/('(,/((, 7+ 6! "05/'"'(&+( ! "

/"!(, 5/'"!+

! 6 0 /''+, "

, ,/'(/A "'+,/'(/"!( ''

((6 !2& " 26 (,/( 785/8 /.

/!. '' "5, ,,/'7

"./!

" /1+&

(, &' !

/""(7 5& 006 !+(/"!(,/(/6'/((, /0 "!

! "0' +"'

6 &,/'1 , "(68 '+7. (( !(,/((,

5/''+

"(./( & /6/''+,"& &!5, ,5+6! "( (6 +&(( ''+ 4+& '! ( "/"! (+6!,/1

"0"

"(78(, &"!

&&!

&+6 +&( '(/665'+,/.

5, ,./87 "

''/&8 &!

&. " "0(, '/ !"(&1 &'87 (5

"(,

2/&( '"8!&/'( ,/"0 "(, '(/"!(/A /""(7 /665 !(7

(/A ", '(/( "( C)$ 6 &A *+" 2/6+" 6

3,& /& "!

&-+./&5, ,,/'"57

"26/ !"& &!

5+6!0"( ',5(,/((, /226 /( " &0 (( "0(, '/"( "

!' ( 26/"5/'!+68

;, 7 ( ! /' ) $ 1 !

5, , (, /226 /( " ,/! 7

" 0 1 " "'(&+( "0(, 7+ 6! "05 "(, "0+6!7 2 "( !+(/''+, 5, & (, ' /"8 ./( & /6 " & &! ( ',5 (,/( (, 5/' /"8 +2/"8B.26 &( /( /''+,5, ,5+6! "/76 +&(( /!4+! /( +2"(, ''+ ".26 2&'2 ( 1

'+76/+'

% (& /!'/'+"!

&#) D(, "0 "(, ' (',/66/2268( /"87+ 6! "0(,

"'(&+( " 5, , ' .26 ! " & / & (,

"( (, '( &/2 & ! "8 /&' &.

!/( ('.26 ( "E 2 /71 '

( "5+6!0"(',5(,/((,

!/( .26 ( " '(, 1/"(!/( (+6!"(7 2 "( !+((,/((,

.26 &( /( '"& &!1 !

5, ,(,

( /! "0'

(,/((, 5/'"& @+ & "((6 /! 1 !

+6!7 0&/"( !((,

& "'+, &+.'(/"

(, '+&( ' 2 " "

(,/( "(,

/7'

/"8!+ ! 6 0 5, , '/2& )& @+ ' ( "! ( "+"!

&(,

2&1 ' /"! "1 5 /71 ! '+'' "

&2/''

&5/'5 664+'(

! "(, /('/"! &+.'(/"

(! '"('+

&./"8 66 0/6 (8& "

&. (85, ,5+6!5/&&/"( "(

" & '

1 ' "/64+& '! ( "78(, '+&( &! "068 1 6& 1 ' "2 ( ( " '! '. ''

C, &'2 /A "0B& /'"

'B C, & 2&(/76

# 'B