← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16737/1990disposed of

Ministerial Staff Association v. State Of Pb. And ORS.

2023-05-26Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari8 pages

  

   !

 

   

"#"$%"&'( )**

 "+,&"&'(* -**

,',#."$,/01./

 ##+,/.,' ".,.,'"$ 2"$#3# 1./." 3'4/5/'&.6"$# "#7'&"'.# * *) ,05/8/,/'&.6"$# ".,.,'"$# 2"$#3# 1./." 3'4/5/'&.6"$# "#7'&"'.#  (9: 1 :;1  :

$"#"'.( $;/0,<=1"',$ &%+/."=>,.6 $1/'&""7 6300= &%+/."

$.6"7".,.,'"$# $ ;1,'8/0= &&0 =3'4/5 

 

                

        !

!"##



$  

  % &' '(( !") * 

'

   #  !"+

,       -    "  . / 0     1! ." /2  0)) 3$$$ .(''! 

*   &    

4 "  

"  

5'

   3

 

 

  

 



  

     

   

  

 

  

        !!"  #

$ 

  %&&' ( )* #+"" $   ((  ,--  



 

 

 



 

 



     



 !



  

  



      !

 "  

 !







  

   





 #   

 

!

   $       % &

  % 

'(  ) $  $ 

"*** %

%

+&,,  

 

     

  

  

 

!



   

    







  

  

  



         

   

   







  "

   

  +&&&  

 

 #

 

-  

 $        



   

 









 

 .

/  

 

    





     $

  "      

 6 .(/0/0/0  43

 77,'.?"'...6"1"$%,+"#6/005"?/&",'.6"

00>,'8?/''"$'/?"0@( '.6"+/#" 0"$<#=,'+03&,'8:"&8"$;""7"$# / 0( !" 

 #7 /

0 !" # ## +  # 8 . +  " 9 9  7 /

0!"    "

         : #      )   : #$  !     !!"# !3 / 0/

6'.6"+/#"  ,"#"03?7 .."'&/'.# / 0!" 

 #7 /

0!"    "

         : #      )   : #$  !     !!"# !3 / 0;

&

$(''

#) % &

 4<,< 3 =  4 

 #!" )

%

+

   2   # # + -  #



 & 0"$< /-  

8  

) >

8  ) / 0?

"3 

    !"



 # / 2 

  

      ) )"

3$$

) >    8  8   "

! 

     6

-  +  #

8 ! 3 

 60 4#  #  B   "

  7 /

=    

1!

"

!  !"

 ,!"



 

 "     #"  !      "

# 

)!3 / 2 

 +

      ) )"

3$$ ?4#  #  B   "  

  7  /

0  )    4  6           3$A # "     # ##

  "      9  "

 /1!

0           9 "   

1!

 "

 ! !"

 ,   !"



 

/

0  @ 

    !"

# ##    . 3 $A# "

-  "          "  

  # 



 "#  

 #           9 "

 

    



   !  

# "

   #     

            !

"



    9 "   

'

$    #               C8   C8 8C)6 8 )>  - + #

6C) 6 

 &  ((  + # 8  #     " 6  #    '

 ((( -  + #

8 - " # 9   "

 6   #  !")

 

    $  

.(/0/0 + # 8 #    6

%! "(((  6# + #

8 6       "

      !               6  $    #   6!": #   + # 8  " 6  9 !4# 

-    "

 ,1 #    # %$  $ #! 6    #!#   # #

        !!      # "       # $ 4,   6    #  "

$    6 #9 

   #    1 # 

!

(

-  4  1 #            

%&&# %$  $  )!$  ,) "@/,)@0  +   )!$ /?4 0  )!9"

 !!   $4 ) #

   " !    ,)@)!$  " +   )!$ /?4 0   1 # 

! 



-       #     #  "    + #

8 -##! <   #   6  # "(((

!

    #  + # 8!6  + # 8 6



-  4        !"    ##!      <        "!##

 $! ## "  - ##!      <                  #   # 

##"

  -##! <  3$$$# "

8"  ## "   

$    

  ./#00$#+" -$1((DD  " 4 "##  3$$$# "! 1    !  "#

A ##! <    !1#   !#

  !  



8  # 

  "

 

* .6/@=**

:;1  : '.

    6".6"$#7"/<,'8B$"/#'"& (!1B 6".6"$$"7$./50"

(!1B