Gurdial Singh v. State Of Punjab
!"!
$ %&'
) %*+!
.....
// &&
0".
%#1 .....
"/ #+ #
. 3- / *"
/ *"
5 +
1%+,4 # .
** +
/ *"
7. 3-
1%+,4 #
%&+ * /
!, "
8*.
9...0!*:( +;
8*.
%*1
- %+- *'( ( %#1 2.
%*+!
!#,-
""
!& +
1%+,4 #
#;!
.).
*+ *
; #
*+ + -.
%*!#+ * %/
- # %+, ( / !
5- * 2'(
#;!
: /!#, "" ""!
:,.
//'
-%":
#'
/ *4!
&! # .
- * 2'(
44!
!#,
/%#!"- %#+ * )
*%,"
"' -
/!
%2"
# "
<)( =- * !#
&& +
> >?(
*+ +
%#+ *,
*!, !4/*!"
#4 #
-"
(@.
%&
'4 #
!# (
%#+ *,
*!, !4/*!"
#4 #
-.
&'
" %
*'
&!:
-!"A
7.7.7(
&5
#,5!
! !
!#,
*+"
-"!42&!
;!&& # -"
"!+ .
# -!#,
#:
- ,, *(
%" +
" #
4!#,
;!&& !*2
"!+ (
**'!#, /&
*!,-
%&+ *.
#
"!"
"%"/! !
#(
//* - #+ +.
!4 ( #1!
3 - +
!# +
'.
&5
!#,-(
- #
&+
%" +
"%"/ !#,
= %" + ?
"" ""!#,
"%2"
-%"
:
* -
* "
,.
&5
!#,-( ;
* -
#+%
! *
,!"
5 ; *(
%" + * / " +
!+ #
&5
!#,-.
#" #
4 4 D.
/* / * +.
* -
**! +
&5
%#+
!#!#, //'
-%":.
5
4/& "
) ,* 4"
; * + //'
-%":.
* 4 !#+ * 5 !,- +
:, ) ,* 4".
/%
* &.
5
4/& * &"
" /
&'
/* / * +.
&&
4/& "
& +
4/& D.
/* / * +.
#+ +
; *
#1!
3.
"" ""!
;!+ 4 4 D.
%E
D.
* ,!"
" ( 5- * %/ #(
*4 D.@ *+ +.
!
/& D.
/* / * +.
%" +
** "
+.
# %*#
#(
&5
8
#.
#
5!#, '(
&5
!#,-(
:
8
+% +
8 ;!#,
//&!
D.
.
8( 1/%*
; *!
! +
"!,# +
& +
+% +
-!4
%*# +
#; "
!,
!#,
! *
!#,
8.
/'
*+ *
8( 1/%*
D.@.
/
- 4!
4!# * D.
!# +( 5- * 2'
4!#
4/&
%#+
!#!#, > -%*
//'
+">.
4 #
# "" "
*+ +.
4/&
!#; "
!,
#"( /%
!#"
%" + !#+!#,
/*!4
!#"
%" +
44!
!#,
/%#!"- %#+ * )
.... *, "-
*+!#,&'(
5-! -( +!+
/& ,%!& 2%
!4 +
&.
:!#, " % ;!+ # (
4 #
%#+ * 77 *...
*+ +( 5- * !# + #! +
" %
&& ,
/& + + !## # .
%" +
-!"A
2 #
&" &'
!4/&!
; *'
-!4.
*!#,
"!+ "
//* !"!#,
!* ;!+ #
4!#,
*+(
*+ +
1%+,4 #
#;!
- &+
%" +
,%!&
: /!#, "" ""!
:,.
//'
-%":.
- * 2'(
44!
!#,
/%#!"- %#+ * )
....
# + -!4
4 # # +
*&! *
1%+,4 #
;
*+
%#" &
%#" &(2 "!+ "
//* !"!#,
!*
4!#,
*+.
%#" &
#+ +
2 #
&" &'
!4/&!
&&'
-!#, ; * +
"" ""!
#.
*+ *
" %
&" (
*,% +
" ; * & , !*4!
! "
" %
5 &&.
!*"
&&(
*,% +
" %
#1!
!# +
!#+ / #+ #
# ""
2%
4!# +
" % #.
"!4/&'
,!; # %/
;!#, 2 #
; *
%" +.
2 # 4!# +(
, #%!# # ""
" %
%&+ ;
2 # +!" & " +.
"
"% - " %
##
%2
%*" ( !#!#,
!#+ / #+ #
# ""
**
/%*/ " "
**
2%
5 + '"(
2&!;!
!#+ / #+ #
# ""
" &+ "%//
" %
;
#".
- *
#'
'/ "
%#+% /* ""%* "
- 4
- '
!#"
-!4.
; #(
!#+ / #+ #
# ""
"% %42
- !* /* ""%*
*# #4!
%" +.
"
"% -(
*#
!;
" %
,!;
%/ "% -
# ""
# ""
2 #
; *
%" +.
5(
& +
#;!
5 && " +
!4 #! "
! !
# "" "
#"!"
!#"/!*
!+ #
4!#+
* , *+!#, ,%!&
%" +.
; *'
-!#,
##
#+"
!#+ / #+ #
# ""( "!4/&'
" %
4!# !#+ / #+ #
# ""
!#+ / #+ #
# ""
2 #
; *
"%//
" % #(
4!# +A
*+
E%!
!,- '.
; # '(
4 "
+%
" *% !#!C
4 #
" % # "" "
4!#% &'
4 #
" % # "" "
#"!"
!#"/!*
!+ #
4!#+
* , *+!#, ,%!&
%" +A
#;!
5 && " +.
"
"% -(
* "
%#" &
"%"
2& .
# D
*,% +
%#" &
" (
4/&!
)
....
2 # + .
%,-(
,!; #
%" +
*!,-
* -
#+%
! *
,!"
# !
! *
,!"
&& +
"/
* -
- !* /* " # .
#
#+(
%#" &
#+ +
4/&!
)
....
# ""
*'.
/ *"
* -.
; * +
/&
**! +
%" +
" ( "!4/&'
,!; #
%" +
* , *+!#, *!,-
* -
%" +
* / " +
!+ #
&5
-!4" &
* -
#+% -!4(
%&+
;!
" %
" .
#
"/
%#" &
**! "
5 !,- )
....
//&!
#&'
" "
/ *"
* -
- *5!" .
- *
* (
* -
#+%
! *
,!"
- !* /* " # (
%&+
;!
&.
#+!"/% +&'(
/* " #
5-! -
; * +
/ *"
%" + "
"% -
%#" &
;
!&.
*,% +
%#" &
))
....
2 #
4/&! + -.
*( ; *'
#+(
+% +
+'.
* " % # ""
! %& *&'
&5
=3?
+!+
+% +
'(
# "" "
#.
"
"% -(
4/&!
))
....
, !#(
%#" &
"%"
&5
!#,-( -!4" &
#( - %*.
!# ( -!4" &
#( - %*(
* (
-!4
+%
'(
# "" "
#'2 +'
&" .
#+ *
- "
!* %4"
# (
##
;!"!
))
....
4/&! + -.
!&!
* # ))
....
5"$
!
+!#,
5"
#"
/ #
,!"
!D
"% -
! & "
:
4/& "
- 4
4/& "
& +
! *!# - *,
#.
D.@
*+ * 5"
& +
>
+% +
,!"
" #( "!,# +
- # %*# +
#; "
!,
!#,
! *
!#,
8.
-!"
*+ *(
-%"( 5"
,!"
" #
+% +
-!4( & +
#+(
*( /%
"!,#
%* "
- # %*# +
#; "
!,
!#,
! *
!#, 8.
#+ *
- "
!* %4"
# (
##
)
....
4/&! + -.
*,% +
%#" &
4/&!
)
....
" .
"
)
....
* /* " #
!;
4/& "
!# +
+% +
,!"
; # /-
,* /-"
!# + 2%
8 +!+
"!4/&'
'( "!,# +
- # %*# +
#; "
!,
!#,
! * ""!#,
*+ * D.
@.
# D
*,% +
%#" &
+ & " #+!#,
4/&
B
4!#
#.
4/&
7.7.7 5- *
B
..7.
*,% +
;!"!
#"
)F
....
4/&! + -.
"
* /
" #!
! *
)F
....
E% "
/%
5-!& *+!#,
4 #
%#+ * 77 *...
%#+
#" !
"" ""!
#+.
-%"(
- "
#"
5 &&(
& +
E%!
&.
-!"
*,%4 #
%#" &
"%"
)F
....
+!* !;
%* .
" ( ; *'
-!4" &
8
#+(
*(
; *'
# D
'( +% +
+%&'
& +
8( 1/%*
, (
%#+
!&&
!4
4/& "
4!# +
B.
!4/&'
..
=3?
" + +%*!#,
%*"
"" D 4!#
2* : #( 5- # +% +
%&+
:
#'
+!
* # .
- *
;!+ #
!&
!#" *!/
2*
"% -
""!2!&!
4/ *!#,
%&+
*%& +
*+
5-
" #"
# ""
" +
2* : #.
2" #
#'
;!+ # 5-! -
%&+
2 &! ;
4/ * + -(
##
2* "% -
## *
4/ *!#,
'(
##
*%& +
"/ !
E% "
/%
5- #
4 #
%#+ * 77 *...
*+ +
" #
4!#,
&5
!#,-(
//
"!+ (
**'!#,
/&
*!,-
%&+ *
"%"/! !
#(
//* - #+ +
* -
,( //'
-%":
%#+
#+(
*( 4/& "
+* 5#
* 4 !#+ * 5 !,- +
.) :,.
3!
- "
E% "
#"(
##
E% "
/%
# ""
* , *+!#,
#" !
"" ""!
#+.
&'(
*,% +
%#" &
%" +
&.
7.
*"(
#'
&.
5(
*"
, .
,* 5# %/ -!&+* #.
+!#,
%&&'.
44!
#'
&!:
%* .
%&+ ;
2 # 4 # # +
+'
/&
!& * # &'.
5(
/%*/ %&+ " *; + " #+!#, -!4
!&.
"
"% -( * +% +
/ *!
+(
&* +'
%#+ *, # .
%,-(
*+ +
"!+
%" +
4!++&
, + / *"
#( 4%"
;!#, ,* 5# %/ -!&+* # 5-
* E%!* - &/
1%#
- !* + ; & /4 # 2 ;
&&(
" (
%" +
/*!"
#(
; *'
&!: &!-
4!#,
*!4!#
"/ !& !# (
+!+
44!
#'
&!:
+%*!#,
* "
/ *!
*"(
#"!+ *
5-! - * +%
&* +'
%#+ *, ** +.
"
+'
%" +
&* +'
%#+ *, -"
'"
# .
"
"% -( +!
'!#,
*+ *
.). *+ +
# +
#&'
/ *!
&* +'
%#+ *,
!&&
#"
*+ +
; (
!#+!#,
4 *!
// &(
//
#+"
+!"/ " +
5 ; *( 5-!&
!#!#,
!4/%,# + 1%+,4 #
#;!
*+ +
#&'
# (
*+ *
.).( *+ +
+!
! +
!#+!
; .
#
* 4
4 .
!#
%" +
-5!
-.
/'
1%+,4 #
4/&!
4/&!
* /
-!#
/ *!
-"(
* !/
/'
*+ *(
!"#$ %
& "4*!
'