Sudhir Kumar & ANR v. Veena Rani & ANR
!" #
#
!"# $#"#
$
% & #
''()'(%* +
, %- # . / +
, '- /
0*/%%11 # /"%)(2+ 11-"
' 3
/
+/ / /1- / .
, 4 /
/ / +
, 5-". / /
6'((22 # 6%+
6% / /1-
# 7 8
9 //6'*:%%(5'(%% //;# 1
< / " /
6'(5='2(*'(%= / 6'(>>'')(*'(%=
%2/ /
# 6'+ 6' / /1-"
// /
/ # .
4
/ 5 3
/
"
/ . +
, >-
8/
#//
" / / +
, '- 0*/%%11"
7 / "/
/ / "
#
/. =)?
%)5'&/
/ / /1
/ /
/
# /
@ 8 7@ //
" > 3
/ /
/ #/ / .
4
" /
8 7@ //
" .
@ 3
/ /
" 8 7@ //
" "
=)?
%)5' 3
/ // .
.
@ " // %:%%%)): '(%%'((=/
A" =)?
&
"/
/#
=)?
"
%)5'. #
" //
1
/
//
# /
.
@ :&/
/ / /. 7 0*/%% 11"# / #/
9 / +
, 5- / # "
//
/.?
%)5' 73
/ / /1
/ / .
// "
/ 0
#
"
//.#
?
" /
/ / 7 / / %&''( )*
#%+,-.% +/-&%01& 23&4*-4+5%6 %+,
&* $
#30&171 '3&/ 8 9 "''+:%&%+ #1/-4% 1/;
)*
&
)%+
'-+ %+,
/-1&* 1/;
8
#30&171 '3&/ <9 %&%+=%+
-%3-%+ )*
#/%/1 '>
&*
?
<
4)46 ?< *-4*- @1&7% )*
11&%= @.%*
/-1&* ?
4)46 = " /
/
/ "
.
/. &/
/
/
/ # / " //
9 // %%(5'(%% / '2(*'(%=
1
< / "/ #
/
.
, 4 . /
. / 7 "
//
"/
/ * &/
/
# &#
=)+%-?
%)5' / / @" // , " / /,
/ / " / /
# .
4 / & 6%
# # "#
# 7"
6%8 6%" // // /
#
9 // // 6'8 6'" . 3
/ / / 1 / /
/ /
#
=)?
"%)5' / / #
"
# 2 ?#/
/ # ". #/ /
) B
" ./ #
0*/%%11".
1=1;/4'+ '> 06%4+/C&/ // 7 //.
C +-. / A + -./ / #/" / "
<
1#/ .
,
1" / A +-./ / / #/" /
/ " / "
<
1 / < . ,
1" / A +-. /
/.A +-. / / AD +-./ / / . #
/ # ,
1 #/ /
< // , /
1"
" / . #
, /
#/ /
<
" ". ,
1
/, ./ # 7 / %( ? . /
/ 0*/ %% 11" / # / /
. ? /
/ ./ ./ / / 7 0*/%%11?
"
#
2%7%6% %+,
/-1&* )*
*-A%&% #% %+,
/-1&* ?
4)46 88" ". E /1
# /.
G%:0*/%%+-1 / / ?
.
/. /
.
# / / 0*/%%" " / , 9 # " / 7 / / #
/ "/
# 9./ /# #
/ +-0*/%% 1# / @ "
"
7
# #
10*/%%1 "
0%>/' H %% ?
%-4B1+ )*
&)4+,B-%4 2%6.%+4 -%+3*%64
%=&% ,1%, /-&'35615%6 &10&1*1+/%/4)1* %+, '/-1&*
# <<" . /
'5'& 0*/%%
/ ". . /
/" .
# "
/"
# " /
# '55& /
70*/ %%+- " / "
/ /%%+-"./ /
/
?
" ./
/ " 7 / . '5>?
IE
#7 #! %)2=115%:"
1/./ . #
/ .
/
"
# #" / . 7 / " //.
.
G%'&./ .
/ .
/
" # # / "
, & ./
#
/ . J# # // " /
, .7/ " /
K '5:&. # /
".#" "
0* /%%< /
'5= L 0 * / %%" . / /
# / " 7 . / ".
/. ,,,,,, '5)?
, . # "./
/
/."7 / "
. 7
/ / '5%( "/
.
/ 7 / "
./ /# "
# "
'5%%& ,
. 0*/%%
# / "
7 . / "./ /
& . / .
3 #/;
3 ;?
3#
+'((>-)11:%' K%5)9/ /
// < B.
/ /@ " # / / & . # / "./
K '5%'?
+'((*-:11=%> 1/
///
" / ?
" / ". / &/
". . ? //
/ . "
< .//
#M "+%)))-511 '=* '5%5?
/
/ "
/ #, .
" / "./ 7 ,
. 0*/%%11 '5%>&. 0*/%%11 ,
"
/ "
" / /" /
1 7 /B # "+'((5-%11::*&/
"
/ /. //
1 IE
#7 #! "%)2=115%: '5%:&# 0*/%% ?
/ K //K 7
/ +-+-? / / "
/." " 7/ K %' & " #
0*/%%"11# / 7 " " / /
/.
%5 /
/ / #
=)?
"%)5'" , #
". , /.
>>1;/ '> +'+&154*/&%/4'+ +%- 6
//
/
// # /
.
@ +'- 6
//
1
/
/
#
.
@ +5- &#
+%- +'- /// / /
" // "C +-
/
/# "
./
/# " + - . /
" #1
.
?
/# " %)() +5 %)()-# /?
/# "%)'(+:%)'(- /
/# +>- & // / "C +- . # /
. , " . /
"
. "
:="
1 / "
+ -
/ ,
#/. "
.
"
%) //1 1 "%22'+:%22'-""
.
" / # ///1 1 "%22*+)%22*-"
,
/
/ %> &#
=)?
"%)5'
/ /
" /
@
1/ +'- =)?
"%)5'".#"# , . #
+%- +'- // " / "
/ A / "
/# A / "
./ I
/# %: & /
/ / "
// =)+%-?
"%)5'" # . /"
0*/%%+-11&
.
@ "
=)+%-?
"%)5'"
" /" # 0*/%%+-11 & / / / 7 & / / 1 /
/ /
/ %= ?
/ / "/F , / / "
,,,,,,, / / .
, 4 /
( / %2 /
'(588>8%8'8' +( 5-" >8'8' +( %:- . %5') %=*> "
& / @ 7 #'(%5 %> 6'((22 # %
# 7
// 9 //
'*: %%(5'(%% // /" // # ". ". /"
. " ./
/
/ / /
/
'(5= '2(*'(%=/
. / '( >>' ')(*'(%=".
/ /
%2/ .
# '
%"5*"*:"2:(8 / . ". /".
". / #
" // /" // # "
. " ./
/
/ / /
/ /
# .
4
/
< / / 7
/ /
#
. /" "",
/
7
/ / // / '((22 '(>>'0
/ # # NNNNN 8 &/ //
% &7@ //
" .
/
( /%2/
'(588>8%8'8'+( 5-">8'8'+( %:- . %5') %=*>
"& / @ 7 '(%5 %> /
/# / / 8 7 @ //
" .
//# / " .
/ / / /
#?
# / .
.
8 7@ //
" # 7
. '&# / %:%'%)): . 8 7@ //
#
</
/ # 7!"77 " # " .
'%%%'((= # 7 %2%%'((= '%%%'((= /
/ # 7" 3 7 . 3 7 # 7 // #
</ 5& # 7 %2%%'((=& % # 7 & %. /
. / #4 "
# # .
7@ //
# 7 .
/ " 9 // # 7
# 7 #
9 // .
#. .//
( /%2/".
# 7. .
.//
%2 /" . / 8 7@ //
"
# %. /
%2 /
# 7
'((22 %>(5'(%= // /" // # ". / . " ./
/ . 8 7 @ //
, 4 .
/ , 4 & '((22
/ .
/ , 4 / /
< /
>&
'((22
# % // // "
% / //
. . / " / " #/ /
" .
/
( / %2 / // #/ %"5*"*:"2:(8 .
//
/ .
/ /# & %;'.// . # 7 . .
./ / %2/ . / 8 7@ //
. .
, / & / '(5='2(*'(%=,
% # '/
.
/ '(>>'')(*'(%= . "
. /". / #
".
"
/
/ / /
:&/
.
4
/ / # .
# / / , #/ =& .
# # .
' .
/ " / # / / 7
/
/ // / #
"/ // //
7 "
. //
*&/ #/ < / / '((22" / '(5= '(>>' / # / / 7
/ " # " / #
2& / .
1 /. /
#
)& # // "& // @ " E O /1 7
%(& 1 7
#/ '"(((8 1 :(8
? " " // / / .
, 4 /
( /%2/
'(588>8%8'8'+( 5-">8'8'+( %:-
. %5') %=*> "& / @ 7 '(%5 %> '((22 #
%
# 7
// 9 //
'*:%%(5'(%%
// /" // # ". ". /".
" ./
/
/ / /
/
'(5= '2(*'(%= /
. / '(>>' ')(*'(%=".
/ /
%2/ .
# '
%"5*"*:"2:(8 / . ". /".
". / #
" // /" // # . " ./
/
/ / /
/ /
# .
/
< //
7
/ /
#
. /" "",
/
7
/ / // / '((22 '(>>'" /
#/
/ . E O /1 / . # / / # / & / ./ %* & " / / ./ .
/ / /
"
# / " / "
. & / ", / "
?
"%)5'./ "
@/ / =)+%- ?
%)5'" <
E" F/ , ?
"
6%/ " // // 7@ //
"
// / " /
/ /
# ?
# .#
=)+%- // / / @ =)+5-+- # #
1/ +%- +'- / /.
/
/ "
./ I
/# " / ?
#"
0*/%%+-. =)+%-?
%)5' %2 &
1"/ /1 / /#
=)+%-?
%)5' / /?
%&''( )*
#%+,-.% +/-&%01& 23&4*-4+5%6 %+,
&* $
#30&171 '3&/ 8 "/ ':+- < ?
"
?
"''+:%&%+ #1/-4% 1/;
)*
&
)%+
'-+ %+,
/-1&* 1/;
8
#30&171 '3&/ <" /
"
. .
?
%&%+=%+ -%3-%+ )*
#/%/1 '>
&*
?
<
4)46 ?< . / / " 3 / *-4*- @1&7% )*
11&%= @.%*
/-1&* ?
4)46 / /
/
& #7 / / / "
/ %) ?
# . #
" 1 // /
".
1
/ "
#
'( "
//
/ + -"
"/
/
%3&%) #'&'/ Whether reasoned / speaking?
Yes / No Whether reportable?
Yes / No