Atul v. Hy.State
!" #$% & '()(*+,- ./
00")% 1
")% $+ 20$
!"# $ % & '''''''
/ "
() * "
"
"+,- .,/ +0
1 * !
"
31*24# "
2 " ") "
)
"
5,,,6
+,-1*2
)
"
" ) "
)
) " 7
"
.,/1*2
""
") "
)
"8 ) " $
) 2 "
9 "
"
5 +,/5,, ,5,, )
:
;
1 " /,/5,, ) % % "
"
;
<
"
2 %
"
) ) ) ) " )
"
"
)
"
) :
) "
3
"
="
&
"
"
) )
"" "<
"" "
) ; ) 2
) ) )
"
) 8 )
) " 1 1"
"!11#>
&
%
"
) &; %=) ? ;
" 11
) 8 )
) 8 ) "
1"
" :
)
"
8 )& "
11>
& ( .,/5,,
) " * :
;
)
)
% " 11>
&
2 " "
; )
"
) /,/5,,!@8*# "
" ) @8*6
"
) 71;@8*65 "
"
"
@8*60
" " A,/5,,
+
)
" " " ""
"" ) @8*2 (
& "
!*<+# %
) % " 3 "4
+,- 1*2 "
" " 1"
2 )
" "
"
2 "
")
"
"
+,- 1*2
"
))
2
? " ;
2
"" " "" "? ;
,.,B5,, "
"+,- .,/1*2
"
*<
) 2 ") ")) " "
+,.5,,5( ) "
"+,- .,/ +01*2
) "
"
2
) 1 "
" "
8 ) % ) % "*<.C
""
" *</C *<+ & "
11 >
&
%
% !@8*$#
" ) " "C *<B & $ "
8
@8*& &
11 >
&
"
C*<- 2 " "
; )
"
+,-1*2 "
0 B,/5,,C*<1"
2
"
"
+,-1*2 C7 )
""
" *<A ; =
;
11 >
& C *<0 " "
=) *<5& ) & ")
" " @8*
"
8 ) ( )
" "
" "
++2*2
" "
)
"
" D1 ) 1 ))
1 +/5,, 5,, ) % +0
"
!") # )"
" :
;
9 :
"
"
!" "
# ) ) "
"
"
) 1 "" % !" # ) """
"
% """"
"
E
" "
" "
" ) + 2*2
"
)
"
+,5,,0
) % " ) " ""
"
)
""
"
>
;
) " !@8&F#" "
"
""
!@8&F6#*<
"
")
"" 5,,+5,,+ ""
" )
" ) )"
"
. >
"
" "
G 2 %) ,.5,,0 9 H ) "
"
"+,- .,/1*2 1
"
"
2
""" "
" ) ) )
:
2 )
"*<. "
)
)
)
,5 "
) )
)
" 2 )
2 ))
:
" " "
%
) 1 " "
" 9
"
" "
" +50 1*2 :
"
%
" "
&; %=)
) 8 )
) " 8 ) & "
*<+
%
) " " " 8 "
)
)
:
% )
%
) "
"
"
"
) :
/ "
" "
"
" ) "
% " "
) " ) "" "
"
) " ) )"
) )"
! 8 " 5# "
) "
"
" ) ) " )
" . """
) 9 )
"
" % % %
" "
&
"
*<+
% " " "
1
) )
%
" (
+,-1*2")
2 ))
"
@
"
"
%
"
)
"
+,-1*2")
")
)
"" " :
"" &
8 ) "
:
" )
+,- .,/1*2 "
7"
" "
" "
")" "
+,- 1*2" "
+,-1*2 " "
" D<
" "
- " )" "
"
) "
"
) "
)
"
)
) 8 " "
"
C " "
"
"
) "
)
" ""
3
+,-1*2 "
"
+,-1*2 !#
"
C !#
"
" )" " "
% "
"
"
" % "
"
""
"
"
) "
"
) )) " )" "
" % "" "
C !#
"
8"
"
"" % 1
" )" "
" "
"
%
) %
"
"
" )" "
"
"
%
) 7"1
")
) % )"
"*<."
)
)
) :
) )
" ,5 "
)
2 ))
" %
)
)
"
)
"
A
)" "
) >
9 "
"
" " "
)
:
) " "
"
) "
"
" :
" )
) % )
"
:
"
"
" )" "
)
"
"
)
"
)
) " "
"
% "
)
"
"
) 7"
" %
) :
" & $ "
*<B
8
!@8*&#
% ) &; %=)
) 8 )
% ) 8 ) "
11>
&
%
) " 3 "
4 & "
" ;
" " 11>
&
"*<+ "
!@8*$# )
G;
%
% " 3 "4
" ) )
" "
% " 3 "4
"
<
" )
%
B " "
*<+ & "
" "
%
) " " "
>
G;
"
& "
"I
%
) 1 %
) " "
"
"
" "
+,-1*2 "
1
" "
%
"
"
& "
%
" ) )
%
" "
% " "
1") )" "
"
"
" D*<A & ?= "
% )
"
8 )
"
% > 5
) "
%
""
" "
"
%
"
) " ) 1% > 5 "
*
%
"") "
I 1!
"# $%
D
%9 "
) " "
8 ) " 3 "
4 "
) )
% " :
" "
% "
" "
+,-
2
" " % "
"
"
:
% "
" ""
%
,
"
@
+,,
1 * +5/
E:
" )
"
"
" " &
"
'
' #( 7
)
" "
1
" +,-1 * 2 E
+,- 1*2 " "
"
9 "" ) " "
+,51*2
8
""
% 1 8
9 "
% " "
" " ?" :
8 50 @ ..B " "
% "
"
" D&
))
% "
8 " ) ) " ""
)
"
" "
"
3 4 ,&, )4 (*&* 5* " "
"
"
" "
$
%
"
" " " " " "
" " "E 2
"
+,-1*2") "
) " """
:
"
)
"
" 7 )
" "
"
2
) ")"
:
"
) :
"
"
) " "
> " ""
)& "
)
< "*<+ & "
" "
" "
%
)
"
" "
) 1 " "
" " % 6 " "
) ?" :
8 """
" ")
" ) ) "
"
"
" "1
8
%
)
9 )
) "
1
" )" " """
+,-1*2" "
1
"
" "
)
" +5/1*2
.,/ 1*2 "
"
) " " "
" ) ") (
9 )
"
"
")"
) " ) )"
) 6)
"
! 8 *5#
" )
5 "
" % "
9 )
) " ) :
)
"
" )"
9 )
"
) "
) " "
"
" ) "
"
) "
) :
. " :
"
"
) " "
";
1
) ""
" " )"
) " " ) =
"1 )
"
%"
)
" :
"
")
""
" ) "
)
)
"
" +5/ .,/ 1*2
" "
5.,,,6
)
% "
)
" " "
) "
%)
2 "
% ,- ./