High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7390/2017disposed of

Ranbir Singh Brar v. Varinder Zaildar And ANR.

2018-08-28Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan3 pages

! "#"

$%& '()%$%(&* $'$

+,%,%-(+$ +$./.

'$%(0+$1'%20'$'(0'(-,*+$

+.3-(0+(,.

$+.+(,!

$ ,*6'2# 07-8',+9-$,*+3+,%,%-(+$

$ /(++, '2%#+(%-$ 07-8',+6%,* $

:'('.*%.*,# 07-8',+'(0 $ '$':7++$%(&*# 07-8',+9-$,*+$+.3-(0+(,.

;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< #

$+(,3+,%,%-(3$+9+$$+0)=,*+2'(02-$0/(0+$+8,%-( -9,*+'.,/(>')$)'(+(,+.,$%8,%-( 8,.++?%(&+7%8,%-( -9,*+,+('(,.9$-:,*+0+:%.+03$+:%.+.% '3'$,-9-/.+

- @# +8,%-( 4 # *'(0%&'$* 9-/$ )+0$--:. 6%,* ',,'8*+0 )',*$--:.#-(+8-(7+$,+0&'$'&+6%,*',,'8*+0)',*$--:#-(+ 0$'6%(&0%(%(&$--:#-(+?%,8*+(#-(+.,-$+'(0-(+8'$3'$?%(& .*+0'(0,*$++.+$7'(,A/'$,+$.6'.'88+3,+0)=,*+2+'$(+0 +(,-(,$-22+$7%0+-$0+$0',+0

@ '(0+>+8,:+(,-9,*+ ,+('(,.6'.-$0+$+0-(,*+,6%(&$-/(0.-9 )-('9%0+ 3+$.-('2 (+8+..%,='(0./)42+,,%(&

+('(,#(':+2=#'$%(0+$1'%20'$*'7%(&3$+9+$$+0'( '33+'2#,*+ 33+22',+ /,*-$%,=7%0+>/0&:+(,0',+0

'22-6+0,*+.':+'(0,*+$+)=.+,'.%0+,*+-$0+$-9+>+8,:+(, 0',+0

@ 3'..+0)=,*++(,-(,$-22+$# #*'(0%&'$*

+./2,'(,2=#,*+%(.,'(,$+7%.%-(3+,%,%-(',,*+*'(0. -9,*+2'(02-$0'..'%2%(&,*+>/0&:+(,0',+0

3'..+0)= ,*+ 33+22',+ /,*-$%,=#*'(0%&'$*

/$%(&,*+8-/$.+-9$+./:+0*+'$%(&,-0'=#2+'$(+0 8-/(.+2$+3$+.+(,%(&,*+,+('(,.B$+.3-(0+(,.:'?+.'.,',+:+(, ,*',*+*'.%(.,$/8,%-(.(-,,--33-.+,*+%(.,'(,$+7%.%-(3+,%,%-( ./)>+8, ,- ' $+'.-(')2+ ,%:+ )+%(& '99-$0+0 ,- 7'8',+ ,*+ 3$+:%.+.%(A/+.,%-( +9/$,*+$./):%,.,*',3$-7%.%-('2$+(, '..+..+0',C

2'?*.3+$:-(,**'.)++(3'%0/3,-0',+'(0 ,+('(,6-/20)+6%22%(&,-3'=$+(,',,*+$',+-9C2'?*.3+$ :-(,*9-$'(=,%:+,*',:'=)+.-&$'(,+0)=,*%.-/$,

/8* -99+$ '(0 ./):%..%-( :'0+ -( )+*'29 -9 ,*+ ,+('(,.B$+.3-(0+(,.%.(-,-33-.+0)=$ ,*6'2# 07-8',+# 6*- %. -( %(.,$/8,%-(. 9$-: ,*+ 3+,%,%-(+$B2'(02-$0 '(0 6*- *'33+(.,-)+3$+.+(,%(-/$,

(7%+6-9./8*8-(.+(./.*'7%(&)++('$$%7+0',#,*+ 3$+.+(, 3+,%,%-( %. '22-6+0 :3/&(+0 -$0+$ 0',+0

3'..+0)=,*+ 33+22',+ /,*-$%,=# #*'(0%&'$*%..+,'.%0+

-(.+A/+(,2=#,*+-$0+$-9+>+8,:+(,0',+0

@ 3'..+0)= ,*++(,-(,$-22+$# #*'(0%&'$*%.$+.,-$+0

-6+7+$#":-(,*.5,%:+8-::+(8%(&6 "

%. &$'(,+0 ,- ,*+ ,+('(,.B$+.3-(0+(,. *+$+%( ,- 7'8',+ ,*+ 3$+:%.+.%(A/+.,%-(./)>+8,,-,*+%$9/$(%.*%(&'(/(0+$,'?%(&-( -$ )+9-$+ D " )+9-$+ ,*+ 2+'$(+0 +(, -(,$-22+$# # *'(0%&'$* ,*', ,*+= .*'22 *'(0 -7+$ '8,/'2# 3*=.%8'2# 7'8'(,

3-..+..%-(-9,*+0+:%.+03$+:%.+.,-,*+3+,%,%-(+$B2'(02-$0-( -$)+9-$+ *+/(0+$,'?%(&.*'22'2.-.,',+,*',,*+ +(,%$+'$$+'$.-9$+(,#%9'(=#',,*+$',+-9C

2'?*.3+$:-(,* /3,- "

"*'7+)++(82+'$+0'(0,*+,+('(,.B$+.3-(0+(,. .*'223'=9/,/$+$+(,',,*+$',+-9C2'?*.3+$:-(,*6

",- )=,*+,*-9+'8*8'2+(0+$

++02+..,-.'=# ,*','(= 7%-2',%-(-9 ,*+'9-$+.'%0 ,+$:. .*'22 +(,%,2+ ,*+ 3+,%,%-(+$B2'(02-$0 ,- .++? +7%8,%-( 9-$,*6%,*#6%,*3-2%8+*+23'(06%,*-/,$+.-$,,-'(=-,*+$$+:+0= )+.%0+. ,*+ ,+('(,.B$+.3-(0+(,. :'?%(& ,*+:.+27+. 2%')2+ 9-$ 8-(,+:3,3$-8++0%(&.

(.,'(,$+7%.%-(3+,%,%-(%.'22-6+0'(00%.3-.+0-9%( ,*+'9-$+.'%0,+$:.

"#"

-,+!

F*+,*+$.3+'?%(&B$+'.-(+0G F*+,*+$.3+'?%(&B$+'.-(+0G F*+,*+$.3+'?%(&B$+'.-(+0G F*+,*+$.3+'?%(&B$+'.-(+0G +.B - +.B - +.B - +.B - F*+,*+$$+3-$,')2+G F*+,*+$$+3-$,')2+G F*+,*+$$+3-$,')2+G F*+,*+$$+3-$,')2+G +.B - +.B - +.B - +.B -