Jagjit Singh v. Rajesh Bansal And Others
!
"
# $% &# $% '
('&# $% )'&#%
'
('&#%)' *+ ,+ $ -' +./ ! "
# $$ #% #
*+
+0('$% !%+ /1/23 + $1+% ! /1 + *+ + #+*4$ / ! /1
+ ./
5 1' ..'/+/ +/+//
"
./23 6/+''+!75! / + !1/ ( ..' '/ 23 *+
+ 8 .+1'+ 91* '/23 ./:6/'+/ /+% 9* $27+2 + !" "(/8/
-4 + / 8+ *( '/ 2 '
./4 1 *+ +8 /8/.+82 +% .*+ ;+ / '+
%<
= ! %+
=! / + > + *= "
? )+%8 '/
> + *= ! *+:5 8/ + 1+8! ( (+ +.+/23 6/+''+8 ///
6/'+/=5 +' . 2( 8' / ./:6/'+/@ '3! 6/+''+ +/+./A
> +*= 2+1/!B
C 5 + +! +''+ +8/ 8//./ 8+
+*) 2@ /! *+ '/ +/ ..'4 8 .+1'+!( (/8/1/ 8.
/+/+ - + .+/
+ + /+ + 8 / 28+/2 '
2 /!( '/2..+.+
+4 +'11+8!( (+8/23 *+:5 )+%8!( (++.+/23 6/+''+/' 6/'+/=5+' .!
> '8 ./:6/'+/*+
+91* 3B
!
" # $ " %$
& ' ((!
)
A
! *+ / '/ ..' /+ +/+,?? ' +/( +/+ ' +/( %A *4 /+ . ./ .+/ / 8+'/ .23 8 *!.+
+8/ 8.+ 8.+1 ' 1'1 *+*+ ..'!( (8/=
#
$
$
%$ $
* $ '+ $ $ "
$& A 5 ./ ../ / ..' / + +.@ +/ / 8 *+ +.'3 > + = (= #+ ,
$
) ,$ -
,
$
)
"
& D ? (+ 3 / .'3 ' (
/ 8 > + = =A (+ '/ 2 + +''+ 1+3/A
( *+ /81/ +/ ..' /++/+,?? ' * E ( + + 1 8 ''
' )+ %8!( //5 +'1/.
/ 1+8 )+%8+/*+ *+'8+3 2$/ + +*+! /D .'3+ 5 +'11+8++.+/ /2'(=
!
" #
,
"
.
/ !
" + $%$ , 0 "
$ "
%$
'+'( ((1 $ 23
0 4$
5 6 0 5 $ 5 735 23
0 "
8(* ((!
$ $
$ , $ $ ,
"
$
'+(8 ((9
"
23
:;
"
,
23
5 6 0 5
$ 5 735
'
"
, %$
$'
!< #'
'
:;
$
$ =
, , 1(>
#
'
:;
$ 0$ "
" $
'(((- 6 $
(((-? @"0 "
:
;
,
, :;
#
# $
#%
#&
$ $ $ " %$
,
,
" " $
&
"
$
8
8
" "
" "$
1(((-? $ "
"
, , "
3 ,
"
$ "
3 ,
$
:; " , $ " $
,
3 ,
,
"
$ "
= ,
"
" , ((9 ('! A $
$ $
$ $ " $
& ? 2 + /2 '
*+ .
+.+/ /' 6/'+/=5 +' . 2( 8' / ./!( ( ++/23 6/+''+!( ''32'
/'!2 '3@ ' /8 *+ /4('/ (5' /8/ .+8 /2./ 1 + ./! 3 / /3.3 %'/ ( +(+ ./ . +5+ +6+8/ ''()*+(,--
*' /2 ..'/ ' !/ ''3! *+(5 +1+3' 8 /+ .+1 6/'+/% + $% //!/
'
. 8 + '+ +8 1 + 3 + .+ '
/ ./! + /8 % + $% ( 1++1/ . 8E + +! /2 // 2+ +/ (+ . ./ + + '8 2 6/'+/F!2 +8 /+'/>+*+D )+ %8! / 1+ ' >.+/ ('' /+ +/8/23 8 21/*+ '+/3+.+/ /21
+ 6/+''+1/ +/+//A
2+1/ .+1'+ '/2/
/' 6/'+/=5 +' .! *+
..'//
> +*=A+/ ''( = #
$
@"0 "
, "
, $
,
,
, '
$3 ,
"
$ 0$ "
"
"
,
"
$"
,
+ $
"
,,
C
$ $
1 B
C
$ $
$ " "$ B
C
$
$ 0$
$
8
, "
, "
$
" 1(((-& " 5 6/+''+ (1+!/8/ ..' 1/8.
/+/+ +2+1 +='= #=
,
, $ '*(1 ('! " $
= , A '
,
,
A $ $ "
$
, $
, .$ '())*+ :$;
$
,
$
C & 5 . +1 *+ + 8 6/+''+ ''8 +++232+1 *+ / // > 6/'+/=5 +' . ( ! .+1'+ '/2/!1 ( + +)+
%8! *+ /// 5 +/.+8!2 /'3 ' / +2'/ 2 2 ' ./!( /8/'3 /1+ / / 8 .+8+3
'8 '+
+8 + 1 +(88 / 82 + '
* / . +2' / 2! *+ /'' +''3
+//. + + /8/23 8!( 1+8(' + +/23 6/ +''+2 + +8 ? 2+/2 '
./:6/'+/ 1' ..''2'2/8/ + !
'( ('' '/ 1 /' 6/'+/=5 +' . 23 5! + . + 8 .+1'+++++ '+/3!1( ' .
+.+/'3/3 6/'+/=5+' .! *+ *+D )+%8 / 88'
+/ /. + +/8/23 8 5 ''( / 1 2 +'/ . 23 ./.. 1' ..'= E 481,- (
A F .'% ',,$30 8+
+/+% ,%+2$%
D
1;(+> ?/ + 68/! * 4 ' , %@ 6/+ ;
+/'% / +
" 1 : /;'E ,% / 0 8+0'+
%6*EA
/ ? 21 /! .+. 2
+8/ +''+ /+2' /+8 .+1' + ( > 6/'+/=5 +' .//23 5*? ! . '(+'3( +' 6/ +''+ B$0'1((2$30345,$67 ,300'48
494: 8.
/+/+!( ! /2 '/ = ,- . . ( .) /.(0 )(1 0- / /0. . 0 . /20 .
)00.)(03 (4 (-.
.)-( /.' .)+0.+02.0.)+0 +/(0 .)..) /.(0 )(10-/ /0. .330 '/5 ( .) 1.(.(0 3.)/ /00-101.5 6(+.(0 2.-0//03 00110. (.5)0/7'(6 .0. ..024'00 .)-(+( +5( 0- .8 - +1+3 .+8( /
+ 5 2'
/' +' .23 5!2 . / ./:.
+.+/6/'+/+ (+ +/ - '/ / 1+ ' '
+//. + +/8/23 85 +!
+ +!/+( + *+2 + +//+2'/2 /!+ 28.'3 +( //23 6/+''+' 23 1+8 )+%8! *+ /// > 36/'+/=5 +' .! / ( '/2 1 1 +/.+1''3 +/. 8 A ? + +/! *+G/ +'/ ./
+B(('0$30+605,0;(,30'73(+<
.
?8328/ 1 / ../ 2 6/'+/! ( / '' / +''+G +/+ > .38 .+1' +! ( +/ 1('' '8 +' .
23 5 /2//5 +/8/ 6/'+/G 1 +2+1 +='= # $
,
$
$
,
)
$ ,
=
0$" $
$
,
$ " , "
,
$ " $ , " $ , $ $ $
, " , ,
,$
$ ,
,$
$ , D$ =
, ",
$
$
"
"
$
$
3
" "
$ 3 0
$
3
$ ,
$ , $ , "$ ,
$ ,
$ $
0$
& D 5 1'1/ ./ .+/ +8( 8'+5 *+//3 5 /8/.+8 ++3! 28 2 5 + +1+3' 8!/ /8/6/'+/ (% + $% //E // 1 +1/388 + +/ (+ . .+8 2 ./ ./) ' / 3 (+(+/@ '3 6/'+/! '' )+%8
+//. + +/8/23 8(..+ +'18+/+/2'3 ! ( '/ 2 ..+.+ /+ 1+ .
+(+/23 *+!( ..+/23+'1/ 8 E'8 125 8 % + $% E .'/ ++/ .3 1' %
// "
'/ 23 / $ % 4 1 +8 /8/ .+8! ( > + *= E ( )+ %8// "
'/ /91*
> +*= > +*=.3 +/+//
./23 6/1'# / # +1!( ( +/91*(/8/( /+( *+G+( '6/'+/!/ > +*= .3 *+G(88/
2 + +''+:1' # / # + 1! ( !
/8/ +.32'23 8(
:=.+8 /
:= .+ 8 + ( /
+ .+ /8/ .+8! ( ( +( ( '8 6/'+/ + + /8/.+8(
:=.+ 8 > +*=A.3 ''+ ( * ( /. + +(8 +
:=/
:=.+8 +(.+.+ /8/.+88/2 '
*+
A (8 2 + 91% (( /+(23 6/'+/% + $% > +*='+//
(+23 *+% +E+.'% 6/'+/ $ % ! ( / // 23 8! ( ! *+ / +@ / /E+.'% +8( 8 '/.3 + + /8 % + $% !/88
/'+% +E+.'% 2 23 +/* 8/
D/ + +23 ++
D'
+8.+ > +*= < + +'8+/23 *+ )+%8 ( 2@ '3 +*4 1(
'/ 823.4%+ D
!.3 ( > +*=5 *+ 91*
'/ ..' /++/+,?? ' +/( +/+ ' +/ ( % A * > + *=
/ 4 /+ . *+:6/'+/ .4%+.+/ +'1/ 8 ( ( / 28(+ /8/.+8 /8/6/'+/
( // $% (+.+ / 3 / 82
+ /.
+ / ..'! 91*'
( /8// ' D
" 5 + +!'+/3+.+/ /*+ )+%8 21! *+ /// +' . 6/'+/=5 2( 8'
/.4%+/
+ +// 3 ! /.4%+1+ / .+./ 4 *+G1 ?((+ 3 *+ +91* .+'+/3+.+/ /21! ./8+'3 /+2/ 8'1=(+/6/'+/ /8/ .+8( 1 3/ ( 3 /28 =(+ 5 . 5+ + 6+ .
+.+/'3 >/ ''()*+(,-- *'(+..+'3 /'1+/ *+' ( .3 91* - .(+ 2@ '3 ..'/' ( +.'3 *+G ..' > + = A
E + + '/ )+%8 1+3>/ >/ + .
+.!( ! ( ' /3 (+ . ./1+ ''
+//. + + /8/23 8?(2/ ++. ++/ 3 ' %' + 5+ + / 1 + ./+ +.
+.+/=(+ /+*+.% ' 8/ 5+ +6+//
.
+.+/'3 823 / + /8+ ''()*+( - ++/ 5 *+ )+%8. ''38/=
' 3 %'/<+8 +++ + '91*! 28'+ (.4 %+3 /28(+ /8/.+8 + *+G/8/6/'+/ $% !+23( /+ ?+ 8 > / 23 / .4 %+! + +
(+ . > A H 1 + ./( ./ 23 / + /8+ 1+8 ./ + 91 * *+ / 1+2''3 +/1 /8/.+823
"!( 2 . ''3 // 23 8 )+ %8 ) ++3 8 +'42( .+ ''3 4.'8+ 1/2'/ '+'-
/2'3. 8! +..+ 1234/
8+1/ . *+ + 3/ 8+'+ ..+ 8( ( '/2 6/'+/ + /8
% + $% !+( + ((+ . +/- '/ '
/2./ +8 + '6/'+/3' 5 5+ + ?8 6+ > + = ( /8/'3 2+ 4('/ *+'3 + .+ 91* 8( '/? + 8! + 1( *++'3 / /+ / 2 +/ ./@ +(+ . /8/ .+8 / @ '3 + '8 2 6/'+/ ) ' .
++/ +/ / 2! 1+ ' '
+/ /. / + /8/+ )+%8- . 1+8
& *+D )+%8(..+'3' 23 +!( ( 1( /' 6/'+/=5 +' .(2'
5 + + ..' + .+1'+ '/ 1+3 +/ + +8 !
( /.
/'3 ..2B +/ + C( 8 .+1% 9* $27+2 + !" " '/23 % .+8 + =0;(,3 %0130>0'0'173(+,5(+,*, 0?106@0'1*,7+40:+2+074'
0'173(+,<
&$*2+(6(*+70,(, (/8/1/ 8.
/ +/+ ? (+ 3 /8
..'! 6/+''+ 2+1/ +( /' *+G( 5 )+ %83( +!+ / )+ %8'
+//. + /8/+( ++ + /! 6/+''++'3 . / = 0?14,30+,3015,(30+30'10'10'73(+<8 //('7 &/!+$/ *+G ..'23 '/ +'++/+ '/ .+1'+2 / '/ 2 /:+1(/ 23 + +''+'
" ? 1( +/ + 8 ++/ .+/ *+ +. ! + 1( +'+/ +/ - + (('0 $30+60", A0,( ,*2+0 8+..'2' /+ 8 .+/ + +! + 8 '
/' ..+ 3 *+.3 .
. / +23(3 8.+1''3 .+8 6/'+/=5+' . /2// ( '/..+2 8++ $ !
/+ *+ /.+8.'3.+3/ + 8 B +/ + C + +8 !( ''3 ( + +..' $ /'8/ 1 .+/ 5 8.
/+/+ + +!'2'2/
) 2+1! .+1' ..' ''(/
5 6/+''+/+// + +' /// . .+1'+/+++.32'23 *++/( % + 1 ..+ 3 + 2 / 8+ % >+ 83 2 8.'/( 8 +8 / 88 +/+! +( !+2'8832 +/ *+ /. 8 /2.32' $ #% #
!
"
% ) +.4 :+/I F:
) ++.+2'I F: