High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7373/2018allowed

Reliance General Insurance Comp. Ltd. v. Kamalpreet Singh And Others

2018-10-30Mr. Justice Satpal3 pages

!"#!$%&%'(

!)%'$!!'!*)'&+*'$!,-'./ # ! % %'!* 0& 1,)-*!! 2%'34'#*& !&-'#!' & *,( '56)! *+& %$!*%'#!*2%'342%#4+

*!&!' (7

&4+-%'#!*1+*8#0$ !"*

*2'9!!01#'8#0$ ! "* 4!-! % %'!*

4! %'&+*'$! $,-'. 4& "%)!# 4%& *!0%&%' -! % %' %,-+3'%'3 4!*#!*# !#:")!*'!# *$$%#!' )%,& *%6+')8*'*'%'&4* 5 4!*%6+')5 ;4!*!6.% &!0%#!'$! ;& $)&!#6.*#!*'# 4!*#!*# !#<=" 4!*%6+');4!*!6.% & --)%$ %'"*)!#%'3##% %')!0%#!'$! -*0! 4!)%& ";% '!&&!&%' 4!$*%,%')$&!'# &+,,' 4!*!$*#"$&!6!*%'3 : # !#:+'#!*2!$ %'&<78='#< 8*!3%& !*!#

)%$!2 %'% .*'*'4&6!!'#%&,%&&!#

!&-'#!' & 40! "%)!# $)%, -! % %' +'#!* 2!$ %'>>" 4! *?!4%$)!&$ 8="*3*' "$,-!'& %'' $$+' "#! 4")@*2%'348;4%&& !# 40!#%!#%'0!4%$+)* $$%#!' ':4!-! % %'!*4!*!%'%&*!&-'#!' %' 4! "*!&%#$)%,-! % %' %& 4!$&!" 4!-! % %'!* 4 4!!0%#!'$!" 4!$)%,' & ;&$'$)+#!#'<4!*!" !*8 4!-! % %';&#9+*'!# <:"*!0%#!'$!" 4!*!&-'#!' & '<:' A;& -*!&!' +'&!)"* 4!#*%0!*'# 4!;'!*" 4! *+$@))!3!#).

77 %'0)0!#%' 4!$$%#!' !'#!*!#%' !0%#!'$!$!* %'#$+,!' &'# $)&!# 4!%*!0%#!'$!?%#! 4!&,!*#!*8*!&-'#!' ;&#%*!$ !# -*#+$! 4!!' %*!!0%#!'$!':&+69!$ )& --* +'% . ' :' A;&-*!&!' 4!$+'&!)"**!&-'#!' !'#!*!# %' !0%#!'$! !& !#$-." 4!%'&+*'$!-)%$.B >'#9+*',!'

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

*+$@;&"+'# "@!'#*!$0!*.*%34 &;!*!3*' !# 4! %'&+*'$!$,-'.3%'& 4!;'!*'##*%0!* 4!*!"24!& !& 4 %" '--* +'% .%&3*' !# 4!-! % %'!*8 4!'3*0!-*!9+#%$!;+)#6! $+&!# 4!* '&%#!*%'3 4! "$ & '# $%*$+,& '$!& " 4! $&!8 4%& -! % %'%&));!# 4!!B !' 4 4!%,-+3'!#*#!*# !#: $)&%'3 4!!0%#!'$!" 4!-! % %'!*%&&! &%#!4! *%)+* ,.3*' '!!""$ %0!--* +'% . 4!-! % %'!* -*0! 4!*!-* "%& *%$ *'&-* ""%$!*8%& *%$ 4%'# #4. *#!&4 ''!B+*!

77 &4))6!&+69!$ -.,!' " &8C7&$& & 4!$)%,' & 4!*!4;!0!*--!*& 6!'%'"%*,% .%' 4!*#!*# !# 2!- !,6!*<8#!$)%'%'3 4!-*.!*" 4!-! % %'!* &+,,' 4! $'$!*'!#4),#" 4!+* "))D 3%& * !*'*')'3;% 4 4!"%)!" 4!$*%,%')$&!-!* %'%'3 :# !#:

+'#!*2!$ %'&<78=8< 8 )%$!2 %'% .*'*'6 4"* 4!*!&'& 4 4!--)%$ %'4#6!!'"%)!# 6!) !#& 3!;4!' 4! $&!;&"%B!#"**!6+ )!0%#!'$!'#*3+,!' &'# 4 4!$)%, -! % %'4& 6!#!$%#!#%'#!-!'#!' ).' 4!6&%&" 4!!0%#!'$!)!# 6!"*! 4!*%6+') 4!*!0%&%'-! % %'D+ 4 %&#%&,%&&!# 4%&*!0%&%'-! % %'4&6!!'#%&-&!#";% 4+ ' %$! 4!*!&-'#!' & 0%#+''!$!&&*.#!).'#!B-!'&!&;!0!*8%" 4! *!&-'#!' &40!'.3*%!0'$!8 4!.*! )%6!* . --*$4 4%&+* "**!7$))%'3 4%&*#!* *%'#!*2%'342%#4+

#%'!&4 +#3!

A4! 4!*&-!@%'3C*!&'!# !& A4! 4!* !-* 6)!( !&C