High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/4110/2025allowed

Manpreet Singh v. State Of Punjab

2025-08-07Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel7 pages

++B4 B4 B4 B4+4<@5 4<@5 4<@5 4<@5 $%.

6!*!$) $%.

6!*!$)&"&*4> &"&*4> &"&*4> &"&*4>34 34 34 34 5

! "# C-

*&* ( $%&' C- $.

) ) ) )

)

:, -

, -'.

!"# !003.8$6

-*'! !"#3 &'(- ;;;;;

;;;;;

;;;;; , , , ,3-<,5 3-<,5 3-<,5 3-<,5

* 6$.

!!$#*(

%!0

6!$B=$%#

$% !/ /!0 .&

3=><%$ *#$

? ---:5< 6!$BA$%#

# !1 " !2 & 2*# #!3 45 "

(!0 $ #

! 6* ( !" $- . . 4-4-43

"!*

. %$

$%% & !*#(0 &.

6!$* @ = $% # 6$!6 &"* .

*16#$ !6 &(*6 *63=A<%$ *#$

? 6:53$0!6 !$ ,$"$703 !6 "

8/ $%# 00 "!$* "!*#

!*## !* 66&* .$% %( !"!8$08 .!

! !"$ 6!8$08!"44 4 !$9!6 * !- -3

/.$0 $0$"

* <44/"5 5

/ &* 44- - , .6$&* 0%$

#*!

.##

!* ! 6&*$.1 * *!6 4-4-4- , . 6$& * 0 #* 0*$ !

. # #

/.$

$8!*!$*$%# 6#8 $(

6$/ 0!

.7!#3.#&*3

6&!$ $6* *&%%

*% $/!#

6*-, .6$&* 0#*%&

.## !0!*.

01 ..# 0!(!0!1 1#

$%6$( %* .& $

- , . 6$&* 0 #* %&

. # #

#* *&%%

.!6

!$%$ /$

#41 *-

#&*3

(!0!*

1 .%$ B- , . 6$&* 0#*$

!!$(1 "&!"

## 00 !$* !* ."!*#

!$&*!&

.3#&*3 .$ *$.

6$6 **!$$%#

(!0-, . 6$&* 0 #*%&

*& &(/!

.## !*(!0 !*(

.(1# !"$ *$% 6!$ >$%# 63.#&*3# */ $&"# #$( .!*/!** .-, .

6$&* 0*

2* *$ 06 $

6$ .6&*$.16

!%!6 . .4-4A-4!$& 7#!6#!*2 $

6$ .- - #8 # .6$&* 0%$ !8 0 *.#8 "$ $&"# # 8!0(0

6$ .*$%# -

$ 4-4-43 7#

!8 *!"!$ 7*6

.$&.6#007*

.$4-4=-4- $0 0

6&!$ $7! ** *#8 (

.3(& &$014#*(

9/! .!00 0 . !8 06$ !$* !* . "!8

((0 !**& **#00(

!$6! . & $ .& !" # 6$& $% !0 0- #!* $& .$ * $ .

/ !

! $ $.

!$# !806$

!$*3#!**"

30 *!/1

'&.!6

!0- $#!""!(0 #*(

( $&"#%$ 7 .$!.!6

0!2 0!#$$.$%

(*6$.!"% $/#

**$%'&*!6 $ !

7!##

6&!$ 8!.

-- .&(!(013 #

!* # * 6$. (1 #

$ 6&

(!0- 0*(!0 0

.(1#

7*.!*/!**

.*7!#.

7$-4>-4B-

!"!8!

7%&

!$ $%#

!$.$%/ /$

#41 .$

** ! !03#!* $& !*!60! .$%8$& (016$ *!.

!* %$ (!0-

$%!(0

3!#!*

" .36( / /.

$'&."/ $%#!*$&

** .! + + +4 4 4 4!0 .*%!EF %!EF %!EF %!EF F#8

*&* $% 1 F#8

*&* $% 1.

.... $#

87#

.**&.

) G4- *

!0$"& $ #

!6!

)

6$.H*&66 **!8 /!!(0 !07@# *$0 01$# "

$&.$%/! - &6# 6$.H*&66 ** /!!(0 7#

7!#.

7H.!*/!** .*$

!!$7*.!*/!** $ * 6$.H*&66 *&66

.3 #

E&!

.$*#$7*&(*!06 $%/

%!6!0$ $* #$ !6

**!$ $% *

$&"#$( (* 6 .!$0 *&(*!03 %% 6!8 .6$* I $ 9#&*!8 "&!.

7#7$&0.6$*!& *&(* 6* #* !* $7 &!E& % !*$#!"(&&$ *0 %$# '&.!6!07!*.$/ 7!#*&6#* 6$.H*&66 **!8

I 6* $& 6#$$* (!0

!!$<*536$"

.0&6

6$ . %$ "

!" *& 6$.H*&66 **!8

!!$<*5- #8!" *&66 **%&001 6$.H*&66 **!8

!!$<*5 6!

% $/# *!.$ ($8 .!*6&**!$3 # %$00$7!"

(!0

!!$<*5 %!0 *&6#

!!$$&"#$$(

!(!0!1#

$%- *!8

(!0

!!$<*5

!!$ 7* .!*/!**

** .H.!*/!** .%$ $+

6&!$ .$/

!*- **!8

(!0

!!$<*5 $ $ !6 *#00 ( ** !001H

! 01 6#"

!6!

6&/*6 *.*#$7!"

*!(0 6#"

7$&0.$*&%%!6

2!" * 6$.H*&66 **!8 (!0 <*5

5 0!

!$*$%

!!$<*57!#$& E& !06#"

!6!

6&/*6 *- 0! *6 $**!(01( 0!..$7*$ !06#"

!6!

6&/*6 **

%6*H6!

6&/*6 - 2!" *&6# $ ! .

8$&

"$3#!*!**& !* /..!*6

!$$%# $& 0!"

(!0

!!$<*5- *$"

* 6$.H*&66 **!8

&6!.

*$*

! 01

E&!

$ &6# .

*&6# ( !"

7$ .*3# 6&* %$ $&

# 6$& 6 .H

! *&6# 5 $&"# $ (

.!01 . 60

** .-K --

&*0$%# J!/!$

** .(1# !0$& 3( $&"# #(1#

3!.!6 *## !0!* *!.

*!!".%$001

$%6$ $( *..0 .& $#

- -*

6&*$.16

!%!6 .

4-4A-4 % %!0 . (1 # 0 . 6$& * 03 #

#* 0

.1 *&%%

.!6

!$%$

!$.$%/$

#41 *34B/$#*. .1*3@!*$ $*#$7$( !8$08 .!1$

H-#!*8!

7$%#

3# "$ !/

6!$>$% %# 6*.*.!0& .! 0!"#$%# !60 $%# $*!&!$$% .!- --

#!* $& ! '&."/ !0 . * F&07!.

*&* $% F&07!.

*&* $% %%%% &'( &'( &'( &'( **

. ! ++B4>B B4>B B4>B B4>B+4B 4B 4B 4B <4 )

)44=5D %

01!"

$ # !

!$ .

6!.

.!$% # '&."/ * $% % # $:(0 &

$& !

&**! F F#$$8*- $/ 61-3 $% %!# <=A45 AD(.&0 0 #/& &018*- - 12<==5 D8 &0/ (! #!2# # 8*- $% # *# . $#

3 4B< <5 < !/!05 B=BD $#.

&*0!/ L

&**! 8*- < $% 0# #!5

. * 4 D D !/!0

0 $-BH44. .4>-4-4 4!0 .*G#!!*7*0!* &(#* 8*-

$% M * "0KD G !

!*# .#!2 1 L 8*-

$% M * "0K3

6!0 , 8 $

0 < 0-5 $-4+4 . -4A-4 !0 . * G$#//. 0/

!% #!2# 8*- $%

&' KD !/!0

0 $-=$%4 . .4-4A-4!0 .* 0 0 !*# L 0 &*/ 8*- !$ $% .!3 . 2& #&.# 1 8*- $%.# #1 .

*#34B<B5< !/!

!05>D#*# 0.3#&*) G>-A-

!"# $ *

.1 8!0*% "& .$

&.& . 9!

1.6$6

66$/ 1!"# !/ !

!# (!0!1$%66&* $8

6#!"*$6!

* 8!"7

.016& .!#

($8 +

.$ &

$& :*'& 6!*!$*$

!"& 78!**$%

.1 !0!*/0"/ .!$# %&./ 0 !"#$0!% .0!(

$*!&!$- !"# $ *

.1 1 .

.!!$&* !0 !* $ $01 . $

**!8 !6

!$D$/!!"

66&*!$*7 00*$6& !01 .$.

.#!/* 0%3(&#

!* 71%$ *

.1 !0- #!* !"##* *.# !$.

6!.

.!$%#

'&."/ *#8 0!..$7*

*$% % %&./ 0 !"#*- 6$6

!60 * ** !0 $%#

3"&

!0 ( "!* 7!# # 6&0

!/ . # !/ $% #

!$ 7#!6# 6$!& * !8 *!"!$3 !E&!

13 !03

'&.!6 #/1

*&0.& $!/

!/ $% # 6$//!**!$ $% # $ 6$*&// !$ %!0!13 6$&0. ( !".E&!62.!* $*0

*! E& $8

$7.

.$& +.$62 *3# # 8

**&

6&!$.# !/!0'&

!0/ 6#!*/& 6$( 96&* %$ 2

!"#

66&* .%$ !.

%!!

!$.$%!/ !/!0 '&*!6 *1* /3 #

! / "&

$% *

.1 !0 !* ! .

01 (1 !/ $*!" $ # $&

.7!## !07!#

*$(

%$0.

*013!

!0 !/

!*$/ D * 6$.013 !

&(0!6*&* !6!$.& $&

*$08 .6

"!* # !*2 # 8!.

7!00 (

**"

$% !/ 3 #&*3 !/ !

!" # #!/* 0%-"$ *7!#$&*1!"##

8 - 66&* .3

*&/ . ! *&('

. $ *16#$0$"!60 . #1* &.

$&*6$.!!$*- E&001!/ *&6#66&* .%

E& 01%00*# %/!01-

!* 1 $#

6$*!.

!$ #!* *"

00 66&* . ( !" !8$08 . ! 6$ (.&.

63=A !6* !8$08!"6$//

6!0E&

!"$& &/

6!$> # $& * 6 "

(!0 $ 6

6&$ .%

#8!"*!*%!

*$(0 "

$&.* %$ ( 0!

8!" # $%% 6# .H00 ..#3# 7#!0 $(!0- * !"

!"$& *$ /&* ( / !6&0$&*01 *6 &!!J %&./ 0 !"#$*

.1 !0- 6$(

.&"$ 1(1&7

!6&0 017#

*&6#.

01<*5!* '&*!%!

.# .$%#

6&!$ 6$ ( 2

( #!. ( * %$

%&"

! !"$& *0!..$7! 6!$ "!*0&

!!*7!*.$/3!$

$ *&.

63#*

$8!.

6!$+$%# 6- $7

6 ..

01*.*1* "!*0!8

-$& $%07 $( 6$/ 6$/ 0!6!!8!$0!$$ $7!#*.!"1#!"6$! .!

!!$!6* "$8

.(1# !"

* $% # 66&* . . 6$* E&

00 *"

*3 / 013 # *"

$% 0 .

8!*!$ *$ # 1 $**!(0

/!**!(0 .8$!.(0 01*!6

$%% !00 # 6 !/!0

.!"* 8

.- *

.1 !03 E&$$%6 !/!0'&

818$0&/ $%7$ 2.#

*&0

$0!6 3!.&(!(012

*# !

**.* !- $7

3#!*

*7$ .$%/$60 *#"!"$#

-.$ *$*

.!$#

/2 * %$ *. * $% %%!

. $ 8$!. $

**!$ .

. #

6&!$ $(0!"!$ $ $ .!* 6#- "&

* *# 66&* ."!*$

**!8

+ * # 66&* . $% # 9!

1 .

!/!06# *.0*013!

6* +

0$* $ / /$ * .!// . (1 #

(!0!1 $% # 66&* . $ .

6$* E& *$%

+ !0.

!$ $6 3 !00

$8 $#

7!* 3

*!60 .

!8!$* $% '!0+0!% 3 &*&001 !/ 3# (& $%.

!$$% 8!01$# !$6 / /(

*$%#!*

6 $% # /

7#!6# .

"!$* ! #

0 $

0!" $ 6$//

6!0 E&!1 $% $

=A-M#!0 6$*!.

!"(!0

!13# $& #*$2

!/!.#

>$% 63=A7#!6#/. 6

66&* . $01 %

# !" # &(0!6 .!* 0%$%7!6$.!!$*7#!6#

# # 66&* . !* $ "&!01 $% #

!*$0!2 01$6$//!1$%%

$% 6!$>$%# 63=A "!* # (62.

$% 66&* .:*

!"#$0!% .

*$00!(

01*!# '&.!6!0

**3 !#

!(&(0 $# 66&* .$

0 '

!$(1 6$"

*$*-!.!8!.&0 !$ .!

!$. $% !/ (1 2!"

!$>$%# 63=A-

.1.!/ 01.!* $*0$% .%$ 6$*!&!$$%*

6!0$&

3#!*$& 6$& 0*$:*

/!6! %%!6!

61#% &* #!* 7!*.&1+($&.$ *&

#!.$ $%!.!8!.&0:*%&./ 0 !"#*3 !0 !*& -M#!0 0!"7!#(!0 "$& *$% 6!$>$%# 63

=A3 # $& /&* * !2 '&.!6 ! $6& (# / 6 $%.

&"* $%!

.!!$&* !0- $0$ 6&* !*2* *%$ /!"

+ !0 .

$&6$/ !# !60$#

!6!

"$3# & E&!8$60 %!0 . $ 6$60&.

7!#!

*$ !6

!$3 ! /!0! * "!* #

. 0!(

1 "

. &.

07 $8

!.!"# *&$ /( "$6

63=A$&"#$( 6$*!.

.* 7$ .*3"

$%(!0!6*

$&.$%&.& 01! !036$ $%# 63=A-K 6!$&* (06 (

# 0 "!*0!8

.# *6 $*6 !"#$%# 66&* "

.!6

!$37!#$&'&*!%!(0

!$ !$ &!!8 !/

!*$/ 3

$%'&*!6 . E&!1-

0!%

!*#7#

!0#* $(0 !/

*&0!" !

$0$"

6!$&* %&./ 0 !"#* $% 0!%

7 .3 * *&6#3 6$.!!$0 0!(

6!$>$%#

%6*$%"!8 6* -$#

!!"$6$//

6!0E&!13$#

$( *!.$( %

.(1 6!$>

> &%%!6 $*13%&

!$$ $%#

*&.

!0!* $7

.!# %6*.6!

6&/*6 *$% %# >- 8!

7 $% ($8 3 #

!!$ !* 00$7 .-

.$(

(!0$#!*%& !*#!"(!0H*&

1($.*$#

*!*%6!$ $ $% # ,.- 6$6

!0 $&

H&1 "!* $7

3 ! ..!!$$6$ $.!!$*#/1( !/ .( (1# 6$6

!0$& H&1 "!* 3#

*#00

/!($&.( (1# %$00$7!"6$.!!$*)+ <!5

*#00$/!

<!!5

*#00$ .$6&/ 13.& !"#

<!!!5

*#00$( *+&* 0!(

.- /

7!#1 8!.

3$ 0$

!0- (* #!/* 0%$1. (

!0- <!85

*#00$6$/ <85

*#00 .

!0$& <8!5

*#00 "!8

8 *!"!"%%!6

*#00 $ 6#"

#!* 6

/!**!$$%# !0$& <8!!5

*#00$! <8!!!5

*#00 *&(/ //!1$%% 7#!0 $(!0- *! #!* ** 3 !% 13 7!# #

#!* 6 #$ &/(

$ #

$%6$6

.$0!6 !$.

00+ #$ &/(

7!#$&

H00E"!*

1$.

01# !0- /!3 $ # %!

* 7$ 2!" .1 $%

1/$#3%%!.8!3 $# %% 6## #*$ 1 $%% %

( !"

!*%$&.$( !

!" 0 .$(!0!

6$6

!0$& (

!8$08 .!6$//!**!$$%

. $ (!0- 6*

!8$08 .!1$%% %

#!*

3$# (*!*$%

#!*%%!.8!$ $#

7!* #7!#3 %$ 66 00!$ 6$& 3*#00( !$6!

3# !*/. .$/$8 $% #!* (!0 7#!6# 3 (& $%

.& $/

!*#

$%- A- 6* $% (

6# $% 1 $% #

*!. 6$.!!$* . #$*

7#!6#/1( !/ .(16$6

!0 $& H&1"!* *.!

!($8 $ & $*#$7!"1$#

*&%%!6 6!

6&* 3# H6$/ 0! *#00( 0!(

1$/$8 66 00!$$%(!0$ $%#

.66$ .!"01- 4- $#!"*!.#

!($8 *#00( 6$* .*

**!$$% !!$$# /

!*$%# - !6 /! 6* #* (

6!.

.!" /!*6 00 $&*

0!6!$3!% %13*#000*$*.*.!* .$ $%%- &"&*4> &"&*4> &"&*4> &"&*4>34 34 34 34 /#8!

2 M#

4 4 4 4 <

!"H

*$ .) *H $ ) *H $