← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7860/2015dismissed

Swaran Singh v. Vir Abhimanyu

2015-11-27Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih5 pages

   

  !

     

 "#$ %$&'(')* 



 +,"-")+')./ 0 $#'#')$- 1$-(2( 1'- 3/'4")52 0$(6)%$)#  * 78 + 

88

-$($)#* - "'%$$61$-4"9 %:&"#$ -#/$6$#'#')$- ;;;

 </$#/$- -$6-#$-(   =&"= 6"6$-( 4"5 3$ "==,$% # ($$#/$>2%.4$)#?

 3$-$ $--$%##/$-$6-#$-(-)#? @ </$#/$- #/$ >2%.4$)# (/2=% 3$ -$6-#$% ') #/$ %'.$(#? ;;;



88 -"= /$ $>$&#4$)# 6$#'#') 6-$ $--$% 35 #/$ 6$#'#')$- ,"( %'(4'(($% 35 #/$ $)# )#-==$-9 :'%$ -%$- %"#$% @  

 ( $:$) #/$ "66$"= 6-$ $--$% "."')(# #/$ ("'% -%$- "'=$% ")% ,"( %'(4'(($% :'%$ >2%.4$)# %"#$%

 

9=")%=-%6$#'#')$-'(3$ -$#/'(&2-# :'&#')   #/$ #$)")#-$(6)%$)# ,"( (2./# ) #,.-2)%('$))6"54$)# -$)#")%6$-()"=)$&$(('#5 -'$ =59 #/$ &"($ ($# 2# 35 #/$ 6$#'#')$- ') #/$ $:'&#') 6$#'#') ,"( #/"# #/$ -"#$  -$)#($##=$% 3$#,$$)#/$6"-#'$( ,"(

A6$-4)#/")%#/$#$)")#-$(6)%$)#,"(='"3=$ # 6"5 "--$"-(   -$)# ,$  2)$9 BBB 3$('%$( 2($ "C

)%9 #/$ 6$#'#')$- -$D2'-$% #/$ %$4'($% 6-$4'($( - /'(

  6$-()"=2($")%&&26"#')"("=( -/'(()9,/')#$)%$% #(#"-#"32(')$(( -$"%54"%$."-4$)#( ) %$ $)&$9 #/$ #$)")#-$(6)%$)# &)&$%$% #/$ -$="#')(/'6 =")%=-%")%#$)")#3$#,$$)#/$6"-#'$(932#'# ,"(4"')#"')$%#/"##/$-"#$ -$)#,"(

A6$-4)#/ ")% #/$ ("4$ (#% 6"'% # #/$ 6$#'#')$- 26# @ 



@ /$ ='"3'='#5 # 6"5 /2($ #"C ,"(   #/$ =")%=-% ) "&#9 =")%=-%,"(&"--5').)"32(')$(( 4'=E%"'-5")%"=(" &"=%$6#"#+/$-62-982%/'")"$,"("=(#/$,)$- #, #/$- (/6( #/"# -4$% 6"-#   #/$ ("4$ 32'=%').9 "( #/$ %$4'($%6-$4'($(9")%#/$($,$-$')/'(&&26"#')$"=( ,)$%#/$-6-6$-#'$(('#2"#$%"#+/$-62-9 43$%E"-"."-9 )$"-"3"/")+').//,E")%">62-"%982%/'")"$ /"% &)(#-2&#$% (/6( ') #/$("'%6-6$-#5 ")% ,"("=( -2))'). " 4'=E %"'-5 ') #/$ ("4$ 6-$4'($( $ /"% =$# 2# %'

$-$)# 6-#')( ')&=2%'). 2- (/6(   #/$ ("'% 6-6$-#'$( ('#2"#$%"# 43$%E"-"."-#%'

$-$)##$)")#( &&-%').=59 '# ,"( 4"')#"')$% #/"# #/$ $:'&#') 6$#'#') ,"( '=$% ,'#/ " 4"=" '%$')#$)#')9)" '&#'#'2(.-2)%9#($$E$:'&#') #/$#$)")#-$(6)%$)# ) ") ")"=5('(   #/$ 4"##$- ') '((2$ ")% #/$ $:'%$)&$ ) -$&-%9 3#/ #/$ "2#/-'#'$( &)&2--$)#=5 &)&=2%$% #/"# '# ,"( 26) #/$ =")%=-%6$#'#')$- # 6-:$ #/"##/$-"#$ -$)#,"(')%$$%

A6$-4)#/2##/$ -$='")&$ 6="&$% 35 #/$ 6$#'#')$- 26) #, -$)# -$&$'6#( ,"(

@

2)%#3$,/==54'(6="&$%9"(#/$($,$-$)#:"='%=56-:$% )&$%$%=59 -'.')"= -$&$'6#( ,$-$ ') 6(($((')   #/$ 6$#'#')$-932#,$-$)$:$-3-2./#)-$&-%) "&#9=")%=-% +,"-") +')./  <  &)&$%$% ') /'( &-(($C"4')"#') #/"# #/$ ("'% -$&$'6#( ,$-$ )# '((2$% 35 /'4 32# 35 /'( "#/$- :$)#/$-,'($9#/$-$&$'6#(6-%2&$%35#/$6$#'#')$-%'%)# 3$"- ")5 (/6 )243$- + 42&/ (9 $:$) #/$ )"4$   #/$ 6$-() -4,/4#/$("'%-$&$'6#(,$-$3#"')$%"=(%'%)#

')% 4$)#') #/$-$')  $)%-($4$)# - ('.)"#2-$(   #/$ #$)")#,$-$3#"')$%#/$-$26)/2(9'#,"(&)&=2%$%#/"# #/$-$,"()4"#$-'"=)-$&-%#=')E#/$("'%-$&$'6#(,'#/ #/$ %$4'($% 6-$4'($( "( "=( #/$ #$)")#-$(6)%$)# /$ ,'#)$(($( $C"4')$% 35 #/$ 6$#'#')$- '$ <   <@9 ,$-$ &)&$%$%=5 )# #/$ ,'#)$(($( # #/$ #$)")&5 $('%$( #/"#9 )#/'). ,"( 3-2./# ) -$&-% # (/, #/"# #/$-"#$  -$)# ,"( ')%$$% 

A 6$- 4)#/ (')&$ #/$ ')&$6#')   #/$ #$)")&5 ) #/$ &)#-"-59 ('4 -"3/"E"-9 =$-E9 9 82%/'")" <  3-2./# #/$ (244)$% -$&-%   6-6$-#5 3$"-'). 

A@9 "3" /") +')./ /,E9 82%/'")"9 ,/'&/-$:$"=$%#/"##/$-$)#"=:"=2$ ("'%(/6,"(-$&-%$% "( 

A 6$- 4)#/ $&-%( (/,$% #/"# ") "42)#   

F9

A,"(%$6('#$%35#/$#$)")#962-(2")##")-%$- "(($((4$)# 6-:'(')"=-$)#,$  2)$9 BBB# 2=59

"=).,'#/&(#(")%')#$-$(#/2(9#$)")#-$(6)%$)#&2=% )#3$$:'&#$%)"&&2)# ))6"54$)# -$)# (-$."-%(

F #/$6$-()"=3)" '%$)$$%9'#,"(3($-:$%#/"#"=#/2./#/$ 6$#'#')$-/"%&="'4$%#/"#/$,"('%=$")%#/2(-$D2'-$%#/$ 6-$4'($( # ($# 26 " 32(')$((   -$"%54"%$ ."-4$)#(9 ")% $:$)/'(()')#$)%$%#>')/'4')#/$("'%:$)#2-$932# #/$ #/-$$ ()(   #/$ 6$#'#')$- #, ,$-$ ($##=$% ') 2(#-"='" ")%#/'-%(),"((#'==(#2%5').#,"()#4"%$&=$"-"(# ,/'&/ #/-$$()("&#2"==5-$D2'-$%#/$6-$4'($(-')#$)%$% # >') /'( "#/$- ') 32(')$(( "#/$-9 $:'%$)&$ ) -$&-% 6-:$% #/"# =")%=-% /'4($=  ,"( $)."

$% ') 6-6$-#5 32(')$(( + 42&/ (9 6$#'#')$- /'4($=   <  &)&$%$% ') /'(&-(($C"4')"#')#/"#/"%#/$#$)")#6"'%#/$-$)#9#/$-$ ,2=% /":$ )$:$- 3$$) ")5 %'(62#$ ,'#/ /'4 $ "=( &)&$%$% #/"# /$ /"% )# 6-$6"-$% ")5 6->$&# -$6-# - '):$(#4$)#6=") -#/$6-6($%32(')$(($"=(&)&$%$% #/"# /$ /"% )# %'(&=($% #/"# /$ ,"( &"--5').

 ")%

 "# #/$ #'4$  '=').   #/$ 6$#'#') + 42&/ (9 )$   /'( ,'#)$(($( '$ ")4/") +')./  <  -$:$"=$% #/"# #/$ =")%=-% "=( /"% ")#/$- 6-6$-#566('#$#/$-"% &&-%').=59'#,"(&)&=2%$%#/"# #/$=")%=-%,)$%")#/$-#,(/6(932#/$/"%&)&$"=$% #/'( "&# /"# 3$'). (9 '# &2=% )# 3$ &)&=2%$% #/"# #/$ "==$.$%)$$%A-$D2'-$4$)# #/$6$#'#')$-,"(.$)2')$93)"

'%$-&)&$':$%').% "'#/

 8$"-)$% &2)($= - #/$ 6$#'#')$- &2=% )# 6')# 2# "( # #/$ &)&=2(')( #/"# /":$ &)&2--$)#=5 3$$) -$&-%$% 35 3#/ #/$ "2#/-'#'$( ,$-$ $'#/$- &)#-"-5 # #/$ 6('#'))-$&-%-(2

$-$% -4")54"#$-'"='==$."='#5 ')#$- $-$)&$'(,"--")#$%')$C$-&'($ -$:'(')"= >2-'(%'&#')9 2)%$- +$&#')    #/$ "(# 2)>"3 -3") $)# $(#-'&#') &#9 BFB $#'#') 3$'). %$:'%   4$-'# '( "&&-%').=5%'(4'(($% :$43$- 9

 ">")  -2) "=='  2%.$