← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/826/2009disposed of

Sucha Singh v. State Of Punjab

2015-07-06Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mr. Justice Satpal12 pages



     

"#

  $%&$'& (()) *+% $ %,- (.

  $%/&0.+$'&1((2 (()) *+% $ %,- (.

+ 3+$(+$'&4.54+&(()) 33,+&+%6%)4..)4 %,-4+&+(.   

     

 

 "7&&+ (++))((+02-))8.&,%.'09  !-+++.& (+++9  :7&&+&,%.'0&%).-+(+.&'9     &+.+&)).(+0.8(()  ;!

<!

=> "

<!

=(+++.-2$%&$'& . $%/&0.+ $'& 1 ((2 +(5)2 ' & ,%.'0  5.+.+..!"

;!

=(.-2&%.'4$() %+4 +)4 8&+-2 -& & (()) 8+ 5. +   (%&-)%.+$"#&++%'> 2&+($%- 4"=;#?&++)).@&@A..%.+'+'+% 0(+0+(+."#2+.(2 ")&

.%)  (20  4 & .%)+ 8 .+.  %.+' +'+% 0(+0+(+.2+ & (+%  8   0  & -  +%B ?C A-2(+ ,&6%0+4$ 4 $&%)!

&&&)'8&&+())8(+&&8/ & +  *))' &   !

   8& () /-..&/'&5&)-%;: 34+%/-+'  <:" < : # 0 +0 & .  *))' & 4 8&& 8 ').  ( -2 $ 3)/ $'&  & .+5+  & +%/ .  (('&04+.(.82%%(4&.+%/8 ((.(+ ,&6%0+)'8&&$'&08+. &.+5+..((+&..&.+5+48&+$'.($'&. %+-&$'&08+.&.%+..((+&..& (+'&.%+.&++4$'.($'&)'8& &+())&/.&++.&+%/48&+&+(+ 8+%.'&'%2-' %.&+(+48(+ ). 82 -2 /' .

5'  .+/4 8&+  (+ 8 ((+&..   & 004  ,.+() $&+0   0+ D) $&+0++5.&+.&8,.&()(+2 B%+24& .+5+).&0$%&$'&,0+$'&48&+&(+ '&.%+..&(+'&-/.&+%/ ).&+03&.+$'&3)$'&.$%/&0.+$'& 1((2+(5)2 %+&+B%+24&2.).&0&+ 0(48&).8246&+$'&0$'&.-.

:

'%2 -' )2'  & +%/ &5 ' 0 ))') C' %-4 & +0. )) & %. -% &+ +'& . %'& &+ (++&&+&(+E. ++3'+ ))&%.(+(.&&28.'+&.&'%2-' )2'&+%/&(+E. +&+0 & +'+. 8+ ++.. (+)2  &++4 (+ ,& 6%0+ +B%. $ +' $'&4 $%- 5 +)4  +&  & (

%+%&+4$ +'$'&4)'8&&+&.&( -%"

:

3+((+'&0)4$ +'$'&'+0.)) &%.-%&++'&.%'&&+(++&&+& (+E. ++3'+))&%.).&&2 &5&&0.&%).'&'%2-'+&.$(+ 00&+'+.8+(+(+. .+&+.+$ +'$'&4 & +%/ 8 ' %).. &+%'& & )  :  '%2 -' 8+ +5+.+0&+%/ ('4))&'%2-'8+%.- '(((2&%/80()!# '+0&8+(+.+0 & -' . 5+.  (+ ). (+) 0+/.  "F"  :

F:

 8'&04&+0'(((2<&%/&-'0- :G#

6'))&'%2-'.0()8+).8&&)H 6I -)''(+ ,&6%0+.H $I-)''$ +'$'& +%4(+ ,&6%0+&..5+&),.+()$&+0 +/'())&+)4(+)+&&%.8 .%.+%)8&& #

F<4 :

F<> "

F<8++5+. +0$%/&0.+$'&4$%&$'&.3&.+$'&+(5)2  &-%&+%B4  ?C F"A+&(%&-)%.+$

"#  &  8 +'+. ' $%/&0.+ $'& 1 ((2J $%& $'&J3&.+$'&J6&+$'&.-.$'& )) & &+ %. ++.  & ( )'8& +  (+(+2 8+ (+.%. -+ & %.) 3'+  )4 +) 

48&.+..%&3&.+$'& 8"

=!

4%.D/&5+$'&16&+8++. + 0()  5' . &+ +0)4 +(+ %.+ $ " : +  8 %-0.  & %+ ' $%/&0.+ $'&1((24$%&$'&.D/&5+$'&16&+48&+%. 3&.+ $'& 8   & %5) %+   +)  $%-B%)24 + & ++  %. +'-. $'&4 %(()0+2 &)) 8 (+.'&048&&8+.+.-&.8&&0&))  02 - 0. & .%+' & %+  +)4 %. D/&5+ $'& 1 6&+..   +%)  8&& (+.' ' &0 .-. %+' +)4 & (+% & C0. 7<"  $+-,4 8& .+. & .5 C   5.J 7<! -) .

+ 6%0+48&).+.&.5C 5.J 7<:&.%+ &.4 4++(+ 4%0'+&48&(+5.&++. +(+%/-+' <:"<< : #J 7<G(+ ,&6%0+4 &5'' +48&.(.8&+'+.&5'++. %-2&0. 7<#$ +'$'&?

.A-+8&0&+&. +5+2(+.'8+++.%

#

+)%&(+%5.4))&+0' +%0((+''&%.8+(%&08&)++.' &+ 0 %.+ $ :": +   85+4 &2 ().. ) 0()   .4 &2 C0. 7<"  6+0, $'&J 7<! ,.+()$&+04&))'..(.8.7<:$%&)6%0+ &(+4 .) +4 &+ +) D0.4 8& -+%'& & ++. (+'  3-) =; !!"";G:  & 0  '.( $'& . =;"G#;!:#:  & 0  6+& 6%0+ % . (+5. & 0  C .   +(5)2  85+4 & )) .) C  (+  3-)=;

G="=G; +''&+%'&&5.++.4&)+.+)%+ B%. +'-. $'&  & &+' )5)). ' &04 8&+ 5. . . $%/&0.+ $'& . $%& $'&4 & (+ (())40.-5 + & %+4 )+. %) + & (()) %).  .(%2(+&0&(+%8(%2 2  85+4 & +'%. &  (+ & (+% 7<! ,.+()$&+08,..(.885+4&8 C0.-2&(+%'24-%-2&.(+%) + & (())4 7<! ,.+() $&+0 & .. & (+  +5+2 &5' - 8. -2 &0    ) +'%. & &%'& & 0()8+.+8!

F!

4-%&08+& & &0) C0+ 

;!

  + & .)2  0+ & ! &%+&++4%&.)2)&(+%)+'%. & 7<G(+ ,&6%0+4&5'' +.$'.(

$'&4 8& ((.&+%/ . ((+&.. & %.48+ & +B%&0))'.+5+248&&5.+0&+ 0-))).)(+.%.C> &%4&+2(+(%..-2 &(+%+)-).+%8+&2&-8&&5 &(+(())-%. 7 &5 &+. )+. %) + & (+  )'& . (+%. & ++. +%))2   .%-4 & (+% & ,. 7<! ,.+() $&+0   .(. 84 -% & ((+.  . 8 . .. & & 8 ,. -2 & () (+2 &.. -2 7<G (+ ,&6%0+4&5'' +85+4&.(.& & & - 5' $&%) )8& & +. ),.

+ $'&4 8& 85'+08&(+ ,&6%0+%+&+.(.& &'%+8+(+%+.-)/((+48&&5. $&%) .+%/+..7.&7<!,.+()$&+084 8&-+).%(.&&5. $&%))'8& &+.),.+$'&48&85'+08&(+ ,& 6%0+%B%8/.)'&2+<C0 7<G (+ ,&6%0+4&5'' +48&&+&/8 2(+-2&0),.+$'&+&,.+()$&+08 8&+5+2(+ &+4 7<G(+ ,&6%0+4 &+<C0.&,.

+()$&+08/8&0 +&+00-+&()(+2$0)+)24B%8/.8& +'+.&-''%+,.+()$&+0-)/((+ (+ +0 &4 8 . & '%+  7<! ,.+() $&+0 ((+'  %0+% ((+  .%0   . .

+5+2  +-.   .+ ()  & (' ,% -& & 8+'&+&++4.%)-)5&%0+%'%+  5+% ((+ &5' .+ 8+' 0+) %). - '. -2  8-)/((+4&+5+2(+.(+5.-2& 4&+.+)-)02 7<G(+ ,&6%0+4 &5'' +48&&8++-+.-2 7<#$ +'$'& &&(())8+((+&..&(&+++& () )  .( ' & (())  &+   ))'  02 ' & () )  ))2 0() & (())  & (+&++48.&&)+.+)%++'&)2)%..

 & <C0  ,.+() $&+0 + &+ & && - 85+-2&%..+2.%-&(+%+2 +(+'%0&&)).)C. &8 & & () ) 0)2 7<G (+ ,& 6%0+ . $ '.($'&8+&+B%&0))'.+5+24 8 . & %& +'%0  '  -)  7&) ((+'  & 8<-C4 7<G (+ ,& 6%0+  & +<C0 . &&+)50&0-)%0-+8=; :G="=G;.&0-) %0-+  $ '.( $'& 8 =; !!"";G:4 8&+ & )) .) C .   (+  0-) =; !!"";G: . =; G="=G; +(5)2&0-)%0-+.).

-2 7<G(+ ,&6%0+   5+ 8& & ++. (+.%.  0-) =; G="=G;  $)) %+&+4+<C08.%.+(&8&&+& 8 8  5)-)  & +  B%  & 0  ))'. +5+2  & %.<(()) 8+ ) . )2 -2 )%.

;

0-)%0-+&++4)2&-)).)C. (+.%.-2&%.<(())4-&).&&()) 8+(+&+B%&0))'.+5+2 +(&+'%0&0()8+& &&0)C0+8& !&%+4)+.%)+&(()) +) %( %0-+  ,%.'0  & %+ %&  $%/&.5 $'& 1 $%/&*$ %,-!

?"A  ?+0)AGJ +0.+$'&* $+2!

?GA  ?+0)AG=#J'0&$'&1'* $ %,-!

?:A  ?+0)A=

J+3&00.*$ +2 !

; ?:A   ?+0)A !GGJ 6+ $'& * $  +2 "

?:A  ?+0)A =

2)*$ %,-!

"G?"A  ?+0)A# !J 0D%-&2*$ %,-!

"G?"A  ?+0)A

=  > +& 1 3) * $  %,- !

"G ?#A   ?+0)A "

!4 8&+&%+&.&5&-&&0() 8+8& !&%+(+&$.'+%%.-2& ++)%+%85+48.&&.,%.'0.)2 .8++)8&)'&&,%.'0&I-)$%(+0%+ +(+.6&$'&* .?!

!AG$:;

 6&$'&I?%(+A4$.' +.+"F;;.$.' +.+ !F;; 8+ +++.  + +++'  & +%4 & I-) $%(+0%+&).&))8' K= & )+. %) + & (()) .. & & +% %. -2 & + +) %+%4 8 )&4 8+  ))8..&E%+008(+(+.&(.&+8 .)2.('&E..+%'&'.88+'%.&&& %. +% (+,%.  & %. . &++4 & 5  5.&%

=

"

&+%%.-2&++)%+%48)& +-))8.-2&+<&+'&5'&+0 0'8&&(%+58& $45&%'&&+% .&5&+)8&2+..'%.&+.  &  + (+.%+  .(. -2 & + <&+'  & 5'   +% & 8&  +-. +)  E. .%+' 5'++&4E%+0&E+&%).-(+(+.&( +. 8& )8 &+ 024 &85+4 - +%0  8&&  8%).&5-(-)+&+(+(+&0&E+& (402-&+5+2.

&+02&5&)2 (+(+E%+0&E+&()&E%+.& ()8&+&++8.&+)2+8'&'& +-. +) + &+ +B% ) + )/'4 & +  (+(+ & E%+ 0&E+   )+ '  . 8& & ) + 5)-)4(+5..&++,%-).+-)'+%.. &548&+&E%+0&E+(+(+.)+'4&+ &%)..&+8&2&&.(+(+.&0&E+& (  +5+2  &+  2 +. .)2  (+(+' & E%+ 0&E+4&02'5((+%20(+8&&+-.+) ))'.)2 E. +0 & %.

 &+ 02 ) - ))' & & +)E.8-2)%-%..0&+08+(). ))20()&%.5.&%(%+%0. &5+(+.%++(+&.E%+4)82.+-) (+(+ & E%+ 0&E+  & ( ) +0 8&+ & +-. +)8+/%.2L &.,%.'08))8.-2&I-)$%(+0%+ $ %,-*3/&&.?!

GA:$G#:4&$.' +%F$.' +.+ %. -2 & + +) %+% + & '%.)%.-2&%+%+'%).+)&++)8+/' ++)%+%%&+2-)&.-2&+)5+0 C+(8+++.%.+$G?:A&$%&%&+2  + & (%+(  C+' (8+ . %  & +) 5+0%.+&&+)5+048&0(8+. +0 %)+0$ &+&$5+0%.+

"

$ ;&&++)%+%.+02 %) %.+& $)) %+&+4 $.' +.+ "F;; (++-. & (+.%+ + .+8)4+'4'..()0()+0E.+.+%'. (2&+(%-$%&+%&5-%.+0)& %'&+&++)%+%8&(%). &0()0%-.(.8& !&%+&E%+4 $#!&48&&.)8&&.()(+++.. +)E.&.$+.%.+ K"  ()  (+ ++. . +) E. M ?"A 2 + ++'(+%.+G"4G!4G:+GG&))4 02-4+0&0&'+%.+%&++ ?!

A 5+2(+++..+)E.%.+8++%.%.+ %-<?"AG"&))-+8+..8&%%+2.)2 &3'+-28&0&8++8%. ?:A #$%&'$%()*%%$(+$,*),*%+-./$($-0$,1),$%(12 ($.+-)3 4 ($.+-)5 ($.+-)5 ($.+-)56%($.+-)55(7*//2$%8*%,$,8-+71+ 1))$.$((*%&,$/*&+M ?A &+<<&+'&+()4+ ?-A &+0(8+.%.+#: ?GA &%&+2++8&02(+++)+8+.. %.+%-<?!A+%-<?:A&))48&))5.(&4 /%&0%+02-+2+&.()+.')8 %&(+++)L?N0(&%(().A $#!&4+(+.%.-54.(++-2 (+. .

%+' 8&& 0()   -    )2 2 & 5+2 (+ ++..+)E.&))-+8+..8&%%+2.)2& 3'+7&&+%+2+%+-).)2B% .(.'%(&3+&&0()8+ &&&0)C0+8& !

""

%+2.)2&++4))&,%.'0&%+4+++.-2 &)+.%)+&(())4&5-+.+.8&%'& ,%.'06&$'&I?%(+A.3/&&.I?%(+A. .)2.8-.'(+. &(+4&0().&%.8+(+.%. -+&3'+!

(+&.5.+.-2 7<" $+-,$'&4&+/'%:

0()(+)(((2&%/). 8&)H 6I>H $I+0&3)/&&..5+&0-) .+6%0+

;!

8&.++'.(&%0-+. +8+.'+0&&$$ 4+).&.(&0 8& &   & &0) C0+4 &.'+&  $0)+)24  (+ .5.+.-2 7<!-).+6%0+4&.(.&0() (+)8&&&0)C0+4&.'+&

;!

. +%+&&..5+&+(3 ;

;!

&&0 &5'+))2.&))&0(+(+2+0.8&&0 &+ &2 + 2-.2 ) 0(+. 8&   +)24 &+   +. .)2 . .)24 0() 8+ +5.  ).  .&++4&+'&&(())8+'.2 0+ &%4 8 .  . 2 +++  & .' ++.. -2 & )+.+)5'&(())+%.+$"#&  85+4 /('  58 &  . +%0  & 4 8 &/ & &  0(. -2 & )+. +) %+  C5 +.')2480.2&0(.%(&(())&

"!

+'+%0(+0+"

2+. "4

F<&(+. 0(+0.%)%&&))%&'. 7&&.-+5.0.&4-& &(()+.(.  ?3

A  

"# ?D$DDA *0)