← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1238/2004dismissed

Kewal Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2023-06-08Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat19 pages

     

 

 !    

"#$ %& $'()(%*

+ ,+  

       

    

- . +

 ++/0  



   !"   

 #    !"  $"%  



& 

  

++/0

+ 1.

The present appeal has been preferred by the appellant challenging judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 14.05.2004 passed by the learned Judge, Special Court, Jalandhar,  #   " !" "$$  "  " '(  ""  )#"

" "

"  '*+(  ,           2#3$   '#4-      "   $ $  #  #  ' .. .../0  

" "  13 .1 1... 4  

 53  4 !   6"     !     " "  7

"

!  8    "!    "   $                  "0""      $

 #

8   # ""     !,8    -     !   8   "" "  #"

    4 $  ""  "  # 4 ! 

6"    $ " #   

% 7 

    $  $94   " '( 

 "      #$  $   

 % $        :    "

        6    94 "# ""   !    #  

     #  7!  $  "0""#   "#  # ##$ ;

        

  "

  " "$  <"  51 

% $    "  $       <  "    ! $      2 ""  "

" "$ $  "  "  $ "  $$       "

   #  $  $8  #     ""     ##$ 9  $1(. $ $"

   

 $  : ## 8  ;.8 =(. $# 8 "



 (.

$(. " ! "    4 !  6"  ! $ >4>                  !    $  >>  2 "$  2       4 !  6"  ! 7

2

 "  8   # "  ""    $#    2       !    " "# "  "# 

7%  " 6 1= .1 1...   "# "# 4  %   4:  

" ?@ 

2 $  "

$"@$   #  "   # 8

    "

    %"  $  

  "$  ! " ""# "  " !    $ "

  " '( 

 " 2 ""   " " "$ (

4         "  "     " @$ @  7% $8

@$ 5'        !  ?@     ! "    

   " B  @$ 51  "

     $ ?!  "" !    "

" "   " <"

       ""    "  "    $      " "  $$  "

" "   "

"  @$ 5;7%C 

   7% 13 .1 .1...   "!#  $   $ "#  $   "#    $  $    # $  $ 5A 

 @$ ! "   "0""  

  4     %      @$     5(    " ""  "#   "  %   ""   "  "#    "    ! " 7% C   

      "  "   4  4   

  @$ 53  "  76" "  #  # 7   ""    

"

  8  " $  $       ""   "  8     

 : ## 8        ! "   "   

!  "     $  6     94                            2           (. # 8 7" "   !  

" " ! "  $   """ " ;';%  % 7 

 "    #$"   " # 

   

  ! #  82$ 6 13 .1 1...



 "8# "  #$ 

  4 "    %         "

 " #  $#  

  #$    7  & 

     # " !"#   "% #  # 8  "      #$"   " =

""@$ 7% 8  

 5'   

94  '=A''

'.

'*** " ;.1/;A4%  "

     $  $B 4    ""2$D$   

$ 2$ ?!   "# 94 @ ?@

'   $ "    "   $B ?!  % 

  

@$  51  @ " "$  " +

B "   ! $ #    %  " ! "#   """!  $  $  # % 7 "    "  #"!" $   " $   "     

""# " % : #    0"$ "$ # ! " A1 

 "    ": #      $  !  " "     ! ?! "  8"":       " "    ?!  %9B$       "   # 2   %9B$ 

, !#!    $ $    ## 9B $        #$ @$     "8  $      8  ""     # !!   "    % 7!    " "  " "     ": *

6  $ $#  "       "    !  " A1 

 " "   "   "!#$""  !  " A; 

 "" $     %  "        " "            9      "     " " " #      0  %9B$  ?!  ! #$ !# "" " @$ # "

7!   " 8!   $ ?!   "":     $   " ;';%  %   $ " " # % '.

4 !  "    %"   " ''

$  $              0"$ "       $ #  !   

 "  A1     

  "  B   "         ! $ #     "  "# # 534 

"!" $     " ""    : # "  

7!  " $   "      

""   !  "  #  $?@ ? "  "  ! $    "   "$ "       $ #  !    " A1 

 " 7!   "   $ #  "    5     ! " A1 A; 

 "  7 >$% %$    ;''1..1 E (6$'#%6"#$ %& $7$*8$ "*9 %#3$6) :)+ %3";;$9 ()"6 %<("= " .( '1 1..=   0  

  

 



  

 

  



 





 







!

 

   " #



  #

 

$

"  "    #

 

" 

"" 



%  

&'(   

   

 

 

   



 

%  

&(   

  

 "   

  





" 

 # 

 

!





 #

  





)





*

 



 "



   !

 

%  

&'(   







 "   

 !



 "  



 

"  " 

+  





 

,"



  







 !

 "   



" 





   

  

   "  





    

#



 

  



   



 



    

  !

 "      

'-.



 /  /    



 "" !





 % "    



 " 

 



 





  !

 

 





 

    



 "   

  

   !

 



   





  

 



 !

 "  

+

 "

 

  



#



  



 "   

 

 ""   #

 

$    





 "  

 

 "

+

 "

 

 











 

"  "  

"



 #  " 

 

     ""  

!

 

 #

 







 #  

"   



   #

    "     #

   

  #

  #



 





"    



" 



  #

  

 "   

 



 "  









"

 "  #

 

"  " 

 , " 

  





"  " 

 " !

#

!



0



 

#

 " !

!



 

 



 

 

  



" 



*



  !

 

#

 

 1  " # 

 

 #



 





" !

)

!





 



 "   

 







 "





    

 









 " "   "  " 



 

#  



  !





#

   "

  #

 #

 " !

 !

" 



 

 " "

  !

 

 

$  " 





" 



  !

 

 



 

 

 "       

3

      

 

  "  "

  





 ,



 #

#

 "  

 #

!

"

 

 

$ !

  !



 

 #

 " !

 





 















 #





 !

 #

#

 " !



  " 

 

" 

+



   

  4%  +

 

          

           





   !"#$%&$'())$''*  ''  &   +,-     #  

 

$

"  " 



/

"  &// 

5%6

 .(

7.

+





 #



  



 

   

 



 

$

 " 

 "



"  " 

)

 #



 " 

  

 

  

   ""  

8 

 

 

  





""  

 "





$  # 

 

"  " 

 



  % "  

 !



 " 

  

 

  

 !

 

8  

 $  

""

  !







$ 



!

3 '

) $ 

 



!

 

9!



:

 





     /



 "  

 

 

 9!

 





,  



 

  

3 '

 

  



$

3  #



  #  % "      

.;



  

 0# /



# !

 



3  





 



   

  

 

 

" 

  !

 " !

  < ....

.....

....

 +

%  / , 

%  =>1/1??1??4 ?? /@9.'

&??( ' // '55

&?? // &/( '.;'



/

    #  

 " 

  

 

  

" 

 

 

  

" 



!

  !



 "

 

 

 !

$

!

"  "  



!

  #  "

! "





 "

   

 

  



  "   

 





 



0

   

  



 !

" 

  

 

  

   



  "   

 

2,"  

  

 !







 ""





 

 ,"



A"  " B  

!

"  

! 



"

   " 

  !

 

 



 "  < '1 4   # 7 F$% $ %%#"

(*>3 :)+ #"#$ %& "6?"*"

  6(;( *"<  "*9   1   0

 '?

+

C   #

 /



:  



/

  4% D.

+

   



  



01

 1!2'''3%&&4*'''%&&2& 35)6 



   "    

  

  

&'(  &(

  %7  0  !2''3)%&&)5*''%&&2& 3-6  



  

  

&'(  &(  

  

) 





  



  &( )  

 #

   

E



 



%  

&'(   

F  !

" 



 

 #

 #

       

 "!

 

  

"

 " #



  



  

&(

 &(   

&'(

&( :



   



  

  



 " 



   



    

"   !

  

  !

  "

   



   



    

 !

 !

    

 #

    #     

!

 



    " 



 

 #

   

#

 



 

  

  

"  

&(

 &(   

&'( 

 



" 



   

 #     



 



 

"

&( +

  

  "    

  

  

&'(  &(

#

  # 

   

  

 # "!







" 

 

  !

"



!

 

$ !

 

:

" 



 #  #

 



  # 

   

 # 

 # "!





 

" !

#

"

"  !

    "



 





!



$

) 



  # !

 ," !

&( 3 



 % "      



 

&'(  &(   



 " 

 

 !  "    

 !

,"  



  !

 "

   "      



)  



 !

 !

!



   " # 

 #

    # 

!    



 #

 #

   

 

  #  

  %  #  "!



   



 

"   

!



 

  

  



:



   



  

 "   

 " 



 



 



  

 

 "   

 

 #

   

 

 



 "!





 

"





"



  #  

  

  

 

 

   !



 "   





   

 





 

"





  

  

  

 

 

3 



 

  "      

 







 

 

 

)  " 

#

 #    

    

  

 !



 ??'

&2 "

( ''

+

9#*  #  

0

 

  





+







  &

  

" .

 

   ( 



" 



"



 

  

 #

  

" 



  

  





/

  #

  

C   #



  4% D'

3

 

&( 











  

 # 

%  

&'( 



 "!



 

  



)    

2,

%'.

 



 /  G

 



"

   



2,

%'  2,

%'

)

  

 

 !

 0# /

  #



    



 

   

&(

'-

+





,

 

 





 " 9# 

    

&'(  &( 



 

  

  

+

" ' 

 *# 

 " 9#

 

  # 

  

0 

 # 

 

 % "      

&(     !

  #



 " !

2,

%'  2,

%'.

  !



  

 

 

 "      

&(

) " 9#   #

  "    

 " 

  

&'(  





 

 

 # 





"

"

#





  !

 !

  H 

 

"

 2,"  

  

 

 



  

" 



"

  

 



  !



   !







 

) 0# /



  

    #



 " 9#

3



"

 , 

    

 

 

 "

    

  

  

&'( " 

6

   #



   *# 

 /



:   



    



 %  "      

  

  .?

 " 

  

 !  "    

 !

,"  

 "

   "      



) /



:   

 



  

  

" .

) "



 



 "      

&'( " 

# 

 

  "  

 



  % "      

&'( " 



   

 

  # 

 

 

       " ! #  

 " 

  



3



  



 0# /



# !

 



 %  "      

&'(   

&(  "  

  

 0# /





 

 !



# 

 

 

 &2 "

( 7'

)  

 "

   !







  



"  

! 



    # #

   I"

 #

) #

 

/  



 

 



"  

  





   )

"

H 

) ,"  

  







"

   



   

 ,"



7"  " <

,"  

 

 

  



 #  

  





/

*#*  # J 0

  

" 

  

 

 

  

        

 

   <

5 ';

!  "  "    " "! " $   ""     ! ?!    " # "  ""   !# : # # 8    "    ! "  "   % : #  "!# "   8 "$E""G @  " A; 

 "  !  " A1 

 " " "   " " A; 

 "  @ E""G " #"" !# "     #  "  # "" "

5   "!#(. # 8"  ""  E""G    "$ " $ #  !     "  A1      

  "       $ #  "   $ 'A %    $ $#  "        " " (. "   '((. # 8

% "#   "#   %  $  2   % 

#!     

!  (.       #  8        "0""  2        "0""   #$  ?!    "   #@         

, $    % 

# !  " ;( (A 

 " " ;(

 "   $ "$  "" 9  " (A

 "!$ $ ""  $"0 + 6$)8;@#(%* &6%;

@%))$))(%* %& (<<('(# "6#('<$) +









!

"  



 

!

" 



   

 %



  





 "

%%%% &( !

  #  "

! "

  

 

K &( !

" """!





" 

  " 

# # 

!

   

 K &( !

""

" !

 #   !

#"



" !

"

 

    !

  #   ! " 

  

 

K  &( !



  # !

"



      #   !%

" 

  

 



 !

  



 

  !

  #   ! " 

  

 

 



 



 "



   

 

%

 !

'( 4 " " (A 

 ""     ""   "   ""  $"# 6 "      "$  " "     4 $" (A  "  $  " "     "  #

 ! "         $   $        $ $ 51 

 534 4 

       "    "!#"$ $ % : #  % 

#  .3 1. $  .1 1...  (.     "    '((.  8     #  8   "!$ " "     2  %   "   $ #   "    %9B$    : #  " 4 "  " " " " #      %9B $     : #  "#       "!#  "$     # 9 "

" "B#    $ #    "        # "" $      $ 0 #:$  2    " ! # 0  $ '3

$   $ "!# #

8$         #$ "# " 7!     !#   " @$ "   #"  "  $  "   $   " "# % 6 # "  $  ! " < " ""$" 2 % 

$  @    ! "  #  "0@$         $   "       2  !   " @$ # $        " !" "  $  "   #  " '= B "   ! " "         $        "   7!   % "         $ # % 2   "

 "  %   " $ " "  ""  $        "     7!  "

 $  !  !!8# %    " "     # ?!   %         $     !  "    " ! " "  " 2   $    $$

'+

  $    $     " !"          "    'A .( 1..A    #        C   " % C     $  '*  /""   "    '(#$#   "

 %C " "           /""    "$$ $"#! $    " $ $ 

 1.

     "      #       "" #

1'

"#  # $#  @#$   

" % "8 

+ ,+ 

++/0 $ 

   /8  H/    H/