High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1038/2010dismissed

Mukesh Kumar & ORS v. State Of Haryana

2022-12-21Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari25 pages

!"!#$!%&'()) *+!&,!-.".&'())

( /0 ) 11

12 3

/0 ) 13 0 2 ! "#$%"%& $ '( )$)& $ ' "

+# ,& $ ' -#'.#( "

- #%&+/&

0 2 4) *

" " #' " #' 1'' &#

#$ 2#""$ #' ('

$#'#

35*5& & (' 65 35*5& "

## # 7

&8#&#'9

*:;

5< 5= 3554& # '# 653165=164>164=16> (98.& & '# 3:1:>1:4 (-'&8 #'# &8#&+##' 8#&2" " "$'

$#' ( " (('#" '# 653 2#"'# 6> (98.& &"$'

( #(& & (# ( *5&5551 '"& &#

( ( - ((#&

( * '"

5< 5= 3554&- #'?@#( -# A&B 8.&2 " () (8-." &# ( & & -## ( #) "% 2#( ( C# # "& # &2"

(( "

#)# 2#""- #'?& (#2"&$# 2"#'"#) "%2(

8/9& "% '# ( '" #( -# & ,#) @8D6A- ?# '- % 2"#) "%2 -# 8- #& 8#& 2" & " '" 8- #& 8#& ( '

" - "& " - #'# &B 8.13& "

' %# ## (# #) "% -% -& 2"#'"& "

' & $# B 8.16& ' "(# -%- "(&"'

" - (#) "%&B 8+&"'

(2"#'" !

E "9-# (( #

- "

9-"$# '?#'2#") (8-." &.7&# (

& 9 2#" ) "

( - # &#%

. 66*6& & #"# "&2 #&9

% 2"- ("

- # &9

) (""

# ' -%" "#&.7&# (,#& 2# ++

F/" &'

- # & ) " -""" '

'- ( %"&"#"$# (#'#'# 2#"

"#- **!651*3!55 &2'" ", (# "

& &2 2(

" & (2"

-& 2%"

" " 2 35 33 ( ) " ' # %" " "

%" "#'

-# "-$" ' "(&) "' 2 8# D " ) $#

2 8# #"-#-&%" "# '

-# &## " ("'&(#

" (( -"#'#$$ $ '

? &" ' '- " (

%" "#'

-# " ( -"' "2 "

) "

# " %" "#'

-# ( ( " #) G' "(&9('

'# 9 '# #( "# # "-

&9- # - ( F '# % # %" "#'

-# 9"$

- - " #&2"#'"#'

' H "# ( $-&B 8+&"9 2 # # " 1'' %" % 2

( ## ("9 & ' '# *=> . .

' 2#" "

() "(& ,#) @8D6A #' "' ''' #I

# "&$# -- B 8&2"#'"2

I # "& &"-2'

$ #

'& 2#"J,8K (&"2" $

I # "

"(& " 9$# # ((#' - #'# &B 8/13& "+ #&8#&( '

" - (#) "%& '# *;>. .

&2" & "

"# D& 7 .

& 8# @8D;A& '

" -& B 8/16& (#) "% >

+# #$# # & .

# "& 9'" & .

-.& ((#'&8#@8D4A&" $' # #

43*3;5;:3: 444;55;;3= 2#" 9+ 2

5* 5;

3554 5;

*5 3554 "9$# # ((#' " '# "- #-2( '

' " " 2#2"

**!33 **!6: **!>6 ( -" 2# ."-'$&, &8# "' #2 '

B 8 :

*6 5= 3554& +$ -&.

((&8# @8D*>A& 2#"9' #) # " .

)#@8D33A&2 # &8#& " #' " 2"# # "&%

''-( -K# &2"#'"2 # &"

2$&# #$# "' #'# & "" ## #"( # '2" & 2"

#' "#-%" ( "## "& &7# 8%" ( "#$ # @ 1'' - " # ""1'' & # 2'

$ & & "( & 9

*;6 *6 5= 3554 2 # #

1'' %" 9

*;> *6 5= 3554 2 # #1'' 7#8%"&8 8#

+# #$# # & " 1'' (( #' - '

--## (('#"'

"(&" 2 #"' +# #$# # & "1'' (( " #' -&2"#'"

$ (#'#-## #' "' 2 " F( ( #'B-## ('

-# (#$# # &" # ((#'(# "# '# *=6. .

( "'

' 9? # # "'B'#$ # "'

(# &" 9? #&'

--#

"' "'

(# $# '

--# 5> *3

;

# #- ('# '& " 1'' 2 '" " ( '

--## (('#" '# 653& 65=& 2#" '# 6>& 64= ( 98.& & ( - "#& '' 1 %" 2 '" " ( ((' #" '# 3: (-'& 2"#'""

# '#- # =

" '# &# $#'&B-# - 3>2# "- ("1'' & '# 6*6. .

&2'

&2"#&" # ''

(#-#'# 2"# # " # $ #"- <

" #.

&('

-# (#&'

5 "#- $ #' ('

$#'# ('&2" & "

"1'' "$'

$#' ( (('#" '# 653 2#"'# 6> (98.

FB-#"

'- 2 $# '

" '# " & " # ("#- $ #'

$#'# &'

" #.

0 *5

#' $& '# (- #'?& ,#) @8D6A&'" ""

# ( ## ##

' (# (#) "% -%-&" '

"-&B 8+& "#2" ("'9 " #

"(& " 9$# # ((#' - #'# &B 8/13& "+ #&8#&( '

" - (#) "%& '# *;>. .

&2" & "

"#D&7 .

&8#@8D;A& " ## (+ 8%) ) @8D>A (# ( " #) -% -

" &+ 8%))@8D>A&$# B 8/& ' "(#

-%- ''

&" #@8D;A&'

" -&B 8/16& (#) "% ('

-&" #& $# B 8/1>& '#(# " " #) -# # (# '

## 2"#-%# - ("'#(# ""- " - 2#"

( -

( " - (#) "%2'

&+ 8%))@8D>A #'#(# ""#) -# #(#'

## # "'

8 ("-@ '# A&B 8/16&- "%' "

2"""

# ,2#"" # "

) & ) " '

' - - ( 1'' %"

D"" 2$# #"#'&2

$"-# #'# ( # "''" 2% 2 ) ''

&) "' "" " ("' 2") - -( -"-&" (# "

) " " (# "

" '#(#' " ("#2%"

"- @A#

' !

E9 "

# , 2#" - # "

) ) " '

' - - 9 ) 2#' 2 $# #'# '&" 2% 2 ) D ' "" "

("' D ' ) - - ( -"- - (- ) &" (# "

"" (# "

- " - (" 2%"

" '# B-# "

"# D& 7 .

& 8#&8D;&2"

# "2# B '

"- ("%&B 8/16& "#'#(#'# (#&B 8/1> 9"#' B-## &"'#(#' "" '

"- (#) "%254!>: *5!65

" '# B-# + 8%))8D>& 2"

" 5< 5= 3554& " 2 8- #& 8# (" "( '

- (#)

"% " #&"'#(# " (# -%-& &('

"-&" #'#(# ""-# # (#'

## # "'

"- '

"# ## 1'#(#'B 8/ B 8/1*'#$ +#

' B-## &" ""- (#) "%2 '

#9.& &('

"-&"2(

"# "'

9,#) # "2# B8D6& 2"

"" # " ##

' ( '

" - (#) "%&B 8+& "(" "# #'# '

-& '# *;>. .

& " #&8# 2 # #'##$ ' B-## &"

2$& "# -#'

B' "

(' "( &2'( '

' "" '# 2 $ &2"#'"" '

07 *:

9 $#'&" '# B-# +

"+#28D*&2"

"F ("% @#' ' A2#( (C## " ( "( 2# #)# "

8 E*

' 2 (#I* >'-L5 >'-2#"

#$ - # $

#2#"

'% %# 2#"

L ("& ##

## 2 $# #) 2%

8#'

-# (### - $( #- L '$#'#2 $# #) 2 % $# H *;

"&+ # "& #'((#'&F 78 #& %"@8D:A& '

"# 2 ((# $#B ' '

(" - ("%B 891* "#((# $#&"'

' " - ("% (

"( 2# #)#!

E"22 *1*13.- # *13'- $ .> .:$ (" #'# &2#"

" 2 '- '

$ #1..>$

- # " $ )'

## 2 '

B' ( -"

' "% 9"# ## & "' "2 "

#) &2"#'"2 ' -# *=

" '# ("B-# + ""#/ & #' ((#'&/ #&8#&8D=&2"

"#((# $#B 8&'

( - () B 81*& #'B 813&2 B (#-B 8* 83& & ' '

## -# B 83 @# $ # -%

B 83A " - & " ( 2# #)# 2 #' $"

() !

F' 2 (#I:

5'-B:

5'-2#"

#$ - # $ - #> 5'-# ( ( ( # ,'%# - #

(2 & $'"# 2"2 #

%#&-' # $ & '#

""&- # -B#(' # &"

22 & #? - # #) #

' # $ ' ""&$ $& '#

-' # &"# '$#'$('

( -

#'6 #'

"' "#"#'2 # "- " "

'% #) "#'

$ ('%

#) &2"#'"#((#'# ' "# -'

(#(

"#)#2 ' -#

-"F 8 ' "%2 8 ' ) &" '# " " "" '

(( "

#)# " ''- "#)# ((

"( &"- #'$# '

' '

" '# ( " '# (( '

"% # & "

&" "

" ' # ' "

#)# 10 1

11 7 1

9 $" #' -- " 1'' " '

$# ((' " & "

'# B-# 9' ,# # "& 9$# # ((#'& 8D3>& 2"

" *6 5= 3554& "

% # '

1'' %" 7#8%"( -8 #'# & 8#&2"

2 #'

#'9

*;613554

*;>13554'#$ +# #$# # &1'' %"

(( #' -&B 8M& #' ("# #' -& *;

5= 3554&"

%"#$# # ' "## ++

"2 &"

#? $ &"

"' '''&$# -- B 81*& "(&"

$ 2 - #& "

( -#' (%

' ' ) & # '& '% % &

"' ' ) " $#'2#I " 9$# # ((#' $# -- & B 813& # " ' ( 9 "# # "@8D*4A /) @8D*;1 " ' ) A

" $ B' ( #' - ( 1''

%"&B 8M& !

E5< 5= 3554& ** 651*3 55 G' '%#"

&9 7#8%" ("#$ #8 #& # (,&2"

#- (# &"

2 "$ '

--#- () "(&- #'&7#8%"' ) &# ( &

"# - # - % "#- '

- "

( -#-&) '- "

, #"#%

. 66*6 "2''

-# "%& # ( & 2"

- 2 %2 ) "#'"

, #

"&9 - '

-# 7#8%"" ("' 2

"' 2 8# "(&2"2'" #? $ &9(# "

( -- 6*: '

- # ")2 () 2"### #"'& &7#8%" (# "

"%( "## "(&2 "

("' 9"2) 7#8%""2"%

("' 7#8%" "%G 9

) G 9 $2 "#' "#-& 2 - #& ' &"

(+F () "

( - ('2 " "

("' 9#'% ""- #& ' "

( - (' % "-#- '% 7#8%" #'% " "

( +F ( ) & ;551 #( -" ("% %"-# "# # ** 5= 3554&#"$# &9

7# 8%"2 - "G# 2 "

# , @ A#"' D"#

"&9

$- "#&# 2#"

& 2 2"# '

8@" '(A&""

(8#' + '&+"# &"-#&( '#

'#$ '# ("- 9"$%'

"'# '& "- # () & ' "

( - ( '& # " ' '

' "'

" '

' "2 (,#"%#- # #"

" % 2

#B'- 9"$( '%

"' "# "% #'%'

$ " '

9 ' '

$ "

#' "% -'# 9'

-' "'2"9" (# "

) #"' "2"#-

2( -"'

9 " - -& 1'' 7# 8%"

(( #' -& B 8M1*& # ' ( "#

#' -& *> 5= 3554&"" $ )& 2"#'""2 " '''& "-2%#

# $# -- &B 81> ("

$ '

- # 6*: 2#" - #$'#

&2"#'"

2%# # $# -- &B 81;&

- #( -" '% ("#( # ) #$# #''

' ) &2"#'"2 %# # $# -- & B 81= " $ B' ( #' - 1'' 7#8%"&B 8M1*& !

E5< 5= 3554& ** 651*3 55 G' '%#"

& %" - ( "#& . 7& # (,#&% - ') &# &"

"#' %"-&9- "

' ) &# &( -- #

444;55;;3= '

"#-"

"(&9 %"

-2# ( ) "

( -#-&) '-"

, #"# %

' #

. 66*6 " 2 ''

-# "%&# ( &2"

2 %2 2$&"%&## " ( ("'& # % 2- )

"#' # "&9 %"-

#"' 2

"' 2 8#

"(&2"2'" #? $ &9 (# "

( -- 6*: # "'% "% %" (# "

) ( "## ( # "

('&9"2 "% %"-"2) (" ' 9 "%G %"-

) G 2 $2 "#' "#-& 2 - #& ' &"

(+F () "

( - ('2 " "

("' %"-#'% "

"- #&' "

( - % " - 2#" "#- 9 #'% " "

( +F ( ) & '' ;551 - #( -" ("% %"-#- '% ((# ( -" #"'& ** 5= 3554&2'" "# 2 "

(%"-G "# , @ ,(

&92" - )#& 2"#'"

# 2#"

("%( -" ('& "(&9" " "% ((#B "2"# "2" - # #" ,#"% "- # "

(+F () ## " '% ("# 92 " '

- # &( -2"#'"9(# "

"%#) G'& 2#" #$'#

- '#

6*: &# " "-# "2" -

" % 2

B'- "2 # "

(+F## '%& &" 6*: '

- # 2#" #$'#

- '#

"# #"2"

- 9 ' " #' '

-'# 9' -' "' 2"9" (# "

"%#"'

"2"

2( -"' 3*

$ " ( # '

$ & '# B-#

/) (8-." @ " ' ) A&8D*;&2"

2 ) # # #$# # 9' ,# # "& 9$# # ((#'& # "2# B8D3> 9 "# # "&

("2# ("'

$ &2 B-# 8D*4 " '# " 2# " '

$ ( ( #

#'#-## #'( -"1'' #' ("# '#$ #' -& "

' ) &2"#'"2%2 "1'' ( '

--## " '#-& 2 '

$ ( - " # ( " 1'' "#- ("# $&"#'& 2"#'"2'

$ ( -"1'' &2#" %

' ( ' ) & 2"#'" 2 % 2 "-&

"( &##"" # ("1''

(# '

# " - ( "%& B 8+& '

,#) @8D6A&2"" 2#") '" , (# "

&"1'' "#' " ("#' "(&) "' 2 8## 2"" 2

2 8#&"

5 1'' (# "

( -"#'#$# ) "% "2"- ("' "( &"'

'''& (# -# #"-@A&2 # "

&, &8#

"- ("%& ,#) @8D6A$## " '''&( -2""#I %

# "$# -- &B 8 +# "'

#$# # '# 9' ,## "@8D3>A&"' '#-2

B-# ( -B ( #''#'F & "&& + - @8D*=A&$## "

('#- ' (.#-## &2"#'"2

"$B' ("# !

E* " ((' 2 8# N , & "

) 1 8-." &

>5 &.7&1 &8 @+"#A

# (-- "%21

C## "&.+"%& >5 &1

&8 @+"#A

2 " 2 '

'2 2" "

( )

"'22""#) 2 # & " #' ((#'# -%2#"

#2 "

> %# -% ($"#' #' 2 8## 2 $ "

( " "- ( #''#'F B-# "

6 %

. 66*6& ' ) &2"#'"

$ ( -"1''

B-## (" ( # '&"( 2# $# 2'

" #'

'#'F !

E*> ,

#2 ' " #$ @'

#2 ' "(

- #

"# " #$@, 2'

(

-A

#2 ' "'

*= ,

#2 ' "(

- "'

' # &"2# 2"

((

"" #'$# ''

( # "' 3>

, $# "( # ' (.#-## '

&" '# "' #" "' ''' # ( '

"-&B 8+&- "%& 2"

"" ' ) (( "

#)##" %

' $&"

#2"#'"2( #"%

' ' #'"#$ $- ("1'' #"# '#-

"& " '# '

" F 65 ** 3554 3< 5* 35*5 B 8L B 8L1* '#$ &''

2"#'"& B-## ("'

"'- '' (

2 ' "" #'

#'B-## &"

""#'

2( ("- # "&"

# '

2 "& '

$ ( - " ' ( '''& 2

B-# ( - #''#'F B-## &"

""#'2 ( ("- #

"#& # #$# # & .

# "

@8D4A& '

"' # (1'' 7#8%"

' ) "' #'

&" '# ("# #2( '

' " " 2#2"**!33

**!6: **!>6 ( - " 2 # ."- '$&, &8# $&1'' 7#8%"

#"# #' -""" ' ' ) "

&"#' (1'' %"& "#- - ( - "# #

444;55;;3= "( & " ' # '

& '

B 8& #""' 1'' &" ('#-&"#- ''' 3=

) # ("' (.#-## &" F "' #'

' #" " " ' ( ''' 2 # "

& #' "%#"-&B 8+

19 7 3<

9 #""'## ("1''

--## ("'#-&" '# " '

" (F& 3< 5* 35*5&B 8L1* 8 ("#

#'" 6*:H(# &% ( -"

8 ) & 2 ,##' 2

#' +#$## ( # B-## 9("$" '

- # @."-

6*:H'#

A 2#" 6*:H(# '#

' (

6*:H#$'#

$ ( -1'' %"& & '

- # @."- ( 656H'#

A 2#" '

- (# '#

'@."- ( 656H 6*:H'# (#-A '

- #$'#

@."- ( 656H

6*:H'#(#-A&'

$ ( -1'' 7#8%"& & 6*:H (# % ( - "

( '

"%&2( B-## (B-## ("( #

'@A&" #''#'F -# # &" $B' ( @A&#

' !

F *

" '

- # -% D1* @."- ( 6*:H'#

A D13@."-

656H'#

A(#- (# #- ':> (*4:4 "#(## -'"#-2( # %#

" 6*:H(# '#

'-% .1*& 6*:H (# -% ,.13 "$ (# ( '

- # -% D1* ( -

"(#-$ ("--% ' $ (#-"

# 2# #$# '"'##'

- (# '#

'-% .13 "(# ( -'

- # -% D13 ( - "(#-$ ("--% ' $ (#- "

# 2

#$# '"'##'-% >

(## ## '

( -

#% 6*:H(# -% ,.1*#' '

- # -% D1* '% ((#'#'

-# #$# '"'##'-% 8 ( " @A& #" " " (##

-'"#- ( '

- # & '

$ ( - " 1'' &2( #2 %# "&2"#'"

2B' ( -"

' ) &-% ,.13& #

#'B-## &2( (# ( -'

- # & -% D1*&'

$ ( -"1'' %"

"# $ " " (# '#

'& '

$ ( 1'' 7#8%"&-% .13&2(# ( -'

- # &-% D13&'

$ ( -1'' 7#8%"

- " ( F& '

2#" " - "% @B 8+A - ( ,#) @8D6A&

'# @B 8/16A'

7 .

&8#&'

$ (%

' "#'#-## #''

$ ( -" # (" 1'' &((#'# #""" " '

--# " - () "% (## "

"-( -"# '#$2

" '

( "1'' " " '# ("%& '

B 8/16 " '# & # (

(#'# " ( "

9$# # ((#' #'2 ' " - ("%& '

B 891*& "" @A& " - ( "% 2 '

' 5< 5= 3554&5:!55 &2"&" '# 2"

"$'

5< 5= 3554&*5!55 &"( &#' #"""' (" '#

( 92("

" - #$"#"# " '# #"1'' ( '

--## '"'#- (' 2B- "-&B 8+&- "%& '

"# '

#"-@A") " " ' # 1'' %" "

"(&1'' %" "#'

-# " ( "'& "( & #' # " 1''

--# "- () "%&2"&( -"( #

#'&#'

-'""2'

## 2) 1'' %"

"- & # 2 " "

#' -&B 8F13& - 1'' 7# 8%"&# -###$# '&"-# "# '# 3;

( " 9 # $# ' ' $& " #' - 1'' %" 7# 8%"& B 8M B 8M1* '#$ & '

$ -- & B 813& # ' ( #' - (1'' %"& #"- # 2#2) # #"#$# # #""#-

" #' - (1'' "#-

((('# '

$ ("#' 6*

" " " & '

( " '

#' " '# - ' "%& '

$ ((' ( -"1'' # #$# # &'

- #' 2 ( #' $# '& " '# '

-'"# ('#'-'" '

" '# &2"#'"' # "

-" #

(1''

#'2

' " - &2"#'"' #" " ""

' # ' "

#)# D"# # "

'-&" ""# "'#'" '# " #'

' "# -& 2- "

-##"$ #' '

$#'# (' "$-"" # .

"'# "#$# '$# '

&### " '#$& '"&"# $# #(#-# #"$ #'

$#'# '

1 1 11 1 101

001: 1

( " - ( " '

( " 1'' '

'# " #'' 2#" " #- ('

'# " - ("% '

'# #'

' &2"#'"" #

(&2"$ B-# "'

"$#$ "'

'# "&#('& "%" # *< 5= 35545=!65 9 # #

#" ( -"- (9,#) @8D6A&+ 8%) )@8D>A "

"#D&7 .

&8#&""-

(#) "%2'

5< 5= 3554 *5!55 # "9. (8- #&8# "'#'-#%# #" - ( "%& "

2# " ( " 5< 5= 3554&2 ( " "1''

## &##- '#'-#%&2"&" "

'- $# '

' #'""%" # *< 5=

$&8D*3& -8%"& '

#' #"# B-## '"#("& *< 5= 3554&"

' "8 ' "

"& " 2 # ' B-##

(''

2$& $#

# 2 ((

"#- "B"" - ("%2'

' 5< 5= "( &#""1'' 2 % (# ('#'-#%&2"#'"- '

- # $' '"&"#'

# (" '

( " 1'' )'

" " '

# ( " '

( " 1'' #" - #$"#"#

" '# 2$&"#'

# 2#"

' ' # '

#' '

# " - "%&B 8+&" ' ) " '

' - -( 1'' %"&2"#'"('" # "%#" '# &- ( " #&

2"# " " " 2" ) - "# - & " 1'' (# "

"- "( & " '

# ( ( -# -''

&)'

("B'

# ( '

( " 1'' $#I $#I '

# # 2 )

1'' %"#'

' &"#'

# '%-#& #- ( -"- ("%""

2#" ' ) 2 "

') " '

' - - ( - 1'' %"

"( & #

1'' %" " & # 2 $# (

' ) "''#2" ("#$## 1'' %"

# (' ' ) # 1'' %"&# 2 &#"B#' '

## 2"- 6:

" B '

# # '

( " 1'' # ) ## ( # 2#

# #$# # &2"#'"-%"'

( "#'

((#'# '

- ( -"- (9 "# # "

@8D*4A&2"

'#(#' ""9$# # ((#'" - (( ) ##' " $ B

### ) #"#$# # 9#2 2") ## 2##- ('# (2

"( & - ' # 2# 2 ) # & " $# ' ( ((#'#2#' #'

9$#2 ("( # #'# &"#.

-##"# ''

&"-#" %.";.""!% 6=

"$ #' ('

$#'# 34 35*5& & ' 65 35*5& "

## # 7

&8#&

'( #(' "#.

" -#((#- -##

"1'' &#( #'

&"( "2#" %# '

("'#-

"' &#( & 2#"#''

'2#"

2(B# ("#

(#-## ( (## " '

( "2#"

12 3

0 2 3* *3

$# D""%# 1 !1

D"" !1