Sardul Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab
!
+,*-#.
/ 00-&&"(,.
1.
,",- %(3"4
/ -.0+($-(,
5 6
5 6
6
77777
# "#8'($-#
'()*9 $:+;",-
"00-&&"(,.
#.
"(3"#'
-*#% <"%&9 $$','+("& $:+;",- -(-#"&9 %(3"4
77777
=*-,*-# -0+#,-#.
&+;"& 0"0-#.
8"> 4- "&&+?-$ .-- 3%$)8-(,@
+ 4- #-2-##-$ -0+#,-#.
+# (+,@
A =*-,*-# 3%$)8-(, .*+%&$ 4- #-0+#,-$ ')-.,@
*'.
"00-"& $'#-;,-$ ")"'(., '80%)(-$ 3%$)8-(, $",-$
A #-($-#-$ &-"#(-$ $$','+("&
-..'+(.
%$)-9
*",'($"9
?*-#-4> "00-&&"(,.
*-&$ )%'&,> ;+88',,'() +22-(;- 0%('.*"4&- %($-#
-;,'+( A BAC 00-&&"(,";;%.-$ ;+(:';,-$ %($-#
-;,'+(
#8.
;, ?*-#-".
"00-&&"(,";;%.-$ 6"4*
?".9
"$$','+( ;+(:';,-$ %($-#
-;,'+( A #8.
;, 1'$- +#$-# .-(,-(;-
$",-$ 9 -";* +(- "00-&&"(,.";;%.-$ .-(,-(;-$
%($-#)+ '80#'.+(8-(, &'2- 2'(- . 9B ( $-2"%&,
0">8-(, 2'(-9 %($-#)+ #')+#+%.
'80#'.+(8-(, 8+(,*.
;+88',,'() +22-(;- 0%('.*"4&- %($-#
-;,'+( A BAC 9 ?*-#-".
.-(,-(;-$ '80#'.+(8-(, ,*#-- >-"# 0"> 2'(-
.
!9B ( $-2"%&, 0">8-(, 2'(-9 %($-#)+ 2%#,*-# #')+#+%.
'80#'.+(8-(, 8+(,* +22-(;- %($-#
-;,'+(
#8.
;,
6'E-?'.-9 6"4*
.-(,-(;-$ '80#'.+(8-(,
8+(,*.
0"> 2'(- .
9B ( $-2"%&, 0">8-(, 2'(-9
%($-#)+ +(- 8+(,*
+22-(;- %($-#
-;,'+( A #8.
;,
#'-2 2";,.
0#+.-;%,'+( "#- &'E- ,*'.F
!
;+80&"'("(, 4#+,*-#
0#-.-(,
*+%.- ?*-#-
"#8-$ "(3',
"#8-$
G*+059 "#4"(.
"#8-$ G<*"0#"59 <%&$'0 <"%#9 **'($-# <"%#
4+,* "#8-$ '#+( #+$.
6"4*
"#8-$
4+#- &';-(;-$ )%(9
-80,> *"($-$9 "&"%#
"#8-$ ;"8- ,*-#-
, ,'8-9 !
A *-> .,"#,-$ "4%.'() ;+80&"'("(, 0"#,>
+80&"'("(, 4#+,*-#
'()*".E-$ ,*-8 #-".+( "4%.'()
,*-8 *-( 6"4*
#"'.-$ " ,-";* &-..+( ;+80&"'("(,
0"#,> (+, )':'() ,*-8 .*"#- ,%4-?-&& - 2'#-$ ,*#-- .*+,.
"'#
)%( ,*-# .,"#,-$ *%#&'() 2'&,*> "4%.-.
;+80&"'("(,
4#+,*-#
,++E )%( 6"4*
2'#$ ",
*', &-2, .'$- ;*-.,9 #-.%&,9
2-&& $+?(
)#+%($ +80&"'("(, #"'.-$
%0+( #-&",':-
"&$-:
;"8- ,*-#-
.*+, "(+,*-# 2'#- ",
"&$-:
*',
&-2, .'$- .,+8";*
.*+, "(+,*-# 2'#- ", ;+80&"'("(,9
*+?-:-#9 ;+%&$ .":- *'8.-&2 ,"E'() .*-&,-# ,+'&-, ?"&& &&
,*-( 2&-$ "?"> .0+, "&+()?',* #-.0-;,':- ?-"0+(.
?*'&- #"'.'()
"&$-:
$-.*
+.0,'"&
*%;*+9
",*'($"9 ?*-#-
.%;;%84-$ '(3%#'-.
*'.
.,",-8-(, )':-( ;+80&"'("(, 0+&';-9 ?*-#-%0+(9
#-)'.,-#-$ ")"'(.,
.
0-# ;+80&"'("(, "8$%#
'()*9 "&+()?',* 4#+,*-#
*".
4--( #-.'$'() 2'-&$.
", *+%.- '.
;+%.'(.
"#4"(.
#-.'$'() (-"#4> *+%.- *-#-
,%4- ?-&& (-"# *+%.- ;+80&"'("(, %4-?-&& ;+((-;,'+(
("82",*-#
'()*9 ;+%.'(9 %.-$ ;&"'8 *"&2 .*"#-
"2+#-."'$ ,%4-?-&&
,+&$
-&-;,#';
8+,+#
+?(-$ ,*-8 , ,*-> ?*+ *"$ $-0+.',-$ .-;%#',> +,*-#
;*"#)-.
-,;
;+((-;,'+( "2+#-."'$ 8+,+# ( "00&';",'+( 8+:-$
"$#%&
#-)"#$'() $'.0%,- 0+&';- .,",'+(
"&'"(?"&'
;+80#+8'.- )+, -22-;,-$ *-&0 "(;*">", 4%,
4";E-$ +%, ;+80#+8'.- "4%.-$ "(;*">",
%#'() ;+%#.- '(:-.,')",'+(.9
%&H"#
'()*9
(:-.,')",'() 22';-# 0#-0"#-$ '(I%-., #-0+#, J = B *-
$-"$ 4+$> '$-(,'2'-$
"))"#
"8$%#
++0
*"($-$ +:-# ;&+,*-.
'(3%#-$
"&$-:
"&+()?',* 6
'(,+ 0+&';- 0+..-..'+( :'$- 8-8+ J "#;-& ;+(,"'('() ;&+,*-.
"&$-:
J !
2,-# 0+.,8+#,-8 -J"8'(",'+( $-"$ 4+$>9
++0
0#+$%;-$ 4-2+#- (:-.,')",'() 22';-# +(- 0"#;-& ;+(,"'('()
4-&+()'().
$-;-".-$ '(,+ 0+..-..'+(
- 0#+$%;-$
0&".,';
4+,,&- 2+#8 0"#;-& J
;+(,"'('() +(- 4%&&-, ?"$9 $%&>
.-"&-$ .-"&
5"($ ."8- '(,+ 0+&';- 0+..-..'+(
:'$- 8-8+ J *-#-"2,-#9 )+'() .0+,9 (:-.,')",'() 22';-#
&'2,-$ 2+%# ;"#,#'$)-.
+(- 8'.;"#,#'$)- ."8- '(,+
0+&';- ;%.,+$> :'$- 8-8+ J *'.
0"#;-& J
&++$ .,"'(-$
.'80&- -"#,* &'2,-$ .0+, 8"$- '(,+ .-0"#",- 0"#;-&.
J A
J C *- ."8- .-"&-$ .-"& G '(,+ 0+&';-
;%.,+$> :'$- 8-8+ J < +%)* .',- 0&"( .0+, ;+##-;, 8"#)'("&
(+,-.
0#-0"#-$ J = B
,",-8-(,.
?',(-..-.
#-;+#$-$
( !
9 '(:-.,')",'+(.
*"($-$ +:-#
++0
3"'4
0#+$%;-$
'()*9 "#4"(.
'()*9
6"4*
"&"%#
4-2+#-
%4 (.0-;,+# ++0
*->
'(,-##+)",-$ ,%#( ,%#(
0#+$%;-$ 4-2+#-
++0
'()*9
'(,+ 0+&';- 0+..-..'+( :'$- 8-8+ J =B
E-,;* 0#-0"#-$
J D "#4"(.
0#+$%;-$ G<*"0#"5 J 4-2+#-
++0
."8- '(,+
0+..-..'+( :'$- 8-8+ J =B +%)* .E-,;* K<*"0#"K 0#-0"#-$
J =B "&"%#
'()*9 ,*-#-"2,-#9 0#+$%;-$ J 4-2+#-
++0
."8- '(,+ 0+..-..'+( :'$- 8-8+ J =B
E-,;* 0#-0"#-$ J =B ".- 0#+0-#,> $-0+.',-$
0+&';- .,",'+(
,",-8-(,.
?',(-..-.
#-;+#$-$
(
C !
9
++0
%&"
;"8-
$-.* +.0',"& .+%)*, +0'('+( $+;,+# 8"E'() #-I%-.,
J =B -22-;, '2
"&$-:
'(3%#-$ 2', )':- .,",-8-(,
+# (+,9 ?*-#-%0+(9 $+;,+# +0'(-$ J =B *-( .,",-8-(,
"&$-:
#-;+#$-$ J =B< 2,-# "$8',,'() ."8- ;+##-;,9
"&$-:
.')(-$ .,",-8-(,
++0
",,-.,-$ 0%,
-($+#.-8-(, J =B +;,+# 0#+$%;-$ 4-2+#-
++0
:'"&
;+(,"'('() 0"&&-, .-"&-$ 0"#;-& J 4-"#'() .-"&
'(,+ 0+..-..'+( :'$- 8-8+ J =B %&"
.')(-$ 8-8+
?',(-..
".- 0#+0-#,> $-0+.',-$ 0+&';- .,",'+(
(
! !
9
"##-.,-$ (
'(,-##+)",'+(9 .%22-#-$ $'.;&+.%#- .,",-8-(, J -22-;,
*"$ E-0, ;+(;-"&-$ +(- )%( &';-(;- '#+( 4+J %($-#(-",*
;&+,*-.
*+%.- ( 0%#.%"(;- $'.;&+.%#- .,",-8-(,9
,++E 0+&';- 0"#,> .0-;'2'-$ 0&";- )+, )%(
&';-(;- #-;+:-#-$ *+%.- %( .-"&-$ .-"& G %(
"&+()?',* &';-(;- '(,+ 0+..-..'+( :'$- 8-8+ J %8$%#
%&"
.')(-$ 8-8+ ?',(-..-.
"#;-& ;+(,"'('() )%(
J
',- 0&"( 0&";- #-;+:-#> )%( 0#-0"#-$
J =B
,",-8-(,.
?',(-..-.
#-;+#$-$ 0#+0-#,>
$-0+.',-$ 0+&';- .,",'+( 2,-# ;+80&-,'+( (-;-.."#>
'(:-.,')",'+(.9 ;*"&&"( 0#-.-(,-$ +%#, ")"'(.,
'($'() 0#'8"
2";'- ")"'(., ";;%.-$9 ,*-> ;*"#)-
.*--,-$ ;+88',,'() +22-(;- 0%('.*"4&- %($-#
-;,'+( A BAC
?*-#-".
*".
4--( ;*"#)-$
+22-(;- %($-#
-;,'+( AD ;+";;%.-$ ;*"#)-$ +22-(;- %($-#
-;,'+( ADBAC ;;%.-$ 6"4*
;*"#)-.*--,-$
+22-(;- %($-#
-;,'+( A ($'"( #8.
;,
;*"#)- .*--,-$ +22-(;- %($-#
-;,'+(
($'"( #8.
;, + ;*"#)-9 ,*-> $'$ (+, 0&-"$ )%'&,>
2,-# ,"E'() -(,'#- 0#+.-;%,'+( -:'$-(;-9 .,",-8-(,.
%($-#
-;,'+( AA # #-;+#$-$ ?*-#-'( ,*-> $-('-$ -";*
0#+.-;%,'+( "&&-)",'+( 0&-"$-$ '((+;-(;- ;;%.-$
,++E $-2-(;-9 %($-#
L
!" # $!
!
%
! &
! ! '
& (
! !
)) *+ )**+ ' ( !
), )**.
/ 0
! 1 "#4"(.
"$+0,-$ "2+#-."'$ 0&-"
+?-:-#9 6"4*
,++E 0&-"
2"&.-
'80&';",'+( ( $-2-(;- ,-($-#-$ -:'$-(;- ;+0'-.
-"#&'-# ':'& 6',')",'+( #-)"#$'() ,%4-?-&& ',.
8+,+#9 "#- J C
J 9 +
J ;+0> "(;*">",("8"
"#E
,-($-#-$ -:'$-(;-
2,-# *-"#'() ;+%(.-& 0"#,'-.
"00#"'.'() -(,'#-
-:'$-(;- 8",-#'"& #-;+#$9 &-"#(-$ ,#'"& +%#, #-;+#$-$
'80%)(-$ 3%$)8-(, ;+(:';,'+( $",-$ A +#$-# .-(,-(;-
$",-$ 9 .-, +%, -"#&'-# 0"#, 3%$)8-(,
=- *":- *-"#$ &-"#(-$ ;+%(.-& 0"#,'-.
4-.'$-.
)+'()
,*#+%)* #-;+#$
'#., "&&9 "#)%-$ &-"#(-$ ;+%(.-& "00-&&"(,. ,*-#- $-&"> "4+%, DB
*+%#.
#-;+#$'() *'.
$-&"> #-8"'(-$ %(-J0&"'(-$ .
0-# 0#+.-;%,'+( ;".-9 "&&-)-$ +;;%##-(;-
*"$ 0&";- ", "4+%, !
A !
9?*-#-".
)+, #-;+#$-$ A !
", "4+%, *'.
,'8- *".
4--(
%,'&'H-$ ;+80&"'("(, 0"#,> $-&'4-#",'+(.9 #-.%&,-$ '(,+ 2"&.-
'80&';",'+( ,*-89 ?-&& 2+%($ '((+;-(,
'(I%'#> #-0+#, J
, ?-&& .-,,&-$ #-.0-;, ;+)('H"4&- +22-(;-.
.*+%&$
4- &+$)-$ .++( 0+..'4&- =*-#- &+$)'() #-0+#, $-&">-$9 (+, +(&>
)-,.
4-#-2, ',.
.0+(,"(-',>9 $"()-# ;#--0.
'(,#+$%;,'+(
;+&+%#-$ :-#.'+(9 ,*+%)*,+%, .,+#'-.
,?'.,'() 2";,.
*%.9 .+8-
'((+;-(, 0-#.+( ;"( 4- #+0-$ ("8-$ ;%&0#',.9 #-.%&, 8%;*
,*+%)*,9 ;+(.%&,",'+(.
$'.;%..'+( ( ;".-9 "8$%#
8"$-
.,",-8-(, 4-2+#- 0+&';- A !
", "4+%,
'()*9 4#+,*-# ;+80&"'("(, *"$ $'-$ +;;%##-(;- .
.%;*9
2'#., 0#'+#',> ;+80&"'("(, ,"E4#+,*-# +.0',"& )-, *'8
,#-",-$ +80&"'("(, ;"((+, 4- -J0-;,-$ 2'#., #%.* 0+&';- .,",'+(
&+$)'() #-0+#, '(.,-"$ ,"E'() '(3%#-$ *+.0',"& %., "2,-#
+;;%##-(;-9 %#3"(,?".
*+.0',"& ?*-#- '(2+#8",'+(
.-(, 0+&';- *-#- (+,*'() #-;+#$ .*+?
;+80&"'("(, -:-#
":+'$-$ )-,,'() .,",-8-(, #-;+#$-$ 0+&';- ( +,*-# *"($9 ,'8-
;+80&"'("(, )-,,'() .,",-8-(, #-;+#$-$ 0+&';- ;"(
4- ,-#8-$ .%22';'-(, ,'8- (+, %(#-".+("4&- "(> 8"((-# .
.%;*9
-J0&"(",'+( 2%#('.*-$ ;+80&"'("(,9 ;"( 4- ."'$ 4- .",'.2";,+#>
*%.9 (+, $-&">-$
, (-J, ;+(,-($-$ &-"#(-$ ;+%(.-& "00-&&"(,. +(&> '($-0-($-(, ?',(-..
"&$-:
*".
(+, .%00+#,-$
0#+.-;%,'+( "(> 8"((-# "8$%#
= ,*-#-"& 4#+,*-#
$-;-".-$
'()* .
.%;*9 '(,-#-.,-$ ?',(-..
*%.9
4".'.
;+80&"'("(, %8$%#
'()*9 ;"((+, 4- ;+(:';,-$ (+
#-&'"(;- ;"( 40&";-$ .,",-8-(, ;+80&"'("(,
2 ;+%#.-9 ;+80&"'("(, %8$%#
'()*9 #-"& 4#+,*-# +2
$-;-".-$ 4%, .'80&> 4-;"%.- #-&",'+( ?',(-..9 -:'$-(;- ;"((+, 4-
$'.;"#$-$ *- ?',(-..
4-'() #-&",'+( $-;-".-$9 ',.-&29 $+-.
(+, 8"E-
-:'$-(;- %(#-&'"4&- , +(&> 0%,.
+%#, )%"#$ .;#%,'('H-
-:'$-(;- 8+#- ,*"( +#$'("#> ;"#-9 4%, ?*-#- .%;* ?',(-..-.
,#'-$
;+(;-"& .%00#-..
#-&",'+(.*'09 -:'$-(;- ?'&& *":- 4- :'-?-$
$+%4,
+ *".
4--( *-&$
!
*- 0#-.-(, (+, +(- ;+80&"'("(, "8$%#
'()*-:-# ,#'-$ ;+(;-"& #-&",'+(.*'0 $-;-".-$ ,
.-,,&-$ 0#+0+.','+( &"?
?+#$ G#-&",-$5 (+, -I%':"&-(, '(,-#-.,-$5
*- ?',(-..
8">
4- ;"&&-$ '(,-#-.,-$ +(&> ?*-( +# .*- $-#':-.
.+8-
4-(-2',.
#-.%&, &',')",'+(F $-;#-- ;':'& ;".-9 +# .--'()
0-#.+(.
0%('.*-$ ?',(-..
(",%#"& +(- +(&>
0+..'4&- ->- ?',(-..
( ;'#;%8.,"(;- ;".-9 ;"((+, 4- ."'$ 4-
'(,-#-.,-$
+ *".
4--( *-&$
" #$%
& '( ( *"($9 ;+80&"'("(, $-;-".-$
'()* %.-$ #-.'$- 2'-&$.
*+%.- , ,'8-
+;;%##-(;-9 4+,* 0#-.-(, ,*-#- - *".
$-0+.-$ $-,"'& 8"((-#
+;;%##-(;- *"$ 0&";- - $-0+.-$
2'#-$
.*+, ", *'8 +?-:-#9 ;+%&$ .":- *'8.-&2 ,"E'() .*-&,-# ,+'&-, ?"&&
.
.%;*9 ;+80&"'("(, 8+., (",%#"& ?',(-..
?*+.- 0#-.-(;- ;"((+, 4-
$+%4,-$ "(> 8"((-# &.+9 ,*-#- (+,*'() #-;+#$ .*+?
"(> ?"> $-#':- .+84-(-2',.
.--'() 0%('.*-$ 2 ;+%#.-9
"&$-:
'()* =A $'$ (+, .%00+#, 0#+.-;%,'+( >-, +(&>
)#+%($9 ;"((+, 4- ."'$ 2";, (+ +;;%##-(;- *"$ -:-( 0&";- (
+,*-# *"($9
"#4"(.
-*&"
*":- "$8',,-$
+;;%##-(;-
'()*9#-;-':-$ 2'#- "#8 '(3%#> $'-$ *%.9
$-",*
'()*9 #-.%&,-$ 2'#- "#8 '(3%#>9 .,"($.
"$8',,-$
,*-8.-&:-.
( 2";,9 ,*-#- (+,*'() 2'&- .*+?
*":- -:-# 8"$- "(> ;+80&"'(, +# "00&';",'+( 4-2+#- .-('+# 0+&';- +22';-#.
+#
"%,*+#','-.
#-)"#$'() 2"&.- '80&';",'+( .
.%;*9 ;+(,-(,'+(
&-"#(-$ ;+%(.-& "00-&&"(,.";;%.-$ $-:+'$ "(> 2+#;-
-J, "#)%8-(, #"'.-$ &-"#(-$ ;+%(.-& "00-&&"(,. ,*-#- '(;+(.'.,-(;> 4-,?--( +;%&"# 8-$';"& -:'$-(;-
#-;+#$9 ")"'( (+, .%.,"'("4&-9 (+ ?*-#- %8$%#
= .0-;'2'-$
$'.,"(;-
2'#-$ .*+, ",
2
;+%#.-9 # "(8+*"(
$-+&
= #-0+#,-$ 4&";E-('() 8"#)'(.
'(3%#> +
0-#.+( $-;-".-$ ;",-)+#';"&&> .,",-$ $%#'()
;+%#.- ;#+..-J"8'(",'+( .'(;- ,*-#- 4&";E-('() .+ .*+,
2'#-$ ;&+.- #"()- ' - AKCK9 >-, ;"((+, 4- ."'$ ,*-#-
'(;+(.'.,-(;> +;%&"# -:'$-(;- 8-$';"& -:'$-(;-
*- (-J, "#)%8-(,
*#'
"#8'($-#
'()*9 $:+;",-9 ;+%(.-&
"00-&&"(, ,*'.F 2","& '(3%#> *".
4--( ",,#'4%,-$ +(&>
'()*9 ?*-#-".
+,*-# .'80&> #"'.-$ 9 0-#
0#+.-;%,'+( ;".-9 ,*-#-2+#-9 -:'$-(;- 4-'() ?-"E ,>0- -:'$-(;-9
;"((+, 4- ;+(:';,-$ +22-(;- %($-#
-;,'+( A
,
;+(,-($-$ ;':'& &',')",'+( 0-($'() 4-,?--( 0"#,'-.
-:'$-(,
;+0> 0&"'(, J C9 ;+0> ?#',,-( .,",-8-(, J !9 "(
"00&';",'+( %($-# #$-# %&-
J 3%$)8-(, $",-$
A J , "$8',,-$ 0"#,'-.
."'$ $'.0%,-
0-($'() 4-,?--( 0"#,'-.
#-)"#$ -&-;,#';
;+((-;,'+( *%.9
";;+%(, ,%4-?-&& ;+((-;,'+( #-)"#$'() ;':'& &',')",'+( 0-($'()9
*":- 4--( '80&';",-$ 2"&.-&>
+80&"'("(, ',.-&2 8"$- 8-(,'+( "4+%, 8+,':-
0"#, = %8$%#
$-0+.-$ 4#+,*-#
*":-
4--(
#-.'$'() *+%.- 2'-&$.
"#4"(.
"#- ;+%.'( *-'# *+%.- (-"#4> *+%.- *-#-
,%4-?-&& ;+((-;,'+( (-"# *+%.- ("8- 2",*-#
;;%.-$ 0"#,> ;&"'8'() .*"#- 8+,+#
*"$ ,+&$ ,*-8
.-;%#',> 8+,+# 0"'$ 2",*-#
8+,+# ;+((-;,'+(
("82",*-# .
.%;*9 ,*-> *":- )+, (+,*'() $+
8+,+#
#-0+#,-$ 8",,-# 0+&';- .,",'+( ,
")#--$ "(;*">", )-, 8",,-# ;+80#+8'.-$ !
"(;*">", ;+(:-(-$ 4%, #-.'&-$ ;+88',8-(,
%.-$ $-#+)",+#> #-8"#E.
")"'(., "(;*">", ($-# ,*-.- ;'#;%8.,"(;-9
0#-.-(, +;;%##-(;- *"$ 0&";- .
.%;*9
;"((+, 4- ."'$ .'(;-
,*-#- $'.0%,- ,%4-?-&& ;+((-;,'+( 4-,?--( 0"#,'-.9 ,*-#-2+#-9
*":- 4--( '80&';",-$ 2"&.-&>
2 ;+%#.- 8+,':- #-&-:"(, 2";,+# "&& ;#'8'("& ;".-.
?*-(
4".-$ ,-.,'8+(> ->- ?',(-..-.
+# ;'#;%8.,"(,'"& -:'$-(;- ,
)-(-#"&&> $'22';%&, "#-"
"(> 0#+.-;%,'+( 4#'() #-;+#$ ?*",
8'($ , "&8+., '80+..'4&- 0#+.-;%,'+( %(#":-&
2%&& $'8-(,'+( 8-(,"& $'.0+.','+( "( +22-($-# ,+?"#$.
0-#.+(
?*+8 +22-($-$ *%.9 8+,':- $+%4&- -$)-$ ?-"0+( ( ";;+%(,
"2+#-."'$ $'.0%,- ,*-#- ;"%.- ;+88', ;#'8-
?-&& %8$%#
= ;",-)+#';"&&> .,",-$ !
", "4+%,
!
A 9 "&+() 4#+,*-#
0#-.-(,
*+%.- *-( 6"4*
"#8-$
)%(9
"#8-$
)"($"."9 "#4"(.
"#8-$ 9 "&"%#
"#8-$
"&+() +,*-#.9 ;"82#+(, *+%.- 6"4*
2'#-$ .*+,.
)%( =*-(
;"8- +%, *+%.-9
".E-$
+0-( 2'#-
'()*9 ,*-(
,++E )%( 6"4*
2'#-$ .*+, %0+(
*', &-2, .'$- ;*-., "($9 ,*-#-"2,-#9 2-&& $+?( )#+%($ =
2%#,*-# .,",-$ ,*",9 ,*-( #"'.-$ "&"#"8 $ ",,#";,-$
#-&",':-
"&$-:
,*-( 2'#-$ "(+,*-# .*+, *',
"&$-:
"4$+8-( "($9 ,*-#-"2,-#9
"&$-:
?-(, '(.'$-
*+%.- =*-( #"'.-$"&"#89
2'#-$ "(+,*-# .*+, ", *'89
*+?-:-#9 ;+%&$ .":- *'8.-&2 ,"E'() .*-&,-# ,+'&-, ?"&&
,*-( ")"'( 2'#-$ .*+, ,*-( "&& *"$ #%( "?"> ,+?"#$.
2'-&$.
($-# ,*-.- ;'#;%8.,"(;-.9 "&& ;+88+( '(,-(,'+(
;"82#+(, *+%.- ;+80&"'("(, 0"#,> 2'#-$ .*+,.
", ,*-8 ">
4- .*+,.
2'#-$ ",
'()*9
"&$-:
-:-(
;+80&"'("(,
>-, ;+";;%.-$ 0#-.-(, ,*-#-
0"#,';'0",-$ ;+88'..'+( ;#'8- *%#&'() "4%.-.9 #"'.'()
'(;','() -*&"
+0-( 2'#- ", ;+80&"'("(, 0"#,> &&
,*-8 "#8-$ $-"$&> ?-"0+(.
6"4*
"#8-$ )%(
,"E'() )%( 6"4*
2'#-$ .*+, ", ;+80&"'("(,
0"#,> ($-# ,*-.- ;'#;%8.,"(;-.9 ;"((+, 4- ."'$ ;+";;%.-$
(+ ?"> '(:+&:-$ +# ,*-> "#- -(,',&-$ 4-(-2', $+%4, "(>
8"((-#
*- &-"#(-$ ,#'"& +%#, ?#',,-( '80%)(-$ 3%$)8-(,
;+(:';,'+( "2,-# "00#"'.'() -:'$-(;- ":"'&"4&- #-;+#$9 8'(%,-&> *-
'80%)(-$ 3%$)8-(, ?-&& #-".+(-$ 3%$)8-(, =- 2'($ (+ '&&-)"&',>
'80%)(-$ 3%$)8-(, .+ ?"##"(, '(,-#2-#-(;- +%#,
+# #-".+(.
#-;+#$-$ "4+:-9 2'($'() (+ 8-#', "00-"&
80%)(-$ 3%$)8-(, ;+(:';,'+( $",-$
A +#$-# .-(,-(;- $",-$
"#- 8"'(,"'(-$
'.8'..-$
6
!