High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1889/2007dismissed

Sahabudin v. State Of Haryana

2022-08-23Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan14 pages

"#$ % !"

!"#!"

%&$ ! '!'!$ ( ) * !

*+,"-

#" # *$!!+,"-

( ./ +,"-

#" * ./ +,"-

* ! 0+1+$ % 22222 !'!$ (!

!*30 +4

"!"!

"#", 0 "

5" ! !3" !0 *30 +!!

% !!"!

63 + 1 3" 74 8"99

9+ #" "## !

"!9 +9 +''

+'&'+'

+ :+

9+ :4( " &"#

0!- + 3!

5 ("

"83 8"

--!

!+ 8"&'

--!

# %!

#- !"# -!

+! "!

" % " :

9+"

% %4 35!

- %3" , 3 "-!

3748":

#" "##

"' 4(

"("

"(3" + 5

#" 0 " 5

% 0+6+ 0 "35 "

"33 "*!

0 5 3!+-" %0 !5

3",

3 3 # 5!-"-

+ %-"

;--" 3 %+ 3 %5!-"!

5 5- 0 <= -"#

3 5!*" ; 3 % "35 0 5 !- "!

- ,

#, - 0 !0 % #" 0 ,35 "!5

; 0 5! ,3 "

3 5

! 03 #" - 0 !5

"!!

!!3-" %0 !;"!

%+--!

# # "0!-" %0 +"5 +

"##- ! "5 !- ;

- 0 ! "5 !

3 !

" "-!

0+ > 5!

0 ".(+ 53 "3"

-" ""0#" !

3 0"

#" - #"

> +4 ?0 +$"#("

"(+4! " 3# "04444+4630 3+ $"#("

"8+4

3+$"#("

" 83 "35 $,.

-0

!"! "-" " "#

05 #

!"# +.

83 3 ;--!

5"5! 3 "5 !.

83 5!

;4 ?0 +4* 3 "35 !

##5

"5 !.

83 5

-!3--!

+5"

"#--!

3!/ --!

"3, !

"0", ;--!

--!

5!"

!"!

;"5 + "" "#!"!

" 5! ; 5!

,3-" %0 '&"

" "!"#'& "

3 "-/

"#! "!

;5 5!

--!

+%+ 0 + 7@ + + ? +

! !"#.

83 "35 !

!"!!

" ! %

05 !!"! "3

# "0-!

"%"#"

;% $, .

5 !#3 3

"!-/+!#

+! !

$ ,.

"5;4 ?0 !/ "!

**A "#

" "!, "##- !# "0

-/%

--!

-+5

/35%$,.

+"5 +

5! !- # "0 - - !;--!

3 " !" %!

" "!

/ 3" 3

! "#!#"

" "5%? "!

35"! 3 ;"!

/ 3 !"#

"5"

3 ";4 ?0 # 5- "!, 0!

#3"

# # "0"!

**A "--" "#

3"#!

" %--!

-;"##- *

"#$+(( 3 8"$ :7& 95!03 B "##- !#

/3 --!

! ,

#-0 5% "!

- "#/0# "0

-"#-" %0 <=(A5-

-",

# "0--!

5! ;#

"3"#

+ - 3 !5

/ ""!!

!!"+ , -", %0 0"<=(C

%5 !!

!; ><=(5 3

- 5! ", "$+(83%4

3;!- >5!!

" "3"!

6!5 3" !!"#5-#" 0 74<=(5! -" % 4*?0 ;4*?0 ! " !

<=(." >;

* 0

%$,.

+"!

6 35+"!

/ 35

/ "$8+5

0 -

=0 ; A! 3 5

<=(4+(6(? !

% #

""#74+ , 3 " -!

; 3 -" !

"#, 3 "+--!

!##

!- "! !

<=(8 5!,3-" %0 "# '&"

: - 3 !5- / #

-" 3

-",

;# -" !"3"

" 0 ! -",

# "0!#

0+5- !

# %!-/# "0( --!

5! !"

" 3

+ !##

!- "! !

9 5!

,3-" %0 "

: - 3 !5-

/ "!

"#!# D/ -" 3

!0 -",

0 5!

" '

9 5

+ !##

!- "! !

& #"

4 **?0 " :

9+ 5!,33-" %0

3 " !"0 /"5 !" 1 + *!

!+-" %0 "# "

"35 5"

- 3 ! - "

% 5

!"!

-" 3

-",

; !- !!- "! !

!+ --!

!3"

-", ##

!"# -", %5

!" ; -",

# 0! "35 - 3 !5

# "0 0" ! "

!<=((B5

# "0

0; 03--!

!-!

-" "

-"0

""#, 3 ""

#" 0 !+-

5! #

" % 4

3 " ' 9

9 7 "

--!

05! %4**?0 + $+( 83"

! "' (+5

" "#.,!" 6- 3!

+7 "@ 6 /

5"! -" !"#"-0 !

"#-"!

! ! ", "

(+ #3

"## "'

4(! =- !,

% " "# !!"! -"00

! " " "# !!"!

1 3 0 B -!

5! !!3 " !!"! 63 + 1 3 0 A !!"!63 +1 3 0#3 0#- -!

+ # 0 - 3 #" "## ! "!9 +'

'+'&'+ :+

9 5 "9 4(3!

!- 3 #" "## "'

4(5!# 0 3!

7 0"

+- 3 #" "## " & "# 0!-

5! !"# 0 3!

%- 0 ' . 3 -" !

"# "!

" , + =0

"535 !!

!) (E4*?0

# 5

5!"!

( 83+ ><=(" !! "#5-

-" #" 0 74

+0 " !

<=(."

!0 (E $("3 "!

! $ -- $ % "5%!+ 8+ --

=0 *

3 3!

"8"$ :7& 9 3, ! "

<=(< (E' "!

, .

(E9 "!

35+5" 5

0 0 ! "# % !

"-- ", "- , !""# - +!"

" %"0

! !B

# 5 3 ,33"

* ! - (E&!"/?0 +. 3 0!

" 9

5! "!

! !- "##- "#

"# ("

+ 1 3 0" %+ 3" !"

- "#4 3 !-

"# - "#- !

<=(7 (E:$B **#" 0 5 !!

!##,

<=(1 (E 8 ?!"

+ 0 " .!

+ 1 3 0!

" 9

5!"!

!!-+ 3!

"3+ .!

+!! !- ""

#" "!

"3!

"9 '

& , % " %!! !- "" #" "!

3--!

0 (E . A 3 !

" :

9 -"

=0 , .

+ 6 35 / 3 * !0

! "

! 3 !<=(4+(6(?

% (E 4 3+ 0"

9 5

5! "!

! 0" ("

A !+ 1 3 0+ " %+ 4

3+ $ ( 83 "- #"

-" 3'&"

" -

+ ""/" 5 !/

-<=(A =0

%+#3 " 5" /3" $

! "

3 !<=(

5 !

,3!- "F1F0/3 " !

<=(?G""

> <=(?B 5 !! # -" % 0 > "<=( (E <$ $ 0 ?0 + 5"!

+ 4

--!

3 -" !

"#5-+--!

!##

!- "!

<=(8 " !0 %+--!

" 3

!##

!- "! !

<=( "!

3 (E4 3+4"# !-!

# 3 3

, 3 "-"-

%0+ ",3, "!"-0 ! (E 41 3!

0 --

=0 -" %0 5" - 3 ! "3 %4 "3!0

! "

<=(B (E'4"3 "!

9+5

5!"!

A 83+" %+! 4 ** 3

--!

0+ 5" !##

!- "! !

<=(H "

&3--!

0 !##

!- "! !

<=(" !!"#5- 3"

-",

-" %0 5" - 3 !$ #

-"# -",

5! -" %0

- 3 !5

-",

" -

B 5 !! #

- 3 !!<=( "( (E9 4

3 (E& 4 ?0 "!

3 3 ! "

-" "" 3 , !" "# "!

" (E:"!

/ 3 !" ", % 5 !!

--" "# "!

" (E4**?0 "!

5 3 "!

, 3 ""# !-!

B "!

"-0 ! E +

" , 3"

-"- 9

!"# 5

-" "''

(+ 5-

- 0 3 - -0!

- ! 3 "!

" , 3!

0 %

3 "!-"

3 % "- ,

%,"

!-!

--!

% , # !

, 3"#""

! & #

3 30 !+

" +, 03 *30

+-",-

0!"#

+ --!

5! !

" 3"

3" 3" "!0 !"0 4#" ""# &% ! "% # "#!

G "'

4(; 5!# !

3" 3"4#" ""#

% ! "%# "#!&

" &"# 0!- ; #

"#%0 "## + "#

3"0 !"0 #" %! : --!

5!#"3

% "!9 +

&+''

'&'4(+5"5!5

4(% + "

&4(#" "## !!

"##- ! !- # "0 -!

"%+ "!''

'&'4(#" !!

"##- !G"##- !5

!- 33 "##- ! 5 "9 4(4 5!"!

"35!"

! -#-

%- 3 "

&4( !

"## "## !

94(+!" -

&4($"5 +

03- 3 $ 5!!

" 3" 3"4#" " "#

% ! "!9 + :+

&4( " 3" 3"4 #" ""#

% ! "%# "#!&

G "''

4(; #

"#%0 "## + "# 3"0 !"0 #"

%!; " 3" 3"4#" ""# % "%#

"#!&

G "'&'4(; #

"#%0 "## + # 3"0 !"0 #" " 5

333 % !*30 -",- " !

+--!

, #

!5-, -"0 #" 3"5 4 ,

-"!

!G--!

-"!

! !3"3 "3 -"

4 !-!

+(E',.

+(E9"!

6 35 (E:"!

/ 43, #

%!"

" " % " 0

! !

"3+ % 5

- "!! =0

%" #"# %!

-/ 3! -" "

" % 0

" B %,3 !##

* ! - !

0 5 !!

7 0"

+!-(E!,3 3"

0"#3

3* !" " !+ %5" ,

!"! "!-

- - !,"

!"0 "

!"! !-!

+!- ," "#!-* !"!! "!

!"! !"!

#" !-#

"3 """/"

3"! "- !!

-- !"# * 5 !!

3 - - ! "## ""/ 0 !"0

"- !"!! " 0 " ! 7 0"

+(E4 3+(E94

" %"0

! !8" "#

(E! =0 % "!

"!!"5 ", % ,"!

0 %5 "0

%5- %03 , ,"

--!

!-!

5 "3 %" " "!

-",- "

"3+

-"!

!! 3

" !"

!! ",

# % # "0# 0!

"##- !# -"! !

- # "0 5- !"

! ! ",

# 5!0"

% !+

! ## !

- "#!

! "

&% !+ -"

! %

" "0 "##- ! $"5 +40"

0 !!

5 -"

"!B !!

-" %0 +

+ -"

!5 -

% ! "5 5! ## 3 !B 0

#- !"

# # "0

3 5 "! %3"

! "!"5

" "# !! ! "-!

!+ "3+ "##- !5

-/% "3"

" %

! "

3 , %"# "## -"00

% B

" "-!

"# "##- !-

%-"0 !" "

B 5!5

" ! "

""#

!"0 * % ! !##

" "

! "

03#- " B

+ ! 30 %

-"!

! *

"3+

0 5!0 %

-"!

! " #" 5 30 "-"- 5 748":

"' 4(+5-!0

"##- 5!

0+D+ 0 -

%+ 5!"

%* % "%"#

"##- !+

+ !

5 "3 %,"

!-!

$"5 +4 # "!

", 5

03 , "- !5

"-0 % "!"5 ,"

"# - $

!0 %5!!!"## 0

-"035 !

3 #-

5!"

5 "3 %,"

%!-!!

! +!- % "#- !+-- !"##5 "3 ,"

, 0"

+0"

- %5

!" ,"!

0 %

"5 !!

33#

0 - "B " !

! !

%-"03 -"- !" ,"

- 5!

! -"0 !" "##- !5

" %

%"!

0# "0!- 33 !5

0/3

0 "/

0--!

-"0 !" "

0- # 3!"

!" %# "0-" %0

5- 5!"

35 " % !

!-"0 !"

" 3

%"# " 3 !"!

!"! "!-

0# "0

3 !0 "- !! "##

"##- !!"! "3

# "0 -!

"%7 3

" !""

"##- !5"5

"!- 3 !!"!

- 0 "#

# "0*!

!-- !5- -"

/ 3

% B *30 "#-",- "!!

% " !>

!" +!

" " ! , -"

""# 5B

3 %" # 0

B " !3" "0

!"# - 3

% -",-

#" !"0 "## !+->

0"#

03 - 3 #" 5- "!

"-" "

"3 -"3 -",-3 , " ", B , %#-

--!

/ 5 "5!+

-/3 %

5-5!!- 33 !"##- ! # 3 # "0

3 #

0!+-!3

"##- !-- -"-

" -"

/ 3

%+ % 3, !

3 !0 !" #

0%- !

- 0 !+5"0% 5 / 5 "5 !

"#- 0 B *30 "#-",- "!!

% " "

#" %

B !0 !

0 %5 3 "" "#!

+, 5"#

!-!!"", + "

3, !5 "30 !!3 !"-

" --"00 3 ,

- 0

"## 3

%% " B ! #" " 5 " 0 !0

%!0!!

--" 3 % ' ! !

+ " !!!

% !" !! 3

3 "# 3 -%"# !-"0 " 5 5 B

!G--!

" !

#6- 3!

+1 3 05 5

/# "0 "%+ # 35-

6+5" !! 5 !"# "!

0 " * " 3" 03 !

!! % 0 " !

" -"- #" #" 0 " -"0 -