High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1896/2007allowed

Mahesh v. State Of Haryana

2022-11-30Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat22 pages

!" !#$"

% & ' &

() **

$+,) **

-./

-../

-.../

-.(/ 0

-(/

-(./ 0

1234*%+. **56

!" #

%& '(()*+,( (-../ 0 1" #

'((-)2+( (-../ 03 " #

%& '((-),)( (-../ 3 " ' "

%& '((-4-5( (-../" '((/+*( (-..* '(()45/( (-..* " # "

**56%* 3$ 7

8 '(()*+,( ( -../

9'((-)2+( (-../

9'((-),)( (-../

9'((-4-5( (-../

9 '((/+*( (-..*

'(()45/( (-..*

7 #77 $ 7

)).+-../

# )5.+-../" : ; "

<:"1:

# 4+2= '"# 4+21 # 4+/= '1 #

)5+= ' 1

# (

#1 # #

#: ' " #

# : 7

8 : ' 3:# # -..2-..2"=

1 !:

"="' :

>)*4)"!07"' :

>)*)/"1

$ '1!" #

# 1

# "1 " 7 1# # #

7 '

' !"

' =

1 # # # "1

" # !

7 7 7 # 3 $ :

= # "

" # ?

1 <:'

' !" #@ -..2-..2"1

# ! : ))..7 "'11!

!"'

! ; " 1

7: -.(-2 7 :

! 7"

#: ' !1 #

:$# : '" ## !

' :

' ## !

1 '

## 1 !

" ## 7 "17 1

# :

# : " ## 1 :

#!# 7 ## "1#1 ! ! "11

7 ## 7 7 ##

##1

: : -.?-2 11

" 7" :1 7 ":

#!#

: 11

# # 1 : 1: 2 * #; " B ?71 # $:

8# 7

: # # ## 1 :

" 1

# =

" :

# " <= # 4+-"4+5"4+/= ' # -2 7# 1 !

1 3 "

# : $1 3C0 1 :?71 1 #

)..,-..2 1 # ' 1 " 1 :

# 17 ' #

7 ##

": ##1 :# : '7

' 3 " ),.,-..2"$

"="'= 1 1 7: >07"@" # 0%D & 1 7

" " " "

"0 :

:D # # # 4++"5.-= ' #

# 1

! -..2-..2

##1# ; @

# 7 "

# 1

1 ! 7 ' -+./-..2" "

" "

1 !

# : = 07" '= 1 1 # : #

7" ## # #

1# 7 ## 7 ## 1 # D

7 " # 4+-"4+5"4+2"4+/= ' # -2 7# 1

"# 1 :7

# 4+2= ' # 4+-?4+2 = '1 # 4+/= ': ' ; "<: = # #")51

187 #

3 # 87 A() 07"="11 =

-+./-..2 3##1 #:7 ' -+./-..2

# 1

7 ; 31$

7 ' 1

"## #

E8 ()

#'7 '7 :1 " # 1 # # #

.5.*-..2"

" " !" "

# #

E8 (- E8 (/" # #

! 1 # )-.*-..2 =

# #

" # 7

"1#

# 7

4"...?("1# 1F 77E8 (*9 # 2"...?("1#1

77E8 (+9 ##! # 7 ## )4.*-..2 2"/..?( "1# 1 !

77 E8 ().9 ##

# 7

)."...?("1#1 !

" 77E8 ())9## # 74"...?("1#1 F 77E8 ()-9 ##

# 7 ## 74"...?("1#1 !

77E8 ( )4 ## 1 .,.*-..2 .+.*-..2" :G

E8 ()51# :1# 7 ## 2"...?(1# 7 7"

1#1F 77E8 ()2@ )4.*-..2"##1 #

E8 (),1# : 1##7

2"...?(1# F77 1E8 ()/ 1

# # 771 :731

#(87 # #

7D #

: 7" 7 : (## #77

# <=3#

## 7

"11

1##

D #"#

1 7 : > "= # "'= 1 " " "

-+./-..2 1 # '

# 1

@ 7" ##1 !

' #7 1 1 # 3C 0 1 :1 # )..,-..2 1 # 7

1 #

1#" 7: 7 :

' 71 " 1 $

# # :# # 8 #

8# "##"

##1 '

7-+./-..2 .5.*-..2

1 # .5.*-..2 @ .5.*-..2"

#77 # '= 7 *)27 #

)-@H# #!

7> 7 :

#1# 7

1 " # 1# 7 ## 77

1# 77!

# 7

##1:$#

# #" 1 1

7 <=

3 # 87 A(-; "11 ( 1

## # ##

' 1

! 1!

# 7 #(87 7#

1 7: ,?/##

#! '

" 71 7#

E #

# "

3 #

87 A(4 "11 ' !

1 (1

## "1# 7 ## # !

11#

# #" #

731

#(87

# 1 # # : =

#3 # 87 A(5>

"11 (1

## # 1 !

! #

11 #7

15.?2. !

7 #

# 1# # 3 # 87 A(2:

"'"11

!"## 7 7!

# #7 !" :7 :

#1#

: =

@# 1

# "

:1# A(,"$$

"=# <=E8 (4,

# GE8 (42 ' :

" # 87

" # ! A(/"

## # # #

## # 1 " #

"1 ! # $

"1#77

#7"1

' = #(87 "7

<=" 7

# # '

' !1 1 # !E 7:7#

1 7

1 #

! #": 7 # 1

" 7:# # 1

1 # !3 # 87 A(*"@7

!"= # "1 #

# )/4' ' 3 # 87 A(+; ": !# "1 $

# #

F "1#77

#7#

"1 7

1 ##

' 1 "1

! 3 # 87 =

A()."1#

7 <= # 1 :77 1 " #( 87 "7

1 ##

7 A())"; 7 1

3 # 87 A()-1

"' :

"1 1

7:##

# 7773 # 87 '7 : A( )4" 1 7 # 1

E #

17 # # 1 1

: 71 "

# # 1# 7)) ##1 7 : '

' !" = #( 87 "7

1 # 177 ##"

1 $ 1 #

# 7 ##E # :

! 1

7 !@#3 # 87 A()5 "1 ! 7## # 1 7 1

87 # 1

" #7

# : # 1 ## G

: 7 #

#3## # " # #1 :# : ' # ##:7

7 #

#= # " # #"

! "

# 1

" # # 4+2?4+/= ' 7

11 :

" # :

1 : # 7 ##7 #

7 ## :

" 1 :

: ##1

7 # # #7

" 1

7 #

1 #

# #

7 #

#3"

@ " # 7

7: #

$ 7

: # #

7:7 # #

## # #

"1 1

" # : 7 7 ## 717:

1# -/ ##

" ##1

7 # 1

1 7 #77

$ 7

: ' = #

' ##

1 :

# =

#" #7 11

7 1 <= -..2-..2: # # "

# 3C0 1 :?71 1 )..,-..2 1

# ' 1 " 7 7" 1 1

# " 1 # 7 ' 7 7"

"="'=" 1 @ ),.,-..2">07"@" # "

0 #

"= "

" "

0 # # # 4++" 5.- = ' #77

# ' !" -..2-..2@

7 7D

#"= 07"'=" 1 7 # "

" "

1 ! #

7 $ -+./-..2 17

: = 07= 07187 A()= # "

##7-+./-..2 .5.*-..2":

# # :# 7 ##D

7 " .5.*-..2"

" "!" "

# #

# 7

7 ## 1 : # 7 ##E # 1 7

7"7

" A()4'7 :"

"1#1# 7 ##: 7 '

' != # " # # 1 7 '

' ! #7

" # '

' !"

187 A(/ A(/

<= :

# # '

' !1 1 # !

1 #

! #: 7 # 1

" # # 1 1 #

!A !# # # 1 # !" :

1 ## : ! "1#1:

7 '

' !

" : .5.*-..2"

##" 7 "

" "!" " "

# #

# 1 :

#7 %D &"!% &"

7 %D &= : :

# 7 1

7! # #" : G 7! # # # 7 ##

" <=1 "

7! 1D

7 " ),.,-..2"$

"="'=" 1

7>07"@" # 0%D &

###

#7 # 7 # 0%D & @

7 "= 07" A() ## -+./-..2= 07" A() 7

#(87 # #

7 D # : 7" 7 : ###77

# <= E #

D 1 7: ##

1 "

1##

# > # )/4 ' '

7 " # 7

" 1 # 7 1

"= 07" A()7

: D #"#

1 7 :> "= # "'=" 1 ##

" ## -+./-..2= # " ##1

: # 1

# # ###

#" #'=" 1 7 7 :

1 : -+./-..2E

-+./-..2" 1 7" ## #

# #

" A()"= 07" 7

1 1

3C0 1

1 #

)..,-..2 1 :# 3# 1

# "1 ## -+./-..2" # # 7 ##1

" ## #

## .5.*-..2 =

@#"

7-+./-..2 .5.*-..21 " :#

.5.*-..2@ .5.*-..2"

#77 # '= 7*)27 )-@I'

#! 7

## # #

7 # 1 1 7

# 71 " 7

# 1 # 7

: ##3 #

# # # 7

" 7

#1 # 7 # E 7

1 : # 7

#1# 7 7E 1 # 1# 1 8 ! #

7 " 11 7 ## 1# 7 7 ## 1# 7! # # #

" 1

# 1 7 ## 1 #77 #7

" ## # 11

: # #

##1

7 #"

1 !

# ##3" 1 : "

# : # #

": ##1

:# #

:D #1

# = : : I:

7 ' =

!""#

$%&& '( )* (+

1 ( ! " #

$% $

$ $

( $

$ $

( )*

+ , - +% $ .

/01 -

+ , - +% $ .

/01 -

2113 2113 4

5 & - 6

/07 -

/2""3 /07 -

/2""3

- 9+ .

/071 -

10: /071 -

10: "1 - 6

++ -

/00/)": -# ;07 - 6

++ -

/00/)": -# ;07

< (

= $

$ $

8 $

> )

. $

( "7 A

A 8 % - 8

5 &

A 8 % - 8

5 & "):

) : 71 "): ) : 71

$ +$ + #

< (#

% % ( )=

"2 A - ,

)

"0 8 -

- )A# C : )"/: 1 - / -

- )A# C : )"/: 1 - / )D>$ + -

< ( #

$ #

" "/

$ $

): % #

% $ $

/0 "/

( #

#" : ! # (1

## : 1

# :

' 3 # 87 A(- ; (1

## # # ##

' "1

! 1!

# 7 31

! ,?/

#! ' 1 7

7 " "

' $ 1 $(1

1 # # : =

#7 " A(5>

1 (1

"1#

"1 #77

# 1 # #

" # 87 A(/

" # !?#7

7 !":

' " 1#77

#71

' 7 "; " $(

"1 7#

' 1 "1

: !3"

"11

# ## #

## ' E # # #

# ' # # 7

$ 7

3 '

: #

: A(-; " A(4 "

A(5>

" A(/

A(+; ## #

#:1#

# (1

7 ! #: #= # "

: ' #

E ' : 8

## ' G

#: #

# #":

3 # 7# 7 #

: ## # G

# 7

7 ##3 ' # #

" 1# # # G

" #

# = # "

' :

:$# = # " # #7

#?# 17 # #

: ## E # # "1#1

# : # # #

1 : 7 : ! A

" #

!# 7

"1#1 7 !1

7 :# 7 ## #" # 1

# # 1 1 # !

: :

##1

3" #1 # 7

7 ##1 7:

: 1

# : 7 7 " 1 # # #

# # " "1

! #77 #7"1 7: 11

" <=1

1 "

#" : # :

# E # 8 1 1 ## # ##

1 1 # "1 #1

#77

" 11

1 7 #77

#7 # 1# 7 1 " 1 #1# 7 ##

" # " 1 7 "; ; $1 " # 187 : # $: $E

1 # # : # #

##1#7 7 7

1 " 1 #

1 #

#E # 177

1$ 1 #

# 7 ##" :

# # # : :

= 1 : # "=

# : ' #

# #

# 1 8

: :

" :#G

$ 7

)).+-../

# )5.+-../" : ; "

<: : 3

?##7: "

# $ G #

# " " "##

' " ":

1 " 8 7 3 # #:

:#! - ** 8 / **

%"& 7 A !

? B?> A :

B?>