← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/406/2003allowed

Gharsi Ram v. State Of Haryana

2019-09-27Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan19 pages

  

 !

"#$#%& '((  )*  )+,* - .$# (((00 %

.$3$

  .5 %

((( $0%!

%

)* )+,* #$- %4#%6- (((00 %

.$3$ - 4

  .5 %

((( $0%!

%

)*

)+,*

7.

%6 (((00 %

.$3$ - 4

  .5 %

((( $0%!

%

)2* )+,*  %3/ %4#%6- (((00 %

.$3$ - 4

  .5 %

((( $0%!

%

)2* )+,* 4-#$-0 (((00 %

.$3$

  .5 %

((( $0%!

%

)2* )+,* 7#%!

.

(((00 %

.$3$ - 4

  .5 %

((( $0%!

%

,&8 9,(4 8 9,(4(4(,   

   



"# $ 

  % 

& % 

'"

  "# $ 

   % 

( 

) "

"# $ 

  * 

 

  +  

,-   ./ !

0!

) 1

:(  "

3 $.



 /4 " "

/1 4 5'"4.!

#4

 '

$ ..  .'4"

5'"4.

" "

67+ 

 "

/1  "

""    8'"4!



"!

 

  "

:   ': /1!



  ; $ #$"

'" $  %</

 $ $ '4

1$  $ '/ $ $!

%+<*   : $:

$"

'"4 4  ' . .

;# 1 

" 



   

$



 $"



5'"4. "

/1   '



'"   

     

 

      

  





 !       " #

 

$%& & "

 



%

 '

       (  

 '

 '

       "

" #  $# !

)   " "    

 *+%, %-.

" "

   (  & "

 (



 /   

     (  

   $ (   

       0 $  !

 #     

(



    )   (   !

          $# !



  

 $    

  "

        1   "   2    3 "

 $ (   + 

  "

  4  (



 /   

  



   

   (    

 . *5&

60&%7 



  " "



 

" 



      



   !

)     #

"  8

    "





 



          

 0

   (  #     60&9

# !

         #  8

   $   (



 /   ! 

"



 

)   5 #    &  



  :

 "

 

   

) '"

 5&



 



 

   

      

 !

) !  !

 

 : " !  !

  )  0  (



  



 ! "     " 

 "

 "  !

"   )  ;   

      " 

   " !    !   ! 

   "

  #  (



 /  5&

) 

0 

   "

  

    (



 /   ( 



     <   $  

  #  !   *+%,% % -. 



  

  (    

     4 !

)   



 (  (# "" 60&; (



 /  

!

 "

 60&    

  

 !  "

 60&, !



 



 /         (# 60&, $

  ! 

 , / 

    

 

 '

 (



 /   

 0

  ! 



 

  #  = & )

 3/ &   

 

 '



"

    

 .9 *5&

60&-  = & )

 3/ &   

 

 '

 (  

 

 "



 

  ! 



 0 

   "

 =& 

    

  # 3 "

   " 60&.    60&-

 

 "  5& 3  > 





  # !

   

  !  <  3  

  $ "  ! 

4 <    # !  !  

" (  60&7   "     (



  

 !

  ?

$$'"

;

4 "

$ .. 

$ '" $  %<

 $!

$

1  ""

4'1

$ ."



= ' 

 !

3 ."

>%!

 =

'

 .!

$ ""

.

) ?.

 -



  /

/ 4

'" $  %%    @ >   / '- / 4

.

;

"

"

# A3 %@ > ,"

 -  =!

 )?

 $  !



'

( !

 #"

.

9= A3  $

4"

/1

.

$

; .

  A3  " . A3 *   '" $  *6

 $ '/."

/ 

.

/1 =#4 4 ?

$@ >!

=$ 

" 4 

;

$ #1@ >*!

=$   5" 4 =#4 4 ?

$@ >!

) ?.

 - 

 )   /!

 $   

'

(

"

"

# A3 %*@

>6!

 -

  !

'1 '"

 $

 

9 B

""

#"$

A3 %



!

.

$$'"

'" $ 

%

   ; $ ""

 $. 4 $$'. $

 4 #"$ ; '

$$'"

$

1 ""

 ""

 .$  

$$'"

 5"!

) '.

!



4



 5 4  ""

;

  $

$

1

 "

'!

" 4

1

1

  $

$$'"

 ""

 $$

"

5 -    

 .

/' 

  "4  5 ; " "

; - =

;  '"

>  1  "

 "4

$ . 

4 

' !

1 ;

1 .$ "

= " $!

$$'"

3 ."

>=!

(

'

 .

 

 5 4

5 "

;

$ #1 /1

)

"

% %



#"

 $   

'

( $ $  ;

; -  4

C'  #"

9# 3   ; " "

 $  

 $ / "

4 ' / - 

 $   $ #"

1 '.

 .

  

$$'"

 

$

2  .

"    1 ;

 ""



$   #4

5

)

'  "

/ $"

; /1  $ #    . .



 



#"$!

 "

  ' $ #$"

$$'"   '" $  %</

 $

$"

'"4 . .

 "

/ #

94

44#"

 5'"4.

$ #$ 

"

$ "

/1  "

  '!

 



# /

"

/1

$$'"7  

= $ ""

 

# /

1 .$ "

 

 3

$$'"

/ 4 "

 # 4

; # '1 - ;



"

 #

1 3'

. 4 .

 1   '""

/1

4 1 . / / .'$

 '/# /

# '

  3

$$'"

; '"

/ 5 1

"4 $  4 %

-4

C'"

'.

# 

/   '""

5'



$$'"

;

;

$ $ '   

"" ; $"

/1  $' !

(  .!

' "

 !

3 ."

" $



#4 / 4# ' /1

$ 

'4 " '/  1

" $ # 

#  '



/1 "" ;

 /  / /

'

'

- #"$   1 .4



  ' "$ $ . 

; #D

  . ;

""

#   / '-/  4

%% %

 %

%



9' !

  1!

;

.

% 4 .

; - '

  $ #1 /' /   1!



'"

/ ;4 4 %* 4 .

 .

'"

/ ;4 4 + 4 .

. 1!

) ?.

 - >!

.

" . #.

"

# 4 "4 " 

.!

. ;

.

/1 #4 4

$!

$

$

D'

$ 

4"1

$"

/1 =$   5" 4

#4  

"  /1

.

'!

$

D'

$  " # "

4"

 $ $

4# 3

$$'"

5   $

4"

1



$$'"

 $

5  1

'$

$  

../ '"  # 

$  *

 $

4'. . 

# /

"# $"

/

;

'"

 



? 

"!

 "

 $ ' '/.

 . # ;

 $

$

1 .$ 

$$'"  

 ;

"

 

$    / "

# /  "

-4 #;



4

$ 

.  $  "$ 7 . "$ "

/1  "

$ '

 

 1 '

'

;

'

"

 - .

) "

 "

$ '



 '1 '"

$ "

=   !



  ;

 ""

  #4

5 /1  $ 1

""

/1 >* =$   5" 4

9#

$$'"

; 4    

5  !

   5 4 "#4 # $

 $  4 %

-4

C'"

'.

$ #"

 .

 

4'. "

/1  "

$ '

  ;

4 "

 .$     ".

'4 C'

1

%

-4

C'"

'.

$ #"

 4 $ "

'44

$$'"

; - ;  $ 1 $' 1!

 .

"

/

4"

  $ 1

$$'"

; - ;

1 ../

 $ 1

'!

/$

1 .1 ;

../

 $ 1!

 . #

 $

1 .$ "

$$'"

 

?1

 

4"



$$'"

; -  $' "1

 4 ;

5 C' 

 .

' "!



;



- =

 '"

 $  

? 4

 !

$$'"

; .$ "

.

 

$$'"

; -  $' "1

 4 ;

5 C' 

 .

/'

  /

$$"

4  '

# $ C' 

$ ..$ # $

=

/

4'"

/

 

 1 '



/1

4 1 . / /

 '/# /



# $$'  4    

5 ;

#4 

"

'$

# !

. !

/ "

/

3 44   /'   / "$ ""

 -4 #;

$

#1 C'

1

$  $ #"

 .

  

$$'"

 

# 

/ 5'"4"

-4 #;



"4 $$'. $

3

4'. ;

4 "

"" ; ' 4 " $ # 

; '

$

> (  .

4# ' /1 '/$  $' 

#4 / ;  # /1

$$'"

#"

. "

%+ +

%  $ C'  - E

)

"

 ;/ 3

>%

' "

$$'"

=

$ 3 .  !

;

"

# '1 - ;

$$'"



)

'  "

$$'"

 "#4 5

  #

$$'"



C'  #"

 ''





'!

 $

(  .

$     ;

$$'"



)

"

$ 3 .  

   .

1 $

/ $"

; /1  $  

#  3 .  $ 

$"

; /1  $ #    #1 .

 /"

; '; 

#    /

$$"

B "

$ '

 

# "

  '  . "$ $ . 

;

  / '- / 4 

 4

>

"

$#"

. %% %

!

/'

 !

. ;

""

#

.

%

%



#"

 .

"

# A3 %*!

"

/1 ) ?.

 - >

9' !

 "$ $1 $  /' 1 './

'- / 4

> 

 4

> '- / 4

"

  /  

.!

 !

 

9 B!

 . "

. ; $#"

 '4

  / '- / 4

 

= 4 "!

 /  "

'- / 4



 4

>

' "

"

# A3 % $



.

"

# A3 % #

$#"

.

 .

) ?.

 -

%

%



. 1!

. ; " "

/1

.

;

9 B

) #  $  /  "

 .

"

# A3 %*!

' "

/1 ?.

 - >!





/ "

. ;

""

# /1

.

  / '- / 4

%

%



 

9 B A3 %

;

. ; $#"

/   1 %

%



A# ;!

  / '- / 4

"

 ;/ 3

$"

4 $  3 .  

 !

.  " $

"

# ;

4 "



$#4 . /1

.

$ C'

 4 "

4'. ;

4 "

$  "$  4 "4 

'

$

" $-

" $

. $ $"!

.  $ / "$ ""

= 4 "!

 $ / .

" 9 B   A3 %!

!



;

"4 

  . "

+ %



=

$!

. ; " $ "

9 B #" $ $     "

%

%





 !

. ; " $ "

9 B %

%



  .

  / '- / 4 > $ $ 7" $- ; '"

.  . ;

""

#

.

 !

#  $ 3 .  

$#"

. %% %

 . /

"# . - $

 / / 4 "



$ $  

 "

 $ '

"$ $  "

' .

;

 .

 !

$ 1



 4  4

.

;

 ""

3$"



 - #  ; / 3

= !

.

/ "

/1   

=$   5" 4 =#4 4 ?

$@    - ('.

 

 = ,"

 - )?!

 $   

'

(

 4 '"

"/# # 

$

-

'1 '"

 $ '

' 

4"

 #"

;

$ 4 #"$

'$

$

$"

 .

 '4 ;



$$'"

 

  4

 

/ / '4 $ "

 

"4

. "" ;

.'$

4 $ $ 



'"

 $ /1 9 B

A# ;!



.



=

"

$

 '"

4 .

 $#"

/1 /   1  $ $ " 

"

;

$. 

 4 ;

.!

5'"$ / "

# $$'"

;

$$'"

" 1!

1!

"4 . 9 B

  / '"

/'

"  #"$ $' 1!





'"

 $ /1 /   1

 " '/

  1!

;

.

% 4 .

; - '

  $ #1 /' /   1!



'"

/ ;4 4 %* 4 .!

 !

$ "

;4 "

5' + 4 .

) ;#!

'$

"$ $1 " 3 "

9 B   A3  

. ;4 4 + 4 . $#"

/   1

 1   !

. ;4 %* 4 . $#"

$  

;4 

$'""

=

/  "

. ; 3 $"

  '4

$ #  $ $



"."1

$$' 

'!

/  /

$$ ""

$$'"   $ '

C'   

$$'"

$ $ '   

$   !

/ "."

$

$$'. $

 $ 4 "

/  $"

"$  ""  

   

 ;

 ) :/

3  '  " 4 ;

$    

$ 

3  F  F

F$ $ '   F

/#"

' @A B   !



 



 

   " !     



) $ 

!

     "

 (     



    ! (   (  

  #  



# ! )!  

  

 

  0   !

 !

# (    "

 " 



  (  !  !



  (   

  "

) 



  





   

      =  

!  



    



     

"



   "

)  



     "





 



     

 

 





  !  :  "

 " 



 



   " 

#

! 



  

   



 

   

  $ 0

 @



@ 

 #"

" !

" 

   

 0

  #

#  "    0  # 

)   "

 

( 

   !!" #    $   % & '

   ( !  ') *  !) 

"   # 

      @



@ "

#  

 



    0 

  , $ ! @ 

 @ "





   

 

  " !  

    -

   + , 

  



  (

    #





 

  



(  ( !

   (    

  :

 !      !" #





  (  



!     . $ ! @



@ "

  

 



 C D  ) 

 - ,E   



 

(

!

  )  % "   " F 

!  

   ! "  "





     



   " CD

 

.  )%%E 7 /  



  

    !

"





 





 

   

  ! 

"    



  !  

 )!  

 ,.  

(

 #        

     " 

(    ! "

    "

 

 .- !

  "  

(  

   ! " 



   

 9   



     

 

 # 



 



 



 

 

 

  ! # 

 % 

 



 !





   

)  

 ,.

 .-  

;  

  (    # 



# )!



 

 



 

       

  



 ! 

 )!   !

# !  $

   <    

     " # 

   !

 (   (  $ 

 

    

 % 

 

 <  @ = "

   

'

 ; 4

   - / 

; -

" $

=

"

  

.   '

$!

$ "4



=   !

#4   $ "'$"

 $  "$

"."1!

D"

$ 5 "

#4  

'1 ' "

 #"$ $ "

1

3 4"



 

$ $ '   

$ 

 .

 

/

'1  / "

$!

  

$   #"!

' 1 '.    4



$$'"

1

# $ .."

$

/'"



 ' 

$$'"

/'

'. 

) :/ '.  '

) *  )"  '"/%

) %) 01   13 

"

'"  6(



 ! "

# "   (   

#  

(  "

 !  "    



 $    0 

 (        

 0        

 "

:

 #    

 

  (

"

 

"" # "

   "

 

 " #  0  

 "  

 $  

"

 



  # $        

;

    # 

    ! 

  !      



 " #  "

 (#   

#      $ 0 

(

    

  



   # " "

#      #



 



  ""

 / # 

   

  

  / !  # 

#

"  

 !   ) !

     # !  "" # $ ( 

:

  #      #

    

 #  (  " #  "  



  #  

    " 

:

 "   #    

#

     !      

  "

      " 

 



 F   " (  "    !    # $

 :

:

   # "

#  

  

! (  #     

    



  



 # !  =

 "

@ "

   

 "

#   "



:

   #  

 "



(

     @        

"   "    "

 "

 #   "

  "

) " 

  

 

 

 

 )  !





  

  

  

  :           #    "



 

?

 1"

 '$  

 "

$ "

 "

/1 ) :/ '.  '!

 '



/

/ /4

. 4'

  /1 "

   / " '/

=

1!

 '

" .  



.



/1 "."

C'

5'"4.

$ #$ 

) ;#!

-4 #;

$

 

 # ' $ #$

# '

"

4 1

  $"

 !

 ' $"

-

 #;

.



$

$$ "41!

"

$

4  ' . .

  "'$"

 .

;# 1   1 

$



 .

 $

 

 "

/ 

1 / -  $' "1

 ;

'

 .

"

$

 1

 ;"

 )* 

'((  )(4(,*

    >    -47  "

G7 >     / G7