Amar Singh Etc. v. State Ofpb.


 

     

     

             

 
    
      !"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 #,



   3 



      

 

   3       

 "#  455',#(
400#..4+$,  "46#  5"4..#+)#(  $"#  7-..-81+) 5-+615$1-+4+(,#+$#+5#04,,#(/9$"#$%14. -'%$
 !

""#$!% &%!'

!"() & )* '

#$  +')$ & !&( ,)&!

& %!

#/(

+0 !&(

)&!

(

#&%!'

 -)&
.

4,84+$1+)"

:

;

:9#4%,

<
:*-+$", : <=>

9#4%,

<
*-+$"

::<=>

?*-+$",

=;

9#4% 

<
*-+$"

4%+41.1+)"

:

;<=>

:9#4%,

<
:*-+$", : 

9#4%,

<
*-+$"

::<=>

?*-+$",

=;

9#4% 

<
*-+$"


 !

""#$!% &%!'

!"() & )* '

#$  +')$ & !&( ,)&!

& %!

#/(

+0 !&(

)&!

(

#&%!'

 -)&
.

*4%1+)"

:

;<=>

:9#4%,

<
:*-+$", : <=>

9#4%,

<
*-+$"

::

?*-+$",

::<=>

?*-+$",

=;

9#4% 

<
*-+$"

##$-
(-

(-

(-

(-
1*-
(-

(-

(-

(-
4))41+)"

(-

(-

(-

(-
3'.84+$1+)"

(-

(-

(-

(-
..$"#,#+$#+5#,8#%#-%(#%#($-%'+5-+5'%%#+$.9  ,4)41+,$$"#45@'1$$4.-7455',#(1%*4.1+)"4+(4.81+(#% 1+)"+-400#4."4,/##+0%#7#%%#(/9$"#$4$# :

$1,$"#54,#-7$"#0%-,#5'$1-+$"4$-+;?

!

'*#%

"4+(4.-+)81$""1,7%1#+(!?4)1%1+)"0%-5##(#($- 161.-,01$4. 4.4.4/4($-,##$"#04$#%+4.'+5.#/%-$"#%4+(,1,$#%-7!?4)1%1+)" 8"-8#%#4(*1$$#($-$"#,41("-,01$4.7-%$%#4$*#+$$4/-'$

0* 8"#+$"#90%-5##(#(47$#%$4A1+)$"#1%*#4.,$- 161.-,01$4.4.4.4/4( $"#98#%#4$$45A#(/9455',#(*4%1+)"##$-1*-4%+41.1+)" 4))4  1+)"  4,84+$  1+)"  4+(  3'.84+$  1+)"  4+(  1%*4.  1+)" 55',#(4%+41.1+)"84,4%*#(81$",4//4.8"1.#$"#%#*41+1+)455',#( 8#%#4%*#(81$" ,-$4, 55',#(4%+41.1+)"%41,#(4 .4.A4%4 $"4$$"#9 ,"-'.(/#$4')"$4.#,,-+7-%"#.01+)$"#0#%,-+,8"-8#%#4(*1$$#($- "-,01$4.55',#(4%+41.1+)")46#4,4//4./.-8-+$"#%1)"$A+##-7 '*#% "4+(455',#(*4%1+)")46#,-$4/.-8-+$"#+-,#-7'*#%

:

"4+(455',#(##$-4+(1*-)46# ,-$4 /.-8,$-$"#+-,#4+(.10,-7 '*#% "4+(455',#(4))41+)")46#,-$4/.-8-+$"#%1)"$,1(#-7$"# "#4(-74)1%1+)"455',#(4,84+$1+)")46#(4+)/.-8-+'00#%,1(# -7%1)"$#4%-74)1%1+)"4+(455',#(3'.84+$1+)")46#(4+)/.-8-+ $"#  .#7$  #./-8  -7  4)1%  1+)"  "#%#47$#%  4..  $"#  455',#(  7.#(  4849 4.-+)81$"$"#1%%#,0#5$16#8#40-+, = !%4%6##+3'*4% 4%)8"-$%#4$#(!

4+(!?,0-A# 4/-'$$"#1+&'%1#,,',$41+#(/9$"#* !%*4%&1$1+)"4+(!: % 4"'.4,,1"46#(#0-,#(4/-'$$"#-0#%4$1-+5-+('5$#(-+!?4)1% 1+)"8"-,',$41+#(1+&'%9-+"1,"#4(

+$"#,1(#-7$"#(#7#+5#!%34$4%14 4(1-.-)1,$

161.-,01$4.#%-B#0'%84,#C4*1+#($-0%-6#$"#1+&'%9,',$41+#(/9 455',#(4%+41.1+)"-+"1,.#7$1+(#C71+)#%4+(*1((.#0"4.4+C-7.#7$ *1((.#71+)#%#4.,-,0-A#4/-'$$"#1+&'%9,',$41+#(/93'.84+$1+)" -+"1,.#7$04%1#$4.%#)1-+4+(*'.$10.#4/%4,1-+,-+$"#.#7$,1(#-7/45A4+( %1)"$,1(#-74/(-*#+ #4.,-#C4*1+#(455',#(4.81+(#%1+)"4+( 7-'+(.45#%4$#(8-'+(-+"1,%1)"$04%1#$4.%#)1-+4+(.#7$,"-'.(#%# 4.,-+-$#($8-4/%4,1-+,-+$"#*1((.#-7"1,/45A4+(*'.$10.#,'0#%71514. 4/%4,1-+,-6#%$"#.#7$7-%#4%*4+(.4$#%4.*1((.#4%#4-7"1,%1)"$'00#% 4%* ?

!  % #+'  1+).4  #(154.  7715#%  4$$45"#(  $-  161.

-,01$4.#%-B#0'%"4(*#(15-
.#)4..9#C4*1+#(455',#(##$-817#-7 4))41+)"4+(7-'+(.45#%4$#(8-'+(-+$"#%1)"$7-%#4%*-7"#%%1)"$ #./-84+(%1)"$8%1,$4+(7%-+$,1(#-7$"#5"#,$

=
 "#$%14. -'%$%#.91+)*41+.9-+$"##61(#+5#-71+&'%#(#9# 81$+#,,#,!

'*#% "4+(4+(!?4)1%1+)"4%%16#(4$45-+5.',1-+ $"4$$"#455',#("461+)7-%*#(4+'+.487'.4,,#*/.94$$45A#(! 4+( !?4+(54',#(1+&'%1#,"#$%14. -'%$4.,-"#.($"4$455',#(4,84+$ 1+)"4$$45A#(!?4)1%1+)"4+(5-**1$$#(5'.04/.#"-*151(#+-$ 4*-'+$1+)$-*'%(#%0'+1,"4/.#'+(#%#5$1-+: ; 8"1.#455',#( 4%+41.1+)"54',#()%1#6-',1+&'%9-+$"#%1)"$.#)-7! 4+($"#%#/9 $"#95-**1$$#(4+-77#+5#0'+1,"4/.#'+(#%#5$1-+:  "#-$"#% 455',#(54',#(*'.$10.#1+&'%1#,4,0#%$"#71+(1+),%#5-%(#(/9$"#$%14.

-'%$ ;

#4%+#(5-'+,#.400#4%1+)7-%$"#400#..4+$,8-'.(6#"#*#+$.9 ,'/*1$$"4$$"#0%-,#5'$1-+"4,5-*0.#$#.9,'00%#,,#($"#1+&'%1#,,',$41+#( /9 455',#(  ##$-  4%+41.  1+)"  4+(  3'.84+$  1+)" "#  (#7#+5#  "4, #,$4/.1,"#($"#1+&'%1#,,',$41+#(/9$"#455',#(/9#C4*1+1+)!4+( !$"#-5$-%,8"-,#%6#(4$ 161.-,01$4.#%-B#0'%"#%#7-%#1$1, "1,,'/*1,,1-+$"4$$"#@'#,$1-+-71+6-A1+)$"#0%-61,1-+,'+(#%#5$1-+, =;4+(=> $-5-+615$$"#455',#(1+454,#8"#%#$"#%#84,45.4," /#$8##+$8-)%-'0,(-#,+-$4%1,#7-%5-+,1(#%4$1-+ >
 .#4%+#(5-'+,#.7-%$"#$4$#,'/*1$$#($"4$$"# 455',#(+#6#%8"1,0#%#(4+9$"1+)4/-'$$"#1+&'%1#,,',$41+#(/9$"#* ('%1+)$"#5-'%,#-75%-,,
#C4*1+4$1-+-7$"#81$+#,,#,#C4*1+#(-+$"# ,1(#-7$"#0%-,#5'$1-+-%"46#$"#9,0-A#+4+9$"1+)4/-'$$"#1+&'%1#, ,',$41+#(/9$"#*8"#+$"#98#%##C4*1+#('+(#%#5$1-+:: %

"#%#7-%#1$1,"1,,'/*1,,1-+$"4$$"#455',#(8"-4..#)#(.9,',$41+#(

1+&'%91+$"#0%#61-',-55'%%#+5#8"15""4(+-/#4%1+)-+$"#0%#,#+$ -55'%%#+5#54++-$/#0#%*1$$#($-0%-&#5$$"#1+&'%1#,,',$41+#(/9$"#*$- )#$48497%-*$"#5"4%)#,7-%$"#-77#+5#'+(#%#5$1-+,=;4+(=>

+4$"-%-')"0#%',4.-7$"##+$1%##61(#+5#-+%#5-%(71+( $"4$$"##61(#+5#-7!

'*#% "4+(4+(!?4)1%1+)"8"-,',$41+#( 1+&'%1#,1+ $"#-55'%%#+5#1+$"#/45A)%-'+(-7$"##61(#+5#-7! %4%6##+3'*4% 4%)4+(!%*4%&1$1+)"#,$4/.1,"#,$"4$455',#( 4%+41.1+)"4$$45A#(!

-+"1,%1)"$.#)81$"1%-+%-(4+(54',#( )%1#6-',1+&'%1#,55',#(4,84+$1+)"4$$45A#(!?4)1%1+)"81$"4 ,-$4D8--(#+.-)E-+"1,"#4(4+(54',#(4+1+&'%98"15"84,(4+)#%-',$- .17#+-$"#%8-%(,455',#(4,84+$1+)""4(*4(#4+4$$#*0$$-5-**1$ 5'.04/.#  "-*151(#  +-$  4*-'+$1+)  $-  *'%(#%  "#  0%-,#5'$1-+  4.,- #,$4/.1,"#($"%-')"$"#47-%#,41(-5'.4%$#,$1*-+94+(*#(154.#61(#+5# $"4$455',#(*4%1+)"54',#(,1*0.#1+&'%9-+$"##./-8-7! 81$"4 1%-+%-(455',#(##$-4+(1*-54',#(,1*0.#1+&'%9-+$"#+-,#-7!

81$"4,$15A455',#(4))41+)"54',#(,1*0.#1+&'%9-+$"#7-%#"#4(-7 !?81$"4,$15A4+(455',#(3'.84+$1+)")46#,1*0.#1+&'%9-+$"#.#7$ #./-8-7!?81$"4,$15A  "#  @'#,$1-+  $"4$  4%1,#,  7-%  5-+,1(#%4$1-+  1,  8"#$"#%  $"# 455',#(54+/#5-+615$#(7-%4+-77#+5#'+(#%#5$1-+,=;4+(=>

8"#+$"#98#%#4.,-$"#615$1*,-7$"#4$$45A.4'+5"#(/9$"#-$"#%,1(#1+ $"#6#%9,4*#-55'%%#+5#  "#*#(15-
.#)4.%#0-%$0%-('5#(/9$"#-5$-%,#C4*1+#(-+ $"#,1(#-7$"#(#7#+5#8-'.()-$-#,$4/.1,"$"4$455',#(##$-4%+41.

?
1+)"  3'.84+$  1+)"  4.81+(#%  1+)"  "4(  ,',$41+#(  1+&'%1#,  1+  $"# -55'%%#+5#$"4$$--A0.45#-+;?

4$

0*1%,$.971+($"4$$"# 0%-,#5'$1-+5-*0.#$#.9,'00%#,,#($"#4$$45A#(.4'+5"#(/9$"#0%-,#5'$1-+ 81$+#,,#,-+$"#455',#(04%$9 "#*#(154.#61(#+5#4(('5#(/9$"# 455',#(8-'.()-$-#,$4/.1,"$"4$$"#0%-,#5'$1-+04%$94.,-84,4%*#( 81$"8#40-+,4+(4$$45A#(455',#(##$-4%+41.1+)"4,84+$1+)"4+( 4.81+(#%1+)"4+(54',#(1+&'%1#,$-$"#* $1,7-'+($"4$/-$"$"# 04%$1#,"4(5.4,"#(81$"#45"-$"#%4+(54',#(1+&'%1#,$-$"#%#,0#5$16# 04%$1#,+-$"#%8-%(,1$1,+-$$"#455',#(04%$94.-+#8"-4%%16#(4$$"# ,5#+#-7-55'%%#+5#4+(7-%*#(4+'+.487'.4,,#*/.981$"8#40-+,4+( 4$$45A#($"#0%-,#5'$1-+04%$9/'$$"#0%-,#5'$1-+04%$94.,-84,4%*#( 81$"8#40-+,4+(#@'4..95"4%)#(-+$"#455',#(04%$94+(54',#(1+&'%1#, $1,48#..,#$$.#(0%-0-,1$1-+-7.48$"4$1+454,#-77%##71)"$#45"-7$"# 0#%,-+,1+6-.6#($"#%#1+54+/#"#.(7-%"1,1+(161('4.45$4+(+-$7-%$"# 45$-7-$"#%,'+(#%6154%1-', .14/1.1$9"#%#7-%#$"#5-+615$1-+-7$"# 455',#('+(#%#5$1-+,=;4+(=> 54++-$4$4../#,',$41+#( :

+61#8-7$"#4/-6#745$,4+(51%5'*,$4+5#,$"#455',#(
400#..4+$,4%#45@'1$$#(-7$"#5"4%)#,'+(#%#5$1-+=;<=> 55',#( 4%+41.1+)"1,5-+615$#('+(#%#5$1-+:  4+(,#+$#+5#($-'+(#%)- 9#4% 4+($-049471+#-7


<
4+(1+(#74'.$$-'+(#%)-47'%$"#% 0#%1-(-7:*-+$", 55',#(4,84+$1+)"1,5-+615$#('+(#%#5$1-+ :

; 4+(,#+$#+5#($-'+(#%)-9#4% 4+($-049471+#-7


<
4+(1+(#74'.$$-'+(#%)-47'%$"#%0#%1-(-7:*-+$", "#%#*41+1+) 455',#(
400#..4+$,+4*#.9*4%1+)"##$-1*-4))41+)"4+(


3'.84+$1+)"4%#5-+615$#('+(#%#5$1-+:: 4+(4%#,#+$#+5#($- $"#0#%1-(4.%#4(9'+(#%)-+#/9$"#*!1$"$"#4/-6#*-(17154$1-+1+$"# *4$$#%-75-+615$1-+4+(,#+$#+5#04,,#(/9$"#$%14. -'%$$"#400#4.1, (1,*1,,#( = 55',#(
400#..4+$4%+41.1+)"4+(4,84+$1+)"4%#-+/41. "#1%/41./-+(,,$4+(54+5#..#("#9,"4..,'%%#+(#%81$"1+ (49,7%-* $"#(4$#-7$"1,&'()#*#+$/#7-%#$"# "1#7'(1514.4)1,$%4$##%-B#0'% 8"-,"4..,#+($"#*$-&41.$-'+(#%)-$"#%#*41+1+)04%$-7$"#1%,#+$#+5# 7$"#9741.$-,'%%#+(#%$"#.#4%+#( "1#7'(1514.4)1,$%4$##%-B#0'% ,"4..$4A#5-#%516#,$#0,$-,#5'%#$"#1%0%#,#+5#4+(,#+($"#*$-&41.$- '+(#%)-$"#%#*41+1+)04%$-7$"#1%,#+$#+5# -6#*/#%

-   .

'.4$1 12