High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7838/2013dismissed

M/S Kumar Enterprises And ANR. v. M/S Mahindra And Mahindra Ltd.

2016-03-30Mr. Justice Rajan Gupta10 pages

!"

"# $ "

% "& "

'

(" "

)*+,

+

"

"

'

$

#

" #$%& '(!)* *'!!!*+

* ''

* !+ *!

+*)) ,- !!) !+" #$%& + )*'

!' !)" #$% $. /0$ 122 ....

+

/# 0

1 & !

2-

3 " 2("

0 1 & 2-

4$ 5677 677 7 /

'

2-

4$ 5677 677 1! "

2-

4$ 57 677 77 67 6 8 5

4$ 5 67 +

2-

$ # " !"

2-

4$ 5 + ( # 1 2-

! 2-

. .

4$ 5 "

- +("

& 2-

4$ 5 677 77 $! 9"

2-

4$ 5 ....

:"

&

0 ;

&&3

#<

= % ;

= :"

#<

"& ;

< = ....

2&&

-

;0

#<

&

-

5677 67 "

0 ;

3""

;#

- %"

4-& $ - 5677 67

-

<"

;0 <<

&&3<

<- "<

&

0

;& &

4

0 3""

&

>

& ?

&

;0 +# ; %

. .

'

"

+# ; %

3 .4

0

&0 "

@ "

'

"

&<

- "

9 0 A<" 4

(< -

<"

& ;& 0 %"

B

&

"

<"

&

&

"

" & ;& 0 "

3

"

<- ;0

- %"

& 3 "

0

-

3"

"

"

&& ;

0 #<

;0

- -

6 4+4 "

"

&<

;

- 0

;0

3 .4

0 ?

&

& ;& 0

"

3 3

- &

;0 4

0 "

-

3""

"

3

3

& & ;& 0 & ;

& &0

3

"

3&

-

. .

&&0 ?

&

&0 &

" E &

< "

&

&0 #<

&0

<"

&

B &

"

;

3& ;

- 3"

& .4

0 3

3"

& &

-

-

<"

"

%"

;

< "

-

4

0

3

;#

"< & "

6

<

3

<" /#

1 & !

2-

;0

<

-

3 && !

3&

&

&0

#<

!

4

!"!# $%$

3&

&0 ;

(< 3"

& ;

" &

& ;

3"

0 & ;

3

. .

!

4

E<

#<

<

;

& &

"

-

" < "

"& &

& "& ;

;&

;&" "

& ;

3 " & ;&

"< 0 %"

& ;

&0 3

& ?

&&

0

"3

0 ;0 ;&< "

-

;0 <

&

;0 %"

< ;

&

;#

3"

;

-<

3"" 3 &&

>

& "& "

&

& 3 ;0 !

4

"&

<"

"

3 "

0

0 7

&

.

;

;0

&

3

&&3

3"

&

&&0 &&

#<

!

4

. .

& '! ( (!"

# % ' ) $ 3""

< " < &

< " ?

< 0< & ;&

(<

"

3"" 3

3

&0

0

& & ;& 0 3"" "

&&

;

&

& 3

;0 &

%"

"&<

<

&

"

3 " ;

<

<

;

3"

"

&-

; ;

&0

;

&0

;

"

>

&

2 <

"& "

&

; <

C& !

4

*+ )

, &

&&3<

0

-

D

&

;0 ;& 4

0 & -

;&0 ;

&0 <"

"

0 "

& &< 3

. 6 .

3

" E<

3" "

-

%"

& 4

0 <"

3

0 & "

&0 ;

"

0

0

8

5 < ?

2

!

7

<

&&0

;0

? "

0 3

" 0 <-

& ;

&&

& 3""

&& &

!

< ?

2

3""

3"" "

3 " 0 <

&&

&

3& ;

&&.& <

<

& 3

&& ;0

<

2

- 0

3

& ;& +# %

<"

3

"0 ;

A<" 4

&<

3

<

4

0 &

<"

4

0 %"

.

< "

& 3&

<

;

C&

" "

&

. 7 .

!

7 < ?

2

#

"

& &< 3 ;

;0

3"" 3&

>

0 - 3

D

&& %"

&-

>

-

-

<

3""

;& ?

;

"

& ;0 !

4

"! )() ,) ( ,-%%% .

/

$& 4+4 <- <"

;

;&<

& ;# %"

& 3 " &&< ;#

( -

< 3""

"

;

<

&3

%"

)!( (01'20$ 34/

;

!

4

! ( )3(#.

!"!#

".

F2

0 3" "

&&0

&

(

0 .

;# "<"

<

0 ;

"

. .

.;# ;

&

#<

&0

0 <

#<

%" 3 3 &&.

& 3

4-& +

4 G ? "&

0

3"

& '! )

,

<

<

&0

#

&&3

3"" 3&& 3 "

" < 0 3"" 3

!

4

" * + )

, ?

0 <

0

"&

0

0

<-

;0 3 0

0

3

3"

"

4-& $ - 5

( <

& ("

& 6 . ?

&

<

0 & ;

H

0 "& ;

C

< H ?

0 0

&

" ;

"

;

<

3"

. .

"

3" &&

; 3"

; (3

"

"< 0 &0 H &

( ;

&;

?

(

2

4-& $ - 5

"

3&&

( 0 H

"

0 " 0 H 3 "

( <

0 <- %"

3&&

&&3 3 "

&

( <

0

;

"< H

&3

&3

;-

-&

-

%"

3&& "

"

3 "

3

(

0 "

&

;

<

& -&

-

- 3"

0

3&&

-

3 " 0 3 0 ;

<

# ;0 ;

;0 "

& -&

- "22% #