Gordhan v. Ram Mehar Etc.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH Date of decision: 07.01.2016 Gordhan ..Appellant versus Ram Mehar and others 4Respondents COCP No.809 of 2004 (O&M) Gordhan
...Petitioner
versus Ram Mehar and others ....Respondents CORAM:
! "#$ %&'(!)**+! ",-,$ .*/!)**%
0 !
, ! $ & 2 # !3$ 45 6 47 ) 8 !
# 7 + 2 6 4 97 Kuldip Singh, J.
"4 4 1* '
)**+ 5 9
:8 , 0 4 11 )*** 5 ,
9 0 5 ! !!; !! ! !!$ )% 5 !!! 8 !
"4 , 4 !!!
:! !!! 1+ 1//*! ! .
/ 1/.)! !!$ )%
4)& .
1/.)! !!$ + )1 1/..
4 1* ) 1/.) ! !!$ %
5 "
5 ! !! 5 4! 6 5!
9 0 ! 45 4! !!$ ) % 5 5 !!!
" ! !! ! $ 1
! 4 %% 1+4 !
5 < !45 !!!!$ )
!!$ 1 +* 1* 1/'/ !!$ ) 4!- 1/()!!$ + 5 1/(&< 1/('
!! !!$ ) 85 5
!!!$ 1! 4 , !45 9!$ 1 !! 5 :45 5 5 8 4!!$ !
!45 3
4 5 5 5 "!$ 1 4!
4
!4!
! = 5 6 !45 5 5
5 "! $ 1> .
/ 1/.)! # -!
!!$ ) 9!$ )4 ! //5 !
4!$ 1! ! !!
!$ + 4)& .
1/.) 8 4 4 4 8 4
5 !!4 ! $ ) !
!
!$ %! ! 4!# )& )1 1/..4
!
4! $ + ! ! ! $ %
1* / 1/..
8 )1 1/..
4 4!!
!!! 8 5 4! 4 ! "!
! 5 !46 55 !!$ !!$ )+ 4
"
4 !$ % 4
! ! 8
! !! #4 ? ! $ 1
8! " !
! 5 !!$ )!
! !!$ % 9!$ ) 4 4 ! 5!
:
4 ! !
4<
! "
#
$
%
&
'"
!
& ##
( # "
# " ) *
"
%
"
"
+ # ) ,
"
#
# # " ) - "
#
)
.
( "
"
#
( /
0
% "
) 1 "
) 2
)
"#
) !
8 , $ 1 ! ! !! " $ ) !! " $ +
!! $ %'
" $ ( ! !!! 4 " $ . !! $ 1* " $ /11 ! , 5 4
" 9
5 = !! 8 ! 5 6 4! ,
" ! !
5 !
: ! = 4
5 = !!7 "4 ! , !@ 4 " ! , 4!
5= !!< 34' &5 6
12&812( 69 "
7
# :;
## #
/
:;
9 "
12-82.< "
1*8,+ :;
+=
9
< 1!&8!( 9 "
" "
9
< "
1!-8!. #
# "
0 +
9 "
1&*8&,
5 /
"
# #
%
/ ' 4' &5#
9 "
% #
/ "
4' &
4' ( 6
7
"
#
> 8 ! !
4 5 5 5 , , 5 45
$
A 8 !
5 $ 5 A " 5 $ 5!A >!);+ 8 );+ 4!= 5!
$
5 446
!= 5 5 != 5!$
$ 5
8 5= !$ 1 != 5
, 5 !
!! !
$
8 ! !A = 5$
" !
54$ A 5 5 5
8 !!
5 ! "!
5
45 5 !$ 1!
4!
8 = !! 5 " 5 !
4! ! !
! ! ! 4 5
" ! 64 5 , 5 5 ?!$ 1!
4!
$
8 4 = !! : ! , !! 4
8 > = !
! 57 "
, 5 5 !?0 5 4 4
! ! 554 784!21#4 ?!! ?!! !!! !
! ! 4
#4 ?!!4 4
5
1/() 4
5 1/.+
!#4 +*5 4 1% 1) 1//% 5 !!!
4 4
5 1/.) 8 4 ! #4 !
!! !
#4 4 <>4! &* 85! 5 4 !
4 4 4545!
4!
40 !5 45 "4 &*45 5!!
8545!
4 5
8 ! ?!> 45!
4 5 ! !!!
8 <>4!#4 !
! # +/ ***;< !
4 A ! 4
>
8 >4
!
4 !
!454 5 :
!! <!> > 45!
4 5 54 8 !! 5 !
3 !
<
+!22.6&7; 6;
7 !(+ 4 4
#64 4 @5 1/''"#B C)''
?
+11,67 @!*(+
9
=
+!22( 6&7;6;
7-+)
;
"
+!2226(7; 6;
7-,+ )
+!22!6!7;6;
-*.+ ? =
+11(6&7&2.+ 0
/ +1.! @!&- !
5 5
8 4 5 5 5
! 5 2 ! 5 = !! !!7" ! 5 !
$ 4 = ! 8 4! 4 !
<! 5 5 < ! " 5 1/.1< .)! # ') ***;< D> / 8
5 8 ! // 5 D> 1*
44 %% 1+4 ! # 1&**;< 5 )& .
1/.) 85!D> 11 0 .
/ 1/.) !
4 0 ?! )1 .
1/..! # )& 0 4 8 ! ! = !
!?0 0 ?!< # )& " 0
0 4!
4 = = !
0
50 ! 0 ?! ! ! ,= 5 ! $ + % & .11 ! ! ! !! 84 6 4 1* '
)**+
5 9
:8 ,
6 4 11 + )***
5 ,
9 0
,= 5 !!!4
" ! ,-,$ .*/!
)**%!
07.01.2016 (Kuldip Singh) :
Judge