High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7769/2012dismissed

Gurdev Singh v. Satpal Singh Makkar

2015-02-06Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari6 pages

!"#$ % & "'("#$)) $ ' !"

# $$$ % #

*$"+,!+ $' ""$!+,!+ $ ' ---- $$&'()&*&+,& $((#$' !'+ ( "

$.%*/0 / ,+ 1 $ +$2,2+ /3$+$

,4 % +5$ /3$ (( +6($ $((5$' ( " $,:$''( " ;8, #(3+ ! :<$

+0 /.%$8==+6($ >$'

;

,4 % 5 ($ #$ $(

+5$$ ($5 $' $ '5$5/ *$5 )<? +$$ $ 0#( +6($ $ +$$#$ 0",$3

$)'5 )#0",5$ :#/)= @$!''( $'

% '( ?3((' <$(((#+ 6($ $ ''( 5 '#5$$5($'' $' >$$ A55/3$:$$!( $ :3 " $,$($$ /$"#$+$

$ $' ' '7 $$/

' >$ 5/#/:9 ):+$# $ '5 (3>$' $+

1 $ +$ '$ '3 $35 ( + 5$$' '5 ( '3:

C8' :$,!("$(/ ( */3 "5< + ' +$5 /$"#$>$' $!#$ $+5 #$71 +@ #/# + %$#5 +5$$5$ $ >$'5 /3$' ' /3 (# ''( " ;8, $,+ (!

$'( )5$$ '5=+ " $,$ $5$5 $5 (( $' ' 3>$' ' 3$/) :9 ) :+5$5$5 (( $/' #( (3 $:/3 /$"#$=5((#$$' ' 35' $' ' 5$ $ '5 :# ##>$ 5 ($' (( 8$+$ ((3/ :/3(#! >$''(5/3$ '$# $$5=((:5 $>$ ($'$ /:$' !(#+ (/3$89 ) :5(3#$ '$!

3 #$#$' ' 3 ! <'#!5$'(#+$ (( $' $! +/!

54:5$$' ' 3$ /' $ :% :*"#$/3$ 3 $ ' 5$($$5 $'5: $ 3 +/ $ (# $ ' '>$'( (5 $/ 3 88'($ ($'$/'$# $$ 55 9 ):5(3#>$:/) 5)'#!5$ #' :' ! $= (( +$ $' 85 * ( $' $!$:(3 #5D $$ 5 /( # #$5 $'(3+ $ 5$'3 $"'(?!%+/ $,'4 $ $!#0"'' +$ +(! $($! /# >$ $!# / + (/( / *+ :(3+$ ' 5 ' $ ' ' 3A+' $(

$+$5 $5 $' ' 3 : $' 3 :$

(# $ ' " 789 $ , >$ 3 # 5$$ A $*:+ # #$ :/)+/#= A : $' : /#$5 $' ' 3 : $ 3 +5 +$+ ( (( >$,'4

$(5$' '($(/$($$ ' :' ! $=5 >$!5$ $ / '' !/3 !6#9$ ,'4

!"5$ $/$($ !:# /#!>$ +#

. %% $ $ /$(/3$,'4 $ / (' (#($' ' ' !#'3 :3 =5$ $ !'((!/ !

"# # " " $ % % "

" "

" ! !

%" "

& ! $ ' (

)

! * , #(3+ $ *#: ( ' /3 ( $ ' $( &

( ) "%%% "

5(/''(/(+$ : $' >$ 9 ):/#$5 (+5(( $:$ $' +:(3+ " $,+$ 5 ( (:#$'$(5$$$

! /$ ($' (( 8/ =(' :$$' ( "

$,+ (:#$ +5$$$/: " $,( +$:$ $' +"5 < $(3''' $ '(3+$:$ $' '5$5 (( $'' ' 3 $($ $/>$' !(: $( /''>$ +$:5:

/ (7%+ (#$!/3$ '>$+ $ +/!+5(#$5$$3$/ '/3$ $$:$ $' ' +5$ 3 ' $ $(( $!#$0"

E5(($ ! 3(#$

# $5$$' ! E =5 / = >$'$'3 $ # 5'( $5#$ #( $:+/3$ '+5$: ' >$:$//3$( (

=+$#+0",+

>$ %

*' (

+ *,%+!+:( :+ *$ #:$$: '#/ $,'4 5$()'#:$*#:' $ &+(01$,'2) &3*&' #$5$$(( 8 5 / =+$5( (( $ =(( + " $, (3/:+ !$/3+5(:$$ 5' ( :

#$: $>$ (!' ) $

% +, - % .

/ 0 "

" !

& 1

" !$ !

! % 1

(

!% % " ! .

2 - 3435334 " 6

! 6 "

" $

+, (2 - !

+, (2- -

$+, (2- %

78 %

- " "

!* ":( !5$/)/3$8 9$ $ -

#' %% "5$ $ = (( 5 E 0< / @$ ' #(3+$ '$($! +)'#!5$F(( 9$2 $ .

. / #' %% % 0"= %1 % 1 #' +"*,%"+$ 5 $(#9 $'' 5((5$/ ' " $,+)'#!5$ $$ A :$ / ( (( , #(3+)'#$/! :$ $ $' $!''( $' % '(((# 6($ $+$ :#/)'' : (3 $(# # ! E5(( $:+3: +)'#!5$/ ! $,'4 4&5&+3006$,'2)' = !5 $ / ! : /!+ $ ' ! ':

"",@,G,?=, 7&,+07) 60 .