High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1147/2010dismissed

Balwan Singh v. State Of Haryana

2023-05-11Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra19 pages

!"#$

%% &

"'()

% *(

( +($,-$./0($%% ( *!1($(/ '() 3$%(%% $4%(((#$5-#6 0((7--64$

%"+

8/ (#(-(9:+

8* " $6/($.!$(4)$%% -/ !"#$/ $4$ #- )(66%-$4 -("

:*$4-(#(#(-6%(6( %)

; :- %)6/$! -($(-(#(#(-6%(6()(

(-($-%4)$%(-( $

84-

%6/$6% /,(("#$/ ($% "$6(($6 ##

$($$$-( ' !!6((

4 !/ 4/$($ ($)-#(/56(- 0$$-(-$% -$0 #!$($ 6% #!$$$(- 0 $-$ 0 # 56($.(-.4(!$$-6

;$4%4) !$ ($46%(( $(-.!$56( '(6$56($ $(-.4- 6$4.4-$(-($6)4((!(6 !

!$6$6)4- )#/56($ <4#$6-$(/4-$6(!%$ -% ' #$$(0##$ ;

84-

6/ 4! !6$$-(6$6$ -($ - 7-(/ !$6-((56(4)#0#$6 4 !!$%$ !)(6$% $4$ 6/-("

:*!(#( :0# %(#!( 3$% %()(-$$%- $4)$06 )# *6(6<6 $4)7-%(#!(- "6

4!- !$4(( -(#0#/ $-!(( '!((#-( -( 66#$0 06$-45(6 '6( $% -(((0($!% % %-(-$ -(6 (6% () 0#-- (6 /$ -(" ( *

!%($-((( $-

%$$ !(-%% $-( 3$!66$-(" # (66%-4 -("

:*/$-$4$(#$(# ) '% #- )$$(# 6(

3 -4 / $ %(- <6

! "-(("#$/4 !(6 ! !$ % 4- 0(# % (%(/

( -.$ $(/ % 4- -# %6(6 <6 4)$06 !%(0%6(6(%(=< *

$#-(7-(%(=< * ' $# $ =< *> *?

' %(0 =< * / %% 604)$% (.#$%!$$($ %(0((6$-- 4-(-#5-( $06/=< *@ ;/%#04)$6$%% $%=< *

"-6,-6(%(0=< * /" % $% -(( ":37("#$/%(0 =< *> 9:(-.=< *

,- 4("#$!$((( .$*"$6/!$%4-%$%(%() $ .$-($$(#$#0($6($ %-(%(<6( !/6*$ *$#(%$(/%(0%$#(%$$4)/=< *8*

#0=< * * / "

,(("#$/6% % -%%($ #$9:%(0$6=< *

' $ #-( =< * / 66 -(

6$-/*

66(0()%/=< * >/ .$ % $ % =< * # 6( %4-#=< * 667- #4 5- (%($(6$% -((4-)#$ 4)$06 ' $/$$ (0$%-!$$$.% 4!$06 $--(%)66-

;4)$06 $-$#$6(6%(6 ' =< * 85-(%/%(-$-( $ "-4:%(6 *(.$% 4-5#$0#8

8/4- (($-4-#66=< * * > %

4!!$-)!$-(( !$6$ 4-$ (%($5-#6

:%(*($0"#$/%4--#0# 4-0(-%.4)$6-(#$-(0# # ((6#05-)#$ %(-$-(66#6-(($06 $4(%$$$ $(-.4(#(#(+

'>8 $56("#$

8 '%(0 6(.%$%)#(6 $(-.(4! $6$06(. %$%)(#(( $(-.

"6-!((-(" ( * !$($% 6% 6$6 4 4))#$$!$($(( !$

$6#($6! %(0$6(6( %(%()/$)$ )6% $6$ '!#0 %%(-)%(-04- ) >

3$ ( ( -( ( %%(# $ 0 %(- (( (# $ ( 4) $ %(-$-/$ $%% #- )(66 %-$4 -("

:*$6$ 6(40 9 ###(0/$%% $4%(((4) $%% -

A(- ($%% $0$6 )(#- $$6%-#5-#6((

!( 4 4 $##04) (( -(!(-(# (60( 6( (6!(-4 $) !

'(#-$$ (( -(%% )5-- 6 :$% -!((( -%$6)*@

4/!$!$ ))!$ #-((4-!$ $66!$$!(()6( %(- (!$ %(-0(! (() *@ ,(("#$! )!$-(($((/$64# $()!!($))( 3$6 0! 0!$$0*@ *@

:!%(0(( $*@ *@ $60 )6% $%% - 4- $ $ 4 . ( @$ -#/!(#-$$##04) (( -(

$6%-#5-#6!( 4 4(0(/$%% (0 4%$$%% (047- ?

*((/ (- ($(%"(#- $$##04) (( -(!(! (

3$(!0(!$ 6#0((%(0$!$ %% !$$66$6-(($%%

3$6)*@ !( 0-($%(% !-$%% !$$(6 3$6) *@ 4! !($)( $<!$$$$ -%%($%(-0( !-$ %% !$$-45(6 3$60$%($%% . $06$ 44 $ '/!-(#$$ %% 4#0)6(/! 4 46

@$0$( (- ($%% ( "- (4 #$!$$(4 /$0 6- )(-B$6( % (( :-(%/$ 67-!$$(7-(4($ !$$($%(-$%(--/#/0# ( 4 0((%(0$$06$$6 $$$%% !$%(!$$6-(($6 3$ 6 0%(-(($(66)*@ / ( -.$$(/-% !$$%6(6<6(%( =< * /-(%/-%(0$$06$ $6 $ 6)-64(!-!(- $%($4)!$$!(-4)6$(%#

!% (#*@ /$5-(-!(6(6 -(--$$(()-(-(

3$5-(40- )- 4 -(( -$/$(4-4$$06$$6 $

+!4!$$(!$%% /!$ $. $06C:6)46$($$06! $($$( 4($($%(%% -/4($( !*@ 4*@ ,(("#$/6% : %-$06$4(#5 )!$$%% / *@ $($ (%($--$0)$ 0 #!$(*@ !(#!$$0 # 3$$ %(-!$$%% $#0-6

;$ 0656($%(%-($#6(-. 56($ $ (-.4-$ #04.$6).4)$6(6$ %% -($($-6$6) (4)$%% 6)%(($-((/$06$ 0 < 4# $ %% # / $ %% $ 6$064)(.#4 !!$% 3$ $%(-6 )(-%$6*@

4*@ ,(("#$

A(- ($%% 6-$($ %$*@ /!$!$ ))!$-(($ -%%($0($%(-$0(6$ 66( %(- ($<$$!0 !4 (<64)$ (%-4 %(-( '(#-$$(

6!!($))( D-4 )/%(- !(%*@ / 4/(0 $$$( ) -%%($0(#0$% $6((#$( 6-(">( * $ .$# (() :$(<6$/$%$$ #$-((/$$($$64-?%6$- $0656( )#6(!$4 $ $($-4 !!%($(/!$$$($$6

'!0(/ (%-4 %(-($-#$%(6(6$( -(( !#$6(<6$!$#(-$ $!-%%(#$(-$ 3$-#$$!(6 )# ( 4$ !4- !#$(4(<64) ( %-4 %(-(6-$(4# ( "$$!$0 -(#$((<6$$#$-((/ ( )$(4($( !/56($6$$-(-. ($0#6 /$$ %$$%% $ ($$6(-6# 7-(4-?%6$4 !$#3&!$$$#$((6 "$ $ $(#(6$6%-/$$%%$(-#$$!! $-$($-4!$ $-( #4-)#$$ 06 !

- (0 4# "$ $ 5--( $ $( $-4$(-.4 !!$%$%(56( -$ 66/6$$$ $% $$($-4$ #04 !!$%56($ $($- "$# 6$$%% $ 4 !

# %( 3$/!$ 4#(<6-($(4) (- ($%% /$#$$$$4) 56(4-?

%6/!$$$64.(6$($( !E$-$)%(!$ -#5-(56(

"$$$$ ) $($( !$$$$ 06 )#5-( :(0 (6$(6$$$4 .# (()-(#$-($(<6 !$7-$(4#)!$-(( $(4)4(4 )(($$$6 % 7-6%(- ( :0!$-640/ 4!$$(0$!!$! 64 $ ))!4( -%(-$($ 6%($(6%%( ) 4#(()$( %(0-0( :$</% !6)4- (($5-#64 !

:$ %&' '(:?> "

/$'E4 %<-($$ $/F$6<6 --/ -64- $#/ 0()$#$( -(- !((- %( 3$-($ $/$( ) 6(!!$0#( -(-$()(<##(/64 $6(64(( :/ $((/$-)$-((-B$0(- )/ (6$ -6%$(/%($#((6$$ : )* & '(*+,!$ $$F6<6 - - -64-E%% )(6 :

!6)4%( )(-$- %( ) $0/$#0 $-( :-+ '(&.& 6 (0!

!<%(4)'E4 %<-(4)$ #$$ # 6<6 F -- -64-E%% 4 :$-( $!$<$%!4( -% 3$-($%($ $(6$(-$ ) <% (-6!$%4 %($#( (6$$4-$)(<(4 )6<-%/$$!$ 0-$!4(

( 46 / %,&* 0(1

- * ',

/(%(

" ?!$(! $ 4)'E4 "-%(6-($$-)$-(%( $#((6$$ 9 )%(- (6( !( 6( %(- (! (-(6$4## 3$6<6 F -- -64-E$%% :$ !44( ( 3$%(% 6( )(- - :! 4(0$$!5-$ %#0# 64(()()/$!0(/(-$6 3$((/$4 %%($!$<$0!($) %/6( )4-6(%/$-(($ 64-(% #( $6)!/ ( ) ! 6( ! $ 6- 4 (#( (%! 3$0$4!$ ( ( 46 /& '( (%(

> " / !$( $

'E4 "-%(6-(4(0$!$ %%(#$0 !/$-($!$$((!$ /(-$- : #/$-($.%6$/(!4. (6-!$$(-$(%$.$(-$-

"6(%-$#$($(-#$ (5$0!$ +(-!%(6#0# 6(% )!$(%(6%4 $(4 )$0(!/$$-(6) (5$0 3$-($$$(6$#( -$(-$ 66)4%( )(5(%( )% @ %!(--- 4$0-(!(6 -#$(50 $ (500 (!6) -(5- :7- )! $0$6)$ !4( $64%$<!$$-%%($ %(-0( %% )#$%(% !

-40 -%$6)*@ /!($%$$(6 $-#$4#0(% 4( -% 4(4-%(0$!$%% !$$. $0656( 3$!!!$%% 40- )6-4$0#6((($6$!$) $ ( )%%($06($ $6$-#$$ %(/ $ 6 (() 6 # $( 6/7-0$!$ ()#0$($-4(6 $ -$ !/$!! !($(%4 )!$$!

$($- (6.(-%4-$-((!$$$ .% $(%($!$)6%(<6 $!!-%%($0($%(-6 0 '!0(/%(#$$(6$#((6$( 6/$(%( )4( -%%(0$$ 06$4 4)$%% 4)(.#4 !!$% $%($! 3$(-$ )4<((6$( 6 '/$-($$$ $$%($ 6)$!!$$-%%($%(-0(- ( )4( -%$6%(0$$$$ %% !$ . #$06

3$<-46 (- ($%% ! $*@ !)!$-(( '6! $()-( )$- 4-% %(0 $$%% $66$6-(($06 D%- )/ *@ !()!$-(( : (($ $()064 0 '!0(/"> $/<%$#( (- -(!$$$()0 46 64 ( $ %-(% () $ $ (60)-$!4($() %6 0 %(.-%() 3$6-#$4 6/$((/(6#%((#6-$046 6%(-!$$(66 )$(( 9(4(## $()0!$$%(0">/(7-(4 4 $$6-46%(-!$$$(

$- 4(0 !$$!- !)4( $(#(4% / '() ?8

(6 A!G-( /$)%(- 6-((()$(((6- - )!$$ ($((/-$664 :$ /%(0(6$(($*@ ,(("#$$ (%($6($% 66 )(*@ / 4/$ -#$( !$#0(64-$6-(($56( 4)$$( ! $%% '6$-#$ 4#)! ( 0-($%(% (# ( )4( -%% )$(-6 $$6-(4--$ # >

3$<#(-$ #64) (- ( $%% !$$( -(($$$ 6 0!0!$$( 0$! !$(#($)%$!%-(-#5-($ 06$((/$(-- )(#-$$4( $%(-() %-4)$6/*@ ( -.$ $($%$-(!-!$$!(-$ 4)$06- 4-4)$6$(%# !%4-$(6#5-( 4(- !$$!(-$%(!(-4)6$(!% : -((%/$6*@ $4 40(6$- (0 "0( !- !(-$4)$06!$$!(40- )-

4)6$(%#!% 4(-! $4)/$((/*@ ( -.$$($ $$6- $04-!$6$(!% : 66.! #$4(4--(#- "6- 6-$0.% 4!$%% $ 06!$$ (!4#- 4)$%% - !%!(7-((-$%-(% 3$((/ )$4 6)*@ /4$$!%! $(%#!%$(#( (/$6 *@ ( -.$$(/!0(6 ) $! %(% !$$(60( 4!$6 0- (0/$- (0 $ %(0 6 04 )%0 ) :$ (#(( 4% -%$5-#6 2 '& 1 3%,&* ).**4

* )*&*&' '( /&

4 '( -+/ :?

"?> / !$(6 (4(0!( 6 3$((/$(#-6(4) (- ($%% $%6()%

6(%- :$%(/$ 6-((06!66$-!$($$ 4(##$(!$%% *@ 4 -$/$ 4-(-(" >$!$0)-%$%% <% $!$06-6)!- 4-$ +-4/" >$4 0$

%(-$(##$%(6()4-(%(0#$#- $ - 4) -4/ 4- 4-( $(#/ $ 46$-)-<% $(-6!$$ $$06$.% " >$( ) %% $ !$( $ %(- $ - 4 $#$(6!$$(4 (4(! (#(# $ < ( $( !$$ ( !$ $ .! #$-!$$- (%(%( <% 4-$<$(/$-( !) (! %%(%( ( (# $ 6 ( ) %(0 .

$$(-6 3$6) *@ 4$$( )4($06!6-((/4$$ %% $06!(%($$-!$($)$4 (##$(/$(6-(0( 3$%% - $!0(/ ()<% 4-$6(!$$$ $6 $$06$4- :!$0($ 6(#($($($-$. $06 +( !$$6$(-%$($-$ 6$ 06 -$/$%% ( ) $(#$4-( %(0#$!$$!%(-64!$$.! #!

3$< 64(#-6(4) (- ($ %% !$$0(0()!% !(#-%$6% !$

4-%%(4)$ )%!6 )/*@ ,(( "#$/$((/$0- 4( -% ' (#-$0$(!/$ -(6- 4# -(- 4(464 0 '!0( $ -( 0 !$ $ (#-6

D-4 )/%("

$- %()%( -( 6 4 -( 4)$ - 64 0 4# -( $ -) $ % 4# -( '!0(/" $$(6 <%$(- %(!$$/0()!$$ .! #$% (7-(6(0 (6$-64 0 :$/$%(- ( -%0*@ ,(("#$/*@?":6*(.$ *@:%(*($0"#$/:0##(%(0$ %=< *!$$! 64-!%/$ 4(0($$%% *@ $-#$-%%( $-6-(# -(64)$%% $ %(7-(0()$%=< *066=< *

4- -(# (<6/ $ $ $ %% $ -() -(6(%=< *!(0( %-(-$6 "6*@?":6*(.$*@ :%( *($0 "#$/ $!0(/ $ % $0 (6 -$( 3$)!((<6 $!0(/$( $( 6 - 4 $. 3$ 7- !$$ ( !$$($6*@?*@4( -%-

$($$)!(((4(4)$6)) % 0 : -( %/ $ !( $- 4 $ #0 :! (#B%(% !$ %-4 (06-4%(-6$ )- )$( 0 $ 4 $ ( !($ 4 (6( )-$( -$#(-$ $)(($-$ :$(#(/( 4% -%2&

* :? 8"? /!$( 6 (4(0!(6 :0!$40 # - % !/$ $$-6(0()%=< * $$%% %(0(6$6*@? *@- 44 0$$% $% $ !%(6!-(5- )6% $-

A )6#$60%( 3$-#$! (04-$6-(($06($6#((

'!0(/!$%% /!$$((4-60 *@ *@ ( )6% #$6/$((/$%4 - 3$% !$$$4.4)$%% $ $!$$(!60$%($!6% $6 )$!$$)!%(0$6(6 ( %(%()!($0#(( !$$6 '!0(/ $ %(-)0$(#( $$($/ 60$%( 6$064 $(6$ 6*@ *@

*@ $(6$% $ 6 ##9: %$$%% $#0-6

;$06($%-(%%-($#(-.$ 06$-47- ) $64-$(-#04.$ 406-$%% -!$$$! =0 *@ 6$7-(( $ .% 4!$%% $-%(($-((-$ ( $$!$$%% !!$$ 06$$$60. $6!!$$60 !$$-#$$$$$(-.0( 4 !$%($06!$%$(0##$ ;

8!$ $0#- .! #$$(4)$$$ 06!- 4-$/$!%(0$066$ 6-(($06 3$60-4 #!% :4 -#(-( 6% 4-#(- (- 3$%% $ %(0$$!*@ *@$606% $6 )4-$(()/ 4 $(6$6$!$$$60 . $06 3$((/$% .4)$%% $ %4$ 44 (# )(5

,%#0!$40-/-% !$ ) $(-66#(6$00 4 $((/-$(40%-#$(/$((4 %4 -$4(!$!$%% /!$ 66$$-(6$6(%(54)$0 %(-(( 3$ (( -(((# $ (-6$((! (#0$

# %% -$-640/!( !$)$6$- 4-%$ (# )/$##04) (( -(((6%% 4#0)6( 6

-%% /)/ % & '

& '

% %

%5 !" " #$%&$'

( H;+ 5 6',

()*+