Binder Singh And ANR. v. State Of Punjab
!"#"$%&&'
! "
#"$%
"&
! "
#"$%
'"(
! "
#"$%
(% )*( & &&( # ) * #
"+, - .
* ( ', - .
* ( /, /', #"$%
&&(+& !
$"(
%2
3 ,
%2
"&
, ,
%2
'"(
( % .." , +
-.
%2
3", . *
.
" % " .
4.
.
/" # 2.
.
"% . .
67 - $"( .
"
(
2
2
, , 8 . "
"
(
2 .
.." .
-.
+
2
..
,
" $"(
-.
.
2 .:"
.
(
(
,
."
2
,
# 3" %2 1 '"$
1-
.81
-
. .
%
& . "
-"
- *
.
..&
-.
+
$ %2
- 3"
$
%
# < * * -
(
-
#
.
% :",
-
$
.
( '"(
*"& +
(
- (
=
(
- ( 3
3 + "&
1-
.
% 2
$
% +
.
(
(
2
.
".
.
( >
.
*
. ".
.
>
.,
1-
. ..
2
(
# 3"
( '>
.
(
( ($
/#, "% /- "( .
1-
.
( ( %
.
.
/# .
&
( +
2 + .
"2 % 2
$
".
.
( * , +-,
/#
((
.
($
/#, "% /- , "
.
? ?%
% "
$
.
2
"
+
% - "(%
.
%,
(
(
. +
% +
(
%
"
& (
%
"
&
%
( -
.
+ % @'@
1-
.
(
,
"
-
(
( ,
"2 % "
+, ( , $
&
- .
-2 ((
.
".
-
((
"
,
1-
.
".
1
" ?;
# 3", +
..&
2, - -
- @@
2
(
,
.
. * '>
.
; , 1
"
".
3". * -
2 ((
.
"%(
&
*& ..
"
.
*&,
"
; "
, ?;
&
."
2
; ( (& , +
%
"2 %
B=, #"$%,
.-
-
( , .
;
.
."(
.
- " .
A #
= 3", . *
% -
.
. " .
.
.
.
( ..
2,
+.,
2
" .(
C
-.
."
/"
"
-.,
."
C( (2 C , (2, #D "&+ # &
/
* , #D ($
/#, #D " 1
8?;, #D ? / #D ? ?% #D 1 '"$
D
."
-.
(
.
" .
#
.( .."( .
".
( %"
2
2 .
-
2 - -
B" , '"(
&
2 .
.
2 $
9C
6 , .."
- B
*"&
"
2 "
".
:"
# 3" &
"
- B
*"&
&
- ..
$
- ..
2 "
".
:"
%" 1 '"$
"
+.,
&
(
-
( %
1 '"$
( , 8
(
2
1 '"$
2 "
"
%- "
1 '"$
" &
( .."
.
-
(
$
.."
3 "&
& %2 '"(
/"
"
. -.,
C(
/D
D
. -.
."
"(
-.
.
( ,
( -
2 -
- "
.." -.
/ - . '
#"$% %
"
.
= "
& -.
( (".
.
-2
%,
1-
.
".
(
1: *
C
2
.
-2
1: *
.
&
(& ..
. + %"
+ %2
?;
. .
.
(&,
"
, ".
"
, &
."
2 +
(
B=, #"$%,
, -
.
&
(
+ ."
2
..
"
.
( ."
2
1
" ?;
, (
"
(
(
*2
+
2
1
"
#D + . C( ,
(&
(
%
.
&
(&
2
%
(&
. .
6
(&
?
. .
( +
(&
%
..
1
" &
- (&, (
(
.
"
2
(
1: *
&
+ ."
2 +
&
(&
".
.
$". (&
/
(
. 2
1
"
+
-
(
9" ,
-2
" -%
(
(
B" ( ,
."
C( *?
.
."
(
&
.
(
- (&
1
"
(
.
(. <C(
<
6
- -.
"
- .
-
C( -
-
- %2
?
. ,
."
."
2
= "
". "
, "%
( %
"
"
."
2
?
-.
+ "
, ") %2 ?
@% "
( +
C
& ".
"
"
-.
! " #$ %
&&'
& %2 ?
@% "
(
.
-2
A (
.
.
(
.:"
+ " ) 4.
.
"% .
*&
>"
C +
> "% . &
(+
(
&
B=
2
( . +
(
%2 (2
+
+2
4.
.
+ >
".
C
".
!
( $
)* &&& + %2
.
1
. ,
1-
.
% 2
*
&
."
2
-.
(
( +
(
9
"
.
( %
.:"
= "
"
$"
1
" ."
2
%"
-+
." % -,
( .
"
. % "%
(
- ( &
."
2
1
+2,
."
"%
-
.
%2
% "%
+, %
"%
9 "
.
.
%"
- " +
(, %2 ".
-. ..
."
-
1
% - ." ,
..
" $"(
-.
. "
"
.:"
.
2 - " -.
-
" $"(
% ".
2
"
.
%
% % " %
4. 2 (
:" .
&&'
-&&(.
$
/0 011 #$ 2#3 4"$5 % #2 /0 01131
% #2