High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7627/2017dismissed

Smt. Prem Kumari And Another v. Smt. Raj Kumari

2019-08-22Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

!"#!$!

! %!#

&"#! ' !

!()$*+$, !(-.$

! $ $!,(- !$'!

!"/#',(- !$!' +!1*,$!$'1 & "#!. $+$2 2$,!3!$4!#2$# 2 $! !1 ! ! "#! (1) $#$!*, #2$! !"#!$!$$.! '1$567$!$11 #!2)1 !1#-11281.,9$1 !3!'!&4!$*!:7'14!2 8:;#!2:;<#!*!# !7,=!4>$

$$1$'1*4*,$.-!,$$('!1, ,$'1).$$'1<#$42 !!!4*$!! !"#!?8-#! $!#2$! (1)$#$!*?8>$'1 <#!!3@(!$112!!-1! ; >!'!$!##1!$44*$ $41,!24!2!1'.! !* 1121* 5# !2! :;; .$ #4 2!!,%&*2$-2!$,!A41'#! $* !$ >$$ 112 2!1 '.! !* . '#!'!1* 5# 4* $ '1-#!8,.$!

$'1 $>$$'112=B.$!2! !>$$'1$-!''$8$! 2!1!*$!-*1!#! $!$,$!!,$2!1'.!!*1 .11$!!'!!1121,#11->$ .$$!#$!<#$'1 1$#,$'14!#2$$#<#)2 1!$1122!1'.!!*4!2# 8(76::;;,$.4!2!$ #4 2!!,%&*2$-2!$,!A41'#! $* !$ 1 4!

; !2! $ #42!!,=!4$!!'!87: ;#4*3@(,=!4!1121,- 42#'!2$,1!!*)$'1$

: '141#.!''18:;$-2! :;<#!*!, !7,=!4>$,$'1 !-!2!!!'!&#!!2$ ! !2 $! '!* ! $ # '!'!* ! 12 $ * !> 4 )2 ! ! !*&#!2$$-!$!21 #'!2$#'!'!*$!9$#.14*$ '1 4! -1 A#2 !- , 3!, .$$ . 2 (1-1A#2 !- ,3!

22,4$$$''! -''1#! !!#1 !!#!$'1 !$!$-1#!3!$-!!!1&#! !''18:;, !7,=!4,$!!$'1. 1414!#!$'1!'!$-1 #!=!4$'1$1#$1-112 81., 9$1 ! 3! $ '1 '1* ! $ &#! -1 #! 3!, $!. $! . '# 4.$'!$#.$!2!$1-11281.>$ $-!!*<#!2!2$1$'1 !'1#-11281.$*1*!2$ !!

$!>$$1-11281..4*$$#4 $'1,.$'!*$#,$!!#!3! #1!!*$#'1.1414!#! $'1!'!-1#!,=!4,.$!

7 9$'1!$''12$$ .!'$1#-11281.,!3! $4!'4* !C)(1,3!,.$$ .11 .$ $ ).12 ''16 $* $ -.!2''1$*&#.2!4$'!'!*$ '1$4!2##!$!#!3!$ &#!!!*$#9$'1'!*!1 $''1 9$#!(1-1A#2 !- ,3!- 1!!7 $1#$$-1#! 3!$-!!!1&#!!!*$#, $!! $ '1 . !! 4 !#! $ '1 ! '!

$#!=!4 9$'1122!-4*$!!$112 4*.*12''14!!A#2,3!3.-!,#!2 '*$''1,1!#1!$''116'1 .$!.2$''1.$'!*!$'14!! 4!#!$''11!'!$#!=!4 ''14.$!.(!21*,$''1. .$!.4*!A#2,3!-!! 9$!!, $ '1 . '! 4! -1 A#2 !- ,=!4 42'#,$$ ''!-''1#! !!#1 !

!&$'1$2!#19$!1#!- !!:;'$''14!-2$'1$

; 414*$'!1,#$,$'1.!& 9$'1122!-4*$!!$1124!1! ! A#2,=!4 4*.* 12 ''1,.$$ . 2(1!A#2,=!4,.$-1 !!'$''1,$'#2!! '4*$!1#!!$4)$!1#! .$!!!!21#4!!!!2#!$! '!2'!1. 9$122!-4*$!!$*$- ))$!$#!4*.*12!-', .$$.2-$!'6'1,.$$'# ''!$!#2$#1 B$-$!1!#1!$'!422 $!#2$$!

!B$$!41#1*!$ '!!-' 9$!1#!$11.''1#! !!#1 14*$!!&$'1.!2 !4!!*!.$##''1&#13.-!,$ .!2.!2$4*1!(1!A#2,=!44* 2$!!C!(1!A#2,=!4$ #''116'1414 7$ C(!!12#=!4.$!'$!'!'!* #=!44!-2$8$!!! $'!'!*4122$'1#=!4-#! 8$4!22!1'.!!*,$!

.2#''!$$'1$1!!#* 4'1*.$$!.$!2!$!'!'!*#-112 81.,!3!!$!,$$1#$#! 3!9$#2$-.)4*$$$*$ !2$!!$!,$!1#!3!$!!#! '1 ! '! 4! #! ' &#! =!4(#$$'!#!2.$$$'1.'!#2 $'!24!$!1#!.11''14!! A#2,3!#1451#.$1#2$'!1 2!24$'1#! 7$C( C!(1!A#2,=!4$$ #1!

$''116'1$-4#$'! #2$''13!!7 ,$'2 $!!4*1!-1A#2,3!,$'2 $!!4*1!(A,3!#4!,$1$ #!14!1!-1A#2=!4.$$'! 19$1#!.4*1!(1!A#2, =!4'!8;!'!'!''!'!!42 !'!##!!$'#!'1!*4!#!

"#$ % % !

& !

)

*+ ! ! ! !

( "

-* .

! ! % /

)0"! ! !

* !

1 * .

) $

-* 2

2 034'5'

6 " 75 8"

*9:'''04958":1 !

" 7;

!" #$ #

% " #$ #

3%;

00 % <

& ! !

4 .'3 !

C!#1!$'!!!!#$! $& % #

' ($$ )( *" #$ #

%" #$ #($$ (

(+$$ +,+

- '

( $$ 3.-!,$''1$'!

#!!#$5.$$#$ 4!-$4 C!#1!$!'6'1$!!! &#2 ./0 1&2

&130'

( !))(14 5 5

% 6/ 6#(!

0 /

(,$$ ,+ @!$!#$,$1. 5<#1.'1!-42- ''!#*5'14!2-$.$#14*$! .$'!1=#!$!!,)'2-.$$ !&'1!$!$#$4!1!5'!* '!1.11*#11! B$$'#2!!'4*1!(1 !A#2,=!4.11!,.$$#!!* 1121*!!*!!$!.$11!.$1 5!2!-1&#! 9$#,2!$-1!-',$

+!&

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#