High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7638/2017disposed of

Iqbal Singh v. Bhagwan Singh And ANR

2017-12-06Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu6 pages

!"#"$% &'

()"$*+ ,

.-#/# + *0 $)"$*+ $- , #1$ $

% 234 ))53

-#$ % 4- ) 67 8!

- +1 "$- 4-1 9 :

-7 8!

- +-#1$ $ # ;;;;

:- "$ +"# 1 "$ /$ - - "!( $# "$ $ "

"# - #

#" - -

<$$=/- >? 1 ## ': -$ "

"$ ( "# / *7 @-"

# -0+-': (/$ - - -> /( <-? +

- -

1 ## ': -$ "8"( / * <)$"-"8"#"$?7@-"

# -<$$=/- ?0 # "#@"## -" !

# +!

#( +"("$* +"$#

-8"#"$1 -

#"( #/"

--!8-: #( ($*0"

B>C1-

$$/@ -@

=!/ "$ -*"# - @- *

': $ "$-&/ $ @ #/-"$* D #"

8"(( * 4- 9 7 +#"( $ "#

@-"

# - 0"

+/ ("8-: 1####"$ ( # # 1- -@# $ !$ "

*- /1$ '

+ 1 "#7 @- * ( $ 0 ' - @ ': E

"$-0 -1 "$&/# ($* 0"

+-$BC1-@$ +">C1- $$/@ > "# + #

$ "$ + -8"#"$ 1

'- =1"-: 1-" - @1 + @- * ( $ 7 "@ - - @1 "$ 0 # = $ 8" *-@$

E +- -78" *-@$

"@ - - @1 "$ 0 # = $ /1 D

$ ( # (: 8"

*-@$

7 0+"( *"8"$* "$ ( #D (

"$-7 "@ - - @1 "$ 0 # = $ /1 D $ $ "(/- -1 #/@ # ( ($* 0"

+ "$

*- -

7 1( # "( #/"

- -!8-: # ( ($* 0"

"$/$ - - -E /(# $ --# "$- -@ 1 "$* 0"

+ 1####"$ $ "$ &/# "$ D $ "$-1/ "$ $! $ "( 0-"

@$ !$ # + !( "@ # 8$ ((: (/- 8" - -

((0

$ -# "$ "$- -@

$ "$&/# "$"$ 8/- $: +-1-#$=!1

"(( + "#1# ( + #/"

$ @-"

# 11 ("( ': "$-0 (# "#@"## ': -$ "

"$ ( "# / *7 @-"

# - 8" - -

<$$=/- >?

"# "$ -@$ "$ !"-!/@#

$!#

"$- + 11- !+ +"# /- ': 0 :

-8"#"$ 1 "$ + $(: #/'@"##"$ @ ': ( !/$#(- "$-"#

-# - -+ #'$ ## "$-"$-#1!

( $ 0+"!+ # 1- !((!

- -

# "# + 8 (/

7D7E7>FA0+- +!( "@ #"# $(: /$ #( ($*0"

BC1- $$/@

"$- "# "$ $*

"$# 0"

( +#/"

1-1- :0+"!+0/( !+ /$ !--# 11-="@

(:+--7 +-# - -0/( '!/$ -A1- /!

"8"$ #@/!+ #"$ '#$! '"("

#((

+1-1- :"$&/# 7 $ "$-0/( $ '

'( 1 +!( "@ #"$ +8$ ("

+#/"

'"$* !- $ -A@$ "$ '

!9*-/$ 7(

"$- 1- :# - @ ""!

+ -# - - @&/ 9 (#( $ "$#

D @ $

"# 8+@$ (: 11# ': ( -$ !/$#( - # 0+ !$ $

-@$ "$ 1( 0 # $8- - "# '-

+ /- # '(07 +--7 # + $ 11- /$"

-'/ @#" #7 +!( "@ # 0 # - -!8-: #/@ # ( ($* 0"

B >C 1- $$/@ 0"

+ !

-@ + :

- $ "

!/( $ ' # " 0"

+ !-

0+$ + #/"

0/( ' !" + ("

"$ '

+ 1 "# !@ $ $

4-8-7 + #

$ "$- 0 # !$ "!

-: #@/!+$ +'

#"#!((!

#7 +-

$ "-( $ 0 !( "@ ' -/$ D!--#0+"("$ @'-

0 !( "@

$ "$-0 #"$$*

"$#0"

( $ "$&/# "$- !--# E #!$ $

"$ +!"-!/@#

$!# +- -#1 ## ': -$ /- '(0-# "$--@

"$&/# "$ " $ 0 -- $:"$ -8$ "$

! 0"

-A@$ "$ #"

"$ ( !/$#(- "$-!$ $

11-1-"

(/ $ "$&/# "$!/( $ ''-/*+ +$ "!

( /-

+ + !--!

8 (/

1-1- : '$ !$#" - ': ( /- 7 + 1#"

+-* -

"$0/( $ + 8'$&/

+$ "- D9 @ $ 3 -$ !/$#(1- :#

+!"-!/@#

$!#7+'1-@"

"$'-

( /- 1( ! $ -!- + !--!

8 (/

$ "$ &/# "$ "$ - - #9 @ ""!

+ - -#

"$ $ "$&/# "$=!1 #

+ 8 !$#" - + #/'@"##"$# ( -$ !/$#( - +1 "#

(:7 +@- *0 #!-

': "$-"$-#1!

D9 @ ( #/@

D ( !# $ 0+"!+ 0 # 8$ ((: "$!- # # !#$E

#1- -@# $ !$ "

*- /1$

$ 0 # '- @ 0"

+"$ # "1/(

1-" "@$

:@$ +@- * ($*0"

BC"$ 1- $$/@ + @- * $ "$ &/# "$ 0 # 0"

+/ ("8-: 1####"$ ( "A-#1$ $ # $ !"-!/@#

$!#7

"$"( ': "A-#1$ $ #/$ - - -E /(# $ --# -@ 1 "$* 0"

+ 1####"$ $ "$ &/# $:$ =!1 "A-#1$ $ # 0 ((0 ': + ( ( /- $ /1+( ': -$ 30-11((

/- +$(: #/'@"##"$( +1 "$-"#

+8 (/

$ "# 11-="@

(: !--#

$ "$-"#"$$*

"$#0"

-#(("$* @

- - -#

+ $ "- D 9 $ '@ "" #

9 (#( $ #/!+ #/'@"##"$ 0 # @ '- -$ /- # '(07

+--7 "A-#1$ $ # $8- * $: 11- /$"

-'/ @#" #7

$ "$-"# !$ "!

-: "$ #@/!+ + 8 (/ # 1- ((!

#"##

' 11-="@

(: D!--#0+- #"$ @ '-

"#!( "@

-$'

- #(("$* $ "$ &/# "$ - !--#$ +!"-!/@#

$!#7"$ $!"-!/@#

$!#0 -- "$* -8$ "$ 0"

+ 0(( - #$ - -# 1 ## ': /- # '(0 # -* - # - *- ("'- @8 11-1-"

"$ - @ ""!

"$ +- - +/- #'(07"

$ #$@$

"#7 8"# 7 "$-0/( '

("'- @8 11-1-"

"$"$ !!- $!0"

+1-8"#"$#

( 0 $ "$!

# $:#/!+

"$"#@8 7 @0/( '!$#" - $ !" #1-( 0

8"#"$ 1 "$ "# "#1# "$ + ("*+ 1#"

#$ '8

!" #$ %

5+ +- +- -"##1 9"$*F- #$ % #F 5+ +- +- -"#-1-

'( % #F