High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1204/2010dismissed

Subhash v. State Of Haryana

2017-05-22Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Lok Adalat Bench - 117 pages

!"#$#% &'() ) *#++ ,,! - . '

& ./! *#

+!

! 0" 120 # &# #&#0 120 # &#&#0

!

"

$$

%

&' (((( #&#03# )# $$

# $

+"

, $

"

- ."

&

- / 0

- / 0

1

2,

" $

$'

3

"

#

"#

" $

$

'

" $

$

'

$'

2 3

"

#

"#

" $

$

4 #

# "*

"

" '

#

$$

*

# " $' $$

* $

$"

+"

*

* 5"

#

#

" '

16

%

& $

- '

+"

##*

% '

# $

$

$'

!

+"

. 7 $

$'

- '

#

0$ 8$

-#

-&7

& $

& 0$

$#

+"

"

%

& $

& 7 # & $

&

$

+"

#

2 $

$'

"

/ '

#

:4

0$ 3-&7 8$

-#

#'

+

# #

'

;8 < =>;

+ # >

&?

#

/

#

* " * #

8" @

>

% #

# %#

>?

'

* ,

# #

$

"

8" @

> $ #

$

#

> * / ?

#

$ #

#

# #

#

# # $?

# #

#

*

" '

#

# 8"* %

&?

' '

) #

# $

# " )#

$'

# ?

#

#

" ##

* '

$

# #

#

'

A "# B +"'

#

>

C

+"'?

8" @

> # "$?

#

"

8" @

>

# #* " # $>$

#?

'

+"

%

& $

# D

# $

+"

%

& $

& >$ "

0+"

>

& $

&

# &

"

*#

* 2 $ 0

$

# '

#'

* "# *

#

"

$ & "

0$ 8$

-# 0$ 8$

-#

*

- /3/ 0

2

"5

# "# * C

-#

D0

D0 :4

- '

-0 -" -# -0 -" -# $"

"5

* >

0$ 3-&7 8$

-#

$'

D0 0

"

5"

$$ $ :4E &

$"

-0 -# -#

& 8 -#

4

"

#

5"

:4/

# &

$ & #

$ $

>

$

A "# B

$

* > $

>

$

#

$ $ # $

# $ ;--; $ >

:4 0

$$

"# $

:4/1 &

4

#

$'

$

"

-0 -# -# *

0

# >

:4 7 216

-0 8# !

-&7

- -

& 7

'

"'

@

##

"

@ -"

8

-

"

"

@ -"

@

##

>

-

$"

'

> < * = !6- 2,,

"

#'

* $$#

$'

* >

-

$"

#

" '

# '

= !6- 2,,

# ' $$#

*

"$ 7

#

"$

$'

>

#

$ )#

# " $

'

$'

-03-&7 8# !

# $

* #

#

$$# 7 5"'

#

@

##

# "

@ -" 0

"5 # "# * 8*

D0

0

$

" # -0 -" 8"

0 -

&

-0 # 8"

#

#

#

>

-0 8# !

"

#

"' $

*

-0 -" 8"

#

# >

"' $

$'

#

"# > #

$

:41 $$ )#

$

$'

$

$

#

# $ ;-8;

>

:46 '

>

- $

:4, "

-0 -" 8"

" $

#

@

##

#

:4/

>

:4/

#

"

"

#

- 1

:

7 E16

@

##

"

@ -" D0 = 2

- /1 0

- -

* #

$

" " # $

"

@

##

"

@ -"

+ )#'

# "

@

##

" "

" :4

$

#

$" #

# $ "

"

@ -"

- 1

: :4/

>$

$

"

"

"

#

> "

"

0

$

$'

#

"

*"

#

D-!

#"*

8

$ #

$

#

$$

"

-"*

."

&

7 $

"

-"*

."

"$$

$

"

"$

- 1 )#

- / 0 4 " * "

-

-"*

."

6

"

- ."

&

# "

"

- ."

&

0 $

#

-"

* +" & $

*

*

." ."

&

E1, $

- ."

& !

- ."

&

* #

- /

- / 0

0

$ @ 8

@

##

#

#

- 1

@

##

#'

##

#'

" '

#

4

" "

"

" 4

'

$

*

F "

$ "$$

" '

$

* # F . F/ <

%

& $

$

16

" #

4

##*

F %

'

# * "# > 8" @

>

4

:4E

!

" # $ % &'( %

% % &

)** # $ &

$'

! :41

-&7

- '

:46 &

4 #

+"'

! * /

16 F -0 -

F2 -0 .

#

:4,

:4

$ ' FE * )+$

$

16

- '

$

$ :4

#

*

5

##

&

#

$

$

5

#

-

# -

& '

,

' F1

"#

$

66

"

+ # >

C

$$

$ :4

F " ;;

F6 -0 +

$

166

-0

- '

"

- "

#

"

"

"

"

F, H -#

$

16

%

& $

& 7

'

$$ :4/

$

<"

#

"

" " $'

##*

2 '

%

& &

"#

$

:4 #

+"'

!" "

" " +,,(

" -

- "

+.,/.-

- " ' "

-

0 1 **

" * +"'

# *

*

#

4 # 4 # " &

$'

$ :42

$$ $

5" $ :4E &

"#

#

$

#

# $$

F -0 -# -#

#

16

$

> $ F :& -#

* "# = ,

6

' 6

:42 F 0$ # -#

$

616

- '

>

"

"

$> @ $"

#

"

" :4E

# -

0

F/ -0 -" -#

16

-0

-

$

"5 :4

-03-&7 8$

-#

D0

$'

* :4

$

$

# # "# * )+ F -0 # 8"

#

# $

E16

F2 +'

8"

- -

0 # -

0%

& &

$

16

$#

-&7

- '

"#

$

+ # >

D0 = 61

16

$ $

$$

$ :4/ FE -03-&7 8# !

#

"

#

216

$$#

@

##

"

@ -" *

4 #

$

"' $

$'

#

@

##

"

"

" F1 0$ A B 8$

-#

#

16

"$

* 4

$ F6 &

& $

&

* "# *

*

>

-"#

8"

*

#

>

= <

#

#">>

. &

= < # 4$ &

$#

$

*

#

> :4/2

:4/, *

#

> :4/,

F, -0 -" 8"

#

"

#

E16

$

$ "

"

!

"* "

$'

$

D-!

:4 $

D0 = 236

- -

" -

- //

" $$

$"

# *" #'

#'

$

#

D"#

$

@

##

> "$ 0 -

&

$

# $ >

# "

16

$

D0 = 236

- -

*

/2 $

$'

' 0 -

& "

'

# "

"

@

##

- /

- / 0

- 1

#

$ @ 8 5"

#

#

@

##

5"

# -

0 +"

@

##

#

$ $$ F # #

"

$$

"

%

-

&'

/ * # "#

#

$$ )# "#

' "

# *" *

$ " AFB

AFB

#

"

#

"

#

#

"' /2 $

#

> " " +"'

" "* )# "#

#'

# #

#

*" #

# # #

#

#

"

$ @ 8

# @

## ' " # #

#

#

'

)!22 A "# B

+"'

#

>

"#

#

#'

'

#

#

"

#

#

#

'

# 8""* %

& )#'

+"

0+"

>

& $

# >$ "

#

& $

&

#

" "*

+"'

#

# # #

"

$

#

' " # 0 D0

$ #

"

#

##

" #

$ #

-

:

'

$

0

# "# "

"

$

## #'

"

)# # $ $

0 '

$

" AFB

AFB $

)#'

#

*

"

$

#

$

#

#

"

+"'

>

#

+"

. F

$ $

# " AFB

AFB

* "

**

" #

* #'

#

# "*+

#'

4 *" #'

* #

'

=

$ " '

* #

#

$

#'

# #

#

$

"

)#'

#

#

#

#

$

"

$

#

' "

" $ $ *

#

* "#

>

$"#

"* # # $

#

"

$

$ '

#'

2 # "#

"

$$

> " '

'

$

C

0

*"

'

# "

D

0

4

#

# #

'

'

'

$

*

#

$

F "

F

#'

5"

$$ "'

* " '

$

"

" #

$

$

#

##

*

"

'$

#

" )#

" # " *

*

#'

5"

$$ "'

*

"

"

"

#'

# 7 "

"

$$

$ +

$$#

# # "

'

*

F "

F

#

# '

$ " '

# # $

#

#

' )#'

#

#'

4 *" #

" # )#

*

E > $ $ =#

'

+

# -#

8"

#

#'

"$ "* " #

> "

/,, 0

> ' $

#

$$

" $$# " # '

" #

" #

#

# )# # #

# "

#

$

+

# )#

#

" ' # $ $

"' $

$'

#

)#

"' $

$'

#

"

*"

#

"

+"'

$

" "*

'C

D-!

$ $

# :4

/2I

*"

>

3

"' $

>

F A #*

/2I B

D0 = 2

E16

- /136E3/6E323/ 3//3/2/ 0

232 32,

- -

'

#

>

3 *

* " '

#

"

# > )#"

#

*"

"

+"'

"' $

1

#

"' $

" +"'

>

$

#

"

" "*

+"'

# #

"

$

0

#

$

"

"$$

" "

"

#

16 /

+ # >

#

" " +"'

>

" "*

'

"

"

"' $

/2 >

*

- 1

+"

$

"

*

"$ $ $$

$$

$

)#

'

'

#

+"

"$#

# $$

* '

' = '

*

5"

4# #&#05 4#&#05 #$#% .6 F## $>3

H3=

F## $ * H3=