High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1213/2010disposed of

Prem Masih v. State Of Punjab

2017-08-18Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mrs. Justice Archana Puri17 pages

"# $

# %& !

(

)*+$ ,+ - #"*# ,+ - #".

/ 0 . #$ +#0 12&/ "

& / ". & 333333 .

/ 0 .&-

+## #" #"

/" 0" !

& %4!5

6 ,7# "

/ 8!% !

!##0## #- &.

8!% !

!#"""

# # # :&!!!;

" 0" !

'5=>;

7 %! !!8 0" !

&?# " 0 <

& # " .

## #5=>7 9 #+#& "

0 #"

0 9 # # #5=>7 ## ?#$

@ # / ##

# +#

##+# B: #? # #" +

# # ? +# C# '! !!8

+#D

+# ?

# A" 1 ?

#& ?

# +# #

? ?/ & 1 #

## ?

# ?C#

% ?

# +# +#?#

+## # "

# "

# +#?

?+#

* ? +##

? "

+#" ? # #&" " ?# ?

0 "

&"1 ?

" "

7 " / ?? #

+#? ?## "

& # #?

1 +# / ?

+# # #9 +#?#"

#F # *? +#"

+# ??E

#" ?

+# 9 /# +# # #1+# " +# # ?"

# D

?" 1? "#

? / ## ?*? +# +#&?#

/ #?"#"

"" 1G 9 " "

" /# " D #

" #&

# " ""

"& "

## ?### 0"

" #

> +#?# "

"9""

#?#

# / %! !!8#9""

##"

#=>.

# 1"

? "

#/ "

# "

# #"

#& ""

# " #" # " E E "

/ ?" ?# 1

#### / "

/ => B F "

" # /# & "

0" '

- " + # # ##&

!4 !!8&? "# "#" #"

" 0" !

?"#>" #/

0## #& "

0## # /

B!' !!8 : 9 0## #- &.

# "

# ""

" # 0" !

& " # #""

# !!8 !!8 ?" ""

# " 4 9

###"#>##%?###

A 9 #+#&"

###

+#?# #

#?#

+## ""

" +#+#? E # ? ""

#" # ""

# / ?? E

+#? #

*? ""

# +# #""

## # +#

#? # ?# # ?

8 # ""

#"#

9 #+# /# #

# 0

#"1"#?

/ ?#+##

# A+

20 #

"?##? #/#=> /" AB 0/ 0 ? "

" #

> +#

/ #

#=>#"

+# # ?#$

HA5:"> "7 #

## #1 "

& >?

HA "

#? #& > ?

# ' AB 0/0 " # ?#

& " " #

A:0 #"

1? 0 # %! !!8?# " 0 # #"/# )"

" ""

" ##""

## # #

# ""

## ##1 #"

#=>.&

& "

#" ""

#&?"?#1 #### / "

/ =>A4 0 1? 0 #

"?##? #/ =>2/" A' .

10 #1

# " ""

##=> =>:A%0 #"

0 &? # /# )" #"### # /# "

<* " % F "

" #

/"&# ""

#?#

# 0"

? "

/" #?# ># ""

# #" # "

"#?

1## # "# 1#&?

" # #

/"?# ?/ ""

##" 8 9

# /" "

# # #" # #""

#""

/"""

#/ 9""

# /

## #

! H "

?## # /

# "

" # # => 9 #+##

9 "

###

# "

##> & 5A 7 9 # +# # / # ?## ""

"9 "

# # ?##?

"?# #" ""

## ""

### ?

# > ""

" 9 "

# A "# /?

/#"#

? # "

5=>7& #/ # &# *?## #

# " *??## >#A ## ?## ""

9 "

# " /" / #

?### "

## # "#?A ##""

#"?

# A ##""

# / ?# "# # #

+# 9 "

### /?

# #"#

& " # # # #

""" "D

) & "

# # 0##

/ ## # ?###

/"# #

?###9

"#"

/ # #"## "? "

?##"

# " #

### "#?A #

#& ?###A *#? ""

## #" /

#" # " #" 9 "

0# ## #? # # #

9 "

## #

###

A/"

# /# ## # ##

? ###" "

#&/#

# "

B 9 #

#D #

## ? " /"#

#"#

# AB 0/0 ?

+#$ @ HA5:"> "7 #

## #1 "

& >?

HA "

#? #& > ?

# /

# ?##" ?

9? " #

" #

" ? # "#

#"?E

"#?

" ?

&# #"#AB 0/0 # " # #"#?## #

?"?## " " #

4 9

& ## "

##"## A A

?#" >#"

/" /? # 0/0 5AB7

# "

##> AB& "

"# #

/ " ##

9>#"

# " ?# /"##" ### #=>## "&" #" /"

# ? / #

' # #?###&# A ##

# #"

##> ##

"?# ##

##> /#""

#?# # #

"?"1"8?"" # "#D

##> A #

" ?

#1 "$

$%&'(( (')

( ' *# + , '

* - & ('

' ,

/ .' ' &'

(( ('(( ( *& ',')

( .'0 ' ((&* **( &*%&& ', - & *' '' ((&*1 '* -(( (+0 &

& ' -& +( '(

('' '+ ,&'

'* .' (' ' ''&'(( (+ *& ' '('- *'&' ((&*

* / '

().-' ((&* '*( &* '' ' 0' &&& * 0 '0 *&&&'

' '23 0 '&&(** 4-0 *( * 0

&& / -&* /' ' /'+** '&' ((&* (' /'&'.

5/'0 & ''''(( (6 + ( ''& ' ',

/ *(' 4- '. && &0.'

*.-' ( '0' /' &'-7'

' '23 0 & ' *,'

##> &A ## #""

# " # ? ""

# ?/ &# # #

??"&#> "## / """

# "#

8 9# A *## #

## "

##=># ##?## ""

"# # ?# " # # A ?=> ##""#*"

?A 9 # +# # A *??## >## #?## ""

! # / #"#

" ## "A *# # ? 0 / ## # #

# 1 /

# #?# /

##> 0 "# & # # # / "####

? ""

# ?

#/""

#/?## ""

" ?

? # #

## #/A *& ? ""

#&# #

?## # 9""

## # "

#### #" "#

"#?

## #9""

## / #

. # #"#

# # 9

# ""

#? ?# # /

# ""

# >" #"# ?"#

? ?# # ?# #

## #"

>& "

/# # #" !4 =/"" %'

&?"#

# #" !

=/""&?"#

# ? ## #>#" # "" 0" !49=/""& %'

" ?

!4 A"##"?1 ? &

/ "#

#7'

7 /,7'

' 8 .

& E>

#"##"1 ? &

/ "# ?

/" "# "

? 1 ? ""

#?#

0" !4# /

/ ""

# #

& #" ?

"##?

# # ""

/ "#

?" # "" ? >#" " "#& ## ""

#/ ##"1 ? # ""#& # > ?" /"

? "9 # ?##" !4 =/""## " >" "##&?"&?

##" "#?" "

?1 ? ""

9 E>

&"#

# 7 9 8

%8 ,7'

':8 '# ?"" #"#?

# ""

/ # "D ""

#9 /> "

" #

" ?

#1 "$ $7(' '2,* ( (';"! ,*&' '0 - ('&& (

0' ') 0 */ - & ;'.*

, /' ' ('& 7 ('& ,* '(*' '

'0 & -'

'00 &&'

- /0'&0 '''

* ';'&'&0 &' 0 ' &**;

-0 ' &(' &&((&&

- ,*' '& **(*

* '

/""#&""

# "

?##"

> #?9 E0

/" # "##" ?#

"/" "

"""

#?"

#"#& ""

# # "

? > " " #"# ?"#

# #

#&? ?# # 9

#" ""

#"#

# " "

/ E

#" ""

" ##"

#=>.&?

# ? #

" ""

# " ? ? E

E "#?"

#& "

### /#""

# / ???

& ##"#?""

# " " #" !B

" #" !

# #"# #

? ? ?

# 1"#9 "

### ##

?###/#""

#" #

### #

"/"# #

# ?# #

) &

0 "

# # # ""

# 1 "##

"# "# "

#" !

: 9 ""

#" ?/ & # #

//### ? "# 0" !

#? #&# ""

#? ??"

?#" #

?"/

1 ? E## "/" # / ##""

###

#9 #&#

" #"# ""

## ?

#&# #

" #"# "## "# /& #I " # I? #I ##" ## &

#" "## "

4 9 E>

# 7 ' &&

(

/ 8

& / <**-,&7'

' & /

# 1 "

# ?" D # J E9 E>

# /# $ = %;'('& * (*'*(*' ,'

>&' ' ' 0'( *( ' &' '0

*(*0'' ( &

& *7(' '+ '++4 -

''- &/ ( ' ''&?

() / ';&' - / ( ''

;> ( * ;'' ( *0*,

.8(' .

(; - *'

'( ' & */ (

&& ( ' / * '&@&

',& ), /;/*;8

&& ( -.''

- .& ' &(( &&% -. ' ' % -. *'

' + (';' - '

, .(

'- ''' *'& (';' -. ( &&*0' ((&* '' '&' ,*'

'- *.- '' ' /' '' ( &' ''0 & ' ' '( &* '+'&'('&' &' ''( && * & .

* 7(' ; ' ( ,'* ' (& & .

* 7(' ' +A++; ( && (

(* ' ' /'*; ' '* &*

& .

*&(' % ' ' '( &* '( . / '*/

- (. ' 0&,

0 /; /'((&'

(&B

''0

&*C 0' '0

0 & ( * .-' ((&*0 &

()* '& 'C 0''.

0& * ' ,'

''.*-C , ' '(

-* ( & / 8-C , 0' ' ('0 & '(&&** > &** /'

/'C , 0'' (* '((&.-( (0''0 &

- *'

' C , 0''0 & - '-0''*( &* & &' /C , 0''0 & -/ , *&** ,( ' ; * &;'( &&( ,( ' C 3 0''0 & ' ' && C 3 0' ' & (' /' 8- & '

) *

*, '

/ & ('* ( * &

C 3 0'' ((&**

' & / .

0&,

0& % ., &'((&'

(&&;(&; '3 &', *' -.&,

'& (

((&'

(&0' (' *,*

( &&0( -'0 /' '>&' ' ' ' ' &'

-D=

' "#

##7!##7 /

/ ,&7'

; E0

" ""

## #

? #&

" #

#" #9 # "### "? "

#/ # # "

<* # ""

# /?

?#??

"#A#?## >#"

## > # #" ??# /A *&# <* ?## ""

" ?##?## ># # ?#? /""

# "#?

#"# #+

&?"## " ?

"" 9? "

?#"1 ""

# ""

" ?" ?# "

" "

# ?

9"# #1 ""

#9 # / #

% #"1

1 /?"? "# ? ?

# "#

/" ""

# ? ?

?# "

"&" #""

# " #

"# "

"#1

" #

8 #"

>& "

## 7;+ * & ,7'

'@? "# # ?""

"#?#"1&?"

/ "

/" #" !

?# !B #"?# " *

#9 /> " ## ?#$ DDDDDDDD6 ',- 3'* - / #!#; ' ((&*

' & 0 ' ( ' *( &*&

- ()* &

' *0'' '/ , .

0 ' *'*( &*%& *.

00 && ( ' ' & ( &> (0('*( &*** 0' *.( *.'

) ''& '

%& *(' 3&.'0 '.

' ** ' '*( &*0(&* ' -( &* '/, /' .

0 6;'; '( &** ' '

'/'

& ( &(

(* ' ' /'*;.'

( &* /' '' 8&0(0 &( &*

''.*-;0 '( &**,0' '

'0 & ' ' ' '' ((&*

'' ( &* ''*( &* 6; ';

' ' ( ,(' '

' 7(' + *

*'7(' '++ *

* ! /?

##"

## #

/&? "### "

"# #" !

& " 1

"# #" !B

#D &"

/" +##

0" !

0" !B ##"

# #

! # 9#" #

#& ?/ & #

9## ??

# "

/" #D " #" ! "

!# # "

$ $

%& '(%) A #1 ;

# C#;

C#;