High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1430/2004disposed of

Karnail Singh And ANR. v. State Of Haryana

2015-12-14Mr. Justice Mahavir Singh Chauhan10 pages

!"" #$%% &

($ #)*+(,%-./! !/#",010-10# !

" # $ %# '

'(" ")'# # *

%% '"+ ),' "

&& -,"

(

.") -/012-3 &4220" 5"")'

'$ & *6 -/07/-3 &4220" 5%'', '$ & *6.

'$ " &% ,, + ), &% $"%"

/8 4220 '

&% /:

4220# .*

; )< '

%=#%>

#>'$"

('"%''%%

(% $"% % !-

# #/# !# #"

0-+/ 14:?/0@

& 8* 48#22?- & 1, ' 82:?/0@

& :

' 822?- & /8 * ''%( % %*

'."&&% &'% "% "'+ ),

.*'"

!- 5/9 4224#'% ", '

&'"$,#"

&$") '"# ) '" , % '

"% "

>' A"$"*# >' ' &&% ' ' " )"%" ( '$") ) ) ("'

%'', % ' '" %" '

% "+" '",

($#',( % ," " ' %'* '&# +" , ("' %%"

' '

%% ',& ('"%''*(%'

%% & ' .

$ %"%,%# %'', ")' % ( '$") ) ) )"', /8 4224# ,#

'" '(' ) %'"$;, .

: :

B'"'' '",& ) %'"$'

&%")'" $#'" '( (")

'"'

'",'(& ( .* '%% +" ' , - %*% B' (" "% & ,''

&%'',#%% +" 'C'

' '% , '

) % & " ' ,",# %'', , ("' "# , , ("'3'#3''#" , ("' '" %, '

.") " $ '",& ")&$") ', -%*%'.& ,'

+" '%"% '",

)"$").") '", B''" '

%* ' ', ")' & ")' ,# "

&$")")"' &%'," ' (% '

('"%''"& (* & , '

)("' '" %"$ (

&)"$")' &"& '&#

")'('"& >*>;"

"# >' .* '",

& ,''(&

' ")'

'." &'",# % %"

141#140#10/#82: ("'

/07 /0@ ( )"

") "$")"

&% %")'. -' "%> & , #%"

14: &' "

(

, & (" ( %

%% %'',# +" # "#3'' '(

4224('%% ,"

(

' 2@ 2@ 4224

2@ 4224 %"$* % "

"$")"

/91

& " & ' %%

")%') %"

129

') %"

129#141#140#14:#10/#82:

/07 ("'%"

/0@ (&, )"'%%

('"%''%% "

)"* %", " $"%#' %"

C,"

'& (")("!- B-/#" ")''

/91

B-4#

>', % " /4 // 4224#C ' ,%"

&, ' % %* ',)"("'"'

B-0# "$> ))( $ ' "+" " .* , $ '%

* &C

, "% -)

C ?/ B-7# "* ))( ' ' /8 4224# , ( ," " ' " %"$ ' "+*("'$'$ *("'&% "& "

("'&%.

)")'"

("'&%,% 8 '

' &"

("'&%&& .

', &'%% (% %"

1/1

'"%","")%"%,%

") "' %"

%( '%%

'%%

" ', &", "%"

%" &%(

" &$"

%#' "

# $"

'", ) + ), #% $"% '%%

14: 82: ("'%"

/0@

($#'%%

(%D" & &&% %"

129

") ""&" ("''", ) + ), % $"%"

' &%#'

'$.

"% ''

+" ")' "

"%"

"' %%% '*'$. &*", "% "' % *><"%",= '.". ', "&' '> ")"$"( ' "&& %". '

#"% ."

' % ,," ' &&%"&'% &'"% ,,

.+% ' '' #'

'+ ), ' .*'"

'$' % & ' " ) ' )''% &'%

")' %* &

#'%% -

%'', "

&" '".'& .

'", * & B-@#, ' ("')

' %%%"$* %"&"% %) "% ')"$ "

&'"%"

'"+"% $" ' %"&"%* ''" '(#+" ,("'%%"

'% "

) .*'",#'%%

' . %')-'

'& #'*' ) ))"'", '&' )"$ "' /8 4224:

22?:

12 ,#'" '(# ' ) %'"$;,('#''",&' ) % '" $ '

& %") '" $# ('" '" '(

(") '"'

#'(& ( .*'%%

+" ' , %*% +" '

"%" '"% -%% %'',")'(, ("') "# ,+(, ("' #3''# ")$.") ("''" $'",&#

")(*& ,'

$")'", %*%'.'( %"% .*'%% + '#('

,""

.") '", ""),.*'"+ #',")' ")',#"

&$")")"' %'," ' %, '

('"%''"& (*

& ,'

'"$"

&%")"+""&*& "&" .*'

& "*))(#('

(C," B-7 ' , , .* ' % "# ,

' # B-@&" % % .

("'', &' "+ #('

B-9 B-7# "*))(

$ '&%" .*'"+ # '"")')

&' '' (

" '&& , '

"," '","' ")"$"(' %"&"% ('"%'&" & % .

& , ' , & "+ # ' ", * & "*))(#'%)"'

" &*."' '" %"&"%"* &,#"+*". ' %% '(

"'%", '(

& &&%"

'"# ) "() % $ .*'

' % , " ' ", * & B-/2# $")") &&"%#

'& #'% &' %"

"&*."'

)"'%%

D*#'% $"%"

( $") 'D, &%#

% & '

''%% '$&% ') *

& % ""%4224 &'" %#'%%

"")'' ) % & *#& , '

(*"C *#('#'%% ,>'")'' )

*#"C, '#">("#+" ")'' ) (

*#'' ) * & , '#3''' ) $, ' ' ) $, ' &'.,"'',""+* '' (% .*%%

%'',('

'"% "

' &',"")%% " "

' &%'', #' *'> ")"$"( '%"%,%#'% &'%% ,*. %

, .C " $ '% '%% +" ")'

'"%" ' '%% ''"+ '

) % -&('#'%% "")'# ,

3''(, ("''" '"+* ")')(% .* ,+")'

'' "+*(% .*%% %'',('

'"% "

' ) % " " & ' ,"")")

%"%,%"&$ &'%%

")"$"(',#'"

" &'

'' &+"%( .&&"%"*, "%'% &'

" % ' "

* ) .*','

($#.+% *, & 82#222?-.* %% ,+ ")' 42#222 .* %' & ' ,"") %% '"+ % "

%% ")* ' , & % "

. "

("'" & '& ,

* %#', &% "

" "

("'" ' "

# '

( . , .

"," ("'

*&'

/0 /4 42/8