Yadwinder Singh And ORS v. Ludhiana Improvement Trust And ANR
!!"# $"#%# &' ( $())'
) #*!#
!
"#! (" +,+"-.+!
"!/*!!"# ("0 )"-.+!
""#*! (""%0+- ".+!1!/ (""2%$" /+"3+-.+!
""#*! 444
!" 3*%5 !/ *"#! ".# # !/ "" +!
-*+##67!/,+".,0%58 ".#9- &%/++-.1//1/,+,51!/!1#,+!:%! +**,+!# +!
; + <
- 1// 1"
"5+"5 !/ *,! < =- 3+#%"5
#> 7+"#- #!%+! +25%"%+5+"-&%/++-!1+#/,!/+!= "# $
# %&
' (
( )
*+ ,- # #. . / 0 + & + / *0
' (
+ /
/
+
1!
/ 0 2 * 3 /
4-5 / / !
.444,
6
!7
&
# %& 8 /
9
( 1!
.444, 6 1! + / :
' (
.444, & 1! + / :
'
;
/
# %& ,.. 8
0 * *0
' (
0 ,,...%( .
/
& 6
< , + /
/
4.,44 .444, 6 &
1! = > ?*@+ ( '$'
6 7 ; 7 '
$ 7 ' / 6 8
7 ; 7 '
)/ *"%#+, !/ , #/1# !/+! %+"#/+ ?%3+" , + #%! " 2%! +5+#! 3*".3! )"%#! &%/++ " "#!"+5 3*".3! )"%#! &%/++- "3+,,5!/+,,!3! *,!< =-3+#%"5
#>7+"#-+25%"%+5+"-&%/+++,,!!!!/*,+!
. +,,!3! ,!!" &)@ A@
+! ; B%"!/" "!1+##%5/!!!+,,!!/#+*,!!+7,#+! +*! !/ #!+,,3!# !/ #+ *,! +# *" !"3# !/ +,,!3! ,!!" )/ #+ #%! 1+# " - + !" !#!67!/"#*!=3*".3!)"%#!-&%/++!3# %!!/+!*!!"/+"+2! 5//#+/++,# ,+#%! "
<
,+"+!
- #C5 ,+"+! +5+#! 3*".3! )"%#!- &%/++ !/+! / # 1" *,! < =- 3+#%"5
#> 7+"#- #!%+! +25%"% +5+"- &%/++ (++!"72%!1+#+,##%5/! ""!5!/)"%#!!+,,! *,!< =-3+#%"5
#>7+"#-#!%+!+25%"%+5+"- &%/++1!/#>%!+,", *#### #+*,!)/ #+#%!1+#+,#"
A!/!/2%53!#+ "#/+.63 +,A!/!/*+"!# %+"#/+?%3+" +/+"+2! 5//#+ ,#*+"+!:%!#1//1" #*#67!/3*%5"" /+./+",+"%#, "!/*+"!#+/+. +,#+" %,,75!/"%5/!/ , 3!!,7- %+"#/+ ?%3+" /+ , + #%! *"" !3 " *"3+! 2%! - 1// 1+# " "#! *!!" /+ , + #%! ,+!" " ,+"+!
+ ! 1+# " 3%/ ,+!"
!!/!3 !/# #%! +.%" /+"+2!
5//#+-+"1+#+,"+7:#!+5+#!3*".3! )"%#!-&%/++',%C,7-!/ +!%3 !/%6,+,,!3!1+# !6"%5/!!!/! !/%"!!/#%! ,67/+"+2!
5/ /#+ *,+ 1+# !+C 67 !/" *+"!7 !/+! !/" # +!/",+3"5+"5!/#+3*,!.%"5!/*7 !/ #%!- 1/ !/ " 1+# *+## +5+#! 3*".3! )"%#!- &%/++- !/ +!%3 *+##5 !/ " 1+# ! 6"%5/! ! !/ ! !/ %"! "+!/" !/ . !/
+!=3*".3! )"%#!- &%/++ 1+# ,# 67 ""# %" "" %, !/#1+7-!/" +.%" /+"+2! 5/ /#+ 1+# *+##- 1!/%! !/ "#! "
+.%" %+"#/+ ?%3+" 65 6"%5/! ! !/ ! !/ %"! B+ 1!/ !/# "%3#!+#- !/ ,+" ., 0%5 ".#9-&%/++/+#/,!/+! "#!" +.%"
%+"#/+ ?%3+" # ! 6 :%! +5+#! *,! < =- 3+#%"5
#>7+"#-#!%+!+25%"%+5+"-&%/+++ "5+"5!/"*+## +.%" /+"+2! 5//#+- !##!+!!/+!!/"1+#++",""-!/" "-!/" *+## +.%" *"#!*!!"+!6:%!+5+#! *,!< =-3+#%"5
#>7+"#-#!%+!+25%"%+5+"- &%/++!1+# %"!/"!!/+!!/+,,!3!*"!+#!!/ 7+" + +,!"+!. *,! #+ +"+ # +.+,+6, )/" "- !/ ,1" %"! +**, !/ !" /+"3%# !"*"!+!- + "" !/+! !/ " +!
+!6:%!##%/-2%53!6!"=3*".3!)"%#!- &%/++-1+#"!!3+C!/*+73! !/%""!*" !/#+*,!!&# /+"+2! 5//#+-+#*",,!"D# "+!*".+,5!/+"+1/"*,!< =-3+#%"5
#> 7+"#- #!%+! +25%"% +5+"- &%/++ # #!%+!- + !" +2%#!5 !/ #+, #"+! *+73! # -
@= )/ #+*+73!1+#"!!63+1!/
+7# !" 55 !/"%5/ !/ 3*%5 ""- +3 !/ .1 !/+! .1 " +! +.%"
;
%+"#/+ ?%3+" "5+"5 *,! < =- 3+#%"5
#> 7+"#-#!%+!+25%"%+5+"-&%/++-!/#%6#>%!" +!6:%!+5+#!!/#+*,!!65#-*"3+= + !/"#,,5+,!7!/"" !/,1"%"!""5!/ *+73! %""!*" !/#+*,!!/+"+2! 5//#+ +# *" !/ ,,!"D# "+! 1."- !/ ,+" %#, " !/ *!!"*"+7!/+!!/,,!""+!#+"3%/,1"!/+!/ +!%+,3+"C!"+!#+!/+!!/"" !/,+",1"%"! 63 +/3+76+,,1!*!%!#3.++!*,! !/ #+3 +"+ #+3 " #3,+" ,+,!7 + *"## !/ :%!+5+#!!/#+*,! !/#+3+"+ #."+7 !!+C,##"*,!/+.5,##"+"+1!/%!,+35
" *"6!1#+ ,!< =+#3+,,"*,! .1 !/+6.-!/*"#!*!!##*# )/3*%5""#%*/,1!/!/ ,,153 +!=
9 )/ *"#! *!!" #/+,, 6 !!, ! !/ *" !/*,!+#"!67!/3*%5""
9 !/+,!"+!.!/*!!"#/+,,6!!,!*! %!!!/3*".3!!"%#!+6%!!/:#! *,! #+3#E!/#+3"#3,+"+"+@#/3+ *+7!/*" +,,!3! !/+,!"+!.*,!- !#
" "3+,,%36"+#",!5+!F 9 B%"!/" *! # 5. ! !/ *!!" ! *"## " +,,!3! *,!/+.5,##"+"+#+3"#3,+" ,+,!7"#/31//# " "3+7%36"+ ",!5+!#%62!!!/!!/+!+#%"!+C 6 " !/# %"!- / 1,, *+7 *" ,! < =- +25%"%+5+". "#+#3+,,"*,!
)/:%!+**,+!+6*"+6. !!"3# ,##!#+7!/+!*!!"#/+,,6">%"!*+7 !/6+,+*"!"3# +,,!3!,!!"1//1+#,!5+! !/#%! ,6!1!/*+"!# #
$