← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7673/2017disposed of

Dinesh Gupta And Another v. Ankit Gupta And Others

2017-11-22Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal25 pages

 

         ! "# $%!! ! &'(#"")"#&*  ##* + ,#'(#"")#&*  ()# -%

    

              

  

!

   "   

#$ # %  ( " ) * + ( "

  ,

    -

.

 ./  , 0

(( 2

!

"

2"   

#$ # % , , 

  ,  &  ( , ,   2"  3 

  -

.

 .

./  , 0

((  "

 4"2



 

#

# 5 ,"

 ' /         



       

                   ! "#$ %

"%

 $ #

"&'

     '          '

(    & 

 & & 



      

       

              )   &'



   

  &    $)    )   %

"

 

    '    #  *  ' 

       + * 

     )   

 '

    )

 

 



       '  )     $         

 

"    - .!



  -  , 0

((  ,  ' 

 



 2"

      &"

    

  -

.

 .

./  , 0

((  ,"

 , "  2 

 /  .          

 &



      

         ! "#$ %

"%

 $ 

#

"&      ) 

 



 & &



'

(  /  .           %

"

   

    ' # 

  ! "  #$  %

"  %

  $ 

#

"  '

'

 $ "'

'  ' 



 & &



'

(  /  .      0

     )       

             '  ' 



 & &



'

(  /- 9!



   0

(( 

,"

  -

.

 .

./ ((  "

 4"2

  

#

#

 " 

2    



,

   

2  :6  

; 0 (< 

##% )  

: :+  '  

 

 

    

  

4"2

  

#

# 

 1!

 4"2

  

#

#

   2   22 "

  22     

2 "      22   , 

 3 0 , 0" =-;

# 22  &, 

02  

  0   

02 (  (, '

  22 ,"

2  , " , ,/ 

  !" #" $   #    

"  )  12.  3  & #

"0 4  5$6 ' #  0 4  5)# 

6)! &7)    #      #

"  5   '  , (  

(  #    '    ,!  4     #   5   ", (8  

 ) $ ! ( &   3 % 9') )  #   

"       #   #

"  '

 "      "

    " #

:;$( $ 

  

 !  

  !% &$ # '

 &$   #  #

" 



  #         "  

  3  # , < #  42##

"" ,! 4  56 9 #  #  6)! " ,!  4  56 

       % 9  $ 

 # 

"  # #

"'   "     

    $ 

" 

 

  !&'$&( &'!

> #  12.#

"  #   

"       #   #

"  '

 "      <

    

  % 9

" " ' #

: ;$(#)  & 9

   $ 

 



' - 5!

? 22 ,"

 , / .( & )'  '*!



&*(+  (  8    *      <       0 5

= 7<&<<&> ' 0 >

3

  ? !5>5 @ ' < 6

= 7<&   "<9!" )

' *   ' , ( $   

, 8 $

"3 ) &= 

8 &8( &= 

 9 6

=     "!"  $

"  3 )   = 

  8 &  8(  = 

)

' *   ' , ( $    , 8  '

% &$ # '

 &$ ',$ & *(+-  ,!

4  5 6 #A7 7B#0CC5>#D    

) "



":  E 3 "E (8 <CC9) FDC" ' 3

 8  $    3, (8 

 E  (8 

 (8   ,!4      9D>

3

0 !:4   07&3 <G#&#

"  9 >        5 

     8   :  ,   8   )

  +  

$ "    )   )   

"      

  ,!4  56 

"0

0  4    3<G#&#

">  5  )

$     & '  &  &  $

  

 ' (  

   >        :$       )( "  >5+= 

9&9<&99   "C9!"

;

"3 ) &= 

8 &8( &= 

)

' 

   $  >  '  

   

   

'H

$ ), (8 ) 3  8 &3 , 8 :3 , ()

  $'

35, 

" C9!" 

'

" ' +

"

 >   8 &3 , 8 :, (8 )

$       , (8   "    

 '

"    

  >  35,  )

 '     = 

>    '$)

'

$   

) E  4 &&&G H    , (   3!A6'  ) HD  :

)$             "         7       )

 '   '

    < .$'      3

   8       "    

'    4(   >(   H       :  ,   4+& %$  :  3   A         H  ' :   '  )

'' '   8 :, (8  >, (8   ") ):)  )

 

   0 73<G# ) '     

   4      " = 

5+ , (8 

 )

"$

      8  :, 8       8 :  ,  )

  $ 

    0 I'

  # &  5 &     "       , (

: 

 )

      

     "$ "

"        

)

 

  )

     

 

  



)

$    3<G# $ "   >       B  ! (6( 7&C& ) ( :C)

 8 :, 8 :6( ), (:

(  >    )

  

              

 >        

'

" 

  

"     ' "                

     $         $  

              

 &  

     '$)            (

   

 

"           )    >       )

 ' 

   *    

' 0 I'

# #

" 7$         # 2 

 

 8  @       " ""  )    

 &      &       )

 '     '  9

 '        !5>5     @ '  ) 

'  ' <       )

'  '   8 ) - %!

- 

  22 2  ,  &  (

%

#  2   ,"

/ .   *& % &$ /& %' ' $  

 &$ 0/& % &$  / $  1232) '456& +'&

.$     )  

     

 

         $  '



  ) ") 

 "

 '  

     1H5.

(' ' 





     1H5

  ) 



)   



 ) 

' '

    . 

() 

$(  )  "$      , (  8     

"        = 

  . 

())



 "

 

  *    

     " "    

 3 *   

" = 

.

       $   "  "                 &  3  <G#& #

"  

         

    4      " '    "$   . 

   

       %

 9- @!

02 '

4 2 

 ,"

/ .   *& " 7$'$  /& % $  

" $ (/& " $   '

 *  1232) '456& +'&

.  $           )  



  

     

 

      

 $' 

  ) ") 

 "

 ' 

    1H5.

('  '  



     1H5



 )  

)   



 )

 '  '

            , (  8   

 <  0 4  3  $ 

 #

#

 .3;$(#

     ' ) "  &   



    "  .

  "   

   "   

  : ) 

   

        %

 9- $!

0 2 (  (, '

 ,"

/ .   *

&'$&$ &'!0/& 89"

&$ &'!  /  6:36:2  ++'  +'  $ &    $ &

A  $           )  



  

     

 

       $' 

  ) ") 

 "

 '  

    1H5

(' '   



     1H5

  A

 

)   



 A 

' '

    A )

  "   

   "   

7:A

            

          %

 9-

#!

A     &2 22   

 3

 22      15.%   B2 

 0  (  (, '

'

"  2    

 





&  22   (  (, '

"      ' 

##5     

" 02 '

2 (  (, ' 2  

,

 "

     2

'

"   

   

'

 2    

#

   22

2 "  

<"

(  (, '

'



2 &  A  



"

2 

& , 22   " 

  -

.

 .

./  , 0

((  " 22  2    

& "

C  D  E

 "2 2   #5 #1 #

        2

!

A    &2 

  2   #5 #1 #

   2



  (2 '

F 

, *  "



   "

  E F

 )+ A 0  

 .

(  (, '

,"'

2   &   

  2 

  , "  



 "         "  

  

 (  (, '  22  D    ,     " 2  2  ,  " 22 

#

  '

, 

2 (

%

#

2&

"

 , 



!

A   &2

  '

 (  (, '

, 

"

& D 

   &   

  "

   ""

"

 " 

   22  

# 0    0

22    

 ,   ,     2 @  B 2  

%

#  2 "

2 '

&2

.)+ '

  

/  >           ) "G 

  7<           

       

  " 



 ' 5   7:"    5      "    

   )  5   

 ' "   ), ) " 

7<  )

( '   $ "

  '   ( " 



)    " "G )&"

G )&G )

G )

5    "



   '  5       ) "



             



 7

    

 

  5    &         5 &  5  

'

(  &

  & 

 & & 

  

     5    )        

 

   <$    5    7  :    



  

 )  '

       85,  35,   $    & )  

"'   *     "  

   =   7  :  < )    $ "     ) 

) $ $ 

5  7:$ "



"  

 $ " $

   *    2)   

"$ '  

 5  7'  ) 

-

.!

A    &2

" 2

"'

  , 2  ,   , E2 

2 "

    2

 , 2< 

 22 G

 " 2  ,

 22 6  2 D   2  "

"2E22 F  

"

"

  ""

2'

2      </ /<  "//

2 </ /< 

"



       6   '

 & 

"



 4

9!

A   &2 2    22 , &'  22

 , 

  " 

,    '

& 

  D & C -

.

 .

(( (   

 

 '

G2 ( 2 

"2  22   &,   , (

'

 4 2

"

&4 

  (  2

 "

'

 '

 22 D



.

((    

"2E22 ,     &    2 , , 2 "



 0      -

.

 ./ (( 

 

 2  '

,"

   G (  '

22 ,   &,   , &

"

2

1!

A    &2 (  D

'

 4 2 , D 2"

2 2 &    2 2 (    G ,  

"  '

   '

42    &

 (    G ( & ,

  22  

,   22  G ,

42    &





'

, 2 A 

    ('    9

 

 &   %9 ;&'$+&

<2::4 ;<224:

  D

5!

A    2 < 22 2"

  '

G & 2 (  22

  ,   -

.

 .

./ ((  

      22  &    2 

2 ,

  

 -

.

 ./ (( F'

"

&'= +&9

+ '7$'

;

 < &'$+&

132>;1<? @A3

'9

7 &9    &'  1321;1< 

 ;9<  A51    2 < 

  

 ,      -

.

 ./ ((  ( &"

 

 G

"

  22 '

,"

 

%!

A    &2 22 

" 2'

2 &,   '    & 2  '  2

'

2   

   

 7  &'

9

%$ !%') '

*     &'

 2:B>A3B  

 &

 A  

 &2  '   2"

 G

 ,

"



   



,  2"  & 

'

'  ,

"

 ' 

 

 

@!

A    &2   < 2 0

.

 

;  

0 (< 

##%

G '

  ,  ( 2"    '

2 0

.

  

 "

  

  2  , "  



   22 ' 



2 ,   2



&,  , 2 '

  (  D "

 

2

'  

,     0

.

&  

$!

A   '"

 ?'  '  

 &'

9

  *'!  &'

132@;2<

;9< @34

$

)& '$%(&* $

);

'

<

   &'9

'' '!& +'&  &'

132@ ;5<

;9<>5>

  0 .

 "

  

 ,  '

"  

& F'

"

  

0

%  , 4  (      

  

"

 2 " 2 2 D

"

 / "

 & 

  

;  

0 (< 

##% , G

,  (

  2"

  '

 

    &

,

G '

 ( 2" 

#!

-       

&2 (  (, '

 " '

22 ,   " 2     D 22 

A     

 

'

2   B

 '

,  '  

"

2  ,

&

  

,  

  '

 5 1   

       , 2  A    &2 2  "

"

E.   B2  B

02

, 2 ,

 (  (, '

  

'2

 5 1  

,    ( "

 A  

 &2 (  (, '

 

'

2 

"



"  2 &'  22

!

A   "

+!"   &'9

7 ?'" &;%< !

  &'

133A;4<

;9<>32    

  G "

  "

 2 , 

 2  & 2'

   

 2'

 

  "

6  &  2 

'

 " 22 22   "

2 '

" &, 

  ( ,  <

G '

 2"

2  '



 "2

   "  

,  



"

 



!

A    

 &2 "

  2  "

2 "

   22 G   



   2 B" ( (-(

.9%

# 22  

#

#

4"2

  

#

# ,  

   #5

#

   

"

   ,     ,  

," 

  2'

, 22

  2  2 '

2

, ,  

 '

, ,  & (2 '

F  , '

 "

 

.!

  &2      

9!

"

     2     

 



 & , , 02 '

2   *   



(  (, '



 & , ,

G2

E.  B2  22

  

02

 &  ( "

"



  F6 

?

   & 2 ,

G2 = 

 5#.E

2 "

.

'" &   '

  

   * 

G2 = 

 5#

2 "

# % '"   & 

G2  "

* * 





 F

 )+ A    *  F

  

  ' 

#  & 22  B,

"

  '

   22      22 &,  '"

 , 4'

 "

, , "

'

 

* F

 )+ A  "



B B2 

'

0 .1/( ( "

   '

"

   '

 '

, "

(2 '

"

 , 2'"

,   

   , B

  

, 

   '

 

2  

 , ,   

 22 , 



 



"

 

 2 &2"



"

  &   / 2  22   0 , '

 , '

&  ,   

#9 #  ,  '

#  0 .1/( ( "

  2 

 

 5 1      4

   ,  2 '



"         ,  

'



2  (

"

 

 2'

'

    2 '2

 5 1    

1!

  4 &   D&   

"

   3

  2  2

 22 ,  '

2 ,

2

 , "  6 

"

  

  " " 2   ,  H"

,   &,  

"

    & 

"

  

"



 '

 &



5!

; "

   (  

'

  2 -

.

 .

((    22 ,"

/ A $)      ')    

    $    &        



   

 &'   )        

 

'

 '     $      

    

 1H#G-

%!

='  ( , "



  2

22  =D (/

-  2  '

  , 2 22  ( G '

 , "

 " 22 G ;   2 , "

22 D &  , , G '

2  ( '

"

2  G (   '



"2E22   &,   , &

"

2 0

 

 2  

"

,    -

.

 ./ ((   2'

  &  D 

 

 -

.

 ./ (( 

 

G  '

,"

 

 &'

 

;  

0 (< 

##% 2 0

.

,  ( , 

  & 

@!

0 2"  &  4'

  '     ( G  2    & "

'

  ( &"

     , "

 " 22 G

$!

0 (  2 ,  -

.

 ./ (( 

,  (   '

'

 2"

 



   0

.

 

;  

0 (< 

##% '

G 2  (  (, '

D

G2 '

, "    ' 

##5 

 G "   (   "

'

2&'

'

 2   (

  "

, 

 2 , 

  2 '



  2 ,

2 , " 

.#!

3 ,

  &     2   ( 

 

 



  , , &"



'

2    &

.

!

"

&  &   

 2  2  &  (

  

  6    

2&



# %

/ - 01 ,(  ; 

"E  IE ;  & IE