High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7769/2014dismissed

Ujjwal Sahrawat Through Gpa Tammanna R. Sahrawat v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-07-16Mr. Justice Krishna Murari8 pages

!"##$%&%'()*+,-

../!*0!12!/!""12)31 !44!''! 0!12!/!" 5 #"%"%'#2 6& 0"!"#!2+!'!!'7"1#2& 5 #&8'7#'"& ( 9: 00 ;;

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

"1#/'#2!'7*!'7*!7+&18& "@+>%2")#!2#3%&"#2#7B%** 0)'#12%#>%!'71!7@##'8!+%'32#'"%'"1#@!'=!$$)'"8#"%"%'#2!"

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

2"%#&,"1# #'"'"2**#21!7 2!4#7%&&)#2#3!27%'32#*!"%'&1%8*!'7*27!'7"#'!'"@#"/##'"1# 8#"%"%'#2 !'7 2#&8'7#'"& !'7 &&)# " "1# ##$" "1!" /1#"1#2 "1# "#'!'"&/#2#*%!@*#2#.#$"4#'"'"1#32)'7'';8!

#'" '"2**#2 1#*7 "1!" "1# 8#"%"%'#2 /!& '" !@*# " #&"!@*%&1 "1# /'#2&1%8"1#828#2"+%'7%&8)"#'"1#@!&%&"1#B%**!'71!7!%*#7 "#&"!@*%&1"1!"&1#/!&#A$*)&%>#*!'7*!7+"1#&18&%'7%&8)"# '7#2 %&&)#%"/!&1#*7"1!"2#'"!4)'"1!7!*2#!7+@##'7#8&%"#7%'"1#

@!'=!$$)'"0)'#12%#>%!'7$'&#C)#'"*+,"1##.#$"4#'"8#"%"%'/!& 7%&4%&&#7 1#8#"%"%'#2%*#7!'!88#!*@#2#"1#88#**!"#)"12%"+,

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

2'#+'@#1!* 1#2 4"1#2!'7*!"#2 '&1# #A#$)"#7 !8/#2 !""2'#+ %' "1#'!4# !44!''0!12!/!"1#8#2!"%>#8!2""1#.)734#'""1#88#**!"# )2"2#!7&!&**/&(; F&8#24+&#C)#*7%&$)&&%'%"1!&$4#'"1# 2#$27 "1!" "1# B%** 1!& @##' #A#$)"#7 @+ & 0)'#12% #>%%'!>)2!88#**!'"!'742#&!"#2"1#7#!"1 0)'1#2% #>% !88#**!'" 1!& @#$4# $;/'#2 C)! 1#2 &1!2# @#%'3 '# "1# *#3!* 1#%2& 7#$#!&#7 0)'1#2% #>% /%"1 2#3!27 " 828#2"+ %' C)#&"%' ' $!

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

&%& "1# B%** %' C)#&"%'G 0!2!&"1#%'7%'3'%&&)#%&$'$#2'#7,%"/!&1#*7"1!" "#'!'"&/#2#'"*%!@*#"@##.#$"#7'"1#32)'7'';8!+4#'"2#'" !& "1# 2#'" &"7 !*2#!7+ 7#8&%"#7 %' "1# @!'= 88#!* /!& "1)& 8!2"*+ !$$#8"#71)31"1#!88#!*1!7@##'8!2"*+!$$#8"#71*7%'3"1#8#"%"%'#2 "@#$;*!'7*27/%"1"1#"1#21#%2&0)'#12%#>%&)@.#$"""1#%'!* 7#$%&%'"1#B%**7!"#7)'#,?,@+"1#%>%*)2"%'!$%>%*&)%" 8#'7%'3@#"/##'"1#8!2"%#&,+#""1#2#C)#&"2#.#$"4#'""#'!'"

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

@)%*7%'3 2 2#'"!**!'7@+%"&"#'!'",#A$#8"/%"1"1#/2%""#'$'&#'" "1#*!'7*27,28#2&'"/14"1#$**#$"%'2#'" 2##&%'!8)@*%$4!2=#",$!2";&"!'72&*!)31"#2;1)&# 22#'"&2&1%8&1!&@##'2!4#7)",2*#!&#7@+! 4)'%$%8!*"/'2'"%%#7!2#!$44%""##G 1#2#&8'7#'"&1!>#>!$!"#7"1#@)%*7%'3%'7%&8)"#!&&)$1 "1#+ !2# '" $'"%')%'3 %' 8&&#&&%' !& &)$1 "1#+ !*&7 '" !** %' "1# 7#%'%"%'#A$*)&%>#"#'!'""1#8#"%"%'#2!

%'"#2#2#'$#%'"1#27#28!&&#7@+"1#*/#288#**!"#)2"7#$*!2%'3"1# 8#"%"%'#2"@#"1#$;*!'7*27/%"1"1#21#%2&0)'#12%#>%,"%"*#@#%'3 )'7#27%&8)"# 1# 8#"%"%' %& 7%&4%&&#7 @&#2>%'3 "1!" "1# &"!")& "1# 8#"%"%'#2/%**@#!$;*!'7*27,/%"1)"#A82#&&%'!'+8%'%'2#3!27%'3 1#2"%"*#'"1#@!&%&"1#B%**/1%$1%&"@#7#"#24%'#7@+"1#%>%*)2" /1#2#"1#*%"%3!"%'@#"/##'"1#1#%2&0)'#12%#>%2#3!27%'3/'#2&1%8 "1#&18&%'7%&8)"#%&8#'7%'3 "1%'3 &!%7 %' "1%& 27#2 /%** 82#.)7%$# "1# 2%31"& "1# 8#"%"%'#22"1#"1#21#%2&%'"1#$%>%**%"%3!"%'/1%$1%&8#'7%'3@#2#"1# %>%*)2" )*+,- 0 &!'.!+