← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8083/2015allowed

Madan Lal v. Umar Mohammad @ Rama & ORS

2019-11-16Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal3 pages



       

   !"#!$%&%'( )

* +#',-   ! % %'!          .  

/+0//#1 / '# 0!&  !&2'#!' & +(  3,+   4,

!&!' ( +0'45/6#7$ !6" 0!2! % %'! + 8!&00 %6#7$ !6" 0!!&2'#!' &  9999999  4,6:

,;

0!2!&!' 2! % %'%&#%!$ !#<%'&  0!#!# !#

2&&!#=> 0!%7%-5#<!:5'%%7%&%';6 -?-:"&0 6 0!%-5 ;6 #%&/%&&%'<'22-%$ %'"%-!#=> 0!2! % %'!5'#! #!) 5-! !#?% 0 !$ %'

  05<0?0%$00!0#&5<0 /!'#/!' %'0%&2-%'  %'$-5#! 0!!%'$0--!'<!  ?&-!#!!#&# !# '#

!@!$5 !#%'

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

&'&&#!"!'#' & C0!&%#22-%$ %'?&--?!#=> 0!%-5

EF '

' 0!>! C 0!2! % %'!$/! 8'? 0 7%#!&-!#!!# # !#     '!  "  0!  &'&  "  !&2'#!'     '/!->  =%=  40'

:!&2'#!' ;0#&-#2 " 0!&5% 22! > '!0 %!7%?0!!& 05<0&-!#!!## !#

 0! 0!&'"!&2'#!'  '/!->&0 +0/#:!&2'#!' C;0#&-#2 " 0!&5% 22! > / 4!- 0!!"!6  %'  0!  -%<0  "  0!&!  &5=&!A5!' !7!' &  0!  2! % %'!  "%-!#  ' 0! 22-%$ %'5'#! #!  5-!   05<0?0%$00!&5<0  %/2-!# 0!

"!&%# /  0 %!7% '# / 4!- & #!"!'#' &    '# )  5$0 22-%$ %'"0%&?&--?!#=> 0!%-5 ' * C?% 0#%!$ %'  0!2! % %'! "%-!0%&/!'#!#2-%' => C$$#%'<->6' 0!2! % %'!"%-!#0%&/!'#!#2-%' %'?0%$07!/!' &?% 0!<# $0--!'<!  0!"!&%# ?&-!#!!#&?!!/#!=>0%/?!7!6&%'$!'"/-2>! 0#=!!'/#!=> 0!2! % %'!"&! %'<&%#!" 0!"!&%# ?&-!#!!#&6 ' 0!22-%$ %'?&"%-!#=>0%/5'#! #!) 5-! !#?% 0!$ %'

 /!'#0%&2-%'  %'$-5#! 0!!%' 0!"!&%#2>!0!%-5 05<0 0!%/25<'!##!# !#

#%&/%&&!#&5$022-%$ %'" 0!

2! % %'!2%/%->' 0!<5'# 0  0!2! % %'!3&&5% ?&  0!"<!'#'# 0! 2>!&5<0  =!/#!'?&05-#07!=!!'/#!=>0%/!-%! ,!'!#$5'&!-" 0!2 %!&07!=!!'0!# G0%-! 0!2! % %'!3&&5% "&2!$%"%$2!"/'$!"<!!/!'  &!-- # !# C  6--!<!#->!' !!#%' =! ?!!'0%/'#!&2'#!'  ?& 2!'#%'<6!&2'#!' &'#C6 05<0 ?&!2 !&-!#!!#&# !#  '#  

6  &-#  2  "  0!  &5%  22! >    !&2'#!' &     '#  ) !&2!$ %7!-> ' 0!022!'%'<" 0!&!!7!' &6 0!2! % %'!"%-!#'22-%$ %' 5'#! #!  5-!  &!!8%'< 0!!%'%/2-!#/!' "!&2'#!' & '# )6?0%$0?&--?!#=> 0!%-5 ' * C G0%-!--?%'<&5$0 2>!/#!=> 0!2! % %'! 0!%-5 #%!$ !# 0!2! % %'! "%-!'

E F /!'#!#2-%' ?0%$0?&#'!=> 0!2! % %'!?% 0%' 0!-- !# %/!' 0! /!'#!#2-%' 6 0!2! % %'!/#!&2!$%"%$7!/!' &?% 0!<# 0%&$0--!'<!  0!"!&%#&-!#!!#&5$0#!" 0!%-5 ?&' $0--!'<!#=>'> " 0!!&2'#!' &'# 0!!"!6 0!&/! %'!#"%'-% > '$! 0!2! % %'!?&2!/% !# %/2-!#!&2'#!' & '#) ' 0!<5'# 0 #5%'< 0!2!'#!'$>" 0!2! % %'!3&&5% 6 05<0 ?&!2 ! &-!#!!#&# !# '#

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

   ' 0!-%<0 " 0!=7!=&!7 %'&6 0!%/25<'!##!%&&! &%#! '# 0!2! % %'%&--?!# !!#-!&& ## 0  0!%-5 &0--#!$%#! 0!2! % %'!3&&5% ' 0!=&%&"% &/!% &'#!7%#!'$!=!"!% '#&0--=!5'%'"-5!'$!#=> 0! =&!7 %'&/#!=> 0%&5 %' 0%&#!

)

* E 4,F &0/&0!    G0! 0!&2!8%'<D!&'!# ( !&D G0! 0!!2 =-!

(!&D