← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1510/2004dismissed

Baljinder Singh v. State Ofpb.

2025-05-27Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti19 pages



       

  



 !

" "



 # $

 !

%""



&'()

) *+



 ,&, - # (&.



/! 0 1 /"

 / 

 

       

  

  !  

  

  !  #$ % & ''''' /  " 



 % #" "     #  %#

   " 

   )*+,**-   &.       /# 0 1        & #2-34(,**5(67  8

 % #  9 6:24 3*+,**,

5*- -43-3-4,*  " : # 

  7 7

  

 

  

&3 -

-- $ 4  , $ ) 

-&#', - -) 

& 5& , ,+ - )$, %

# 5*- ": #    

,***( 6

#    



 .

, ,    "

 "    3*+,**, : !

  !  #   ""    

"  # 

 

 #:



  

# "

# 

 #;



 :!

 !

# 

 # 3*+,**,  #  "< !     < !  ""

 #

"  & !       & *4** .  " & !  ."   # "  ; .

 .  %

#0& " & !  1 7  #0"

  " & !  1        # 



#   <  !   0    " & !  1   #   "   &  #    / #  !   0    "

& !  1 # " #   % !  0    " & !  1 # " "

 & "  

#

# =    &. 0  

>" .1 

  . 

  & !  & " ; 0  

1

    &  !      "  &   <  

1"

"< !     < ! 

 

  #   " .& 7  "

.   #    



 

.  : !

 !  . 

 

  :

 "

 

 &.  

   &  !   0

   1 

 % # ,**3,*** . # 

  . <     " 

   ? 

5 & #   & 

 # . # @****(

 

 < <  

.

&  . #

 ;  #   .6:  # 

5*-   

-3-4": 5 A # 

 #   B    #  

  &. " 

   

  <  # "  

 C 

 #     "   " 

      # 

.

  <  <           

  

  

 

"

 

) A #

 # ""



 -43  ,*  " :     "



 #

   

5*- -43-3-4

,* ": 6 



+5   

&

&"  : B  #

 - 

    ."   

   

,*+" 

""



5*-  " :   C  .

 & &.  

  "  

& A   /    #

 7  7



 

 "    /#   "

    

   )*4,**, @ D      /# 0 1   "

#

 "

 #  # 

 % #  % !  < !  / # !  7  #

-55*,(-4":   



5*- ":     C       # #   .

-   #  

  ) :

 "

"   C 

#  ; <  !    ;,  % #  ;5 A  !  # = < 7 7

 ;-/# #  ;@<  # ;) % # ;+  "

  ;3 : # ;4  # ; * :!

 !  ; #  # ;,< #  ;5   #  ;- 7  "

     &   "

  

 +

" 

   

55   &.

  

  .   

 "  



 "

C  

 .< # A;  # A;, 3 "

 #

 

&.  &    "

    

   

   . / #  !   7  #  %  !  < !   B

" #"

 #  ;  

 % # #



5*-  ": %#

 "

 )*+,**- 

"

 &    &.       /# 0 1   6 # ##   "  %#

  

 

 % #" 

   4 D "  

# %#

 "



"

  

 " D

 

 "      

@   #   

    %#

  

  

&.    # # "  &  

#  . 

 % #   "  # . " ""



5*- ":  

 B

"  #"

 #  :

    "  C  .  

 

    #    #  

E     

 #   

.

 .

# # 

       #   "  . D

  

        "  

#; & "

 < !  ;,  ""  

  

 " .& "

    D  "  

"

 C 

# ;    "

    

#    EC      # 

 

 &C      

     &  #  &.

  



 .< !  ;, 

"

  

 # # **-,**,7 "    "& 



& ".   :



    #. & &





 &D

  

  "    

 #  "  

     #. & " 7   "    

   

 &.

  

# #"

 #   

  #  

   "

-5":

5*,  

-4":     "

 & 

)  "  # 

# ." ""



5*-  " : 7    #    &    &"   



 &%

 .

" "  .:

 " 

  

 

   

  "  

.

  "

 #

 

   #   @****(    &. 

.

 :

  

   C 

  " " # ;     #. #   @****(  7  # "

 " 

   ,+*5,**,

 "

  .# &.

 

D

 "  

   C    # A;,    

  @*-,**,ECA # #

 "< <    

.

 "7  # 

.

 

 &.  # "

    "  < #  #  $   



 $    A;     

 " 7 

#ECA2   . " 

   



# " 2  

 #  

 &. :

 # =""  

.&."

 #&  " 

"



   



   #  "   "     . &  7     &. "    &

   &%

 



   &"      

 "     "  . D

 

# .# & " "&  

"

   

&    #.

 

     " 

 D  "  



+   %#

 " #5 3 # , -

)&

  86& & ) *+

# ,&, - & 7& &9 & # 



         "



"   &

8  



  9    

" #; < !  ;, & " ""



-55*,

  

 -4 " : &  

(&  

 " ""



5*- ":   "

 :

  "

 & #  "  



    .  

   

#   :

  .  & ."  

      

  "

      "

&. 

  . &

    . & B

 " # "

 #   * =      

" % &

#  "

 "   .     &.  

#;& "

<  

&. "< !  ;, # 

  " & !   ." 

  



# .

  

  



 

 

   "   @****(  

  

.

 F 



 # ;  

#  @****(    #  7  #   ,+*5,**, 6      . <  <     

.

 

  @*-,**,A #

 #   

.

     

      #  # ;, 

3

"  #  

 &

@****("

  ,-*5,**, A

C 

  C     



 " #   "  -****( "

   #

****(  . # 

#    

#A  ". 

 &. 

.      

  

 



  3*+,**,  &. 

  #   

 :

 

   

  B

 &. #  & "  " &   



 " # ." ""

  &

5*- ":7   ".

&.    

 

  "&.A !  #;- #  " &.     .  &.  %

# #  ;5   EC EC@ #  EC) EC*7  

       " &.

#   C  :!

 !  ;

 : # ;4  

 #

 &.

"

  D 

     D

  

" % &

  



 .  "  

# #   "  "   

   

  " 

    . " 

 #

  



 #    

    ?  "  .7 " %#

 "

  )*+,**-   &.

  

 B  

 %

# B .

"



4  :  #

 

&. " 

   

" % &  #

#    & 

 

6: #

#& "

   "

3*+,**, EC "

" 

#>  &  !   #  

   % #  

   ,**3,***       

 &.  &     " . "  & # #  . 

    " 

.

 "@****(    "   #  & =  "

3*+,**, #     # "< !     < !   & *4** .

 

  "   % # 7 

# 

# #       "    

    < !  0   1 # " #/ # !  0    1 # " #   % !  0   1 # " "

=    &.  .

  . 

 

      &      ;  # :

 # #="" :!

 !    

 EC(   &  "   6: EC(,   #

5*-   

-3 -4":= 

 #         

 5*-  -43 -3 -4

,* ":   

 

 

=    )*4,**,   

 

  #   

 # 

-55*,  

-4"

* :    

 

 5*-  " : D

  

 % # 

 5*-  " :     

/ # !  7  # % !  < !  

B

 " # "

 #   #  & "  " &  7 "    

 

    

 " 

% #

5*- ": & ."   , :

     

 

    3*+,**,  

6: #   .  . .:

  

"



 "" % #7.# 

 ,**3,***#

  

     .  " 

 # :

      



 

 

 "   "  .   

#

 

  ; :

   

 

    " .

 

 "

 . "

 &. 

  

  :

C   "

 ""

"

 5,*** 



"



" & #   . 

    

.

   "  @****( 

"

C    "

C  .   "

  7  # 

 #  . < "

 C     

 #   **-,**,      



 #  

      )*-,**, "   "

    . 

 "

&  "      " .&  % " ."  

   "  "

  

 

 #"  

# "

  

 % #

  & 

: 

 C 

#      "

    

EC   #  #   = 

#  " "

&  %#

"#5 3 # , -

)&

  8*+ ) *+ 8 # /&+&.

) *+  "9        

":

    

 



   

  &

     2 ,4     8,4:



    





&#    

 &  "

 

"



 7        "

     "  

 :"

  

&

 &

  &.   

   .

 

    :"

     



. #   

  

#   "

 

#"



:

     

 

 "     "  





 # "

&

  ""

"      &   &  # %

  

7 

  &  &

"  



  "  

 :

   .  

    . ""

"   & 

 9 :

#  &%

&. " 

 & ."  #  &

,

"

  



&C ;:

   

  # ""

   &   G  > :

"

# ;  

   

 &

 

   

# ;

# .

 

EC 

  

 # @****( &. 

.

  ; 

  ,+*5,**,   @****(  #"

" 

 .&

&. #

 

  "  &.  #  # ;,  # A;,  

  @*-,**, # #

 "< <    

.

 "7  #"

" 

 D  "  

  C     

.

   

 &.7  #&. #  .   # <

# # $    

$   C   A;   

ECA     " . 

 " < <  

.

E

 "

 



   

         " .   

  

   7   

 " < !   ;,D

 

# .   

" . "



 # **-,**,&  ". " "



   

   "

#     

   :

   

C 

  < !    



 #& #7 "      " .   

&

  # 7  

 

  

 

  

5

 #  "  . 5 7   

 

 "  

        " &. A  !  # =   <  7  7

C    ;-    " A

      

  =   <  7  7

 ECA  # " A  !  #A  % A A A& # #A !  #

=  ;-    

 

 " 

 <

# .

 

  

 4*+,**, *-* # # &.  &

   87   &.   

. &           ? &    &  

 #   & # #  

    

  " & 

 # "C &   %

 # . #

 "

   # . .

 7 "



 %   

 1#   "



. #"

, ,@ 

  ?

. & .



 #

 . "

  "& "  #        "  7 #     . &     . =  

 

.  

 ,1&  & 4C+ 

  

" #   51&  & )C3   " 

""

 



 & ,**

"# " #    . 7    "  "   #  &  



-

#   "" 

  

"

9 7 # " &.  &.  % #  #  C   ;5:

   

    #  "   &.   3*+,**,  &  *,5*    #   EC  EC@ #   EC)  EC* 7 "        "

   

#  - :

 #  " 

  &.       

 "

# 



 

  

.

"   #  "   . B

 " 

 

   &"      

 

  

  .   



= 

#  " "

&  %#

"#5 3 # , -

)&

    

 86&+3)

6&#

&

& ,+

8 # ,&, - # (&.9   ""

 

 5*-  " : " 

      8) 6   &     " # 



 &

  17

  "

5*- :

 

   # 

""

& &  &"  "    &%

 



  " . &17 "      &. .& &. % . 



    

1    

      .  "

    "  

 #

@ 17

 &%

 .  

&. &   " &  1

 .  

&" 

  " . "1:

& & 

  

    &"    #17C  0 &" 1        



 "    

# %   

&        "  &" 

 1 :

 & ?

 

. "C  & # 

"  C  & "  ""

""

" .   "  #  

5 " E



 17 "  C  H &" H  ..

 

   &   & 

 .  

  B 7  & C

"  C  " &  ""

 &   .

 :

   &   

 &.      %1< C  H &" H &#  

 #  " .  "   " 

    &   1

 5*-    C 

 

 "

 %  

 

 :

D 





"

,*"        "

 "

7

 " "

   .  &

  %  

 &  



 

     # 

  "  # "

    "

5*- 

) 1  #"

 #      

&

&  &   

&.    "

  # 

"

5*-   " 17 " # "

&

 " #

  



 &%

  "       #   "  .   

   

 # =

   # 

  " &  . &.  "

 "    &      &   

""

9     

 5  " 7 :

 E



3+,       . 

5 "7 :

E



3+,    8: "

#35,) & ,

;

&,+  ; B       

 . "        &"            & &%

 &.    

 .    

 "    

  . "  . 

  

       .    6  " 

8 . 9      #    

 5*-  "  :

   0-@"3)*19  "

 &     

5 " 7:

E



3+, # # . 

 

 .

 &    7   

   

 " 

     





 

 " 

    

+

55   .

 " ." . 

     

 " " . &  "  " :

 

      .        #

 &.  "   && F  

5 "7:

E



      .

   &  &  &"  "

    &%

   

 "  

   " .7 " 

 

" 

           "       &.

# 7    " % .  &.:





   "  &        @ D "  



. # 

 &

 "

# 

 

 & # &  " 

   & #.

 

 &.

  

  G 

>7

 #

     %#

"86& & ) *+

# ,&, - & 7& &9<#5 &= "   

  &.   "  



 " 

  

 "

 & 

  &    # . & 

       

& 

    # "

 #   

:

"

 

 &

     "

5 "7:

E



3+, :

 #  " "   "

    

  

# .#

 

&  % #

3

5*- ":7 " %#



5*- ":".% "   B .

"

 ) :     "

 &.

  

 :

     

     3*+,**, 

  

 

   )*+,**- < 

       #  *5. "

 

     &   "  # "

  # #  " & ,* .  

    



" 

 

  

 "   "  .  # 

     &. 

#   .  " 

 # 7 " 

 

   

    #      #      

  "

  .  " 



 #

."""



&. 

:

#  " 

   )*+,**-   &.       /# 0 1  B .

"

 

#. C  " 

5*- ":     & #&.   "

5*- ": +  

    "

 &. 

 % # 

#.    "   "



 " 

% #  &. 

 

" 



 

 &"    " /    #

   

"

  ."  #  "/   #

  

"

   

 

 %    #   # 

 2  . 

  & 



"   



4 3  #    

01 " . 

01  "

#. </  =



%""

     ;   #(    I(2 ; 

&  I(2