← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1065/2011dismissed

Mohinder Masih Alias Billu & ANR. v. State Of Punjab

2015-09-16Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik,Mr. Justice S.S. Saron7 pages



     

 !"

$%&'$%())*+%'  ,,)) -'* . */0  ,&         

1%%' ,'')),,'230))4&%/*&526 "0'''&% ,'''6  71%%'%/*&52%*)&0','&%56

' $'-,$%/8&98'%,,)) $'$/'%'*:*)8&&)8 */0     % ,' ,,)  ,'''& 03 $%&' $% ( ))* & 55 $% ( :&*8 0%   %' $% 5 % /*&52  9 & '&'   && "#

 ,& 03 % &&) .*&58*'&,*'84%'030%%,,))4'9&'% ,*%0)*&'.7 "'&4%.7; && *&'52,'2')&,3 # <=%&*)  8 % &*)' %)) *'%' *&'5 '5'* 2,'2 ' > 2%  "!

8 ,*'*  '2  %  % ? .5%   4 .5% '&  :)%,*' % && &*  /*' '9&   5%8 . .4&' .5%8 .5' )54% %' ,)

) '%& 9) ,)8 *'&,*' &5 ''&&%2 )0'.5%4.5%%2@> A8)0'.5%& %%%40'%'*4%%%)&'0'%'?.5%%&0 )9522*')52&22%2%9))5'%) 0*" <"#&3%'$% ?%$%%'*&%%* ',*'%5%)&0* #3'5'%'%*0*" <"

&3 58 %' $%  '&'5'0 %9 )& %' ))&

&&'*52%%30/&*%%'$%&%& )'2& %3&',0)80*%'$%%&'29& % 2%  *  %8  )' ) ? ,) 04 %2 & %'$%*'%'&%3'&3"B 0*B <B

$8%)54%%0'%'?.5%&9&'.5%% .5%84%%'')9845%84%%2&* 0*%%)%%%'?.5%%4&4'%)) *'   ))4& %2 1% ? .5% 4 ' % %*  %' $%8 ' ,) '8 %' $% '2& 4%&58 % ))* $% '2&4%4&&:&*$%'2&4%''&4'&5 '%'%*%228%'$%'&))?'%? .5%%0258*5%%)&%2&)%25)9 %8% ) '& '*)   '*)  4%% % ')9 9&' .5% ) 2 '*5%24%)8:&*$%59''&0)4%0'%'? .

%%&8%3?%2%'%*'''559%)8%3'29& %29'2,)85'84%''>25%0'%'8% ')&%2?%29),)8*'&,*'%''8%& %')99&'.5%%&%0'%'?.5%9),)8 *'&,*'84%'%'&)'&%2&&&%%'$% &%:&*$%&))*$%94%%%'& % 5 5%0' .5% &%0'%' )/ .5%%'9))58 22&2*'&'%0'%'?.5% %0*%28 '*E@> < A4% ).''5' '*& " $ ','*E8 @> <"A4''&&*&'.

7 "8 7;8 " =  ',','5%E*','> 1=B<8..4&'.5% %&&0&3?.5%',2'2>2%''8% '%&%,&,','&%,)> 1=B< %2&38 *& 55 $% ( :&* $% 4 ''& 9& 22 > 1=B< *'5''58%*'&&)*'2@> 1=B< A', )2''& *'**%28%5'9'&% ''&'2%'%?%%%*%''8%95 4%&&9',')?

8*&%'$%&$%&'$% 4'''&*'5''58%'$%&$%&'$%*'& &)*' 2 >  &

  ',  )2  %' ',9 4,  5 & . ',9)3  *'*  *% 28 %' $% & $%&' $% 5 '9'& 5 & . ',9)3'2%&)&,)03,5*%2%,) %,)'9'3> < & < %90,','&%''8

;

2,)'3'2)8','*&'. F7'

4)& 5%'$%8$%&'$%&55$%230&% *&%'$%&&&*'5%,&3')  ,'9  8 % ,'* % >2&  23   44%%)*& 1= )0'.5%G2,)C4%''&% ')' 9' >   % 0  C 1=" 9&' .5%8  3 48 4% *,,'& % ,'*    '3C 1=7 ' .%))84%&*&%,=2'2>2%&&0&3 ?.5%4)) 1=B,'.4&'.5%& 1=!)? /8 4%&,&4%'5'&%95''&*03%2 )) % '25 '*2 ,,'5  % ,'* 9& 4' ,*  % *& $%&' $% & 55 $%  %' 2 ''&& *&' . 7 7 '

  49'8 0% % *& ,)&&)2,)'&'5%'9&''&8% )'&')*'9&&&%,',,))82& 09 ' % *'8 )'& *) ' % ,,)) % 9%2)3 '5*& % % ,'* % 2'0)3 )&  2,) % %'*2'*'&5%%,,)))84%' ',0)'*5&%%&&?.5%'5*&% %'*>,)&&)3 7%*')&55 "!

%*5% %*''&%9?,)"B 0*B <B $   ) '5*& % % ,)  *''   '  % %*  % ,,))&%4,'&584&+''&84%% '5'))39)0)%''8%/*'4%*%4,'4%* 3,'2&&2&&4%*3*&%,,'

#

0*&&5%%*84%'%9' ,*%0)*&'.7 " *0)80*0&0 09',*%0)*&'.7 ;   1%9%'&%)'&*)'%,'2)5%8 0*&&32'%,',,)%','* 0&*,%23 1= )0'.5%8*%' &0'%' %&&8''0'&03 1="9&'.5%84%%&,&% 2)'2'%'2*)&0%'&03%*&% '=>2 1= )0'.5%%59%99&&',% 2'*''8%4))45%0'%'?.5%@&&A .2)'  % 2  1=" 9&' .5%   % ')' 2 @> A8)0'.5%%5'))3&%0*" <" &358%' 4)'04%2&%'$%8%'$%))&

&&'*52%%9)&%''&'5'0% 20*%8%3%&0/&%%'$%&%&) '2& %3&%'',0)80*%'$%%&'29& %2%%'%5''&84%%*)&'&*00*% 9'3%'&4&4%3%3%*)&&,))35% ,,)) %2'%%'&)3)&55 %), %,,))&&'&%,'**'*%*),') 9'@> A5903)0'.5%8%*''%&?,)0* B <B $  "B   ' '95 /*' '2 % *&= ,,))8?.5%G&&))&4.0)&4D5'2% %&?.5%8 1= )0'.5%& 1="9&'.5%)&%2 & ?  %' %*  %''8 ' ''55 9%)8 0%  %2

'29&?.5%')39'2,)85'84%'&' '>25%2'))3)&%2?%29),)8*'&,*' %''8 0%  %2 %& ? .5% G &&  9) ,)8 *'&,*'8 4%' % ' &)'& ? .5% &&   8 %''8 )0'.5%'2&%,)),%))3,' 1=B..4&'.5% G % 955 '8 % '9& ),%))3 '2 '5'&5 ''9)  ? .5%  0* "7  $ @ % 5%A  *'*  *% '28 % '%& 9) ,)8 *'&,*'  0*   $ %''8%''&&%2@> A)0'.5%',*5% &'2> < %&28%%2%'*5%)0' .5%% ).''5' 0*" $ ', *%'28 > <"4'5'&0*

#$% '*28   0 & % %'  &)3  )&55    .*% &)3%,'%2,)0'%'%&&% ,'2'3 '  % 2)3  % 92  ,'9& 2&)  %*5%  %' '=>28 1=  )0' .5% & 1=" 9&' .5%%9&2&%%3%&, ).85'4% 255%%,)&%%3&&'2%,)80* ? .5%8 0'%'  % 2,)8 % '9& '* /*'8 2 20*&%9?

,)','9&522&2&)8 4%%%'2)%*2&*%,'2'3*','9 %)%/*'&&55%,)%''84& &%%'3)&)3)&55 1&%%2  1= )0'.5%80'%'%&&& 1="9&'.5%' %   ')0) & '*4'%3 48 4%% ,' % & & %90'5%)3?

1)&&32'%'5*2%*&& ,'94%*3,'=2&&2&&8%''8%9% ,,)) *&' . 7 "     *0)  % ,,)) 4' ,& 4% &58 4&  & ' '&  %3 %9 59 2*),) 0)4%%&4))%'0&3,'?.5%G&&4 %58 0*  '*)   *5 &% ))3  % &  % ,,))     *&& 5%8 0*    &)  %' 2 ''&&*&'.7 7'

%,'*4%0 *55&%%&%4*=&&&%5'%''8% &*  % ,,)) &  4'' 3 2& '   ,*%0)*&'.7 ;  94%0984&&%%&5''&&03 % )'& ') *' *' '2 3 ))5)3 ' ''5*)'3  % ' 9& % 0 ?  &'  '*'  &5 % % ,'*%0**),'955%*&03& 3'0)&*0 E*)38%,',,)&2& @$

A   @   H A  

 !"

#   -2)