High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8149/2015allowed

Purshotam Kumar v. Kusum (Since Deceased) Through Lrs. Suresh Kumar & ANR

2019-01-31Mr. Justice Arun Palli5 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*

+,'-"!./+.!, #"&"&(#, 0#,'+'

/+'+.'&(%#$#%#!'#$"-,+1-2'!($!("-#, #'3($#("'

) 4 2 5 2 5 ,#'#(") , "+6!+,7 $0%!"#7

,"-#3#"&"&(#, ,5-,#8#67 $0%!"#7

,,#'3($#("(

2 57 ,!6

8"-&'3#"&"&(7"-#3#"&"&(#,%-!66#(1#'"-#,$#,' "-# 6#!,(#$+,"'9#6:98:-&%--#-!'9##(,$#,#$"+($#,1'&.36#%&0&6 &.3,&'(.#(" ,!3#,&$ $!8'(!%%+(" "-# !%""-!"$#'3&"#!( ,$#,-!0&(19##(3!''#$&("-#%&0&6'+&" &6#$98"-#,#'3($#(";36!&("&

&(:-&%-"-#3#"&"&(#,&'"-# &,'"$# #($!("7""-##

#%""-!"'"!"+'<+ :+6$9#.!&("!&(#$98"-#3!,"&#'<+!"-#'+&"6!($%('&'"&(1

7"-#3#"&"&(#,:!' +($"-!0#'6$6!($""-##="#("

'< 8!,$'"-#,# ,.

2#!,(#$%+('#6 ,"-#3#"&"&(#,'+9.&"'"-!"!'!.!""#,

!%" "-#!

,#'!&$ ,$#, :!' 3!''#$ :-#( "-# !336&%!"&( &6#$ 98"-# 3#"&"&(#,+($#,,$#, +6#* "-#:!''"&663#($&(17"-+1-( '3#%& &%<+#,87-#%+6$("$#(8"-!""-#'!&$,$#,:!'3!''#$&("-# 3,#'#(%# -&'%+('#6:-&%-&'!6'90&+' ,.!3#,+'!6 "-#%38

"-#,$#, ((#=+,#; :&"-"-#3#"&"&(7:-#,#&(5-,&52&,:!(&!7

$0%!"#7&''-:("9#3,#'#(" ,"-#3#"&"&(#,7&#,#'3($#("(&( "-#!336&%!"&(+($#,,$#,* +6# ;

-#!

,#'!&$

'<8!,$' 6!($&''"!"#$"-!0#9##('6$ (

7&#!9+">$!8'!

"#,"-#,$#,$!"#$ >

:!'3!''#$ # +,"-#,'+9.&"'"-!"!

"#,"-#!336&%!"&(+($#,,$#, +6# *:!'#0#("+!668!66:#$98"-#!33#66!"#+,"0&$#"-#,$#, ((#=+,# ;7!($!

"#,"-#3#"&"&(#,;$# #($!("(:!'-#!,$(.#,&"'7"-#'+&"

:!' #0#("+!668 $&'.&''#$7 "-+1- !( !33#!6 -!' 9##( &6#$ 98 "-# ,#'3($#(";36!&("&

!1!&('""-!"?+$1.#("!($$#%,## &' %("#("&( "-#,# ,# &' "-!" "-# ,$#, $!"#$ >

-!0&(1.#,1#$:&"-"-#,$#,$&'.&''&(1"-#'+&"7&( !%"(%("#.3"&'

.!$#+"!1!&('""-#3#"&"&(#, #(#="'+9.&"'"-!"&(!(8%!'#:-!"-!'9##('6$98"-# 3#"&"&(#,&'

'<8!,$':-&%-&(!(8%!'#&' !,6#''"-!("-#'-!,#"-!"

:+6$ %.# " "-# ,#'3($#(";36!&("&

7 #0#( & -#, '+&" &' #0#("+!668 $#%,##$("-#,:,$'7&"&'-&'%("#("&("-!"

'<8!,$':+6$9# :&"-&("-#3#"&"&(#,'4:('-!,##0#(& "-#'+&":!'"9#$#%,##$&( !0+, "-#36!&("&

2!'"687-#'+9.&"'"-!""-#3#"&"&(#,&(!(8%!'#$&$("-!0# @(:6#$1# "-#,$#, 4'"!"+'<+49#%!+'##0#(!'"#'"& &#$98"-#6#,@ "-#%+('#6,#3,#'#("&(1-&.9# ,#"-#",&!6+,"("-#$!"#"-!""-# ,$#,:!'3!''#$7"-#,$#,:!'!%"+!668(#0#,%(0#8#$""-#3#"&"&(#, * 2#!,(#$%+('#6 ,,#'3($#("(("-#"-#,-!($'+9.&"'

"-!"#0#("-+1-&"&'("$#(&#$"-!""-#!,#! 6!($'6$&'(68!

* 8!,$'7!($!$.&""#$68"-#,#'3($#("36!&("&

-!''+1-"!A>"-'-!,# > !($B 6!($7:-&%-:+6$!.+(""'6&1-"680#, 6!($7#0#('7"-#3#"&"&(#,-!0&(1$#6&9#,!"#68 6+"#$"-#,$#, "-#",&!6+,"98:-&%-'"!"+'<+:!'"9#.!&("!&(#$7-#$#'(" $#'#,0#!(86#(&#(%8 !0&(1%('&$#,#$"-#.!""#,7"-+1-6#!,(#$%+('#6 ,"-# ,#'3($#("&'!9'6+"#68,&1-""-!""-#3#"&"&(#,7&("-# !%# "-#,$#, $!"#$ >

7 %+6$ (" -!0# !6&#(!"#$ !(8 3!," "-# '+&" 6!($ :-!"'#0#,7"&66'+%-,$#,:!'0!%!"#$7!($&"&'0#,8$&

&%+6" ,"-&'+,"

"9#6&#0#"-!"$#'3&"#"-#,$#,3!''#$&("-#3,#'#(%# -&'%+('#67:&"- "-#3#"&"&(#,!6'-!0&(1 &6#$!(!336&%!"&(+($#,,$#, +6#*

,'#""&(1!'&$#"-##=;3!,"#$#%,###!,6&#,3!''#$!1!&('"-&.7"-!"-#$&$ ("-!0#@(:6#$1# "-#'!&$,$#,7!($"-#,# ,#-#&(!(8%!'#$##.#$ "9#-!0&(1'+%-@(:6#$1#!'-&'%+('#6:!'$+68,#3,#'#("&(1-&.7 8#"7@##3&(1&(0&#:"-# !%""-!""-#!,#! "-#6!($'6$!$.&""#$68:+6$ ("9#.,#"-!(:-!":+6$"-#,:&'# !66""-#3#"&"&(#,'4'-!,##0#(&

"-#'+&" "-#,#'3($#(";36!&("&

&'$#%,##$&(-#, !0+,#0#("+!6687&("-# !33#!6'"!"#$"9#3#($&(17&("-#3&(&( "-&'+,"7!6#(&#("0&#:" '.##="#("%!(9#"!@#(7!',#1!,$'"-#&.3,&'(.#(",$#,#$98"-# 6#!,(#$+,"'9#6: #(%#7@##3&(1&(0&#:"-#!

,#'!&$ !%"'7$#-,'"-# !%""-!"

"-#'+&" "-#,#'3($#(";36!&("&

-!'9##($&'.&''#$7:&"-!(!33#!6'"&66 3#($&(17 9+" 9#%!+'# "-# '+&" 6!($ '6$ :+6$ (" 9# 9#8($ :-!" #0#("+!668:+6$ !66""-#'-!,# "-#3#"&"&(#,7#0#(& "-#'+&" "-# ,#'3($#(";36!&("&

&' $#%,##$ &( -#, !0+,7 "-# 3#"&"&(#, &' &('"#!$

$&,#%"#$ " 3!8 ! '+. '

A; " "-# &'",&%" 2#1!6 5#,0&%#'

+"-,&"87/!,(!6 -+1-&"&'"9#("&%#$"-!"+6# ;

,$#,* "-# $#' (" '3#%& &%!668 3'"+6!"# &.3'&"&( ! &(#7 9+" &" 3'"+6!"#'

!""!%-.#(" 3,3#,"8,%&0&6&.3,&'(.#("7!($!6''!6# '+%-3,3#,"8 "%.3#('!"#"-#&(?+,#$3!,"8("-#3,#'#("%!'#7!'!6,#!$8("&%#$7"-#

'<8!,$' 6!($'6$9#&(1:#66:&"-&("-#'-!,# "-#3#"&"&(#,7"-# 36!&("&

!"6#!'"!""-&''"!1#%!(("9#'"!"#$"-!0#9##(&(?+,#$98'+%- '!6#C9+"-:#0#,7:&"-+"!$+9"7"-#,$#, "-#",&!6%+,"-!'9##( 0&6!"#$7:&"-&"'"&66"9#$#"#,.&(#$!'":-#"-#,"-#3!," "-#'+&"6!($ '6$7:!'3,&.#6!($%.3!,#$",#'" "-#6!($7,:!' "-#'!.#0!6+# ('#<+#("687!""-&''"!1#7&"&'%('&$#,#$!33,3,&!"#"-!""-#! ,#'!&$

&(#9#&.3'#$+3("-#3#"&"&(#, ,0&6!"&( "-#%+,"'4,$#,7:&"- "-#3!8.#(""9#.!$#""-# &'",&%"2#1!65#,0&%#' +"-,&"8 ,$#,#$!%%,$&(168 :#0#,7!'&"-!'("9##($#"#,.&(#$!'":-!""-#0!6+#

"-# '+&" 6!($ &'7 !' -!' 9##( '6$7 "-#,# ,#7 & #0#("+!668 "-# '+&"

,#'3($#("(-#,#&(&'$#%,##$&(-#, !0+,7"-#+,"'$#%,##&(1&"

'-!66,#%,$! &($&(1!'""-#6%!"&( "-#6!($'6$98"-#3#"&"&(#,7 !($& '+%-3!," "-#+(3!,"&"&(#$6!($%('&'"&(1 > !($B &' !-&1-#,0!6+#"-!("-#,#.!&(&(16!($ '7"-#3#"&"&(#,'-!66 9#$&,#%"#$7!'3!," "-#$#%,##"9#&''+#$&( !0+, ,#'3($#("( & '&''+#$7"-!"'-#9#%.3#('!"#$ ,"-#6''%!+'#$"-#,98"-#'!6# .,##=3#('&0#6!($"-!(&'6# ""-#,'-!,#+3('+%-$#%,##9#&(1 3!''#$

5+%-%.3#('!"&('-!66!6'&(%6+$#&("#,#'"!""-#,!"# ("

6#''"-!(D3#,!((+. ,."-#$!"# '!6# "-#6!($98"-#3#"&"&(#,7 "&66"-#$!"# 3!8.#("98-&. '+%-%.3#('!"&( !0&(1'!&$"-!"7&"&'.!$#!9'6+"#68%6#!,"-!""-&'+,"-!' (".!$#!(89'#,0!"&(:-!"'#0#,:&"-,#1!,$""-#.#,&"' "-#%!'#

,,!1!&('"#&"-#,3!,"87&#!',#1!,$':-#"-#,,#'3($#("(;36!&("&

&'#("&"6#$"!(83!," "-#'+&"6!($,("7:-&%-(!"+,!668:+6$9#1(# &("98"-#6#!,(#$!33#66!"#+,":-668("-#.#,&"' "-##0&$#(%# 9# ,#"-#6#!,(#$",&!6+,"!($"-!"+," E&"-"-#!

,#'!&$9'#,0!"&('7"-&'3#"&"&(&'!66:#$""-# !

,#'!&$#="#("7:&"-"-#&.3,&'(.#(" "-#3#"&"&(#,7!',$#,#$0&$#"-# &.3+1(#$,$#,7'#"!'&$#7!($! &(# '

A;&('"#!$&.3'#$( -&. *

3@A$&(#'- E-#"-#,'3#!@&(1A,#!'(#$ #'A E-#"-#,#3,"!96# #'A