High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/85/2013allowed

Amar Singh v. Lakhvir Singh

2015-12-24Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan8 pages

!"# $#%&'&() *

+!,-&(./ #0&'&(&'"

1#,'2'

3!4/0&,-&(./ #'5($#("

) 6 3 -73- ,#'#(") ,-2(&8/!$/!9-#(&, $0%!"#9:&"/9 '!80&-&(./9 $0%!"#9 ,"/#,#0&'&(&'" ,28;!,/$9 $0%!"#9 ,,#'5($#("

</#"/#,"/##5,"#,' 8%!8(#:'5!5#,+!=># !88:#$"'##"/#?2$.+#("@

>#,# #,,#$""/##5,"#,,("

</#"/#,"/#?2$.+#("'/28$>#,#5,"#$&("/#$&.#'"@ 73-9 +52.(#$ &( "/# 5,#'#(" ,#0&'&( &' "/# ,$#, $!"#$

((#B2,# 9 5!''#$ >= "/# 8#!,(#$ &0&8 2$.# 2(&, &0&'&(9 7/!((!9 :/#,#>= !( !558&%!"&( &8#$ 2($#, -#%"&(,#!$:&"/-#%"&( * "/#3&+&"!"&( %" ,%($(!"&( $#8!=&( &8&(."/#!558&%!"&(2($#,,$#,C28#

, '#""&(. !'&$##B5!,"#?2$.+#("!($$#%,##$!"#$D EEA:!'

$&'+&''#$>#&(."&+#$>!,,#$ 8'&+52.(#$&'"/#,$#,$!"#$

9 5!''#$ >= "/# 8#!,(#$ $$&"&(!8 &'",&%" 2$.#9 32$/&!(!9 :/#,#>= "/# !55#!8 !.!&('" "/# '!&$ ,$#, :!' !8' $&'+&''#$ ($&'52"#$8=9!'2&" ,5''#''&(>=:!= '5#%& &% 5#, ,+!(%# 8!($+#!'2,&(.E4!(!8'E+!,8!'9'&"2!"#$:&"/&( "/# ,#0#(2# #'"!"# 0&88!.# !""!(/#,&9 #/'&8 7/!((!9 &'",&%" 32$/&!(!9:!' &8#$!.!&('""/#5,#'#(",#0&'&(&'"&("/#2," "/# "/#( $$&"&(!8-#(&,-2> 2$.#97/!((! ":!'!0#,,#$&("/# '!&$'2&""/!"$# #($!(",#0&'&(&'"/#,#&(/!$!.,##$"'#88"/# '!&$8!($""/#58!&("& ,#'5($#("/#,#&( ,'D

D90&$# !.,##+#(" " '#88 $!"#$ *A EE /# '!8# $##$ :!' " ># #B#%2"#$(,># ,# A EE ":!' 2,"/#,%8!&+#$"/!""/#'!8# $##$:!'("#B#%2"#$>="/#$# #($!(",#0&'&(&'""!8'%+#' 2" ,+ "/# 5#,2'!8 "/# 8:#, 2," &8# "/!" "/# $# #($!(",#0&'&(&'"&("/#'!&$'2&"&''"!"#$"/!0#>##('#,0#$ "/,2./ ,#.&'"#,#$ 8#""#,9 >2" /# $&$ (" !55#!, !($ :!' 5,%##$#$!.!&('"#B5!,"#( * EE %%,$&(.8=9!(#B5!,"# ?2$.+#(" !($ $#%,## :!' 5!''#$ ( D EEA /# 5,#'#("

,#0&'&(&'"9:/:!'$# #($!("&("/#'!&$'2&"9 &8#$!(!558&%!"&( 2($#,,$#,C28#

,#!$:&"/-#%"&( 9 ,'#""&(.!'&$# "/# '!&$ #B5!,"# ?2$.+#(" !($ $#%,## 8(.:&"/ "/# '!&$

!558&%!"&(9!(!558&%!"&(2($#,-#%"&(,#!$:&"/-#%"&( * "/#3&+&"!"&( %" ,%($(!"&( $#8!=:!' &8#$( D EED9 :/&%/:!'$&'+&''#$ "!8'%+#'2""/!""/#8:#,2,"/!$ ,!+#$"/# 88:&(. &''2#' , $&'5'!8 "/# +!&( !558&%!"&( &8#$ 2($#, ,$#,C28#

,#!$:&"/-#%"&( ) </#"/#,"/#,$#,$!"#$D EA&'8&!>8#">#'#"!'&$#@

</#"/#,"/#!558&%!"&(&'("+!&("!&(!>8#@

</#"/#,"/#!558&%!"&(&'"&+#>!,,#$@ * #8&# G /#!558&%!"&( &8#$2($#,,$#,C28#

,#!$:&"/ -#%"&( :!'$&'+&''#$90&$#,$#,$!"#$ D

>="/# "/#( &0&8 2$.# 2(&, &0&'&(9 7/!((! ( "/# !55#!89 "/# 8#!,(#$ $$&"&(!8&'",&%" 2$.# 9!'",!%42,"932$/&!(!9 0&$#,$#,$!"#$

*9'#"!'&$#"/#'!&$,$#,!($$&,#%"#$"/# ",&!82,"" &,'"$#%&$#"/#!558&%!"&( &8#$2($#,-#%"&( "/# 3&+&"!"&( %" !($ "/#,#! "#, $#5#($&(. 25( "/# $#%&'&( !558&%!"&(2($#,-#%"&( 3&+&"!"&( %"9$#%&$#"/#!558&%!"&( 2($#,,$#,C28#

! ,#'/ ":!'&("/&':!=9"/#'!&$ !558&%!"&(:!'$#%&$#$ /!0#/#!,$"/#8#!,(#$%2('#8 ,"/#5!,"&#'!($/!0# !8'%!,# 288=.(#"/,2./"/# &8#!($8:#,2," &8#!':#88 /#8:#,2,"9:/&8#$&'+&''&(."/#!558&%!"&(9+!$# "/# 88:&(.>'#,0!"&(')

* FD

"#,/#!,&(.8#!,(#$%2('#8 ,"/#5!,"&#'9/!0#5#,2'#$ "/# &8#-#%"&( "/#3&+&"!"&( %"5,0&$#' ,%($(!"&( $#8!= , &8&(. !558&%!"&( ,"&%8#

"/# 3&+&"!"&( %"

5,0&$#' ,5#,&$ 8&+&"!"&(

$!=' ,!(!558&%!"&( , .#""&(.'#"!'&$##B5!,"#?2$.+#("!($$#%,## /#,#8#0!(" "&+# ,'"!," 8&+&"!"&(&' ,+"/#$!"# 4(:8#$.# 2"&("/# 5,#'#("%!'#"/#!558&%!"&(:!' &8#$( D EED>2"!558&%!("

/!$!8,#!$=!55#!,#$&("/##B#%2"&( $#%,##$!"#$

EED /#,#&'$#8!=

$!='/#!558&%!("/!'"'/:'2 &%&#(" %!2'# $#8!= #!%/$!=/#!558&%!("/!'"!4#("/#58#!"/!" ! "#,!55#!,&(.(

EED9/#%('28"#$/&'%2('#8!($/&'

%2('#8!$0&'#$/&+".#""/#%#,"& &#$%5&#' "/#?2$.+#("!($ $#%,##!($/#!558&#$ ,"/#'!+#(

D!($.#""/# %#,"& &#$%5= "/#'!+#( *

E/#,# ,#9,#8#0!(""&+# &' *

D9 >2" !558&%!(" /!' " #B58!&( $#8!= #!%/ $!= #8#0!(""&+#:!' ,+$!"# 4(:8#$.#&#

EED0#(& &"&'5,#'2+#$ ,"/#'!4# !,.2+#("'!($& "/#5,0&'&('&' 2($#,-#%"&( "/#3&+&"!"&( %"&'+'"8&>#,!88=&("#,5,#"#$ !($&"&'5,#'2+#$"/!">#&(."/#'&+58#"(5#,'(&""4!>2"

$!='""/#!558&%!(""2($#,'"!($"/#:/8#'%#(!,&:#+!= "!4# EED !' ,#8#0!(" "&+# >2" #0#( ! "#, "/!" %5= :!' 5,#5!,#$(A EED>2""/#!558&%!(".#""/#%#,"& &#$%5=(

* EED/#8!:("/#5&("&'0#,=+2%/%8#!,"/!""/#"&+# ,+"/#!558=&(. ,%#,"& &#$%5="&885,#5!,!"&( "/#%#,"& &#$ %5=&'">##B%82$#$ ,+"/#8&+&"!"&(/#,# ,#9"/#,#8#0!(" "&+#&'A EED /#5,#'#("!558&%!"&( &8#$( D EED&# ! "#, $!='/#8&+&"!"&( , &8&(."/#!558&%!"&(&'

$!=' #+!&(&(. $!='!,#2(#B58!&(#$>="/#!558&%!("/#,# ,#9 5,#'#("!558&%!"&(&'$&'+&''#$G /# &($&(.':#,#25/#8$&(!55#!8 "/"/#2,"'

>#8:/!0#$&'+&''#$"/#!558&%!"&(("/#.,2($"/!""/#5,#'#(" ,#0&'&(&'"/!$!55#!,#$&("/##B#%2"&(5,%##$&(.'(

EED

%%,$&(."/&+,#0&'&(&'"9/&'%2('#8!$0&'#$/&+".#""/# %#,"& &#$%5= ?2$.+#("!($$#%,##"!558= ,'#""&(.!'&$#"/# '!+#/#%#,"& &#$%5=:!'!558&#$( EED9:/&%/:!',#!$= (A EED9>2":!'%88#%"#$( * EED/#!558&%!"&(:!'

&8#$( D EED "/"/#2,"'>#8:/!0#/#8$"/!"#!%/$!= $#8!=/!'">##B58!&(#$9>2""/#'!+#/!'(">##(#B58!&(#$

/#'&.(!"2,#' "/#$# #($!(",#0&'&(&'"(0!,&2'$%2+#("' '/:'"/!"/#!55#!,'">#'#+&8&"#,!"# :9"/#H2#'"&(:28$!,&'#:/#"/#,"/#"#%/(&%!80&#: "/#+!""#,&'">#"!4#(,"/#>,!$#,5,&(%&58# 8!:!($ &("#,#'" ?2'"&%#!,#".#"5,&,&"= 3#!,(#$ %2('#8 , ,#'5($#(" /!' ,#8&#$ 25( "/# !2"/,&"= "/# 5#B2,"&(

EED*&0&8 * "5,#''"/!""/#8!: 8&+&"!"&( '/28$>#!558&#$ #/!'!8',#8&#$25("/#!2"/,&"= "/&' 2,"&(

&0&8* "5,#''"/!"'&(%#"/#$#8!=/!'(">##('!"&' !%",&8= #B58!&(#$9"/#,# ,#9"/#!558&%!"&( ,%($(!"&( $#8!='/28$ (">#!88:#$ ("/#"/#,/!($9"/#8#!,(#$'#(&,%2('#8 ,"/# ,#0&'&(&'"/!',#8&#$25("/#!2"/,&"= "/&'2,"&( !,&'&(.2"

$#%&$#$(

D!($,#8&#$25("/# 88:&(.>'#,0!"&('

+!$#>="/#2,") FE (

&0&8

D-"/#5,&(%&58# 8!:8!&$$:(9:!'

"/!""/#"#,+I'2 &%&#("%!2'#J&(-#%"&( 3&+&"!"&( %"9!($ 28#E ,$#,

9+2'",#%#&0#!8&>#,!8%('",2%"&(9'!' "!$0!(%#'2>'"!("&!8?2'"&%#</#(((#.8&.#(%#,&(!%"&(, :!(" >(! &$#&'&+52"!>8#"!5!,"=%($(!"&( $#8!=&'! ,28#9!($,# 2'!8!(#B%#5"&($2>"9!0!82!>8#,&./"!%%,2#$ ""/#"/#,5!,"=9'/28$(">#8&./"8=$# #!"#$>=%($(&(. $#8!=9&(!,2"&(#+!((#,:#0#,9>="!4&(.!5#$!("&%!($

A /=5#,"#%/(&%!80&#:9#B58!(!"&( 2,(&'/#$9'/28$(">#,#?#%"#$ :/#('"!4#'!,#/&./!($!,.2!>8#5&("'!,#&(080#$/#2,"' /!0#"'",&4#!>!8!(%#</#("/#!55#!8'!,#5#($&(. ,8(. "&+#9"/#5!,"&#'!,#("#B5#%"#$"4##5%('"!(":!"%/ "/# #0#("'/#28# 8&+&"!"&(&'("+#!(""$#'",="/#,&./"'>2" &'"4##5"/#%!2'#!8&0#9 ,'2%/5,#'%,&>#$"&+#!($&'+#!("" '##"/!""/#5!,"&#'$(",#',""$&8!",="!%"&%'(

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

(&(. 28+!((#,:/&%/'2>'#,0#'"/##($' ?2'"&%#9 "/!">#&(."/#8& #52,5'#' ,"/##B&'"#(%# "/#&('"&"2"&( 2,"'2,"'/28$("!$5"!(&(?2'"&%#,&#("#$!55,!%/9&( ,#?#%"&(. "/# !558&%!"&( , %($(!"&( $#8!

! EE-25,#+#2,"

9"/#$#8!= $!='9&( &8&(."/#!55#!8:!'%($(#$9( "/#.,2($9"/!""/#'!+#/!$>##(%!2'#$$2#""/# !&82,# !(

$0%!"#9"&( ,+"/#!55#88!("9!':#88!' !&82,#""!4#!%"&(

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

:/#("/#2,"%($(#'"/#$#8!=9$2#"8!%/#'9("/#5!," "/#!558&%!("9&"'/!88%+5#('!"#"/#55'&"#5!,"=9 ,&"'8''G /#8#!,(#$'#(&,%2('#8 ,"/#,#0&'&(&'"/!' 2,"/#, !,.2#$"/!"&("/#+!&(%!'#9"/##B5!,"#5,%##$&(.'("/#>!'&' '#,0&%# "/,2./ ,#.&'"#,#$ 8#""#, !,# (" !%%#5"!>8# !($ ( !""#+5"/!'>##(+!$#"# #%"5#,'(!8'#,0&%# :#0#,9"/!"

D H2#'"&(&'("&(&''2#># ,#"/&'2," $+&""#$8=9"/#$# #($!("

&'!'#+&8&"#,!"# #!55#!,#$&("/##B#%2"&(5,%##$&(.'(

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

&($#8!="/!'>##( 2,"/#,%("#($#$"/!""/#(8=8!($+#!'2,&(. E4!(!8'E+!,8!'9:(#$>="/#5,#'#(",#0&'&(&'"9&'!88#.#$" /!0#>##('8$"/,2./"/#!.,##+#(""'#88$!"#$ *A EE /# ,#0&'&(&'"!8'$#(&#'"/#'&.(!"2,#'("/#'!&$!.,##+#(""'#88 !+ "/#0&#:"/!""/#&("#,#'" ?2'"&%#,#H2&,#'"/!"&( "/&'%!'#"/#+!""#,'/28$>#$#%&$#$(+#,&"'/#"#%/(&%!8&"&#' 8!: 8&+&"!"&('/28$("%+#&(:!= $&'5#('!"&( ?

/#,# ,#9"/#5,#'#(",#0&'&(&'!88:#$ /#$#8!=&( &8&(."/# !558&%!"&(2($#,,$#,C28#

'"!($'%($(#$9'2>?#%"

"5!=+#(" '

!'%'"'9">#$#5'&"#$&("/#&'",&%"

3#.!8 &$2($932$/&!(!/#%!'#&',#+!($#$>!%4""/#8:#, 2," , ,#'/$#%&'&((+#,&"'("/#,#+!&(&(.&''2#'

%%,$&(.8=9"/#5,#'#(",#0&'&(&'!88:#$ 73-

'?4'