Saroj Devi & ORS v. Indrawati




   
   

!"# $#%&'&()

+ ,!-. #/&!($"0#-'

 #"&"&(#-'

/#-'1'

($-!2!"&!($!("0#-  #'3($#("'

 ) 4 5 ,
 5  , -#'#(") - 6#78 $/%!"#8

-"0#3#"&"&(#-'

-9&:-!;,&(<08 $/%!"#8

--#'3($#("( 

5  ,8 -!7

=  "0&'  3#"&"&(8  "0#  3#"&"&(#-'  0!/#  %0!77#(<#$  "0#  -$#- 3!''#$>="0#7#!-(#$
&/&7 1$<#,#(&- &/&'&(6!-(!78$!"#$



 %3= ((#?1-#@+8>=20&%0-#'3($#("( 0#-#&(3#"&"&(#-># -#"0# "-&!7
1-"8(!(!337&%!"&( &7#$1($#--$#-17#



'##:&(<" 2&"0$-!2"0# 3#"&"&( 4( "#%0(&%!7  <-1($'4 2&"0  ( '3#%& &% <-1($'

!%"1!77=<&/#(&("0#!337&%!"&(8!%3= 20&%0&'!((#?#$!' ((#?1-#@ 2&"0"0#3#"&"&(80!'>##(!772#$"$'82&"0"0#"-&!7
1-"07$&(< !' 772')@ A(/&#2 "0#'"!"#;#(" 3#"&"&(#-($-!2!"&8"0#3-#'#("

3#"&"&(1($#-,#%"&(B "0#($&!(,1%%#''&( %"8&'

0#-#>=$&';&''#$!' 2&"0$-!2(2&"0"0#3#-;&''&("  &7#

-#'03#"&"&(C'1&"('!;#%!1'# !%"&('1>.#%""7!2

7&;&"!"&( &7#>#%('&<(#$""0#-#%-$-;! "#-$1#

%;37&!(%#D 01'87&>#-"=0!'>##(<-!("#$""0# '" -#'3($#("8/&$#"0# &;31<(#$-$#-8" -#'0'1&"C3#"&"&(("0#'!;#%!1'# !%"&(8 2&"0"0!"3!-" "0#-$#->#&(<!%!1'# <-&#/!(%#""0#3#"&"&(#-

# -#>'#-/&(<!'!>/#8"0#&;31<(#$-$#-3#('2&"0"0# 7&(#"0!""0#-#37=""0#!337&%!"&(1($#--$#-17#



0!$("

>##( &7#$>="0#3-#'#("3#"&"&(#-

"#-"0# '"%("#'"&(<-#'3($#("31"&(!(!33#!-!(%#13( ("&%#  0!/&(<  >##(  &''1#$  &(  "0#  3#"&"&(  2&"0  "0#  %!'#  0!/&(<  >##( !$.1-(#$  "&;#  !($  !<!&(  (  "0#  -#E1#'"    %1('#78  #/#("1!77=  (

+8"0# 772&(<-$#-0!$>##(3!''#$>="0&'
1-")@ A-#787#!-(#$%1('#7 -"0#3#"&"&(#-'813(E1#-= 3&("'""0#!337&%!"&( &7#$>="0#3#"&"&(#-1($#--$#- 17#



># -#"0#7#!-(#$"-&!7
1-"&("0#3#"&"&( &('"&"1"#$>="0#-#'3($#("0#-#&(1($#-
,#%"&(B "0# ($&!(,1%%#''&( %"820#-#&(&"&''"!"#$"0!""0#;!""#-!'

-#<!-$'"0#'"!"1' "0#-#'3($#("!'"0#2& #C2&$2 7!"# !;3!7!7-#!$='"!($''#""7#$&(!3-#/&1'
-&<0"13""0&'
1-"!($("0!"<-1($!7(#"0#3#"&"&(1($#-,#%"&(B

-
2!'(";!&("!&(!>7# #"0#-#!

"#-3&("'"0# !%""0!"2&"01"!(=-#37= &7#$ ""0#!337&%!"&(1($#--$#-17#



8"0#-#'3($#("

&7#$  !(  !337&%!"&(  '##:&(<  "  2&"0$-!2  0#-  3#"&"&(  ( A"#%0(&%!7<-1($'D%3= ((#?1-#@8'##:&(<3#-;&''&( " &7#!%&/&7'1&"E1!"0#'!;#-#7&# 820&%03#-;&''&(0!$

>##(<-!("#$/&$#"0#&;31<(#$-$#-8'1>.#%"""0#%&/&7'1&" >#&(<&('"&"1"#$
2&"0&(7&;&"!"&(      5#!-(#$%1('#7 -"0#-#'3($#("(">#&(<3-#'#("

"$!=20&%0&''##(">#'#/#(("0#7!'"$!"# 0#!-&(< 20#("0#%!'#!%"1!77=%!;#13&# B

  $.1-(#$"

+ >#'02(&("0#1-<#("7&'"D

$!=8 -9&:-!; ,&(<08 $/%!"#8  !33#!-'  --#'3($#("

( !($ '1>;&"' "0!"( -#!'(&(< !%"1!77=0!/&(< >##( <&/#(&( "0# &;31<(#$-$#-8"0#-$#-;!=>#'#"!'&$#82&"0"0#"-&!7
1-"$&-#%"#$" 3!''! -#'0-#!'(#$-$#- B 5#!-(#$%1('#7 -"0#3#"&"&(#-'02#/#--#&"#-!"#'"0!""0# &''1# -#'3($#("( >#&(<"0#2& #C2&$2 "0#7!"#!;!7!7-#!$= 0!/&(<>##('#""7#$&(!3-#/&1'
-&<0"13""0&'
1-">=2!= 
   B

B8$#%&$#$(

8"0#7&>#-"=<-!("#$>="0#"-&!7
1-"" -#'0'1&"&'2077=&;3#-;&''&>7# # 1-"0#-'1>;&"'"0!"#/#(&("0#!337&%!"&( &7#$1($#- -$#-817#

># -#"0#"-&!7%1-"%3=!((#?#$!' ((#?1-#@8"0#

'"-#'3($#("0#-#&(0!$<&/#((-#!'( -2&"0$-!2&(<"0#3#"&"&(!($

&7&(<! -#'0(#  !/&(<  %('&$#-#$  "0#  !

-#'!&$  !-<1;#("'8  "01<0  20!"

-#787#!-(#$%1('#7 -"0#3#"&"&(#-'8&''!=&(<217$   

'##;">#%--#%">="0&'
1-"&(/&#2 "0# !%""0!"&(
  B

&('"&"1"#$>=-#'3($#("( 0#-#&(8"0&'
1-"0!$!7-#!$=0#7$"0!"

"0#;!--&!<# ($-!2!"&8&#-#'3($#("( 0#-#&(82&"0!;!78%!(("

 >#'!&$">#!/!7&$;!--&!<#!'0#0!$(""!:#(!$&/-%# -;0&' &-'"

2& #3-&-"0&';!--&!<#2&"0($-!2!"&82&"0"0!"-$#-&( !%"0!/&(< >##(%0!77#(<#$># -#"0#,13-#;#
1-">=-#'3($#("( >=2!=

,5
&/&7( B

20&%02!'$&';&''#$802#/#-8'&(%#"0#"0# &;31<(#$-$#-&'!%"1!77=>#-# " !(=-#!'(&(<20!"'#/#-82&"01"

;!:&(<!(= 1-"0#-%;;#("8"0&'3#"&"&(&'!772#$!($"0#'!&$-$#-'#" !'&$#0#"-&!7
1-"&'$&-#%"#$"3!''! -#'0-$#-("0#!337&%!"&(

&7#$>=-#'3($#("( 0#-#&('##:&(<"2&"0$-!2"0#3#"&"&(2&"07&>#-"= " -#'0(#8'3#%& &%!77=<&/&(<-#!'('"0#-#&(& 7&>#-"=&'">#<&/#( "0#-" -#'0'1&"C3#"&"&(("0#'!;#%!1'# !%"&(& &("0# 3&(&( "0!"%1-"8'1%07&>#-"='017$>#'<&/#( !"1-!77=8!(=!-<1;#("'-!&'#$>=-#'3($#("( 0#-#&(!'" 20='1%07&>#-"='017$>#<-!("#$&('3&"# "0#$&';&''!7 0#--#/&'&( 3#"&"&(>="0&'
1-"!($"0#,5'1>'#E1#("7= &7#$>=0#-8217$># ("&%#$>="0#"-&!7
1-"&(&"'-$#-

+ 











 3:C$&(#'0






























  F0#"0#-'3#!:&(<C-#!'(#$ #'C F0#"0#-#3-"!>7# #'C