High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8173/2016allowed

M/S Devyani Food Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. M/S Neelkanth Agencies

2019-07-19Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu11 pages

!"#"$%&& '(#)* $" $ +# ,"# ) - .

"$, /,#+# '(#01 23$!"# . #4$ $

,#$ % ',5+$ 0 ,7 )!

, "$, ',8+9"

7 )!

, :::

)"#"$ 4 "$ 2 # =$ "0 +$ , , "!0 $# + "$$ "

#" , ,7$$>+, ?

## =* 2 0 ,$ ")"0 + 3 @8, ")A7

= ,B!

"$3 "$ 4

"$ @$$>+, ?A 9) =* , 4,9"##"$ 0 ,* )" $! +$ , 8!

2 $ "

)" $!!

;< ," # 2 !

# 0 2 "0"$3 2 ,)"#"$ ,

""0 !")"0#+"

,,!),* #C7&7& 0$36"

2+ +, $ 4$ $ 0"

"$ ,# $ 3,+$

6 #$3 3 "$ 2=+#"$##9 ,1 "$3! , 9 $ 6 #$ 2 "# ,"=+ ,# 44"$ =* ?

94 $*7

"# ,"=+ ,#2"4 3,9$

6 # $ ,

)&* 6"

2 "$,?94 $*, 2,* ,#62"!26 #> $ ,9 "9

"9 "$# 4#"

0 !# 6 , # ## $ "# ,"=+ ,#2"4 #!+,"

* "$ 2 9$ 2 '

,!2 7

# " 6 # , 00*

,9"$

"$ '

,!2 6"

2+ ##"3$"$3 $* , #$#7 62, , 6 # ,D+# "$ 0"E !!+$ $ ,0 # + #

$ "$3 *9$

#!+,"

* 4#"

=+ "$#

, "#"$3 0# $ ,")0+# "#4+ "$# "(,#4$ $ ,3 , "$3, +,$C4+#2!

6 4,E,# 62,+4$ 03 0 $ "!

#,) =*

F 94 $* +4$ 2 ,#4$ $ " !0 "9"$3

9+$ 7&7(? $ #$ "!"$32,

#4,4 3, 42 240 79

0 "$# "$)"!# $

& ,#4!

")0*6 #$),,!") ;< 2

?94 $* "0

6,"

9$ 0$36"

2!+$ ,?!0 "9,,!),*7G7(? 0$36"

2 + +,"$ ,# 0##+32 ,0"9

,*"$B+$!

"$, ",!

" , +,$CG4+#2!

6 4,E,#"$3 !$ "

"$# $ 4 3, 42 C 2 4,0"9"$ ,* #+=9"##"$ # 600 3, 42 $ 9,"

# 2 6,"

$ #

9$ 7 =#" #7 "$ 4 3, 42 2!+$ ,!0 "97,,$!6 #9 "$)"!#

$ $ !4"# 2,6, 0#

!2 +,"$34$ $!*

2 4,! "$3#7

"$ 6 # 9) =* 2 ,#4$ $ " +$ , , , +0G "$ 29 "$#+"

, ",!

40 !$,!, !4*

C,0" +4$=* "$ 26,"

9$ 62"!2 #4, 240 " " $ >"#

)%* ;G< 2

"$ ,#4$#

"$7 $$>+, ?

7 ,40*7 $$>+, ?

C 6 # "0 !

3,"!

00* #

C 6 # $ =0 2, ,7

"$7 $$>+, ?

& 6 # 9) , 0 #!$ ,* )" $! ,3 , "$3 !+9$ # $$>+,# # 4,

"0#3")$=06%? 8, $$>+,# 5"$

0"$3D+"49$ !9$ 3,9$ & 0"$3D+"49$ !9$ 3,9$ G $)"! #7C7& & G $)"! #77&&

003"$3

$ & 940*# "$,?94 $* $ 90* ',$+B $ ',2 #1 ,6, )00"$3"$ 2'

,, "$ 2, , "$ 2,?620,,!$,$!6"

2 294 $*H# )!

= 62$#9 2,"3"$ 0 !+9$ #"$ 2"06,0# 62,+4$0# 4,4, *,4, 6 #3 ,3"# , )"

"$7$$>+, ?&

0"!

= $ 07

= ;C< 2

"$,40*

"$,0 "$3#!$ ,*)" $!7 #

1$ +4 6

2 !+9$ # #+32 = 4, +! =* 6 * #!$ ,* )" $! 6, =,"!

)$ + 00* )" , ,

7 2 0 0 +, ,B!

"$ 4

"$ , 4,9"##"$ 0 #!$ ,*)" $!D+ ="00#("$)"!#

$ 62"0 006"$3

"$, 2, #"$)"6 $ =B!

"$ =* 2 ,#4$ $ " =* 20 "$3

,* )" $! $*,"3"$ 0 !+9$ !+0 =0 $0*""

6 #4,)

!+9$ 6 #"$>"# $!7=#" #7"$,40*

"$+$ , , , +0 G 7 "

2 =$ #+=9"

=* "$,

C6 #$ =0

)+* ;

< - ,$ !+$#0!$ $

# "$,6 #D+ ,0* !), +$ , 8!

C @!A 2 $ "

$ )" $! !

>"# $!="00#

& $ 2 $ =$ "#4+ 7 $0*40 6

0 "$# # " ="00#6 #$ #+440" #6 #)" $ ,94 3, 42 26,"

9$ 2!+$ ,?!0 "9"0 =*

"$,7

20 0+, 2 "0 44,!"

3,+$ , 0 "$3 #!$ ,* )" $! D+ # 62"!2 2 =$

006 2="00#"$D+# "$62"!22 $ =$ 006 6,$

00+, !+9$ #2 =$0# "$ $#"

$ 3 ,!, , 9#" #7

"$,#!$ ,*)" $!6 $ 6"

2,3 ,

03 0$ "!7$$>+,

?G "##+ $ =2 0 "$, 2 ,#4$ $ " $ 6 #=, 2"0"$3 2!")"0#+"

=* " 62,"$ ,,$! 6 # !0 ,0* 9 "$)"!#

& =+ 20 0+, 0# #"32 ,9$ "$ #4!

2 !+9$ #"$D+# "$2 =$,0" +4$)$4,",

"0"$3 2#+"

=* $ >"# $! 9 6,$), "#4+ =* 240 "7$0*=B!

"$6

0 "$#

2 # " ="00# 6 # $), ,!") =* 2 ,#4$ $ "7 =#" #7 ) 0+,0!

=*# " ="00#6 # +0*"$!0+ $ ,0!

"$/

,9-8 & "$D+ ,0*, +,$, 2D+ ,$ "$3

# '

,!2=*

"$,?94 $*7 $ 62 2, +0 "9

0* #+!! "$ 4,)"$3

0 6 # #+440" "$# 2 # " "$)"!# D+# "$ $ 4$ +4$ 2)" $! $ 9,3, 4,9"##"$ 0 ,* )" $! 6+0 $ 9

2 ="00# 2 =$

"$)" $!>"# $! 2 !+9$ #,"

#0##!+0 $ =4, ,9"$ $ 62"0 !" "$3

"$,#!$ ,*)" $!

),* $0*4,"9 !">"# $! $ 0##6 =4,) $ "

6 #, * 62"!26 0 #!$ ,*)" $! 4,) +>!+ "$ " !+9$ =*0 "$3!3$ )" $!7=+ 20 0+, "$#

0"9"

2 D+# "$ , 0 "$3 #!$ ,* )" $! ,9$ "$

#4!

# 29

,2 3$ !$#" , 9"##"="0"

* 2="00# "$D+# "$62"!2!+0 = $$0* , 006"$3

"$ ;<

, !$ 7 0 ,$ !+$#0 , 2 ,#4$ $ " !$ $

, + 6 ##+32 40 * =*#1"$3 =,"!

!+9$ #"$)" $!

,"3"$ 0 2="00#62"!26,!0 "9 ) =$ 0# " $$>+,# $ 2 $ =$ "0 0$3 6"

2 "$3#7 2,,7 2 $ ,"32 4, +! #!$ ,*)" $!D+ # " !+9$ #!!, "$30*7

"$2 =$,"32 0* "#9"## =* 20 0+, D+ !+9$ #$$>+,# $ " "$)"! #

&7 $

;< - ,$ !+$#0, "+, 2,!$ $

6 #$!## ,*, 2 )4,) >"# $! !+9$ 2 ),* >"# $! 2 # 9 6 # "#4+ =* ,#4$ $ "+, 2,!$ $

#"0 =* "+$ , , , +0G "$62"!2 6 # 9$ "$

2 ,,, !,

"$ !+9$ # 62"!2 6, "$ 4####"$ 4 (!+$ ,?

!0 "9 =+ 2 # " !+9$ # 2 $ =$ #+440" ,#4$ $ "

2 0# ,0" +4$

C =+ 2 1$60 3 ,#4$ $ "7 $ #+!2 !+9$ >"# *, 6 # 9

)(* ",!

"$ = "##+ 4, +! ,"3"$ 0 !+9$ # ;&<

40* ,9$ "$

"$ 6 # "0 $ C 40

00 !+9$ # 2 =$ #+440" ,#4$ $ "62,

C6 #$ =0 =* 7

"$ ,9$ "$ 9 $$,7"

6 #!0 ,

2 !+9$ #"$D+# "$6,$ =0"$ 2* ,"

#07 ,"3"$ 0 !+9$ #6,$),4, +! =* "$ +, 7

2 =$!0 "9 ,0",

2 !+9$ #2 =$#+440"

"=+ 2, ,"

6 #="$340

!+9$ =$0#

"$ 2 !",!+9#

$!#7 62$ >"# $! !$!,$ !+9$ #"

#06 #$ ="$34,) 7$4,9"##"$!+0 =3,

"0#!$ ,*)" $!!$!,$ !+9$ ! $,!, ;< - 0 +, "#9"##

"$ D+ "$)"! # $ 0#

C$ 23,+$

>"# $! $ 0##,"3"$ 0 !+9$ #2 $ =$#

"# ,"0*4,)

$ #!$ ,*)" $!6 #$ 9"##"=0+$ "04, +!

"$4,0"9"$ ,* )" $!6 ##

"# ,"0*4,) , "$3,9 "$"$3 !+9$ #7#"$! $ =B!

"$ 2 =$ , "# =* !+$#0 , 2 ,#4$ $ "7 # 96, 006 = $ , "$#!$ ,*)" $!#+=B!

4 ##"$3 # 9"##"="0"

*"$)" $!

3"$ 0 ,3+9$ # ;< 2 ) !$#" , 2 #+=9"##"$# 0 ,$ !+$#0 , "# ;< #4,4 3, 42#&7 $ "$7 !+9$ $ ,,

C , $0* 6"

2 ,3 , !+9$

&7 G7 &

)$* 2+#7 2 "#4+ "# $0* 6"

2 ,3 , ,B!

"$ , 0 "$3 #!$ ,* )" $! D+ "$)"! # $

& $ ,,$! " !+9$ #"$ # 9$ "$ "$ 03 0 $ "!7 $$>+, ?G

#,) =* "$,?94 $*+4$ "4,", 2"0"$3 #+"

62"!26 #"0 $ )" $$>+, ? ;< 8!$ 0*7"$ 240 7 2>"# $!="00#

$ 2 #$ =$ "#4+ $ 23,+$ 92 )"$3=$ ,3 2!

# #2 #=$# +4 2,"$"#

0 "$# # " ="00# 6 # $), #+440" #" #7 2 3,+$ , 0 "$3 #!$ ,* )" $! D+ # 62"!22 =$ 006 $ , 2="00#"$ D+# "$62"!22 $ =$ 006 6 #$ 9"

00# " +, !+9$ # 6, 0# "$ $#"

$ $ ,* 3 ,!, , # 9 ;G< $ 2, ,0) #4!

2 9

, "#

2 ) 0+ ="00#62"!2"##+32 =4, +! 2 =$ +0*"$!0+ $ ,0!

"$ /

,9-8& "$D+ ,0*, +,$, 2D+ ,$ "$3

# '

,!2 =* "$,?94 $* I2 2, +0 "9

0*#+!! #"$4,)"$3

06 ##+440" "$# " "$)"!#"# D+# "$ $ 4$ #+4$)" $!',3, 4,9"##"$ 0 ,* )" $! # $ "940*

2 ="00# "$ D+# "$2 )=$

"$)" $! ,$!"$ 2"#!$$!

"$!

=9 2 !"#"$ 2"#+, "$

0) > 2 # 9 "# ,4, +! #+$ ,%?

)"*

% & '

(

)

* #

+ ;C< 4,+# 0 2 !"#"$ "$ #21 5+9 ,H# !

# @8+4, A ,) 0#

4,)"$3 !+9$ #=*6 *4,"9 ,*,#!$ ,*)" $!"#

,+0)" $! 2D+# "$62 2, *#1"$30 ) +, 0 ,* )" $! +0 "9

0* #+!! # "$ 4,)"$3 !+9$ ,$ "# D+# "$ $ 4$ $ +4$)" $!2+#7

2D+# "$"$62

!",!+9#

$!# 2 !+9$ #6,0# "# D+# "$

)-* $ )" $! # 4, 0 6 "

"# 600?#

4 * "# $0* ,D+", "#!0#9

0 $ $ 40 )" $!'

0 "$

2!",!+9#

$!#="$30## !+9$ $ !",!+9#

$!#0 0## !+9$ D+# "$ )" $! ,# " D+# "$ !

$ $0* = !" ,4,)" "$344, +$"

* *!$!,$ 0 #!$ ,* )" $!',3, 0 ) 0 #!$ ,*)" $! #$ 9

2 !+9$ "#

"$)" $!$,"#"

"$ "$3 2>"# $! $* 2!$ "

"$#"$ "!

"$8!

C 2)" $!!

$0*

9+$ 20 "$3 $$D+",*,3 , "$3>"# $! !+9$ $ "

#0## +$ , #9 !",!+9#

$!# 2,,7 "0+, , #+!!## 4,) >"# $! !+9$ #,"

#0##!

$$ =4,?

,9"$

2+ 4,)" "$344, +$"

*I2 2, 2 !+9$ "#4,) ,$ "# =#$

,0 )"#3, 29

0()" $!4, +! "#) 0+

$ "

"#$0* ,4,)" "$3 $44, +$"

* 0 #!$ ,*)" $!

0 +, !

$ ,9 "

# 4"$"$ ,3 , "$3 >"# $! !+9$ !",!+9#

$!# $+9,

"$ 8!

C 2 )" $! !

, 0 #!$ ,* )" $! "# $0* 2, ,

2 +, 2 !" 2, 2 !+9$ "#4,) "$)" $!,$ #"9"0 ,!

"# !"#"$"$!

#$ %& '

,9$ "$ !"#"$6 #006 =* ?, "$

$!2 2"#+, "$ ( #% %& ( ) %# %& % %# * "+ ,-

0) > 9"#,4, +! #+$ ,%? ,

* #

)#'*

% & ' $

#$ %& '

'+ ; < 2+#7 >"# $! $ 0## "$)"!#

& 6+0 2 ) =4,) =* =*0 )" $! 23$+"$$## 9"##"="0"

* " !+9$ #!

,9"$ =* 20 0+,

44,4,"

324 "$, # !

3,"!

00* 40

2 !+9$ # "$ D+# "$ 6, 0# =* "

940*# 62"0 "$ $#"

$,+ 9 2", )!

= , 4,9"##"$ 0 #!$ ,*)" $! #$ 9+$ 20 "$3

2 !+9$ "#

"$)" $!$, # 9 9+$ "$ "$36"

2,3 , 2>"# $!,0## 2 !+9$ "$D+# "$$, #"

9+$ 20 "$3 "$ "$3>"# $! $* 2!$ "

"$# $+9,

"$8!

C 2$ "

$)" $!!

, 0 ) 0 #!$ ,*)" $!$0* 9+$ 20 "$3 $$D+",*,3 , "$3>"# $! !+9$ $ "

#0##+$ ,#9!",!+9#

"0+,,#+!!## 4,) 2 >"# $! !+9$ !

$$ = 4,?

,9"$

2+ 4,)" "$344, +$"

* ;< $ 2 !",!+9#

$!#7 "94+3$ , ,

@$$>+, ?A 4 ## =* 2 0 ,$ ")"0 + 3 @8, ")A7

= "#9"##"$3

"$ , 0 "$3 #!$ ,* )" $! D+ "$)"! # $ "# # #" ,9"##"$ "# 3,

)##* 0 ,* )" $! D+ !+9$ # @" ="00#("$)"!# $ A

& $ -

0+, 4,! "$ !!, $!6"

20 6"$ 20"32 24#"

$ =) 2 !"#"$ 2"#+, "$#215+9 ,8 !2 ) H#!

# @8+4, A ;<

)"#"$4 006 "$ ,9$ "$ ,9# @8I 0"

A + 3 &&

I2 2,#4 1"$3(, #$ % #( I2 2,,4,

=0 % #(