Chameli Devi v. Arun Kumar And ORS
!"
# $%& $'
( $ )$ %
*$%+%!$ $
,
!"
# $%& $' ( $ )$ %
($!+%!$ $
,
($
$+-".
/ & 0/$*#- $*
/ 0*# $ , $ $)&%$#/ 0*# $ $ ,
*$&%! -$ $2%&!- $ $#
3 .%&!
4 &$" 56
.%&!0$#
, 4$ &
0
"46 ""6 $%& $"&" $
& -
$ ""& & $$ ,
46
$""$
$!46 *,,""*% $ 60 ""
, 0
%- $!
!!% " $ ,$ $ "
&$ 4 , 4
, 46!! .%&! 3
%-
$
- $,$ $
" ,$!
% / 7$6 &#$ 46 7$68$4$" 9# *0 : $ $4 $ $$ ; * :<04&# &$% 4
$=% $!0#
,$ ,$!
- "% $$
"
,%$, $=% ""$
$$
",$!
,$ %"$"6- $
4"
,$ ,$!
" %& ,$ $
",$!
04,%$
> ,$ 0 # 4 %& $!-$!
- $,$ % 02& 0+ 5?$0*!4">
, $ $ ($!
& &$ $ *,$ "
0 $ $# & 9/
# & "@- -
"$ "& 0 $ $0 - , ,"
& "$ " !
$! $!
=% 3 $-$ $&$% - # - %& 4% #4,$
!
$&%! 3 , ," $=% ""$
4
'$$""$ -"" *,,""*% $ 6 #
!
$#
, &$% $
"
,$!
"% $$
4&# $
$
>!64! $ # %$4 $ / 7$6$&#$46 7$68$4$" 9# *0 : $ $4$ $$ ; *
:<3 4% " &4&# $4
$=% ""$$
$!"! *" %& 0 ,$/ * :0 # &$% 4
$=% ""$- # "4""6- $ ,$
"
4% " &7-#$0 $ ""- & .%&!,
467A4" /%,$!%$
0 -$A$
"A ,,$ & * : "
4"$% % " .%&! "
! " #$% & ' %%(0- -
$!46 #
5
%$ '$(*,," " " ) *" + * "
) ! #$ ' ,0 $ $0 -$A$
"A
4#$"@- "
$ & &$% #
%$ %-.%&! $ 5 @# - $
",$!
4&# $ $
- ""
&- ,$#
* : $4! .%&! ,
46
%$ - ./ / ) #$&00 ' 1( 23 ) #$&004 & ' &
B >-%"4,,$,$ !,$ ,$#
*
: ,$#
9 (%.48$4 $ *0 B $ $4$ $$ ; * B< ,,"
4"(%.4 &$ *!,$ $
""-
5*1$!!* 5* %4 $!!* "
+ + )
)
) )
!
!
"#$
%
# &
'
&
&
( "## & ")*#
%
+4 6+* "
$4 5 /" !!"
* ) ! !
$ * )##7 $ 8 9
**! # **!" ) ) * * +* * ) 9 * * *// */ 15* :
, '
'
- . / 0 & ")"1 - . &
2 - & ")1# - . 3 - & ")14
% -
")5)& 6
&
-
7
8
9 & ")5*
&
'
'
'
!
"# $
%
&
'
' "( $
)*
' +
!
,-
./
#
"
$
0
")$1 2
0 "$ #
# "
$3&
0 "$3
"$ 3
0
2 8
'
* 8
(
: & ")4!
# & $ % ;
+ <
'
")5)& < %
( .
= -7> =!( 3 "))*
-:0**4 +
<
7!3
+
< ( "##
! - =% - 4, 4#
$=% $4 - $ $ ,$#
* : ,,"
4" / 7$6 >
$&$0
$ .%&!- !
%$
/9-+ ;. #&004 " !%>
0 %$- "
&- ,$#
* B ,,"
4" / (%.43 %$
: - "$"6 &%,,$# % .%&! 7A4" /%,$!%$ 5 ) < ./#5< % %%4 " ,$ 4% " &- - & # $$
4 &# $4
$=% ""$ $$
> #$ %""6"6? ,$#
(%.4*
B 7$6* : >!6
$# -- $&$ 4
$=% $! $
"!!$ "4% " & 0 ,$#
4 * $ ,$ !$ C $ ,7$60 -$;$
"< 4 "4% % "0 $ $0 $%@- $!/ *3 % 0 ,$#
* #4$46!
& -$;$
"< / - $ - $ ,(%.4 *0 &$% # 4
$=% $!- $ , $
" 4% " &
,$# ,$"6 %$ /
"%44- $"3 $"
*
"6- $ ,6"" ,$"6 $ ,%$, 4 &% ,$ ,""6
$4%
$$ > $ %""6$ .%&! ,
46 7A4" /%,$! %$ *$ / & A /%,$0 7A4" /%,$!%$- "
&- $" &#$ 46/
/ !
"$- ,
($! -$
# /%,$7-#$0 %$- $- 4
4- ,$#
* ,,"
4" / 7$6(%.4- " & +%!$ /%,$/5@ ( "/%,$>7$6 $ .%&!
,
)($@ D%,0 $=% ""$ $
-%,
&#$46/ 04 - $ , $
" -"" $
"4% " & 3 $ $0 .%&! +%!$/%,$/5@ ( "/%,$ ""4 ,$ %$ ! >" 0 / 7$60$!""6 $
? & ,$"6 $$
" $ !!$ " $ C &$- 6E%$4$ 0$ % - $" ! $0 $ ,$ $ 4 # "6 % $ !!$ "
,%$, 0" %& !6 #4"% $$
"& ! 4@3 ""$- $=% $ $,$ % $ $
,$ # # %"
," ,$!
$=% $ $$
0" %& 0 -
% $ $
$ .%&! )($@
D%, %,$0 $
4- $
" $
" 4% " & #
#
&$% 4
,$ " $=% $!0
""4$$ " ,$!
"% $$
0 # "64 %& $4
$=% $
"6 > ,$ 0 *$%+%!$0 ! # $!
4 &% $$, $ & $! %!
46
!
% !$ ! '$$""$ $"
%, .%&!,
467A4" /%,$!%$ =/ ) 5"/ 9 #&00$4 + %&1$
> $ 0
*$6/!./-/0$ # # " "$ %& #
$!$
",$!
&$% 4% " &
$=% $ $ $% & "
4$$6 7A4" /%,$! %$ % $% &,%4"
"
4$$6- %6,$
-%"4$ & !- !4 !!$ 70 $ .%&! "6- ,$,
"- 4% " &"% $$
"
,%$, 4&# $$
*" %& 0
$% /
* :,$#
,$ ""#$$
"4% " & $
"
4% " &F,- ,$!
-$ & $""$7-#$0
% ,$!
4@ $ 4% " &! ,
""$> *$%+%!$0 "$6! #
& % !$ $!$!0 $
,$ 46 '"*% $ 6 $!%
& ,$!
$!!$ "
$
",%$, 0 $=% ""60-
!$0
$ $ 4 44
$=% $! ># - $ 04 $#
, $""-3 $$ ,
464 %$ $
3 $&$ $! ! #$ #,
,$!
""$ *"" , &!
""% ,,"
0
60$
, 0 # - 4# .%&!
!
-
"#$%#$&'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$01 $'./ "#$%#$&&$(/&%)23$1 $'./