S.P Gupta v. M/S Pavani Civil Contractors Pvt Ltd. And ORS.

 
   
   
   
  
 
 
 
 

! "#$#%& '() (* 

! "#$#%& '() (* 

! "#$#%& '() (* 

! "#$#%& '() (* +

+

+

+ ,(- *  .)/

 ##% ( 0 ($)$ ,1$ %#
#2#.
%( "($(#2  3#4# !

%!5 ($  $/%! %$
,&
,&
,&
,& 63,--
- 63,--
- 63,--
- 63,--
- ( $ %& ( $ %& ( $ %& ( $ %& ,($57)/ +!2"

(5 / ##% ( ,(-
5 .+!2"

(5 ( $/%! %$ 88888 88888 88888 88888 -+ -+ -+ -+  ##% (5 #. !5#$/ ##%"5 .. %9#%95

(!  !

 !    

  / $$ !  '*  5  3 ')( 
)(+ :5 ( '*+5 ( .#  4 %:

$! ".#% !5 / ##% (  ##% (  5 !  ( #$ !  %  %!)$(# .  !#$/)  '* $ (2#%9 ! 4 %!%#" "5 .. %9#%95#$ (4#% #% 5

//(/(#  2 (%4 %( (( !5 !#$/) 5 3 ')(
)(+4'

.

( !;)!#"

#% 5 2 5 (!.

(% !")%$ . (5 / (# $ 2 9% 5()955 ( "(! #.

'. %5  #. "

)..* 5 "

$  5 / ##% (+#%'(# +:

$5 5 !;#% !5 ( $/%! %<, 9 4 % #4 = / (

 %  >? %!5#$$ (2#" $5 !' % (4#%  !:  

?>  :#5)  "4/.*#%9  :#5  5  4 (* /(2#$#%$    5  %!)$(# .  #$/) $  "+  @?  A6"6  ( $5(B 5 "

$  5 ( $/%! %+%5 5 (5 %!+ $5 5 / ##% (5 !' % %9 9 ! #4 = / ( % "")% / %!#%9:(7 $5 , 9 4 %5 !9 C %$#% ("4/. #% 5 /(; " - (2#" $ 5 / ##% (  5 !  ' %   (4#%  !  #%  ""(!

%"  :#5  5  (4$ 5#$ //#%4 %1 4/.*4 % %5 /.

!#%9$ 5 / (# $+ ..:#%9#$$) $ : (  4 !'*5 %!)$(# .(#')% .<")4<3 ')(
)(&< D  $/ (( ( %" 1%)$/ (# $  5 5 (  / ##% (  #$  %   :(74 %  !

#% !)%! ( "E $#$

"E,   .# F  (# $  . !  5 #(  2#! %"  #%  $)//(    5 #( ( $/ "#2 /.

$ 5 3 ')(
)(

 ("%$#! (#%95  2#! %"

. !'*5 / (# $+9 2  #%!#%9

"5 5 / ##% ( !( %! ( !@!

*$ $ (2#" /( " !#%95 * ( 5#$  (4#% #%5 3 ')(
)( )(5 (5 .!5 5 $ (2#" $ 5 / ##% (5 !' % (4#%  !#%2#.

#% 5 /(2#$#%$    - "#%   <    5  "  : 2 (+  :5#.

"%$#! (#%95 G) $#% $:5 5 (5 / ##% (:

%#. ! (( #%$  4 %#%$ (2#" +5 3 ')(
)("

5 "%".)$#%5 #:

#"

$ :5 ( 5 / ##% ( $.# '. ' "4/ %$  !#%$ !  4 % '

"7<:

9 $5 ( $%$9#2 %'*5 3 ')(
)(#%5#$ ( 9 (!#%   #$ (!( ! $)%! (&< H CG) $#%' !  (4#% !#$:5 5 ( ##$ #"

$ #%:5#"5( .#  4 %

)..'

"7:

9 $"

%'  (! !5 / ##% (   (5 2#%9 #%$"()#%#I !5  %#( 4  (# .+ 5 2 "4 5#$"%".)$#%5 9( % ( .#

 ( #%$  4 %  :#5  )..  '

"7  :

9 $    5 / ##% (#$%/$$#'.  $%$#%$)//(

4*  2# :  '

$ !  %  2#! %"  %  ( "(!  (  )%! (&<  $  2#! %  (4  5  /.

!#%9$  4 #% $% ( ( %"54 %1 (4#% #% 

/ ##% (  :

$  5  ( !)"#%1.

"7  

:(7+  $  5  /(; "   
5 %!#4 %!#( :5 (  / ##% (  :

$  :(7#%9  :

(#%9"4/. #% 

")4 %C,</(2 $5 /(; "

"%$()"#%  "44 %!  5$/# . 

5 %!#4 %!#(5 $"4/.  !  ,<  -5(#  (# 4  -#%95  =5)( + (; "  , 9 (+  5 $  2)"5 !  5

$4 .."%$()"#%:(7)%! ( 7 %'* 5  4 9 4 %  5 !  "4/.  !    5  /(; " :5 (  / ##% (  :

:(7#%9  :

$  % (#%9  "4/. #%  %)4' (    4/.* $  5 !    '

( .

$ ! 

!4# !

!2 (#$ 4 %#%2##%9 //.#"

#%$ ( ( "()#4 %  : (  /)'.#$5 !  #%  % :$<

@ / / ( 5 $ /:

7 %:#55#$ 5/ 5 5 4 9 4 %:).!9 % :  "%$()"#%  :(7   )  5 9 4 %").!%.

*%#$5 %!$

% :/(; "' "

)$  %! ($ 5 ( / (# $: (  "" / !  $  !% 5  5

 (   (4#% #%    5#$ / ##% (% ( $5 //#%4 % #4 = / (  :

$  4 !    -/ "# #"

..*  5  !  #%  5#$  2#! %"  5   5 9 4 %  $ '.#$54 %  5 $  ' % :)%!<)/F 5  ( $%$  9#2 %  '*  5  3 ')( 
)(  :5#.

! ".#%#%95 ( .#  4 %5 / ##% ( $)%!( $%$5  4)% "4/ %$ #% (! ! 5 / ##% (5 $$#%" ' %( .

$ !5#4 .%9:#5 #% ( $  $  #$  2#! %  (4  5  (! (  !

 !  

@ / $$ !'*5#$
)( %  5 

"$  %!  "#(")4$ %" $    5  /( $ % "

$ +  %  9()%!  (  #% ( ( %"  '*  5#$ 
)(  :5#.

C ("#$#%9  5  ;)(#$!#"#%  )%! (  (#".      5
%$#)#% %!# +#$4 ! )

#$4#$$ ! A-B A-B A-B A-B          '() (* +

 '() (* +

 '() (* +

 '() (* +

2#(