M/S Indian Oil Corpn. v. M/S Shiv Oil Carrier
!"!#$%$&'(
)%&"$ & $*+,+ $&- " ! $ $&!+ .!+%/%
)%01$2 $* ++$!+ &" 1!+% !%,&"!& %
&3 &0+$2 % 2 41$! & 5!+ ,!+ $&4&"$ & $* +,+ $&- " ! $ $&!+ .!+%/%
)%01$2 $* ++$!+ &" 1!+% !%,&"!& % 6 6
+2!%1" 4!,/ 7!&!+ * & 5!+ /&3 80 !
$#!&"$ & $*+,+ $&- " ! $ $&!+ .!+%/%
)%01$2 $* ++$!+ &" 1!+% !%,&"!& % 9 9
: %%4;!#/ $2!$+!# +4&"$ & $*+,+ $&- " ! $ $&!+
.!+%/%
)%01$2 $* ++$!+ &" 1!+% !%,&"!& % ' <-
0 00
==== >1! 1!+ !,+ !+%-# *, ,!+%? 78! **@!" %!! 1!3/"5?!& A!% 8!+!!++!" 1! !,+ !+%+& A!% 6 >1! 1!+ 1!3/"5?!& %1/*"8!+!,+ !"$& 1! $5!% A!% ==== 004 + *
"
#
#$ #%&
(
!
#, #%&
+ -, . /
1 +2 ( 3# #%&
$ 2 45
+
- +
--7 "
#- % #%&
1
'5 1
' & 2
8
1 9
: ;
'
1 , ;
'
1 9 :
&B.%:/%/?55 +@ * 9 - 6(
? 1 &" .% *#7&
1 +? #!/ $# *- " +$?$& *6
'
'
6
'
- ;
'
4 < @!+ $51 /+ ,/&$%1 #& !?, % %/8+"$& ! #/+ %=>'
?
" '
?
=>'
?
" '
?
@A
1 9
; + B C /&$%1?!& +#& !?, #/+ D ./ "
?'
'
" '
'
? ?
'
? "
=./ "
?'
'
" '
'
? ?
'
? "
@A '
" '
>? = '
1
.#/ ("
'
'
"
?
4 ./ '
.0/ ("
'
'
'
?
?
'
1 .$/
'
'
1
' '
'
' " '
'
'
4 '
1"
?
.&/ ("
'
4 .$/
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
>? =D 4 .$/ .&/= ./ < 'B '
'
E . / < B
B 1
"
'
" '
1
9
'
"
'
?1 &"<%# %! 0/,+
"
4 <
"
'
"
'
41@!2!+4"!%& #&!+ &7,@!+ &%/8+"$& !#/+ $&$ $ ! # $&##+"$&5*7& ,! $ $& /&"!+ 0!# $&% &" 1! # @ % ? $& $& 8*!8!+! 1!""$ $& *$% +$# /"5!4$% + -! +&!" ""$ $& * $% +$# /"5!4 $% + 1 " # !" **7@$ 1/ 3/+$%"$# $&$&$%%/$&5& $#!+%!#/+$&5 ,+!%!&#! 1!,! $ $&!+ +!
' 7 $ #%%-
?
4$ & #%%-
?
4&
.
?
50/
'
B
'
&B<%# %! 0/,+
"
4 <
;+;+;
1
1!/+ @ %+!%,&"$&5 ,+ 7!+ /&"!+0!# $& &" 1!& !?, /+ %# 1!/+ 1 %&,@!+ $%%/! &7%/#1"$+!# $& ,!+%&% , + 7 8!+! 1$? 1! ,@!+ /&"!+ 1! & !?, /+ %# # && 8!!;!+#$%!"87 /+ %/8+"$& ! 1!$51/+ 1 %&,@!+ # **+ 1!,!+%&% 1!1 $+? & 1! &B$& 1!? &&!+ @1$#1 $ 1 % "&! 1! +"!+ , %%!" & 6 $% !++&!/% &"$ $%E/ %1!" ;
"
+ $% ,@!+ 1 +!%$"!% &*7 @$ 1 1! $51 /+ &" 1! 0/,+!?!/+
" B 0 ; "
"
"
" '
$ +!
'
'
"
#$ #%& #, #%&
'
&
(
+
7
1
00 ( 1