Dharminder Kumar Etc. v. Pb.State
!
"
# $%# " &&''
% (
)%* + &
*$%# ,- * .$%# , *% &&''
% (
)%* + &
!
( #* $ % )
% (
)%* + " & "#$% &'()* "+,-./* #0.123#"$# &'()* "+,-./*#".&4*"2.&532.43+ )
$%' / '0
0 &&''
- 1 #$%#
) " 0
0 &&''
'* $ %0
$ ( / '0
0 "&
223 *" / *0( &% .
4 '0)%* +
#0.123#"$#6 5" *%6# / '' & " + 6
0
223
##7% '
/
' "
5"
&& '
% *%6#
2 +. '( 8%6 " 0 9 5 1 % 0 :"
&% ( ;95;;0 /"+. &&''
"
# $%# 0 (% $%# '
(" 0 *$%# ,- * .$%# , *% %1"
( 6",46 / "
6 "
&% "
+'% ( ;;
2<) &&''
"
# $%# 0(% $%#
'
(" 0 *$%# ,- * .$%# , *%/ %6 #& # '
%( <) & . 0; "
%'
& .# 0 % " %6 6% #& # # " " %1"
( 6", 46 / 7%
5" &&''
/ %6 #& # '
& . 0; "
%'
& .# 0
% "%6 6% #& # # " " # ' 223 "
+& +.
( #* $ %/ / $ "
7%
' %1"
( 6",46 0 % " % = 5" #&'
'6
"
"
( 6"
6 " #0""
13 '
''
6*/ ' 3
+% = 0""
6 " ' : % +. %
&/ " *% " & (#+."
"/ " +. ' :'
:
* ( 6"
"& 6% "+. :/ &'
'6 "& 9< / 6 "#
/
+. "&' 5"+./
& # #> #
"+ '%
# # +. %&0 /
5" "
''
/ &%
%&
#&' '' " ' # '
5"& % > # %#+ %&&
5"
# %/ ' %(
) 5". "& % %1"
( 6" '
46 / 7%
5" &&''
/ 0 + : 0 "& && ' "*%6#
2 ? %' && 6 +"
'
" &&''
"# '. 6%
"& % "
' & ? %' && 6 "(
" %' &
( #* $ % "# '. 6%
"& % "
&
%1"
( 6" '
46 /'' @"
" ' %' "& 6 "%6"
" %''.
6 )@
'+ ( 6"+ " '
/ $ "
0" " ( #* $ %3 3
+ ' .
: '" #
$ "
"
6% .
: #+ 1 '' +% A & # :/ " " # :
%" #
6 "
1 6' 7%/ " %& :7% " + " '
/ #& ." # 6"# : '" #
"/%' #'
> .0 +. " + " '
// % :
% "% )@
'+ ( 6" "#
'
/ : ( #* $ %/ # / "$ "
$ "
/ /1 6 5'6 &"& # )@
'+ ( 6""
'
2 &
"
6"
" % %& " > .0 " +. / < " > #
0"&
%/
+." #+
" 6
"&' "
%#+ & : 1/
%0/""
##
"#%0/
5"
0 "./&% + "%
)@ ?
1"+ ( 6""
3 0 * $%# " ' :# > *% ' + " #
'6/ " " "&"
##
"#% & #
&/ ' : ' ' " # " "& *$%# '" #
""
# # ./ &' &'""%'+&% + "&' )@ 1 * $%# " &'
+% " &0 /" / 1/0 /
*$%# '
"/%' #
2 .0+% " %%& <" > #
0" '
" <(
3 )@2 "
( 6" &
" / 6 %'
% +.
& :"
13;
'
' #:
* ( 6"
3
+% # 0"/ " ' : +. 5"&' / # ? )% )@ "
% " & # # > #
:"
''/ 6 *% " +.! B "+/#%'
&' + '' & 1 "+/ % +' C> 6
''
+ " 5" % > 6 / " + " #& '
= 6 & '+
%
%/'' 6 #>= # " &
'6 '& "%6 +' '' "
#
# & "1%'' %'
0> 6
/ '
#& '6 & 6 "1%''0 #
# & " &
'6
#& '6 '
##+ '
%+% ' '' +' ' & %'
&' "+/ + /&
& & '
# = "+/ % /& #> = # "'/ +#&'
" C
''. "+/ % #>= # "'/ & '
" & 03 "0
" + /
% &' % ' .
+' ?
'%6'
(1 &' "# ' & '
'6 D
6 " #0 %
"/ " *%.' 6 #"
6 " 10/" "/ %
%
" .
%
% '' *% / # # 2 )@ ( #* $ %&
""%+ / 6 5'6 &"& # 0:"
&% :/ + . '3 3
+% ) (""
" +. ""%+ "&
' = )@2)
&"
"/ "' 6' 6' 7%
''
6 '.
:1/$ "
0/"
# #%
1' 7%
" +% . + 10$ "
" %#' 7%
+% & #
1 6' 7%0"/ / .
3 3 )@3(<5*& '&
# # + " # +.)@"
( 6" : "& <7% & && /
5" "& % & '.
$ "
"
6 %#' 7% )@
'+ ( 6"7% " # #+ 1 " "% : '
'+ ( 6"
"/%' #+ 1 5"
0 " +. / % " # 6 )@
'+ ( 6" "
6 ''.
"
#
""
6 + 6+ 1$ "
# " :"
'
$ "
+%
" #+ 1 < $ "
"
# "#0 " & %' + # +. )@
'+ ( 6"
0)@
'+ ( 6""
% #
"% 5" "& %
%/ )@
'+ ( 6" " > #
% / ' .
5" ''6 /# /"
%/ ' . " % . "&'
)@ ?
1"+ ( 6""
+ % +. "& % &
% *$%# "
# > *% ' + " # :
3 *$%# "
# " # :
1" # "&' 5"
0/"/ 1/ " #0/ ' .
*$%# '
"/%' #
. <" > #
0)@ ?
1"+ ( 6"
6 ''.&
""
"
# %( 3 ) < * $%# "
# > *% ' '
# )@ ?
1"+ ( 6"0""%'"
# "&' "
:
# & :/ # % " .
A )@2)
&"
"
" "
'
" #& . % 5" + %#
'
< & "+ %#
0 " "
#% + #&' '' " %#
#% & % '% '.
/ "6% '
% < "
0 " "
#&' )@
'+ ( 6""
&
$ "
6"
" %%& "> .0" +./ % "# 6 6 " #0 %/
6 "& % 0 %/
5"& % "
' ' 1 %/ " ## #% $ "
5" %/
+.
)@
'+ ( 6" # "% 5" ?" & ":E+'(%&#%
(%&#% 2 "
"'
% # ' / 1 5" ?" &"
"' %!
& "
+ 7%
+. " : 6"
% " 6%
"
. %' +
+' "+. "& %
'5" #
&
" # & / 1/
"& % > "%" #/ # "9<0(""
0 "/
& '6/ " (%& )' 0 AA 0
& F/ " "&/" # 1/ " #&'
& #&'
#"+ 1 6 66"#% " 5".
&% %&" # "' / " +' >% ' % / " "F < "
# + ' % "& % > #
""
1/& ' % "
<
& / % +.
6 6 . (" % " #
"
6 & " % '.
" . % :/& / # % & #. ."%/ "%+ /" ""
+ &&'. %
'. >&'
+. & % % 6 "
# &' 6 . 7% "'
&
"&%& +' 6 "/
. & ''6 "
##
"
& %'
'./"% "&/ & %'.1/
"/ " # 5" +
<
# . +
' % 1/ %
'. + " #&'
' 6%+
" # " % 6 6 " '#
<
& # . ' + . /" %&
"& 5"
. 6 %&
'
# 0 # .
%0 " '.
/ 1 "
5" % %" (
G ) "'
" . "%' '. '
. "/ % /"
%#
" #&'
"/ & 1% "& %'
%& "
'
" & /" " " ''6'. &'
. " # 7% / " +'& %'
'. <% "
%' &% 6 ''.'1 +
"/ #.
% "
. % /" 6 "# 5" # .0 "/0 + > & " 6 '%'0/"0 > #&'0 % #&+. & %'
/ /"
#.
'. '. / "% % " "
A +
5"%6" " "' 6
& 6 %+
H ". % +
&%& +' 6
& +%6"
+ " % / " ' & ' " ## " # 5"
& "'0 0 '' 0+
0' % / ". /" " " % %'+%
< %' &% /" " 7% + ''/ /" % 1/ "/
" #&'
5" ?" & ":E+'(%&#% "
< (
#% "
. '% +
" "
% % 5" ?" &"
"' %! B= < %+ %
#% "
. '%
+
" "
% % /"
. 6/
' 6/" *% ' 66' #& "&
/""
& %'
##+ "& 0 "
# # %
<
(%&#% = 0 " ?" & :E+' "(%&#%
"'
/"
%+. #
# % 0 "%' # "+ 5" ?" &"
"' %! B2 '% "'
&
# 1 "
% # +'0
" " # .#% " # +' '
/ @"
%+. #
# % 0 "%' # " + D 2 <
(%&# % =0 " ?" & :E+' "(%&#% "
"'
'8%6/ ''+ %#& & 6
% +./ % 5" ?" &"
"' %! B= @"
6 "%6" "
+. ": 6"%
'.(1 :
+
. ' <
0 " % >&'
&%& 5<) < +
& "'
"
6 +.
6
/ '&%&!
.
"&& .%+* #
''6
& ''6
%
6 % " .
"
& 6 '6 " 6"
' 9 " 0
& "%'+"'
" ' 0
##.
" # /" ' #&
'.0"/0 %
"
& &
0
& % +
1 <& " 0
/ "'0'. 6- 1%
#"
&& (
) 5"
!(1 :
+ 0(&&
3
0& = F= " %+
# % "&%&
0 "
%'+ 6
"/ #. "/ % "
. %/"
6 " #0 6 ' %'0 7% +
" # '
& 6 F
7% '.0 " %+
%0 5<)/ '' "& % D =
%1"
( 6",46 0@ )#
"
&
" . 6"
/ 1 ./
#" # : 7%
' %&"' 3 6'.0 " && ' ''/ 5" &&''
7%
" "
6 # "# 5"*%6#
2 7% '.0 # ' & +.
( #* $ %/ / $ "
7%
' %1"
( 6",46 0 #
( " &&''
' . + '0 ". % 5" + '+ "
6
#0.123#"$# +45*
#".&4*"2.&532.43+ +45* @" "& 1 6; H; @" "&
+' H;