← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7930/2014disposed of

Randhir Singh v. Rajinder Kumar Makan

2023-01-20Mr. Justice B.S. Walia6 pages



      

 

 !"#$# %&''  %()#*+#%,)$- +)*# ,

+#%,) . # %* /*$0$  1#%(*203 *4 %$- +)*#2*#$) %6 7 .'$8 %(%

3&

%9:74*'0$ #"'+';

7# *$% & 4*' #/#* /<+%# *(/ "

  4*'# #$)+) *3 <(/ "

 ! * # %*' 4*' ,$#3 

*#<(/ "

! * 4*' 1#%(* = 7<(/ "

 ! * )*$8 %(% ' >>> '+';

7# <'?* 7@ 

77%, #% # % #$  10(,3%  (

( 'A' $$( :=

=< !!#*3#%, *(*

( 'B' 8 $$( := *%( % (#$3#$$#%, )*% # %!#7(:= # %*' 

#3:! * * 77*C $! *1"

3% ! ) *$8 %(%  !* 3 $) 8  '< #*"07 *  ( 88 $# +"

B <D#77 ,0* #7< < *)<  % ),* 0%(

# %* *E0#*( ) $) 8 #% (#$80  ! * )#$ 8*$ % 7 0$ ""08

# %! **0%%#%,:0$#%$$ !( #*=8* (0"

$ % "" 0%  !$0!!#"#% F8*#%" *7#* # %*) (:%)78#%,)#$:* )*#%*0%%#%, #*=:0$#%$$#% *% ($) 8'%8  'G ! # %<# ) (:% 3% # %(

# %*) (%# )* ""08#(% */

%=$) 8#%

)0*:

% *)'  *)<C)#7(#$"0$$#%, )

  %(/#(%" ((0"(:= #$)7(

# %*) $088*$$(3

*# 7!

$C# )*, *( )#$) /#%, )*8* 8* #$#% /#"#%# = ! )(3#$(8*3#$$ %(:=*7=#%,08 % )("#$# % ! )#$

#% H 



   9<  )7(

)3 %(

" %

#%(0%(*+"

# %?@?##@

#% $ !% %*$#(% 7:0#7(#%, %(7 *(C $*E0#*( !!#*30%(* $0:"7 0$?:@

)C $%  ""08=#%,#% )0*:

% " %"*%(! *

)80*8 $ !)#$:0$#%$$ %= )*:0#7(#%, %(0%(*"7 0$?"@

) (% /

($0") :0#7(#%,C# ) 0 $0!!#"#% "

0$

#% #%$

 "

$< # %* ) ( %  87 ((

 ) C $ C%* ! $) 8  '?$

: % )!#*$ !7 * !$) 8 '@<:$#($ )* $) 8$% )(3#$(8*3#$$ %( %7= %"* $$F 3#%

# % !;<

) $ #( !

 ) ( :% F ( := ) 88 $#  $#(' "" *(#%,7=< # %C $(#$3#$$('  ) *(*8 $$(:= $ 08)7( :=

= /#( 10(,3%  (

'A' '7/ F )("#$# % ! #% H 

/*$0$

 

9?@6GB< #$*8* (0"( $0%(*&  

   

! "



!  $ %   &

!#

" !  " #

  !

    $

(!

)#  "

"( "

 

    !

" "#

 !

#

 

#

     (   

 !  

 

( &



 

(

 *

   $   &   " !   +  (   

 )" 

   

 #

"  )#    ( # (  (    &

, !!   

  

 -



     !## 

!"  !  !

   

 ! 

  

 &##

 -  

   ##

" ( "#

 (( 

#

  

!

 " #   # (

  

 

 $ 

&##

 -   

   #  !!

           



 )

. )) )) )) )) / 0   (



!     

 (    !  ## 

! "  ! &  " !    "  

)# #



+( 0 !



    )

( !  +



(  "  " 

)" 

 0!  1   ( " ) ! 



1)" 

+  

 (  !     ( !

   "  " 

 (

   "

 " "  

2

- 

   

 ( !

!

"     &

+ (  

   !



#+"

)# 

! )# 

#  0

    

"      

  

 "

#  !

 $   (

 0!   #

#!

 " !    ) !  

#  (#  #

  #

 "(

 !

$   (

 "#  !

 % 

 #  

 #!   

  ! #     #

 

   " !    !

 

# - "*

%   # "        (  !

 

 

!



 



(  "" 



 0

 !!     (





2

- !

 &##

- (  

 

   

#

 #  ( 2 *

!#

!(



&##

- ( 

# (

 (

!   #

( 

     $

 ( !!

! "  (



(  1        

 '## ! $ (

( 

 

(

"#

 

#

+

(

#    

   !  ""  )#



#

$ 





( 

         (  

 (  #   "

 3 +   



( 

 

! 

(  

!

" ! $ " 

  

( #

 





!

(  !

(  B )("#$# % ! $*!**( : /

$") 77%,(:! * )+08*3 %(/#( *(*(

 ''#% #/#788 7 $'A !< )+08*3

C $87 $( $ $#( ! *3% # %(10(,3%

%( *3 ) 3

*%( %

*)<C)#7,* #%,7#:* = %(7 *( 3%( )87

) *$8 %(%  !#7 *87= ) $ 3 7$  := 8*3#

#%, #$ ((# # % 7/#(%":= :$*/#%, $0%(*&  4 !    (

 ' #

  

! (   ##

  5  + !   !

 

#1"1!



!

( ##

(

!! 

  *

(

 

    !

+  ##

 "    (    

 6 G +#%" ) *%  8 # % C $ *1"

( := *%( %

*) )$ #(*1"

# %C $08)7(:= *%( 8877

= #% ) #%$

 "

$< 8*#3 *#7= % ) :

$#$ ! ("#$# % !  #% H 

 ?$08* @ 7$ 

5#%,#% "" 0%

)*C*%  (E0

87 (#%,$*, *(#%,

 !%(! *$

:7#$)#%, )%( ! # %*<$8"# 77=#%/#C ! $) 8 ':#%, % )!#*$ !7 *< )*! *<% :#%,$0#

:7! * *0%%#%, ( #*=:0$#%$$< 7$ #%/#C ! )!

)("#$# %#%  $8* 5) *9$ "

$ ?$08* @ C $ $ $#( := ) +08*3

<(3# 88* 8*#

$ $#( )#380,%(10(,3% $$( :=

= 08) 7(#%, ) *(* ! *%( % * 77* %( *3 ) 3

*%( %

*)< C)#7 ,* #%, 7#:* = # %* 3%(

)*$8 %(% !#7*87= )$ 3< 7$  )*#,)

#$ ((# # % 7/#(%"'  +#%" )*% # %8*

#%$ )= *<# #$(3(

88* 8*#

*E0$ ("#(

)3

* % )E0$ # % !

!%( ! # %* !*$) F8(# # 0$7= $ 8 $$#:7 %( #% %= "

$ %  7

% %= * !* 3

=' A  # %#  !C# ) ! *3% # %((#*"

# %$'     '' 7%  8  #* 9

: ;9<  #

 : ;9<