High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/378/2019dismissed

Harjinder Singh v. Manoj

2023-04-24Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil10 pages

-1-

!"#"$% &'

% ()'* * )

!"#$%&'"

(& ) )& ***** "$ '&+ (& " ++" ,- ()+). " "+# $

)&/012344#""")+$ 5$.6 $"

$7171# "$,-

$)')"+ ".) "

4+"# "5 "# $)6)). '&6 +") "$ "'8)

). &$ 9"''$ ) &( '". ("6$ ".") )6 $'

)&/1&( .& )",+ 6 '

2(&& : '

:3 ;"'

"+6"

)<&( ) )&(&+$" ++" =4&6 +")" "$ ()$+-+"

)&>) &$ =''$"$"$6 "+$ "$). $ &>)' ++" + #0?#777=9 & ''$(&)$&6 )'$ ) 6& &( +- 7 "$ ) +) &( &$ )$ " ') - '8&70@7$"

$7@7"6& ). &#0?#777=9)("%&&( ++" $">&4& &"

)&A" # ""

4&+&-#"5 ""$ "6>" $ & ")$," &077>)'>"$)&&$"$ $" B;C

C;; 4

D "$ "( " ++" )$ "+."+ & )'$"

$077 & &$ >)'>"& &&$ / "$ '&+ (& " +)'" '& $ )."

'8>& $)$"$"' )" 6 )& '8

-2-

",)$(&"%"+)$'&)$"

)&,- &$ ( ,6)

)"+'& "(")+$ & ) &"''& ("'

&$ " "$6)

$)+)",)+) - )"+'& "$)&+$). '8" ,6)$,- " +)'" ,-()++). " )'+",-)6+(

) ( " $ )"+ '& " &+- '&)$$ & " '

" ++" >"& ",+ & &% <"'

&( "-6 &(

+&""$& )%-.&$ &$ ","'8)

$+&# )"+ '& " (")+$ & '&)$ ("'

& ,$ &( &&( +) & ) )&&' '8. $)&&$"

)( & "''$ & &%

'8>"& )$(& $)'".&("-+)",)+) - ? "$+"$'&+(& " +)'" =" ++" E &$ ) ) 6 $ '

)& // 44# @0/ $)$ )')6)"

).6"

)"+ ,- ) )&#&>%"$6)

$ ("'

'8)8 )&,"))."

"$( ,6) ,+" '8 >" )$ " " ') - '8 & &"' "+ ). >&)"&%6 "')-"77".") ?7#777=9"$) ) &. "' "+ ). ,+" '8 "$ , "$$ &% & ++" ='&6 +")" >)' " , 6)$ "$ (&.$ ,- ()+). . "6& )+"' 0 )4& )&,+)%)&&( +."+ & &) )& $ '

)& /1 &( .& )",+ 6 '

# &' )& &'$ >) " 6 )&

"''$ )$ $)&&$ '8 (& $)'". &( " +."+ +)",)+) -=$, "$$ '

)&/@&( ")$'

#'&6 +")" )& 8)$

& &%)'"&' )"+).$) &( )'

)&" )6"("') 6"$ & # &>%# ")$ 6 )& ) ,

",+ "$ &' & ) $)'".$ ,- "''$# ) )( & '&6 +")" : & &% '8)8 )&))("%&>")$(&$)'".)."' ")+."+$,

-3-

"",+$) "6 ++- -"""-"""&% $)">",+ .-

%+& 6 .'- $#7E23424)6)"+3/1? 1 "+ &( ()+ &> " ++" " & , ",+ & &%<"'

&>)' 6&->"+ ; "'& "$)'

)& >) ."$ &) +"$)."$$ &) )&)'&<"6)"

)&&"$ "6& >" &, ")$>) )6& >"$).) '&<"6)"

)&"%&+ ")+-$ &$ +&">",&&>$(& 6& ++" % "$6) >" & )& $"+). , > 6

&>'&6'",)."6& ,+ & &$ >) & ,). "-+"

)&>)''" ""$&>& &-&( ++" "''$" & $)$))."

& $)&&$'8, ) ')()'$)"+

& "++.$()"')"++ (&6 '&6 +")" " )'+"+-) +).

&( ("'

'&6 +")" (")+$ & &$'"-%)$'>) ."$ &+$).&(

"6& & &$ >)''"& ,,+)%$"".& + #>)' ) "+& & & $ ,- "- 6 )&). &( "6 ) "- &( "''& ,&& 6") ")$ & '&66))&". ,)"$)'&6 "< +).

&( ")$ ')'6 "' "$ %)$' & ) )# ) 4& )'&%)'$ "''$ " ''(++- ,

$ 6 )& &(

)&1"$/@&( .& )",+ 6 '

@ ; # +">& 6 )&", &&.+-<"6)$"$ "$5$)'"

$#>)'$ &,+&& $"

)">++ 9

! " # " $ %&' ( % ) "#*

# $ %

-4-

& '

+( ,- .% /

0 !" 1 *

1!2 () * + $)++,- %*% . "

# "

& () * ! " - &

" "

! "

- &

() *

" ! " &

& " "

/ 0 1 "

-5-

! 2

3 "

2 2 3 4 ,* 3 ,. *

.- 0 1 !#"*

1 "1*

61 2 "

! 2 3

78 9

7 ,,:-

2 !

" ' 3

2 '

3 2 ! 3 2

789 ( ;

78 9

789 ! 7%,,,,:- "

3 ! 2

3< 3

3 ="

-6-

2 3

" / 4 /*( 0)# !"*

!"*

")*$ 2 .( -.

.5,*3 ,.0 1*

1!2 .& "/ 4 $ 0*

1 "1*

126*

&16& 17#>%5 !

() *

@ ( ) *

" "

- -"

& "

0>5

/ 0, . . 8.

9 0)# )")*

)#" 8)1* 2 .(

" *

&))6& * >,5! '

3 '

& " 3

-7-

B "

" !

" '

+ " & 3 / 0C9

+ /

:01 #" *

25 .(

&& #7!6& 71 %%@ "

- & % "

" & &

& !

" & &

; <* . 3 ,( && 0# !#!"*

#!"*

#2 0%A

! "

" 3

/ 4

-8-

" ! "

$ 00 ! > 3 **

.-,/0#1 1" # *

"# *

126 :

: * *

.-, 0!%&'

1 " ! ! *

# " ! *

!)2 : : =

0) " ) *

) ) *

!#2 % $ .- >(.& . ..( &. " ="

3 =

2 3

" #

# 1

3 !

# 3 "

" 3

" B " " "

3 ! @ 7 " 9 $

;

>%,,65+DE)C @ *0% $- "

-9-

' "

" F' " F 9

" 3

# "

/ 0A

! "

" G

# "

" / 7 ("'

"+ ,"'

.&$# +"

)&) &( " ) "$ "6& &(+&""&6&( )$)' &$()) +-'&6 & '&'+)&#

) )&'&+$& , 6 )&)("%&&( &$ ,).

&+$&( '8 ' )& &( %)$'# " ')"

)& &( +"> "$ ) " +)'"

)& & ("'

&( '",- )"+4& '"& ,("+ $ >) D " '+))'"+ &( $)')& 6"$ )",&% " ("'

"$+."+ & &) )&" +-). & ) " '"# &-&( " +)'"

-10-

" ++" (((&6)&$&, "$ 5$.6 &("'8)

"+ "$,-

)"+ 4& $"

$ 7171 $& & (( (&6 "- )++."+) -# )()6) - "$ %) -# (&# " +)'"

)& ) $%&)$ &( 6) '# "6 ) $)6)$ "$ " " + &( "''&6 ")$ 66& &( " "+ "+& "$ 5'

$ (SANDEEP MOUDGIL) & + ), A : H :

A H :