High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/735/2019dismissed

M/S International Coil Ltd. v. M/S Dlf Cyber City Developers Ltd.

2019-05-24Mr. Justice Sudip Ahluwalia17 pages

# $ %& '( !(! ! "" !#! "

$)*+!' *" ,, +!'-* . */$0 +!' *(!

1*'"*&(

!0*2($0!

! !!

3(!&,* *)*4+ +(( ! &* * ( " -* (!*+ "

!0-***!$0*

4 *22!&+

* !+((5+6$ "7 8*"

*!*0!*2& *+ "

!0 4$ ! *+ *2 $& -!!&* *" *,$ 1$! *(! 2 0 ! !

!&-*(

9+$* !0 *" *( ' . :

&5 !

;'8+ - ((&*( 2) &!'- 6 $*,( 00' * *(*2 $!&

!! - !! &* " * *

'$ * !*!&' ! &*(! $ ((0+ *-**- *( ( 4$<$!

(*( ( $ 4$!** !($!2$!& ! !' ,$*!& !&*" 0*(!* $ !'=$!05=$ '8>$ $0 2-*** (!*!& !

2!(0*"

2*2!"

2!* ! -( '-* * + "

!0 - ')! ,$* ( !0 * !0*" - !&& !

((! *-* #! * 2($0! ! * ! + 4! * !&* *" +(( 1* ' * & ! &* * (! 2-****$!!*$ !$72&'- *,$ ( ' * + + -** *' *

0 =$! ' + "

!0 6( -* ( ( 2!*+ !+5*

&?*+ +@89;'* -*& !!**! * !+ *!0** (! 4$ ! * 2 2 * + $2!* ! !

2 +*0*$ ! !

-** *( '-$! &2& '- * =$!+$* ( '!!* + +

, *+ +( '!7

9 / ( !0! *2( ,

<$!&'(( ( !' ,9 * + +-**( 2( + 1 &$

$-4$ ! 1* ', ( !$!

&-7 !" #$% & & '

' ! "

$ !

%!&

'!&

(!"

) %!) '!

*!"

) %! ) '! +

,!&

!$ *" *!!**( ' ! $! +

* $ ! 2&-*!0* 2(!$(4$! '&' $ , <$!&'1$(( * *,$( 2$ * $!%&'()&*+,&) -.'/' '(/&01/2/3445&367 7*&! -& '!* 7 - .

" 0./

0 & %%,

0 & '% 0

3 2 0 4 0

2 0

0 "

2 0

3 1*+(6$ * - !7 "

2 0 & %%,7%%8 4 0 & '% 0

0 1

& %%,7%%8 '% 0

1* " A ! * ! $( *

$/*A! *,$( 2$ $ 8." -.

8. &953':/'55)/': !9(')0/2/3 445&3 6 ;7

* =$!02 * (- * =$

0 !0((2 + 58$! , 2$(

! -** *2*((&6

+!2 ' =$!(- + *$ -!

- ( *& '2!" *=$!02 -***!&!7 9 4 ,

: ;): ;

4 5

9 & <

4 ,

4 8! &

4 , "

4 &

!$ *" * !* ( !($ * &-***$ !& -**,$(!0-$!&--*

0* $ *( -*!0 +0 2 &- *2 $ * % $2

2 * !($1$(( *$&2

*$ -!

-*! *+(6$ $< 335'&'(&,/39''=-.",5/'&'=5!9().0

> ?" -**-*!7 0. 7

5 &

; )

= !

$ ! $ !

!$ !

,2 $/,&':'/'95)4)/.5.-.*&,&3@559"/':% %3+A&3/&0

> ?>5'9? *+(6$ !2!

*((! !0*=$!02 *+!! 4$!0,$*; -*-**-

2!&* * .0* $ & ' $ -** ,$ ! & * ! !

' * 1 ! 1A+(($! ,3 *+ +- 4! & '07 %'

> <; & ? 2 -

0 / < ! +

@ @ /

) = ', "

) )

= !

$ ! )

$ !

!$ !

%* B

@& 9**

4 '! &

1 %, "

& "

4 '! &

& &

7 -

" &

0 0 - 4 ' & &

& &

?&9)&@"9+(/.>?!9(-.&2)&':"9+(/.0 7 > ?

" 1*!&*!&*,$( 2$ 7 5 "

04 0 !

& (!

. &

0 .

. 0

0 &

@& 4

04 0

0 -

04 0 - 0

- 0 0

04 0

0 0 -

0 0

4 .

0 ) 0 4 0 0 0 - .

0 0 0

1*+(6$ * ! 0*+ $ * 0 +0 2 &- * ( & ( '

$ * -& '7 %( -

4 %5 < @2 B 2@ 0 & 9(8

C F

0 < +B

F7 C

?3 ! 04 0

) ) +

) )

0 < 4 5 & & + & "

) )

04 0

!$ *(!**-' !

- *$ *$&<$$/*A! * ,$( 2$ * $ 8."-. 8.&953 ':/'55)/':!9(')0/2/3445&36 ;7

,( -!

-* -0& '2!" 9 *!-** $ -7 (( -

2 0

& %%, %%8 0 -

4 '8 +

G 4 '(

)

4 , & "

4 '8 &

" "

& "

2 0

2 0 & %%, %%8 0 -

4 2

(* "

;

2 0

& %%8 0 -

& %%, 0 -

4 '8 &

(, 1 =

!!666666666 !3

2 0

4 '8 &

4 '( &

'- *&'2(*B!6 *!( $!

8." .0=&.5>.+4)&?*$ *'- *( !0+ 1 &$$!0! !!-4$ !&*0!$! +

*$& *.0*$ ! * ! !$(&*" A!-$!& *( * &0 !!* -0" 0 (* 9

*2! ?

8." .0 =&.5>.+4)&? 0!&* " A!* 6 *2*2( *+ 1 &$

$-4$ !-**$&472 &' !

*( ' ,9<$! ( /$

2*& ' *$/* !

! !' ! 9

* 2 (

!$&0** ! !(!&+ 1 &$ !$ 0*$ *( !0(!0& &

!-*&=$!+$* $!0.0*$ $!

6(-*( ( '!!" * + + 1* ! ! * $ /* * '

! * ! ?! %&'()& *+,&) .0=&.5>.+4)&?-*** =$! ' ( !$! & * $&<$ 2 *2!!+ +$!*''2 $( ! 1*!?!%&'()&*+,&) .0=&.5>.+4)&? - ( $!&*$/* '+(( -**-!2!*,$( 2$ -&)31* ((& +

*$2$(

! *!*6 * ' 0 $ * 0&- +!2 '1 &$+3

-**- * 0-**$2, "- ! *+(6$ 1*& '!( !0" C3

* =$!02 - * 6 * (- & !*1 &$-**- !$! + 7+C / *$!*( $ *!+(( - * +!2 '1 &$-***!

2 6 * 2 1* ' 2!$ *2(0 !*1 &$* *,!- !( " 3 ( !$!&'**6 ( ' &$58$!$! + 7+!/$! -)-

2*4$ !

!$(.0*$ $! +

!$(,$( 2$ $! +

*$-**( *'&& $$ $

$!*** $ !1 &$2(

2 $((2 !* 00 * (-

! & * + -**4$ !&$! 3 -!&!**2!!+ +*!

&!0 *'+((*!&!2!3 !2!!( '$!0, 0=$! '*!2$( =$! '-/$*2

* & 2( *' ! * $&<$ $A /* ! ?

8. " .0 =&.5 >.+4)&? -* * +(6 $ *! ( *! * ( !0 + 1 &$&*0!6 +

* $ 6( -* $* B!

$! *+ !*-*!0(*

0 ! + !!" * *$ *!&!

-" *,$( 2$ A=$!02-** *!*!*((2 + &**

=$586 =$!!+!2 '+$* /$*( $ & '" !-**

<$ 0 !02( *=$!+$* *0 + "

!0-*( 2!& *+ 6 (- $! +

* $-*** !&$&<$" 9 *' 24$!02*'&(( '! &* $/*

D* *!?<335'&'(&,/39' '= .0=&.5>.+4)&?2!" &'&!* -( $!*&)0 $! $ *$

*!($ $! ,3 *+ ++ 0**$+ 1 &$-$!, * -<$ =$!+$* *'0 !

+(( " 0 * + 1 &$A ( !0-* $*( !0$!' *') ( -*$ $ $ * 1 &$ 1* * !?<335'&'(&,/39''= .0=&.5>.+4)&? *( $*"

,2 ?/,&':'/'95)4)/.5. .0=&.5>.+4)&?

" 0*( !0*! $ 4

*1A+(($! ,3 *+ +& *+!! =$!0-**!-

2!&** .0*$ -*+(6$ *0+ &$*!' &$!*+(( + - !2!! $**<$

*00 * ( !0 & $* 76 + &$$!*'

?&9)&@"9+(/.>?!9( .0=&.5>.+4)&?*,$( 2 $ *!! !( '+ $* 0 +0 2&-*( 1* ( '( * =$!02(!&*+(6$ *((&7 %5 -

F %5 986 "

*$**-$

!2 *+(( + -***!

&-!*.0*$ '*0 ! (!

&*1 &$ -0*$&472 *! !* ' -2!* + + *=$!02 *,$( 2$ -!' !-&) 3 -** 2 * & * 2!!

+ + *! ' 2 ( ! ' * !& *(*"

D**$*!0*( !0

! (!&* + 1 &$&*0!$! +

*$6(-*( 2!$! *+ $

9 - * ( ' ( 0 * 2( *+ 1 &$ $-4$ ! & *(*" 1* ',9 * + +* !& ( !$!" 9 + $ !0 , 95 8 5 8 58 ! 5 8 0 *- *04$ ! *+ 1 &$ (** &$6!0*( +$* &)* ( $ &0 **$&2 2 ! !*2 0!&&!*( *1 &$A $* ! (' E $ * &$ !0,958! 2!

2$* ( ! *!4$ !/$ !0,95 -* *1 &$)! 40* *( <$ !$-**+ ( !0!2) + +- !1* !0,9598*00 '!

( (( 0! $*+- ! !-* , *+ * *',9! 2( ( ( *0 * + ( !0& (0 * +- !*1 &$* ! 2!*(! 4$ ! *!($

% * ! *$ !4$

0-**2($0! ! (!&*+ 1 &$ ! &$ !*<$

*1 &$A2(!4$ ! * !

!($$-* *1 &$-$!-*$ =$! '!*& +(($!

,3! *+ +<$'- * $ /*A ! ?

8. " .0 =&.5 >.+4)&?*$ *4$ ! *0 *2($0! ! !*" * &0! -*$ *+ "

!0 -** **0$*+- ! E ! * &

0 , * ( ( '( 20*2! $! *+

9 1*( '+((* !2!1* 2( !0 *+ 1 &$!'!

-**& '**( ! *&$!* ! 2 *1 &$ *($ ( , + * + + >" !#!?

+, D** ()0

!F G

D** ( &F G