High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7957/2014allowed

Exide Industries Limited v. Manpreet Kaur

2015-08-24Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

#$%&%'()(*+

,(&%*&-)$.(%)/(0($%& %1()(*()$ 2%.)-) 30$!#*4.%%$5#-.

%)4*&%*$

!+ 6/ ! 3 5 /3 .%)%*$+7 !. 8%$#*!($$#9:3%*(.&1'#$%:;($8:

!.3#0(.#$8.%#*&!.2(4-9:&1'#$%):

.$8%.%1()(*()$ *%..%)4*&%*$

<8%$8%.$8%%4.$%.)9'#9*%;)4#4%.0#=>%#99;%&$)%% $8%?-&@0%*$A >%.%%..%&$$8%%4.$%..*$ <8%$8%.$8%?-&@0%*$)8-9&>%.%4.$%&(*$8%&(@%)$A 77 77 /3 : /"

04-@*%& (* $8% 4.%)%*$ .%1()(* () $8% .&%. &#$%&

**%,-.%77":4#))%&>=$8%9%#.*%& (1(9-&@%-*(.

-&@%": 8#*&(@#.8: 1(&% ;8('8 $8% #449('#$(* $8% 4.%)%*$ .%1()(*()$-*&%.3%'$(*$8%.>($.#$(*#*& *'(9(#$(*'$:

B(*)8.$6$8%'$6":..%%..(*@$8%&()4-$%$$8%.>($.#$.;#) &()0())%& 8% >.(% #'$) $8% '#)% #.% $8#$ $8% 49#(*$( .%)4*&%*$8%.%(*":;8()$8%;(%%?(*&%.#93(*@8:8#&(9%&

77 #)-($.4%.0#*%*$(*?-*'$(*..%)$.#(*(*@$8%&%%*&#*$.0 %*.'(*@ $8% #@.%%0%*$ &#$%&

: %,%'-$%& >%$;%%* 8%.

8-)>#*&#*&.%)4*&%*$.%1()(*()$8%.%(*"$())$#$%&$8#$)8%() 9%@#9 @-#.&(#* 8%. 8-)>#*& %?(*&%. #9 3(*@8: ;8 () $8% 4.4.(%$. ! ) 8#&8# #*& 04#*= * #@.%%0%*$ &#$%&

;#) %,%'-$%&>%$;%%*%?(*&%.#9 3(*@88-)>#*& 49#(*$( .%)4*&%*$"#*&$8%&%%*&#*$8%)#(&#@.%%0%*$()1(& #>(*($(-*&%.3%'$(*

$8%*&(#* *$.#'$'$:

*#44%#.#*'%:$8% 4.%)%*$.%1()(*()$ &%%*&#*$(9%& #*#449('#$(*-*&%.3%'$(*$8%'$:)$#$(*@$8#$-*&%.'9#-)%

$8% @.%%0%*$ &#$%&

: $8% 0#$$%. () $ >% &%'(&%&>=$8%.>($.#$. 8%9%#.*%& (1(9-&@%-*(.(1()(*": 8#*&(@#.8:

8%9&$8#$$8%)-($8#)>%%*(9%&*$8%@.-*&$8#$$8%8-)>#*& $8%49#(*$( .%)4*&%*$;#)*$(*4.4%.0%*$#94)($(*$%,%'-$% $8%#@.%%0%*$8%.%.%:'9#-)% $8% @.%%0%*$()*$ #$$.#'$%&(*$8%4.%)%*$'#)% 8#1%8%#.&9%#.*%&)%*(.'-*)%9.$8%.%1()(*()$ #*&8#1%#9)'#.%-99=@*%$8.-@8$8%(9% 8%.%)4*&%*$&(&*$#44%#.:&%)4($%*$('%#*&8%. '#)%8#)>%%*'*)(&%.%& 4%.-)#9$8%49#(*$)8;)$8#$$8%49#(*$( .%)4*&%*$ ())%%C(*@.%9(%*>%8#98%.8-)>#*&%?(*&%.#93(*@8:)$#$(*@

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

%:$8() -.$()$ )%%#)$;8%$8%.'9#-)% $8%#@.%%0%*$()#$$.#'$%&(*$8% 4.%)%*$'#)% 9#-)% $8%#@.%%0%*$().%4.&-'%&#)-*&%.+7 *= &()4-$%: &(%.%*'% . E-%)$(* ;8('8 0#= #.()%#$#*=$(0%8%.%#$%.>%$;%%*$8% 04#*=#*& $8% #*&@%*$$-'8(*@$8%$.-%'*)$.-'$(*$8() @.%%0%*$ . $8% .(@8$) #*& 9(#>(9($(%) $8% 4#.$(%) 8%.%$)8#99-*9%))$8%.;()%8%.%(*%,4.%))9=4.1(&%&: >% .%%..%& $ #.>($.#$(* # )(*@9% .>($.#$. $ >% #44(*$%& >= $8% 04#*= (* #''.&#*'% ;($8 $8% )->?%'$ $ $8% 4.1()(*) . $8% .>($.

*'(9(#$(*'$: B8%1%*-%#.>($.#$(*)8#99>% 59C#$##*&$8%4.'%%&(*@))8#99>%8%9&(* *@9()8F

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

)?C)