High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2107/2021dismissed

Ramesh Lal v. Deepak Jain And ANR

2024-10-01Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl17 pages

"# $#% &'(#

# )*+(,)-#&#

# ) #$-')..#/!,)-

01#,)-

# 0%*2% #%#+,)- ##&

"##-& ,4!4+ !.#& &'(0 ( -! -, !!. 4 *%.

5 6 &"7 8656- /#&%#069#+:#4#! ;-),<6!4+#&.&# &#/#&&7 %( #',)#+0 * ,0#1!4#,/#4!!/&#/ #- /&#/ # ## !!.!4 *%.

8 <

& ) 7 < - / )&&!! )%#+ &&! ! 4+ &# ! . *%.

5 6

1#&###&! 6-&/#&6& &7 , &!.6&/# %4!#/!!#!

4%4##%4+#&7 &'( = /%!4#!-#&7 #,- ##4&6 6 >.&&!! &#., &# /%,%##!!. 4!4+ )4#4-, &##-&!./ &+.#-&- 4!/#&0&7 =&#.#&6 4 -&6 )?%#" ,#&-

!-# /#&#@%# & @%%4+#&7 &'(

=/-###&&'(/& 7 /&/# &#/ &//#*.&@% &7 !!6&/##@%###%.4%/!!#! 6&/# %4!# /!!#!4%

=/#!+-&#&7 /#/##&&/#%#+ -#%&#/6& 0&7 ,

6 /&# /# %4! =/%##&! #&/#%&+#&A

#!4%!.

+/##-+'+&##+

4%!.#+#< <#-+-#-+%& = /%##&!##&/#&##

##" (#&7 &'(/ /#'. # A "+# ! # ! / / ! &#&##&#" (/#/.!#+ ,A&# -# /#%.4% %,/!/#'.# ,#&7 . ?&#4% B.#%#-/4 #/#### =-&,/!&! &#&#+@%4&%#4+#&- /!6 %,4+&# !/,&#4 #

B/&##&!/#!-& = #&!+

)?%#" !4+&# !,&#%!#!+&#.#&&#! #+4* , /&%&/&#4.4%!./ /!## &!&# =/&! #&#/4%,#&# /#!- =/%##"

(/!&#&### A"+# ! # !

B#!!#-/&#*%.

- ,5 6 !!/4&%#06!4+

#&##-&# # &7 .#%&#!+ )&#%!*%.

5 6 &&# !/%!/ #!!#'#!!#!-& %#%7 ///#&4#@%# =/ 4#-4&#-### A"+# !

# !(/!&#&##&" (/ #& ,-"C67-2% #,B?) !./% &#%4+ ;?

"C6A;?

"C6A6 !&#?#%##&7 &'(;?

"C6A ;?

"C6A/#'# ;-% &#%4+ "C D.#, 4%#=&#,/&#%#.# ### A"+# ! # !;?"C A;?

/#!'#4# .!% # A"+# ! # !(/!&#&##& " ( =&#.#& *%.

,/!4#- #&44!&#-#&#%# # ##.#,-"C>0+4#0.,0%4 =&#,E0%&&!+,/&#-##;? "C>A ;?

"C>A8%###&&'(/-. &#### #4##0##!- -#.#/!'#

&&#!+,/4#-"C8 &'( !&&/4?%&&# -# &&! !#!+"C" (

8 !%&&##&%## #&&'(//#'.&!4%##/ .. ,A!#+&# &7 , /# %4!#4%! #&#&# #&# @% B /#&7 &'(# !!#'+ #&!'&!/! B-&# / ! %!+ ' # 4# &. -##

B&&!!4+&# #/#! 4+)&&!!)%#+ )&#%!*%.

8 < &&#&# !)</%! /-#+#.% #4!&##/%!+ #/#*#&#%.## B#.% # A"+# ! # !/*9%E !+ 4%%,#&&'(/4#+#%# / %!+ # #* # '. # % ## !%. % ;?

"C8A, ;?

"C A,;?

"C6A;?

"C6A ,;?

"C A;?

"C / /# /!&#&##&" (

#!4 #? C8/ " (/!&#&###

;- #/ &# /!./#%##& 7 &'(/ 4## A"+# ! # !

> # /!&#&##&" (

B#.% #4!&# &7 , ,,4 -#!.&, /!'#/4#-&7 , /#% #/# #%4!## 4%#&//#!!+!& 7 , =/%##4#-/&&!. #&6&/# %4!###+.% 4%/!!#! $#%*%.

9F4!0%&# %#/!!%#/&!!+!/ &##.-!!#.-&&# #@%# &%../&4. -#!!#/&#% & #@%# !!# /# ' # ;-!/&## %#-#*%.

!!##A#,/! ' # B ! -#+ & / ' ###. ,/4#-/# &/# /',#&/#&.%& ##/###.!!&,./ #%# &/# #%4! # & / 4 -!4! # !. * &&!!!#A#&/4 .% =/4#-!!#/4*%. #@%# %,&&!/#.!+

#%!#&#!!.4- *%.

/& B#&#4+!#%!# &#/# A"+# !

# !/ !+# /!&#&##& " ( / * 9% E !+ 4% #&4." (4##. 4%%,&!#4+#&- &/ &!+ # / #-.% ,A!#+&# # # / ## =%&&##.% ,!#%!#&# ###&!/4?4;? "-!0% 4/" (4##,.##

. &##&#.#&6 &!.!.&#/###+.% *4% /!+ <5, #/ #! !+ ! &# !+! ," (/ .-# A"+# ! # !,%& = %4 # &!.,&&#&#&#+/ (9%E !+&#&#+#&4.4##.

B #.% # 4+ !# %! # &##!.-&, + &-!!-#&%,#& ##+#4%& =%&&##.% , !#%!#&####&!;? CA

5 /4?)?%#"6!./-!-7 .!.&7 ,6, ,, &7 -!!- =%4 #&/#&# &, 4 %!!!# &/-4 -#!. &#-& =#.%-/%4@% -,/-&!4+#&#-4 #* &%.###-4

#%!##&!!##, &&4#-&%4 *%.

#!!#)&&!!)%#+#/!!# !#-&4. #!#-4 = %4 4%#-.-./#& #@%# #&#%# %#4. =#.%.#- #/!/#-4%&! C#&#.%

4!&#&# , A"+# !

# !4.!&#&##&,% % 4#% -4&#%4+#&4# #!!#/!!)&&!!)%#+//%!/ !&#&##& =%4 % /. ?#%#,##!+./ 4%#=&#-!4 %!+?4-/!%.C8-, #? # ! &#&##&" ( =%##-

< #&##.&#!+# ##!4 &#-4+%4#.#,-"C>0+4# 0.,0%4=&#E0%&&!+,/&#%&#- #!-% !%.##4.!. = -#%!&#%!&!% ;? "C A !

,/4.!.4+!#%!# &#/%!/-+#<5,4 # #" ( =%##%4 %%!

&.*%.

# 6 6 <5 /4?4;?

" !

/#4+# A"+# ! !!!# " (

=%##%4 &!/#&-& 4.-!4!#!.-&+/+ %##&# =%4 &## & &!.-&&7 , / # # %4!, 4 .!. - &# ;?

CAG&!&#%4+&#&# H,#&# -# !+%4!, %,&7 ,&%& #,/#,#&& # = %##&7 -#+ !!&/ %#.

8I?8I,/#,&7 88I?<I =- &7

,#! !!& &#&7 &#&. #&7 /#&,/&#&#!!-

=#.% &# /-4/;?

CA, &#%4+&#,&7 6,#& 4%#&. =%###.%-&# #' 4&,!,&7 ,/%!4 #%4! ###+.%4%#&

B%##!#%!#&# &#%&&#4'&*%. #!!# 5 6 )&&!! )%#+ 8 <#!#/!/#-4%&! 4 &# #- & 4. #!, #- 4

1 %# %##!+ % &#* 4+ #& &# 6 4 - & / .%4.4#%##'. # % - ## B# &#-#+#!!.!+. B#.% #4! &## A"+# ! # !/ !&#&##&#&4##. %,&!#-&#& &'(//#'.# /#. ,A&#

/!, &!!+ - )&#%!## *%.

4#!%#/!!E#)&&!!%# /%!/###/'# !%# /!&#&##&" ( B-% !%-"C67-

2% #,B?)/&#-#%#&#&##+ # A"+# ! # !-4!4+" ( ) &#%!;?

"C6A/%!/= B?%## ) J#<,&!!+4" ( . /&#&## A"+# ! # !

(#%#4%!+.4+" (

;-,&#?% &'(#& 7 -!4'#4+%# !% A"+# ! # !(!&#&##& &' ( / !+ /#'. &!+# #%#

"C6A8/#%## +#/#& &'(/%!/%#.K # !#+L, &!!+ 4 !#+ ? ,,A4#-# A"+# ! # !( ;- ;?

"C6A,/!#%#&'(# +#<%#.K # !#+L,4 !#+#-4+&'(# A"+# ! # !

( ,<,A E%##"C D.# 4%#=&#4 ? ,/&#%###.####

A"+# ! # !(;?

"C A;?

)&#%! ;?

"C A/E# MEF!!%&%#"%*40&

#! ;4! ), <85 /%! / 4! 4 A"+# ! # !( +&4! 4!&#&##& &!+#/%!4# ###&#&##4

" ( )44+E#)&&!!%#&# ,-C8,/4? / !,! #? " ( !&#&## A"+# ! # !(%,.4 %## !&#&##&"

(44&#-##!!.!%,!!# ## ;-&!/#!4&!%&4+ !#%!#&# ;?

"C A,/%!!/ &#6,4#4#! !+! # #" ( #-#, #&&'(/#/.!#+# # / %##&#-# = B?%#/-4### #4-%,4&!#- &&!##

B #.% # 4+ !# %! # &##&!!-#!. -&&%!4%4+#&!!#

#@%# &%.###-4 &,!#-4#* =#.#,/%!4 #!-##&#6 4 -&!4+#& !!#/4&!!+&7 , /# %4!###+.%/!!#!4% /#&7 &'(/##+% "#6 4 -&6 !&# !#&#%#4!/

! " # $# %

" &'((() * #

# # # ## #* # #+ '('& , #

#+ '('& + '( '&'' # # + &&-

$# , # + &''

$#./

# # $) 0 + '( '&''

1 " # &-2- " %

)&#%!4-/%!/ &!! /#&#&!!&-4.-& -# - 4 / # / !/ = &!!+4-##&7 ,# %4!#

/!!#!4% BE#)&&!!%## #.#!/##4#-&7 ,, /#% #/# #%4!#4% #&/#&7 , ,!! .#+/4#-&#&!,&/- 4 -#!.&&!#* /#&. ##/#/#&. #/# & =/!4#--!4!+!#& 4' &,&.##/#%!4 #4%4!#4%&%#&/ & /# /'/# % #%4!##+4%

B.E#)&&!!%#&##&#% #4!/

# # & 2 &( &4 '( 5, "67& 5, "678 5, "9' 5, "98 "

"#$ %

& '()**!) +, '-!.! -/0 1/)! * !

& '2 !

'( '&'': ;

8 # & 2 &(&4 / * $* # # # # # #

,,, ,,, ,,, ,,, &2 $ # # # 34 &*) 0 )

# #

" 1 $ # , #

# #

# # # " 1 ## !) & !

3&& 5)67!

) 6, # #

##3

)% "7& ,-58+

> 5 *

$ 57

87!

) -- " 1 *

$ )3&&) 0 6, < == 3 5

)&#%!&!;?

CA,/4&#% 4+&#4?)?%#"6/%!! %!!+#+4-. 0&7 88?</# &7 8?8,&7

>?<,&7 ?,&7 ?,&7 /4< ?&7 6/4<?<%,& 7 #4..##& )!!+,&7 , & ##.%%#%, /%!4 %4! #,&7 -#+ !!

N 8?8/#&7 .%%# & &7 , ,6!&%&##/# &%& # ;-&7 , ,6,& ##/#& # B%,- ,&!&#%4+'#, !&&#&!'4+#&!!# &7 ,,# #%4!,.%4 -# !+4%4 =4#.!+4#- &%.*%.

%##&#% &

#@%# !!#4!!# 4*%.#@%# ##%# -#*%.

!!##A#%,*%. #!!#/!!)&&!!)%#+##/ !/#-4%&! B#-&4. #!,#- 4 #.!+,

)!!&. !!%&&!,+,!! &-/4-*%.

""#

$%&'%&()*&+,-./0(&+)1.&2 &)01 $%&'%&((&*1('+34& &)01