Ajam @ Billu & ORS. v. State Of Haryana
!!
# $% !&&' ( ))&& ' * + , ) !"# $%&'( )*+,-( !.,/01! "!
$%&'( )*+,-(2)'3,40,$51 - * # ,.$ / / ( .!( &0 1/! ! & 0 &/-'# 2
!.,/01! "!6
3(! )) &!! ! ' ! (#'1$ 4
2,& ! ! &*!5'1/ 6''7( /!*! 8 /9(2, '# $ &!
!&&'/ #'/*( ( ( !$ /*( 2/* &$ &!
*' 5
&!
*'9 ( 19! ( ! ( )'!( 2&' * !:
/:8/"
8/ 8;- 3(,9 ! ' * !"
8;- '1!$)!$ &! ) ,! /< ! '& ) ,$ !/ (,9! ' ( '1!$)&!$)!$ ($ ( 3(,9 ! '* !:8;- '1!1'!$)!$
)! , ) ,! /< ! '& ) ,$
!/ (,9! ' ('1!$)&!$)!$ ( $ ( 3(,9 ! '* ! 8;- '1!1'!$)!$ )!!=$ ( && ( 9 ' ' &, 3( () ' !! ' (&&! (
->46!) &*!1(&1 ( $)& ! /?= -"/ ( ( (,9 '2 ( ! +!! 9 $ ! 9 !!1! !&& 1* (&! 3(,9!!1!!&& 1$ )' (& ,
! (!1( / (,9&)!1! (' 7!1 (! $ & +! (3 ( 9 &)!1 ! (!('
2' :
/ (,( ( !(! ( 3(, &&97') !$$!
&, 3(, 9 ( () $9! ( 9 !1 ( 3(, ( 7!&& ($! (, ! 7 ,
! @9 ($9 &7!1' ! ((' 3(,99 !1 ( ) 3(,9( !1 ( 3(,9 &7!1!& 1'
1 3(, ( (9(& ! &&,!1! ((' ( & (' +!2 (A () & 7 ( !& 2 (! (/ ( ($1 2&9(!( 3( !& 9 ,$ ( ) 3( / (,' (! (&,!1! ()&2& ;#' () & 3 ( 9$ !!+)!
&/-(9 /2, $ - 7 ( ! $ 3 ( 9 -0;
( !1 ( +! @;9 1! 3( /! !1 !9 $)& ( && 9 )' ') $)& ! && ( $ &! ! "
3() ' != $! '$29! !')) ( 3( $ ( '9 & '* !
" "
" - 3(,! ( () ' ! 3(,9 !
/ ! (! 2 + / () )) & :
B '& )) !1 2( & ( ($ &, 1' ( () ' !( !& )! B '& )) !1 (* ($ &, 1' ( () ' !( )! 2, 2&'2 ')) (#'1$ ( & ' 2&9 >( ( & '& () ! 1 ('1( (#'1$ , '&&, -> A *
& ' () $ $= $! ! (2,3 ( " +)- $ $) + &(!! 2,!&!1 ! ! /?= -: ;(!)!!/ ( ' (9 ' ! 2 & $ 1 C' 2&' '$ ( && (!#'!9 $ $! ' 3()2 2& !$& ) 2 9!#', (9 ' , 2 9 ( ) $ $= $! !9 4(' -> A 6 0') / '
&! ,!
&! /* 9 !
!!+)!
&/-(9 /( $! &1 &&,= $!3 ( + ( ! (&&9!1!#'!(!2, D! 3(!"& 9'& &)!E: $ " $/8 $= $ &)= !1') $!& &)/2)/( ,2&!1) ! 3 * !! 3(!)'2&!1$$' ( !!! 3(2 (, 9&&2& 7! &'9! (&1!( !&!1( -')!& !& F -> *;*( ! $) ( " : /( 7 && ( != ' 3(,$ ! &' $ ! @; 4:
:
" : ' !&&' &!
E $'! &' $ ( ( (! !1!1(
<
/( &19! (
'* &$ &!
*'/ #'/*( 2/* ( ( ( &!
$ 5
&!
*' '!#'! ()&)!1! ( 9 ! '
!!&& 1$ )' $$! 22, ( ' , #9&&, +!! &' $ !?= - 3( / ( ( '
&$ ! &' $ !?= -/?= -"/?= -:/?= - ?= -8 : /( !! 1 ( ' 3(,' ) ! &' $ / (2 !9(! ( '5 *!1(1 ') ! 7& /9(! ((( 7) &! ( !&& 1 ( ' #' & $ ! &' $ (2 !9(! ((1
/9(! ((( 7) & & !&& 1 *'$! ( ' *( 2 ! & ( ( ( 7) & / 9 !& ! ( !&& 1 ( ' * ( ( ( &!
$ ! & ( ( ( 7) & 9 '* &$ &!
*'! & ( (( 7) & 1&
$2!& ' !&&' &!
E $! & ( 9 !1 $2!&( 27) &2,(!$ ( '&1 ( $ 3( $ ?= -4 ?= - 3(
! &9 ) (! &' $ ( '! ( ) '7(/6!) &*!1( *;;(9 *!1( 6!) &*!1( '7(6'$ ! !! (#9&&, -> *;-$*!1() ( ( '9! 1 2,(!$!@; 4: " :
->8*;;(9 *!1() ( " : / && (
'9! 1 2,*;*( ! $ 3(!!! !
& $ ?= - /?= -/?= -"/?= -:/?= - ?= -8 3( / && ( ' ') ! &' $ !?= -4 ?= - / (2 ! 9(! ( ! &9 ->46!) &*!1(! (,9!
/ (,( 1 &)! ((' $ ! ( $ 7!1$ & +! (3
( 9 &)!1 ! ((' 2' / (, ( !(! ( 3(, &&9 7') 3(, 9":) !1 ! (!(' 3(,9 ,!1 ! 7 3(,99 !1
) 3(,9( !1 (9! ( ($ 3(, ( ( ! (, ! / (,9'& &27!&& @9)9 !1' ! ( (' && ( !& 9 ) 7!1 & & & 1'
1 3(, 7) (!1 (2= ( ! &&,!1! ((' 2' ( & (' +!2 (A () &C' ( !& 2 (! ( (!/ ( !& 1 2&9(!( 3( !& 9
,& !1 ( ! & 3( / (,1 ') 9 ( (! (9 &,!1! )&2& +! (9 72,$- 7 (! (! !!+)!
&/-(9 3( /(9 -0;/ ( !1 ( +! $ !?= -" ;(!) / !9$ : 3(9 7! )! ;(! = $! !/ () ( (9 $)& 7! ((' B!1( 9 $!1$' ! 3( '$ !! ((' 2' ( & ('
-> * 2!*!1(( & 2 ( $ (! 2 (->46!) & ! & ($ !9(! ( (! ! (
8
7)& + &) ( (! (9 &)!1 ! (!(' + &( (! (G ! +!2 (C' ( !& 1!!#'! (! ( +9 &1! 2&9 ;(! = $! !/() ( ' !& 9) !! ( (' ( !& 9 !1' ! (('
"
-> " ;) A (9 ) ( ( 9 ) ;) <*+-&! * !/-(9 +)) ('1(! )& / ?= -:
'!1! !1 !/( $ 79 ( ( $! ! (
7)& ( 1! '& ' & $0'&( 6( ! + &)) '1(! )& )& ' @ $+'0'&( 6( !
:
->4 6!) & *!1( ( 2 ( $ ->
* 2!*!1( ->46!) &*!1( 1!
&&,) ( ( 9 ,!1 (! (!( 3(! ! !9! 2,->46!) *!1( -> * 2!*!1( 3(,( ! !! ( '! (' 3( ( 1!2 !1 (! ( 2 ( +! (! !-0;/( !1 ( A () &9 &1!!#'!(!( 2, (
*'! ! &!1( 9 !& 2& 1! ( !& 3(
!& ( $ ! &' $ (2 !9(! ( ! 9 = $! !A () &9
& () ' !
-> A *
&/ 9( ' ( ) $ $ = $! ! (2,3 ( /)! ( ( ' (9 ' ! 2 & $ 1 C' 2&' '$ ( 3( !#'!9 $ $! ' 3()2 2& !$& )2 9 !#', (9 ' , 2 9 ( ) $ $ = $! !9 4('
4
3 ! !!
! ) 9 , ! (
9 1!2,->46!) &*!1( -> * 2!*!1( !1 ($/ ( $ !!(' '! ! !$ 3(
( $ ,C' ! !!
!)
3(!B(!)+G2& (*')$' !
!$! &:8/( (& ( !&' (& ! !!
!) 9'& $ 7! $!!2&! ! !!
!!' 3(!B(!)( (& ' :
1 ( & !$ ( ! !!
! ( '2, (9! 9'& '2 !
() ' ! / $! &, ) ' !9! ( ! !! ( ' 9(! ( $ ( ( ) ' ! ! ( '! & !1 1 &'&/! !!
! ! ' '2 !! 3()') ! !!
! ! &, (&) ( ! !1 !1 1 , 9( ( ( ! !1 !! ( !) !1!
!1( ! ! ; ' !9/ ! !!
! ( 2, ,) ' ! 9! 9'& ! !
() ' ! ;
!! $ ( ! & $ (
' ( ( !$ ' (
( ' $) ! #(!91'
!1 ' ! (!$ I('9(!& ( ' 9 $$! !1 ! ,!! > (!7 ( (! ,#' !!
! ( 1'$ (
() ' !9! '&2 2& ! !, ( /( 2 $
' ; ' !9/ ' ( ! !! ! 9'& 2
& () ' ! ! (
1! ! '$ 3( ! !!
! ) 2&1 ( 1! !1 !/ (!)!!! (9(! (2&!1 (! !1 !1 1 , (& !1( ') ( ' !$/ ! !!
!) 3(, ! ' '2 !! ()
!
&&,12,* ! 8 ( @ !&' (& ! !!
!) 9'& $ 7 ! $!!2& ( ! ! !!
!!' 3(9!1( 2
( ' (! !!
!('&2 $ ( ' ; )))!
! $ , ) ( ! ! !!
! 9! ('
!! !1 2 !J* 6 - ( &(! $!! !/
!B5 8
.
!7' $ ( )) * ( - (/;
8* ":K F 3( ( ((' 3 ( $$! ! , 3(, ( $' 3 ( ! ( ) $$! !1 ! , * $ ->46!) &*!1( -> * 2!*!1(
' & !)! ! 3( !( 2$ $ (
' (2 ! (!! &' $ ->46!) &*!1( '7(6'$ ! !! (#9&&, 3() ' !( ) ( ! ( 2, 2& '2 3( !
& ' ( &, )) !
( ! 2'1( 2, () ' ! ' ( '1'!& , ! ! &&! (9&& #'1$ 2, (& ' 2&9 !1&,/ ( )) &!!$!
) !19! ( (/9)& '! 1 ! '
( ! 2, * # ,.$ / /9(9 ))! ! () B1 &! '&2( & "/ (9/'C' /( &)) ) ( 2( & ( &/ ! !*!1(/9(( !& (
)) & ) !1 ( /9 ))! ! (! 0 #!*( $ 5'1
6'&!)*!1( 5'1 >( () 7!1< A< >( () 2& A<