← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/322/2010dismissed

Harvinder Singh @ Ravi v. State Of Punjab

2015-09-02Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik,Mr. Justice S.S. Saron13 pages

     

!"

 #    

$% & '()"

*  



   

        "#

    ! "    

  #  $!  " %!

%

&   

        "# #    

  #  $!  " %!  &  +,-.

/ 01'2.

.+2 31 2  +,-.

'/ 01'2.

0 133 44444 ' (     "  )*        )+ , -        + . (      )        + ///// 0 133/0/ -   )        )  0,0,,0'0  *        & !

& !

* ""1 

  %

&  ""  ")) "  

  " .22! .32 4 5  .,.  6  7 4   86785 - *   "    "    9"   )  "    6  '0 *     ,!000:1   "  ")) "    " .22 67;    6  '< *     ,!000:1   "  ")) "    " .32 4 5 67     6  2 )   ")) "    " .,. 67 71"" 

*    "*     = "    " "    ;    '>03,003! %

!      "?

 " @6   "    "    

  $  )

  *  

    '3 * 4"?5! *

 '0 7  %) "

!

!    )  "

  'A03,003 -  "?

   "

   *   .0  

   ") " ) "

  .

00         B  ! ")  ) "

 "?  C      "? )  !

!

 ")     

      "

   * 7)   1    "   * " 

 7)     )    "   '1D )  

 "?    "

! &  *!    =!

 1  - *    

    )"*"     

     "



!    ) *  )      "?  "  ) 

 )*   " *  & 

 *           "?  0,','>>0 @6  " .2.:.22 67    "

   ""  ) B   ? *   ,003,003!   "?  " ) = ! # %!

      

)  "?   " *   "   "    'A03,003   A .0  !

      "

!   !       )  *  &!

  * !   )"*" - *   1     (        )! *    )   )"*"   "

 ! "         )"*"   ) !  !  *    *   "?! )"*"    * %

& (       8!

 )    

    - *       9 4 9E6   &5   "" )*   *     

 !  !

 : %)

!

 

!  "

       "" )

   "1 *!    "" (     ""!       ? "   "" 



      * =*   )!

    (       8!    ""        "   - !    )    *  6   ) !       "1  ")  )!     ") "" !  !

   )    ")) ? " 

 B    ) ! "" &  *     "



5 "   "*

 *   )"*"  "

 =

! # %!

     !  *    )   )"*"     * "   ""  ) *  "?!  !       ""  

)* )  ") %

 "

)  "?  "  " '2< 77 

 "   ! "" %

&!  

*  

   ""  

 " ")       * "  B   )  %

!  6 =

! )

 ) 9?(3:     )  

% =

   " ! $!  "  ) @6!

!

) @6 9?(3:=    B ,003,003!

   ")!  "

 "?!

 "

 =     # %!  *       

   * %

  

  )  " *   "

    7 ! $   )" ?) )       7 ! & 

  )"1 * ?)    @) )"   ?)  !       "" " B"! 7 ! & !  "?    7 ! $!     ?)  )  ) B ,'03,003!    "   6C    

 ) "  " '2< 77  !   7    "  "   ,.03,003 B ,.03,003!   7    "     "

    "

 "  "  "   "? 

 ,203,003 -  7 "   )  "? !  !

 "?       B     " )! ""1

   ,F03,003 

      9? (3:

  B " 9?(3:9    "!  ,A03,003   "    7 ! $! ""   )" ?)  "" ) ""   )"1 * ?) * )

" 9?(3:@  9?(3:%  @ E   !

! "  " .32 67    ")  "*  !   "

      7    "" @     "     ""!  *  "

 1   ")) "    " .2.!.22!

.32 4 5  .,. 67!  "

*    *  ")     " "! )  ""  " .'. 77  "   *  "

"       "" "" %

&    "     ")) * "

" 

!     =!         %

1")!

  )"   )   )*  )

  "    @6    "  

* %

 E !   "?  )!     * 

 %

 ")   ) )    1    "    "))     "  "? 6 "!   "?  

   * )"

            

6 * *   ") "" 

!  * *  "   * )" *   "   ) )  "          "?      "  """ 6 "! "" ?) =

 ('

 

!

"

  ! =!  (,     "      

  "  ) ")  "!     7!

   )   )  ""    "! * )          ) (    "      

 "     )  " ")  " E "             "   "    )  "?!    ""    "))  

        ""!        "))   *   "" 6  "?  ""    )  "))  !                  " 

 "))     6     *  "    1""   "?

   (2  "" 

!

  1              ) - !

 "" 

!        "?!   )  

! ""    "! ") 

7 -    )   "                )  "? 4(25        %

4(<5!

    ")    " 6   "!   @6  ) %

4(<5 " "*   "?

   "

   3 .0    'A03,003

     .

00   =      !

     "?  ) C )  !

!

 ")     "?      "

   *       )    "! "*   )  *  &   "  " "*    "   )  '1D )      "! "" *  &!

  1

 

 (  "?  "   ,003,003!    )          "

    *  "

 *  )"*"

 ""*  

      )! "" * "    )            *  9 4 9E6   &5

     %

&    )"*"   )

   " "*    "" 

         !  !

 ""!

 

!  "

   - ! 

 )   *   !  "?

  )   "" 6 * )  "" 

!  1   "?  !   " )               !

 "" *  &   *   "?    

"   < ""   "

  !      "?    !           ""  "

8   !     )  )   "   *!

    ""           "  ") -   )  * "    1""  "   "?  ""    )    !  !

  "           "))   ;

    6     "    "" ")) 

   "?  "" !  !  *    *  

   ""   ) 6   "   "?

 " "*       " * *  &       *  "



         

     45! ""    

  !  !

!

 

!  "

   - !

        "      ""   "))  "     # *  !     " "*       )    "1 !  !

   ""       ""!       "    )  ? "   "" 

          *    " "*         *   "" # *  !   ""      " - * )   - *     

       

     *    ""  *  6     )       )  ")  "1      ""!   ""    ")) ? " 

 -    "?

)   ""  , *    !  

9  ""    "  """ 6     "    "      , *!   "? ) ""  

   "

!   )  %

4(<5 ")  "? 4(25! *    ""    ")    *  6  ?   *  "    1""     "!      E    "?

  * )"1 * ?)  ,003,003 * "  $ =  4(.5  E! "*  "

 9?7    )!   " "         B   ) *!     !      

4('5!

  )"1 * ?)   "?         >       $ = !       >       "?   $ = ! )"1 * ?) "?     " -  "     !  "!

""   "     "?    )  " *        "?     ? 

    

 -  "?  

! !  !  ""  )*  %

 1         ")!

  )    "  ""     * )"    " -   "   "    1 ""     !    )   6 =

!

6  B"    "!

   (3   ?   "")"  "

, E    "?  ""  " "*     "*  "?!  * 

     7 ! $   )" ?) @) !      7 ! & !

   "?

 )"1 * ?) * " B" @ )"1  ?)  !        "" " B"!

7 ! & !   "?    7 ! $!

    ?)   )  )

  $ =  4(.5! " "*      )"1 * ?)   "? *      "))   G   "")"!  ")    "   "?

   )"1 * ?)       *  *

" B"!  !      7 ! &  "" *!    ) !

  $ = ! )"1  * ?) "? 6  B"! (3! " "*          !   "?  )"1 * ?) *  

4('5 B "! "

""  "   "     "?  )"1 * ?) *  * " B"!      ?)  )"1  *                  -  "   "    1""    "!     " * %

1")      "?!   !

  ")      "     

   ? 

);    * " 



4('5!

             "?   )   "     ,  . * "            B ,003,003!

 "?  "

  )"1 * ?) * "



  7 ! &    * "  77! $ G  "")"!      ""  ") %

!  "   "?       )"1 * ?) 9   !

 %

"        "?!   "      )  "   !

"

    " B   " C!

"?   )"1 * ?) *    , " G   "")"!  )   "    1 ""      )  )"1  ?)  "?!   )   E! "*  "

 9?!   "?   )"* ?) * * " B"    ?);    !   

4('5! " "*   "   "1?)      "!   "?   ?) *  %*"   7   # 03000F0>  ,003,003 -  )     "*  E 9?   "? -   )     "?   )"1 * ?) * * " B"    ?)!

 88  ) * "    "       "?    "                     )  "

! )!

 88     6   "  )  8=8!   "?   ?) *  %*"    # 03000F0>  ,003,003!

" 

       "    " *  !       ""  , )"1  ?)    "? 6  ?   *  "     

  6  B"   ""          1  * "" *  %

& 6  B"   ) C )       "?

 "        "?   1 * "" *  %

&!   #        "?         " 6  " "* ) * ") %

    "?   2  )      "? "  "?     "

    -    )   "        )"

        "    "   "?

  *    "

    ")*          6      "    "   "" *  %

&   1  "?    "  "

1)  "?     ")    ' D )       """! "" *  %

&! 1   "?        *   "* 1

 9   "?  (2   "     

    ,:.

       ")  "

 -  )  $! $)  )) - *  * '0     )   "

   ))!  *   * )       * ))      )  )

 )    3 .0     1)   ")       ))!  *    * )         "

  ))     "

     )

         *  """!

  *  G   "")"!    6 

  B"!    *        "

    "?

  !        " " @    " !   )    !

)  )   )  ""  0,0,,0'0    "   !        )

.+2 31 2

0 133 013.

013.

) 0,!,0'F