Balbir Singh v. State Of Punjab
#
%$ &$ !'( $ )
* * '+ , $+
$&$-$
$$- $(*
(
$+ /"(! ( 0 !
$+ -&
+! !$+ &
'+, $+
$&$-$ $(* '($$
+!$ &
( !
("
# 1 &$ "
.$!
&
$ ( $/($, $+$0 3 .$!
- &$ $( *
( !
& "/" & &
$'!$" ( .$!
$*& !
&$ 1
4$# 0 !
$+ -&
5 -(- , 2$$*/ 67%*$( . % 2,85 ++#9$ (- !$+ ' !+ $- . 2 8% 7: - (' # , $$/ $'($ $/($, $+$
$+ !
* '($
+!$ &
( !
1 &$ "
& (!+$( .$!
$ - *$1
$( $!! (-+# .$!
&$ ! ((
!
#$ "
+(
"
(-
# "- *$( # "-
"
(- $(0 $+-
# "- $++0 #$ (- $$ +#,
(- " $2 $-"&$+$! -, +# $+ -
+$ % #$ (- $$ +# *
! "!
-$ $$ " $"$* $(2 $-"&$+$! -, $
$(-' *7 +$($+ -&
;
$( *$- +$( &$ 1
# $ - *$ $!
, &' $+- - ( * &
$
! $ + '$($!
&
$+- - *!$+ &$( *< ($#
% $+ -&
.*$+/ &
"
$(& $+1-&
$!
$ "
)
*& +-
! " #$(&$ $+- & + +(- ' +' $($+ -&
& $+/(;$"$(
$+ (
" $+- ($" -+ "( ' !, &$( &$ -
- * $-
& !$* "
* $+- ($
&$( * ( 1++ *& !
+ "+($( $
+
- $+- (= *
& !
! ( ' *,$ ( "$(!#$( $-
.*$+/ $(
$+ $ ( "$(!#
*$ *$!!" (+($&$# *
0 $
- *$(*
('+, $+
$&$-$ $ $$--$ ' !+ *& &$ ( $/($, $+$$( -
-
$ * 7 ! $#' -$
&$ (
" $ $- $ !
! & >!+" '+# $+#
"
!$ &$ ! **
" 5"(- 9"-
! " $+
$+ " "($ !$ "(!
:$(7 $(&
!
:
*
!
$(
++$ &$ !
$- ($!! (-+#, &'
+$(( -"+ #
!
$-$(!+$*( $+ 6 "
? !$
>$*( 2@
2@.*$+/ 2@ 9;88 #$+2@7 9;"+( - 2@ 9 8$-$( $"( $# 2@6 9;;$+$'$$2@:92$'2"2@%, 2@ ,$$/ 2@ &$ $*$2@ $+&(- $( 2@ !
8"* $(
$
'(!
&$ !+ ( : !+ "
'(!
++$ "(!
2&$ ! ((& (($++
$++-$ . '(!&$ +((! %
'# "
+$( ! " +
++$
"*
( !
$++-
/"(-* ! '!
$ ($-$
++$ #
$+ " &' *+!# *$# & & +$&$(-
! * A'
"- +$(! " +
++$ $ !
$++-(
/"(-* ! '!
++
" $ ! ((
!$ *
3$( ! " + "*
++$ (
( '
! ! -$(- !$(
$
$+ ( * ( $' $(+$(! " +
$( " (
! (!$"++#
0 '
!
>$*( 2@
! * +$$ =/"(& $( "
!$
$+ #B"
* #&$ ("+# "
(#
2@.*$+/ A'
& & ! >$*( $ +-
&'
* ! "+(
$1$#*$2@79;"+( $(*(! +-$++# >$*(.$!
%$( "(
++ &- /" )
! "
#
" %&$
' % !
"
$
( " " %&$ ! "
$ " ) !
$
$ * " %&$
' )
!
$*!" %&$ + , $+ '( !
# 3 A>2@7= $( !
$+ ($-$*A>2@7= $("
'( *$
+! -$(- $(* .$!
$ - $ A>2@7= , "
'( ( * A>2@7=9*$(# *
+!$ * '(# +!C" - * 1 &$ "
/"("
.$!
$ - $ (
$/($, $+$$("
'(
:
%
+!$ +! -$' A>2@7=A
/" . $(7
.$!
$-' " $ " & $ /"#. * + %
%
+!$
+!$
$-$ -$' A>2@7=B
/"
! "+(($- + B"
9 ;8 8 + &$ >$*( $ 2@ &
"
(
* # 9 ;"+( - 9 8$-$(
$"( $#$
$($ 2@6& (
%4$# >$*$ .$!
&$ ! ("!
( !# $( -$
$/
$+$($ >$*$ -$' , (( $# /"# 4$#
-
- , &' 4 $#
+
-
$( $( $C" $( & *"+$ - "++
"
+
- *((+ D&
/"# $( *+$ >$# + $*
( $( $C" $( & *"+$ -"++
"
+ $*$
/"!
*((+$(+ &
(&
/"# $( '( $ A>2@ =$(>$#+*
$ A>2 A>2 2@69;;$+$'$$(
% (!+$(
.$!
$ - *$1 '( ( * A>2@6=92$'2"(!$+!9 *
$(! $/($, $+$&$ >$*($ 2@:&
(
%.$!
&$ $(*
(A*-!#
@$($/($, $+$,*(!$++# $
*
%$(( !
$-(
%$( '(
( $(
!1 .$!
$ - $ A>2@:= 0 "
>$*(2@8"* !
& $( $++#! ("!
(
' -$
!$ ++"
$( >$*(2@%,
-$(
( -
!$ #$( (-
B3$( $++ !A> $1-
B *
'(!+(#
&$ '(
++$ $(! **
! " $+"(!
:2A' &$ $+ -
+#! '!
(
! **
! " $+"(!
:
* !
7 . &$(' -
( C"$ "* !
! " !$ + -
$!
$
++$ $!-
!
%
+$ *
$%#$
++$ $-($ "
7 #$ $(
+$($
$*+#A'
*$
$ $*!$+# +'( &
$($! * * ($ $ >!"
( &
++"
++$ $(
/"($"!+$(
& +$ $(
+$ '$+ #$
# $ +'-
$!"++# C" +# 1 - '&
$ $( * -$ - !!"* $!
!* ( * ("!(
( $+$(#"(- # * @
$ '* (!$
$
$+ +# $++ &( $(
* "-( /"(-* ! '!
$( ( !($ (: 7
$ (#
" (( $+ 5"(- ( ! B0 $-" $ "
+( & $
! * (
++$ ("!(
($+$(#"(- #
*, &'
! &++*$
$* 6 !$ #$#*$#($+
$
"+ : 2(- $
+!$ $# $( $+ ( ( $!! (-+# 6 .,A;,@0 $* $$ 5E98A @
$ (= $1- ) < =.
@
$+ ) < =.